No Clear Consensus On 29 Palms Fire Merger

TWENTYNINE PALMS—A specially called meeting of the Twentynine Palms City Council on January 14 did not resolve the issues relating to the fate of the fire department.
According to the Local Agency Formation Commission, the Twentynine Palms Water District, which has since 1958 overseen the fire department, can no longer afford to carry that financial burden. Fire department operations are defrayed entirely by a special parcel tax that  generates $1.24 million per year. Currently, the seven-man, two-station fire department costs $1.48 million to run and carries with it a future unfunded liability in the form of pensions for its firefighters when they retire. Last year, voters turned thumbs down on an increase in the fire service per parcel tax.
The water district voted last summer to have the county’s fire division take over the fire department’s operations, but missed an October 1 deadline to have the Local Agency Formation Commission initiate the processing of that merger. The water board’s members along with members of the community grew concerned that county fire chief Mark Hartwig‘s plan to reduce the department to a one-station, three-firefighter operation would be inadequate for the city and its outlying area.
Pressure has mounted on the city, which has historically made no contribution to the operation of the fire department, which serves the 59-square miles within the Twentynine Palms City Limits and 29 square miles of unincorporated county property around the city, to subsidize the water district or takeover the district.
City manager Richard Warne, in his powerpoint presentation to the city council on Monday evening, made clear his recommendation that the city not take up the burden of operating the fire department.
The fire department is “insolvent,” Warne said. “The city cannot take on the fire department’s open-ended responsibilities.”
Warne said Twentynine Palms and government entities throughout California are confronted with a “new reality” of uncertain and diminishing revenue. “The water district has not recognized this new world and/or made adjustments to the new reality. As a result, the Twentynine Palms Fire Department is insolvent today due to decisions made by the firefighters union, fire chief, water district finance director and water district board. They all share responsibility for the current situation. The fire department’s controllable expenditures have significantly exceeded inflation as measured by the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and they have acquired huge unfunded firefighter pension obligations and post-employment retiree benefit obligations that appear to be impossible to pay. In this respect they are like many governments in California facing bankruptcy.”
Warne said that “after years of deficit spending and nine months after the failure of the ballot measure, the fire chief and the water district board still have no plan to bring expenditures into line with revenues. The fire department cash position is deteriorating each day due to deficit spending, while the unfunded firefighter pension obligations are growing each day.”
Warne’s bottom line recommendation was to have the water district proceed with turning the fire department over to the county.
“The county fire department proposal provides the city a higher level of service than is currently provided by the Twentynine Palms Fire Department and more efficiently directs limited financial resources,” Warne said. “More importantly, the county fire department proposal keeps expenditures within revenues.”
Warne’s hands-off approach was not embraced by several people in attendance. A few used Warne’s citation of a $12 million municipal reserve fund to suggest that the city could afford to effectuate the takeover.
Among those who lobbied the city to keep local control over the fire department was Paul Regner, “Isn’t looking after the residents and citizens of Twentynine Palms our primary responsibility?” Regner asked. “Do we really want to farm that out to the county? What’s the point of being a city if we don’t  provide these kinds of basic preventive and security services for our residents? We have the ability to sort this out and make it work for our city. I think maintaining control of the fire department is essential in that.”
City attorney Patrick Munoz said the city could opt to take over just that portion of the fire department function within its city limits or more energetically take on the department’s current service area. Arrangements would have to be made to pass the special fire department service tax to the city, he said. Munoz also said the city could expedite the LAFCO application for the county fire district to annex the city and unincorporated areas for the purpose of providing fire protection. And, he said, a joint powers authority could be created between the city and water district to run the fire department.
In response to suggestions that the county should help subsidize the department because a large portion of the department’s service area lies in the unincorporated county area, Hartwig said declining revenues have already resulted in “service delivery cuts” to the county’s service areas. He also said county firefighters had made “concessions” on salaries and benefits. Councilwoman Cora Heiser inquired about the relative pay provided to the county’s firefighters and the firefighters currently employed by the Twentynine Palms Fire Department. She was told that Twentynine Palms firefighters average about $14.05 per hour and county firefighters are paid about twice that.
The county’s Local Agency Formation Commission executive director, Kathleen Rollings-McDonald, said that the incorporated portion of Twentynine Palms generated enough revenue to sustain the fire station servicing the city but that the sparsely populated county area did not provide enough in the way of special tax proceeds to support the fire station outside of town.
Councilman Daniel Mintz said, “City money being spent outside the city is a complex issue.”
Mayor Joe Klink said, “It is a very difficult decision to make. I ask the four council members and myself to go home and think about what was said and come back to our first meeting in February with hopefully a decision we can make if the water district cannot make a decision on how it will handle it.”

Brulte, Rego & Hagman In Separate Efforts To Rejuvenate County, State GOP

With nearly two years before the next set of statewide elections, the foundering California Republican Party is seeking to remake itself. Locally, one currently established GOP Sacramento officeholder, Assemblyman Curt Hagman, is loading up to displace current San Bernardino County GOP leader Robert Rego.
Unknown at this point is whether Hagman can effectuate the coup he envisions, and whether his intended vanquishing of Rego, if executed, will have a salutary result for the party in San Bernardino County. As the Republicans have receded into political eclipse in California over the last few years, San Bernardino County  has remained as one of the last few remaining bastions of Republicanism in the state. While some believe Hagman will be able to assist the county party to tap into a wider variety of fundraising sources and expand the grassroots organization that Rego has struggled to build up, some party members fear a Donnybrook between Hagman and Rego could in the end hinder the party rather than advance it. Even if Hagman can marshal forces from outside San Bernardino County and match that with money based upon his fundraising capability as a Sacramento politician to dislodge Rego as the county party chief, such a victory could prove a pyrrhic one if the party donors and supporters Rego has been cultivating over the last three years are offended by such an unseemly internecine squabble.
At present, those in  San Bernardino County’s Republican camp, which was already polarized by the slugfest between incumbent Congressman Gary Miller and former State Senator Bob Dutton last year, are choosing sides, in some cases reluctantly.
There is a perception that Hagman’s effort is a subset of a larger strategy for the party involving former state senator and assemblyman Jim Brulte’s quest to capture the leadership of the state Republican Party. Brulte has so far stopped short of openly endorsing Hagman.
Brulte, in the wake of the 2012 November election, which stands as the most resounding electoral defeat the GOP has ever sustained in California, is seeking to succeed Tom Del Beccaro as California GOP chairman and take control of the party’s state political machinery in an effort to reestablish Republican relevance in the nation’s most populous state.
On November 8, the Republicans suffered a defeat of catastrophic proportion, with the Democrats capturing well over two-thirds majorities in both houses of the legislature, locking in a Democratic advantage at the statehouse while governor Jerry Brown, a Democrat, holds sway over the state’s administrative function. Democrats have firm possession of 84 seats in the state’s 120-seat legislature. This supermajority provides the Democrats with the ability to raise taxes without the support of any Republican votes. Emboldened by the position of power they now hold, elements within the Democratic Party in the state are calling for the elimination of any remaining tax breaks for businesses.
While it is doubtful that Brulte can effectively reverse the statewide trend of growing and energized numbers of  Latino voters registering as Democrats and voting  overwhelmingly in support of candidates from their party, it was Brulte who in fact engineered the last effective Republican takeover of the California legislature when he succeeded, after a protracted power struggle with  former Democratic Assembly Speaker Willie Brown, in installing Curt Pringle as Speaker of the Assembly in 1996.
As a longtime Republican elected official chosen by his party colleagues to leadership positions in both State Senate and Assembly caucuses, Brulte  has a command of the methods and science of campaigning and in horse trading among politicians and business interests in building a well-funded political machine capable of targeting and reaching the requisite number of voters in those districts where Republicans either hold a registration advantage outright or are in a position to get out the Republican vote in sufficient numbers where the Democrats hold a less-than-entirely-overwhelming registration advantage. In office, Brulte demonstrated himself to be basically a conservative, but was not so ideologically rigid in his approach that he could not be pragmatic and recognize the need for compromise in a circumstance where Democrats held the majority of the positions in the legislature. On occasion he reached across to moderates when some political mileage was to be gained. A cunning strategist, Brulte was not unwilling to push the envelope and secure whatever advantage the leverage he and his party possessed at any given time with regard to specific or general issues.
Nearly a decade after he left the interior of the political cauldron, Brulte has his work cut out for him in jumping back into the partisan fray.  For the first time since party affiliation records have been compiled, fewer than 30 percent of the state’s voters are registered as Republicans. The state’s demographics show that portion of the population from which the GOP draws most of its voters – upwardly mobile young white professionals, non-unionized tradesmen and older white males – being eclipsed by minority voters, who tend to identify themselves as Democrats.
Moreover, the internecine fighting among Republicans reached fever pitch this year, partly as a consequence of California’s open primaries, which provided for the two top vote-getters in June regardless of party affiliation to qualify for the run-off in November. This resulted in  a handful of head-to-head contests between Republicans in some of the congressional, state senatorial and assembly districts in which Republicans still hold a registration advantage. Curiously, the state party devoted a significant part of its resources to some of its Republican candidates engaged in campaigns against other Republicans while providing less funding to Republicans who were simultaneously waging campaigns against Democrats. Some of those Republican vs. Democrat races were highly competitive. In this way, the party actually ran campaigns against Republican candidates that were more vitriolic than those which were run against Democratic opponents. One of those was incumbent Congressman Gary Miller’s congressional campaign against then-State Senator Bob Dutton. Dutton had been the Republican leader in the State Senate. He was assailed in a number of attack pieces paid for by his own party.
The Miller vs. Dutton debacle took place in San Bernardino County, in which the 31st District is located. Ironically, Rego decried the squandering of Republican money in the Miller electoral effort against Dutton, as well as in other head-to-head contests between Republican standard bearers. Rego’s entreaties to his fellow Republicans were to no avail, however. Equally ironic is the very real prospect that in San Bernardino County, more Republican resources will be utilized in the effort to topple Rego from his perch so that Hagman, who owns a string of bail bond businesses, can oversee the San Bernardino County Central Committee, which is the controlling organ of the county Republican Party.
There have been suggestions, though nothing tangible to definitively establish, that Hagman’s move at the county level is being done in concert with Brulte’s move at the state level. Arguments in favor of bringing Hagman in to oversee the county party apparatus include his ability to network beyond the confines of San Bernardino County and reach into the pockets of donors throughout the state and conceivably beyond California to fund electioneering and informational campaigns aimed at promoting Republican candidates and conservative ideas and formulas. Hagman’s ability to author and sponsor legislation and interact with other current office holders provides him with a reach Rego does not possess. A phone call from Hagman is nearly always taken. Those calls that find someone not in are nearly always returned, usually sooner rather than later. Moreover, Hagman, like Brulte, possesses at this point a practical understanding of the political reality in Sacramento and a real world understanding of how business is taken care of and things are done.
At the same time, some consider it unwise to have a full-time state legislator committed to the running of local party operations. As the 2014 election date approaches, the time commitment will increase. Hagman’s future political ambition is unclear at this point. His control of the county party machinery could put other potential candidates for an office Hagman covets at a disadvantage. Others frown at the prospect that Hagman will be putting the arm on donors for money or political personages for endorsements while legislation is pending in Sacramento that might impact those donors or endorsers.
And Rego, who has steadily grown into the role of county party chairman, is in no hurry to leave the position. Under his leadership, the party has maintained its historical edge in San Bernardino County. While it is a reality that registered Democrats now outnumber registered Republicans in San Bernardino County 39.1 percent to 38.4 percent, the GOP countywide still outmuscles the Democrats at the polls and in local, state and federal offices.  Three of the five Congressman who represent San Bernardino County are Republicans. Five of the eight  members of the Assembly who  represent San Bernardino County are Republicans. Four of six state senators currently representing San Bernardino County are Republicans. County and municipal offices are officially considered non-partisan ones. Nevertheless, party affiliation plays a major role in the electability of candidates in nearly every city in San Bernardino County. In eighteen of the county’s 24 cities, Republicans outnumber Democrats on their respective city or town councils. Under Rego’s direction of the party, the Republicans in San Bernardino County have turned out at the polls in far greater numbers than Democrats.
After Brulte captures  the party chairman’s position when the California GOP meets in March, his first order of business will consist of convincing party donors, many of whom supported the Republican candidates who were the targets of Republican  attack campaigns last fall, that they should continue to stock the party’s coffers with money. Sacking Rego, whose reputation as a party loyalist and someone who inveighed against cannibalism within the Party of Lincoln is well established, could result in those donors refusing to open their checkbooks for the Republican Party altogether. Thus, in seeking to ease Rego out of the picture, Hagman, and by extension Brulte, will require a degree of tact and politesse the situation does not permit, leading to a perception of Rego’s removal as a counterproductive bloodletting aimed less at advancing the party than the political fortunes of a handful of party insiders.
Brulte told the Sentinel his campaign for the state party chairmanship is entirely separate from Hagman’s effort to assume the lead of the party in San Bernardino County.
“I am not playing a role in that,” Brulte said. “I am not a member of the county central committee. I would refer you to the Republicans who make up the membership of that committee. The chairmanship there is wholly a local issue.”
Brulte, who on January 14 in San Diego formally announced he will be seeking the state party chair, spoke with the Sentinel prior to that announcement. “I want to be the nuts and bolts Republican Party chairman,” he said. “We have three issues we must deal with. Our party is in debt hundreds of thousands of dollars. We have allowed our fundraising function to atrophy over the last few years as we have depended on members of the legislature or gubernatorial candidates to raise money. My number one priority will be building our statewide fundraising operation to erase that debt and provide funds to build the party.”
Brulte continued, “Concurrently, we have got to rebuild the grassroots base of our party, particularly in target areas of the state where we are on the defensive in trying to hold onto seats in the legislature where our candidates are under attack by the Democrats and in those areas where Republicans have an opportunity to pick up seats. Third, we have to go into every area of California, and I mean every part of the state, and recruit candidates and train candidates and to the extent possible provide them with technical support.”
Brulte said open primaries that will in some cases pit Republicans against Republicans are a reality the party will have to live with. “Voters have put so-called open primaries in place and I don’t think they will go away any time soon,” he said. He indicated he did not personally approve of the idea of dedicating party money to the campaigns of Republicans vying against other Republicans.
“I wasn’t a member of Republican Party’s board of directors when those decisions were made,” he said, referring to the expenditure of party money in Republican vs. Republican match-ups. “My view is that we should use Republican resources to elect Republicans and to defeat Democrats. As to the policy the California Republican Board of Directors will enact, I cannot tell you. The board might change. Of its 28 members, nine are up for election or reelection.”
Rego declined comment. Hagman did not return a call seeking his input.
Brulte is scheduled to speak at the San Bernardino Republican Central Committee’s organizational meeting at the Hilton Garden Inn, located at 11481 Mission Vista Drive in Rancho Cucamonga on January 31. There will be a social interaction period from 6 p.m. to 6:30, followed by Brulte’s speech at 6:30. The meeting, at which the organization of the county party’s leadership will be discussed, will last from 7 p.m. until 9 p.m.

Mitzelfelt Contemplating Comeback

Former County First District Supervisor Brad Mitzelfelt has taken a step toward reinitiating his political career. Appointed to succeed former supervisor Bill Postmus in 2007 when Postmus left to become assessor, Mitzelfelt ran successfully to retain the supervisorial post in 2008. He fell short, though, in his 2012 bid to be elected congressman in California’s 8th Congressional District.
Mitzelfelt had $226,210 remaining in his supervisorial electioneering fund. Last week he transferred it into an account designated Brad Mitzelfelt for Assembly.
The move sets him into position to vie for the position in California’s lower legislative house now held by Tim Donnelly. Donnelly is eligible to run for Assembly again in 2014, but  is now contemplating a run for governor next year.
Mitzelfelt was Postmus’s chief of staff during the four years the latter was supervisor.

Ontario’s Once Burgeoning Homeless Camp Depopulated

Ontario’s homeless encampment, which began as a group of about 20 ragtag squatters who occupied open property just west of Ontario Airport without authorization in 2007 and then grew to become a shantytown of roughly 400 that was quasi-sanctioned by city officials, is now defunct.
When two of the Sentinel’s writers drove through the area near State Street west of Grove Avenue on January 13, the area was empty.
“I do not get updates on it every day like I was before,” Ontario Mayor Paul Leon told the Sentinel. “I know there were fewer than 15 people there a while ago. We have been ramping it down for years. We now have a very sophisticated homeless support program that has replaced it.”
The encampment spontaneously emerged in 2007, as growing numbers of people were displaced by the stagnating economy and many found themselves living on the streets after a round of foreclosures. The homeless began congregating in the area and a tent city formed that Ontario officials at first resisted but in time reluctantly grew to accept. City officials began providing water hookups, sanitation facilities and other basic services to those living there. That official acceptance generated publicity, which in turn resulted in larger numbers of homeless flocking there.
In 2008, the city drew the line, disallowing outsiders living in mobile homes from occupying the area and then instituting a policy of having those accepted there show proof that they had lived or otherwise originated in Ontario to receive the limited services the city was providing.
Since that time, the city, as Leon said, has been seeking to substitute in other services to discourage the homeless from taking up residence in the area.
The city now offers short-term rental or rental arrears assistance for up to two months, utility payment for up to two months, the provision of security deposits for would-be renters along with utility deposits to city residents who have been evicted and who are under the 2010 state annual income limits, which range from $26,000 for a household of two to $42,900 for a household of eight.
A partially city sponsored program, Mercy House, is the city’s first line of offense in the war on homelessness. Mercy House is located at the corner of Bon View and Holt.
Leon said he has faith Mercy House is making inroads on the problem.
“I believe we have a very good program with Mercy House,” Leon said. “Someone on the street can walk in there and they will put him up in a motel or hotel and get him entered into a program that would turn him back into a productive member of the community. I checked it out myself. Just to see what they would do, I took someone in there myself. I tried to make it so the people with Mercy House had no idea who I was. I wore a hat that I pulled down as low as I could. I wore sunglasses and had on just a T-shirt and a pair of old jeans. I took this guy in there and said to them, ‘This is somebody who needs your help.’ I can tell you they did a good job. They got him off the street.”
The Mercy House phone number is (909) 988-4562.
Ontario’s secondary  lines of offense against homelessness include the House of Ruth, which provides services for battered women and their children, reachable at (909) 988-5559; the Foothill Family Shelter, at (909) 920-5568; the SOVA Food Bank, at (909) 391-4882; the 211-United Way, which can be reached by dialing 211 for assistance; the county of San Bernardino Department of Veteran Services, at (909) 465-5241; and the Kids Come First Clinic, which provides free/low cost medical care for children 0-18 years, at (909) 673-9125.

Mountain Top Café Serving Customers A Year After Fire Disaster

Just shy of a year after the Mountain Top Café near the confluence of state highways 2 and 138  was forced to shut down for nine months because of a fire, its significance as a celebrated establishment near the gateway between San Bernardino County and Los Angeles County was marked with a ribbon cutting by the Phelan Chamber of Commerce on January 4.
Fire department logs show that a distress call from the restaurant went out at 5:15 p.m. on January 13, 2012 and that firefighters were en route to the scene at 5:16:39 p.m. Four engines, two from Wrightwood and two from Phelan, including a water tender and units that were diverted from a vehicle fire at Sheep Creek Road and Highway 138, responded to what was described as an electrical fire in the roof. The fire was confined to the dining area due to an aggressive interior attack by firefighters and the blaze was put down by 5:28 p.m. The Gas Company was on scene at 6:06 p.m.
Damage was extensive enough to keep the café shuttered until October, when it reopened.
The Mountain Top Café was constructed in 1940 by John Lovett, who also built the Mountain Top Service Station in 1937.

VVUHSD Imposes Employee Salary & Benefit Cuts To Prevent State Takeover

VICTORVILLE—Over the objections of a handful of teachers, the Victor Valley Union High School District Board of Trustees approved three percent cuts in the contracts for classified and management employees.
Those reductions are being made as administrators are working to stave off a state takeover of the cash-strapped district.
The four percent downscaling of the district’s certificated personnel, i.e., teachers, was greater than the three percent paring done to management and groundskeepers, secretaries, cafeteria workers, bus drivers, librarians and instructional assistants, prompting protest from some of the teachers.
Superintendent Elvin Momon called the reductions “painful” but necessary.
“I ask each of you to stand with me, the administration and our board of education to problemsolve, collaborate and fight with every ounce of energy and integrity the challenge of state takeover,” Momon pleaded in a letter to district employees last week.
In addition to the 4 percent salary cut teachers are sustaining, they are also having a 30 percent reduction in sick days and a 40 percent reduction in bereavement time off being imposed on them. The district has also upped the teachers’ contribution toward their medical visit and prescription coverage.
Teachers bemoaned that they, more than the district’s other employees, are bearing the onus of the district’s pay and benefit reductions.
The board voted 4-1, with Timothy Hauk dissenting, to implement the contract changes, which will last, at least until June 30, 2015.
The cuts will apply only to those district employees who are still working for the district after the end of the current school year. Just before Christmas, the school board voted to hand out preliminary layoff notices to 80 district employees, including 37 teachers and eight counselors as well as 35 non-instructional workers including information technology specialists, clerical staff and custodians. The non-instructional staff will be let go as of April 26. The remainder of the layoffs will come in June.
Finances in the district have deteriorated to the point that if the district has not put together a game plan for reducing its deficit spending by February 15, the process of turning the district over to a state receivership will be initiated. District officials said a state takeover would likely result in a curriculum devoted solely to core educational courses with the elimination of most or all electives. Included in the layoff notices were two for teachers in the district’s popular cadet program.

Needles School District Employees Given Raises

NEEDLES — While teachers and other district employees in the Victor Valley Union High School District were preparing to lose their jobs or accept substantial pay and benefit cuts so that district can avoid a takeover by the state, 175 miles across the desert teachers in the smaller Needles Unified School District are about to receive five percent across-the-board pay raises approved by the school board on December 19.
The revenue for the pay hikes will come from money coming to the district by way of Proposition 30, which was approved by voters statewide in November.
While many parents in the district and others expressed concern that the district should use the entirety of the Proposition 30 windfall for education improvements such as class size reductions, reading programs, library enlargement, increasing electives at the high school, buying books for the middle and elementary school libraries, increasing Regional Occupational Program classes at the high school, and rehiring previously laid off teacher aides at the elementary level, district superintendent Mike Davitt said the district could legally utilize the money for upping teacher salaries despite the way in which Proposition 30’s promoters had emphasized in ads that went to voters that the proposition was intended to shore up educational resources that had been cut back because of the statewide budget crunch.
Davitt said teachers deserved the raises the district is now able to give them, since they have stuck by the district over the last four years when raises could not be afforded.
Nearly half of the Proposition 30 money, which is to come from temporary tax increases, will be utilized for yet-to-be-determined school improvement programs.

Diesel Injection Service Moves to Colton And Remains in Enterprise Zone

On Saturday January 19, Diesel Injection Service will commemorate its relocation to Colton within the San Bernardino Valley Enterprise Zone with a grand opening celebration from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Colton Mayor Sarah Zamora, Councilmember Isaac Suchil, the Colton Chamber of Commerce and company officials are scheduled to christen the new facility, located at 1690 Ashley Way in Colton with a ribbon cutting. K-Frog 95.1 FM will host a live remote broadcast as the official emcee of the celebration, which will include music, food, raffle prizes and exhibit booths for the local community to come out and enjoy. Many local residents are expected to attend.
Established in San Bernardino in 1951, Diesel Injection Service is a Southern California leader in commercial and non-commercial diesel fuel injection pumps, injectors and other performance products. To accommodate recent growth, the company expanded into the new 22,000-square-foot facility off the I-215 late last year.
In addition to freeway visibility and proximity to clientele, Diesel Injection Service selected the site to remain in the enterprise zone. The company currently employs 17 service, sales and administrative workers and will pursue the enterprise zone program as a tool to hire more employees as growth permits.
The new facility features a 5,500 square-foot showroom, a 3,300 square-foot injection pump and injector department and a 6,700 square-foot fleet service department. As an authorized Bosch drive-in diagnostics and repair service center, Diesel Injection Service also offers fleet services.
The San Bernardino Valley Enterprise Zone is one of 40 existing enterprise zones established by the California Department of Housing and Community Development to encourage investment, growth, development and job creation in economically distressed areas of the state. The enterprise zone program grants employers tax credits and incentives for pro-growth business investments that improve economic activity within designated zone areas.
The San Bernardino Valley Enterprise Zone is located in Southern California and includes the city of Colton, city of San Bernardino and unincorporated portions of San Bernardino County.  In addition to the tax incentive it offers, the San Bernardino Valley Enterprise Zone also features a highly developed network of road, rail and air transportation infrastructure, a skilled and educated workforce, affordable commercial and residential real estate, and many other pro-business programs that make the area a highly competitive location for business. Those wanting more information about the San Bernardino Valley Enterprise Zone can find it at www.SBVEZ.com.

Rialto Lowers Bloomington Residents’ Wastewater Treatment Rates

Bloomington residents who receive sewer service from the city of Rialto will no longer pay three times the standard rate, beginning the first billing cycle of 2013.
During a Dec. 11, 2012 public hearing, the Rialto City Council approved recommendations from the Rialto Utilities Commission which included reducing the 300 percent extra-territorial sewer fee to 130 percent of the standard rate.
In the months leading to the decision, San Bernardino County conferred with the city of Rialto to resolve the issue that affects over 100 Bloomington residences.
“I want to thank the city of Rialto for its leadership and cooperation with the county of San Bernardino in considering a fair approach to managing sewer rates for unincorporated residents,” wrote 5th District Supervisor Josie Gonzales in a letter to Bloomington residents.
Eric Scott, member of Bloomington’s Municipal Advisory Committee, is one resident who will see an average sewer bill savings of $55.18 per month in 2013.
“[Bloomington residents] I’ve spoken with are quite relieved. The original proposed rate increase was substantial, and would have severely impacted Bloomington families. This demonstrates the importance of clear and consistent communication between Bloomington and her neighbors, including Rialto,” said Scott.
Following the council’s decision, Rialto Mayor Deborah Robertson said, “The city council recognized this was an important issue for residents in the Bloomington area who had previously paid three times the standard sewer rates for their service.”
Recommendations were also approved to apply all previous “standby” charges paid by property owners located within the city of Rialto as a credit to currently owed sewer connection fees.

Board’s Charter Selection Ratifies Parent Union Group’s School Takeover

ADELANTO–The Adelanto Elementary School District’s board voted unanimously January 8 to approve converting severely underperforming Desert Trails Elementary School into a charter academy, more than 20 months after a group of parents at the school launched a school takeover bid using California’s new and controversial parent trigger law.
The school board’s acceptance of LaVerne Preparatory Academy as the operator of Desert Trails beginning next September prepares the way for the first ever full employment of the Parent Empowerment Act, authored by former state senator Gloria Romero and passed by the legislature in 2010. The Parent Empowerment Act  enables a majority of parents at a school at which students score  as low-performers on state academic tests to force a district to implement significant reforms, ranging from replacing the principal and up to half the staff to reopening the school as a charter academy. That process is known by the colloquialism “parent trigger.”
The school board’s endorsement of the takeover plan is a reversal of the initial resistance the district administration and school board made to the parent trigger effort.
Pursuant to the Parent Empowerment Act, a parent union was formed by parents at Desert Trails Elementary in 2011, in large measure at the instigation of the Los Angeles-based nonprofit Parent Revolution, which is devoted to challenging the traditional authority of school districts.
On January 12, 2012 the parent union submitted 466 signatures on petitions asking the district to undertake a set of what the parents union maintained would  be reforms at the academically challenged  school.
Those petitions, which called upon the district to sack the school’s principal, David Mobley, and surrender to the school’s parents authority in hiring his successor, infuse in the new principal hiring authority for the school’s faculty, reduce class sizes and increase the number of school days and instructional hours, and include more science, history and art in the curriculum, were sufficient to meet the requirements of the Parent Empowerment Act, parent union members believed. The parent union subsequently modified that agenda to request that the school be converted to a charter academy, offering an intensified curriculum.
A group of parents opposed to the parent takeover of the school formed and went to work obtaining rescissions of many of the signatures on the petitions.
In February 2012, the school district, to whom the parent trigger petitions had been entrusted, announced that it had validated the signatures of only 301 of the 466 signatures on the petitions and declared that the parent trigger petitions were thus 20 signatures short of the 321 needed. The Desert Trails Parent Union, represented by Mark Holscher, a lawyer with the firm on retainer with Parent Revolution, Los Angeles-based Kirkland & Ellis, on April 5, 2012 on behalf of five of the members of the parents union – Doreen Diaz, Kathy Duncan, Teresa Rogers, Olivia Zamarripa and Bartola Del Villar – filed a petition for a writ of mandate and a complaint in Victorville Superior Court seeking a court order that the district verify the signatures and allow the Parent Trigger process to advance.
Holscher maintained that the district did not make an impartial tally of the signatures and “engaged in a systematic effort to invalidate the petitions.”
Judge Steve Malone, to whom the case was assigned, restored 97 of the signatures tossed out by the district. Malone ruled last summer that the district did not have the authority or a basis in law to discount signatures that proponents gathered and the district had abused its discretion in doing so. “Once the petition was submitted, the district and the trustees lacked authority to reject 97 signatures from the petition based on subsequent extrinsic evidence of rescission,” Malone ruled.  “The district and trustees have a mandatory legislative duty to include those signatures.”
By his ruling Malone raised the number of qualified signatures to well above 50 percent. He ordered the Adelanto Elementary School District to accept the petition as filed by the parent union within 30 days and seek proposals from charter school operators to take over Desert Trails.
Even so, the district balked at the parent union’s proposed direction, and delays prevented the school district from converting Desert Trails Elementary into a charter school at the initiation of the 2012-13 academic year in September. In the same time frame, the district’s superintendent, Darin Brawley, resigned. The leaders of the parent union considered several charter school proposals and in October gravitated toward and then chose LaVerne Preparatory Academy, which is operated by Debra Tarver in Hesperia.
LaVerne Preparatory Academy scored among the highest ranking schools in San Bernardino County on Academic Performance tests administered to the state’s schools and school districts, registering 911 out of 1,000 on what is known as the Academic Performance Index. In San Bernardino County, the average index is 767. Desert Trails this fall scored 699 on that index.
By its 4-0 vote, the school board agreed to have the district relinquish control of the campus to LaVerne Preparatory for a three-year period after the current school year ends in June. Tarver and her faculty will move into the Desert Trails this summer.
At the school board meeting on Tuesday, most of the parents in attendance were in a triumphant, almost giddy mood as a result of the board’s action.
For the last seven years, Desert Trails students have had the lowest scores within the district on state standardized academic tests. The school’s students have also collectively scored in the bottom 10 percent of all California elementary schools. In the school’s 2011 graduating sixth grade class 72 percent of students were not proficient with the English language and 70 percent were not proficient in math. Two-thirds of last year’s crop of graduating sixth-graders were unable to read or do math at grade level. Since 2007 Desert Trails has been classified as a failing school. Parents and school board members expressed hope that Tarver and LaVerne Preparatory would be able to apply their formula to bring the school’s students up to par with the norm.
Yet there is remaining skepticism that the parent trigger process in general and in particular the way it is being applied in Adelanto will have the salutary effect that is hoped for. Indeed, there have already been indications that Tarver will experience a severe challenge in uprating academic performance at Desert Trails.
A central component of Tarver’s approach is engaging parents in their children’s educational process.  Whether Tarver can achieve that component at Desert Trails is under question. Whereas 466 parents at the school signed the petition to move forward with the parent trigger process in late 2011 and January 2012, when the parents union held its election in October 2012 to determine which of the charter schools that had submitted proposals should be chosen to educate their children, only 53 parents participated in that vote. Moreover, a significant number of the students at Desert Trails Elementary have parents whose first language is not English and nearly all of the instructional materials used by Tarver and LaVerne Preparatory are in English.
Board president Christine Turner said that nonetheless she is “hopeful” LaVerne Preparatory will be able to turn the situation at Desert Trails around.