Supervisors To Decide If Ramos Will Get Airport Board Berths Next Week

The nearly  two-month-long delay in the appointment of a key member of the boards overseeing the development at and around San Bernardino International Airport  could end next week.
The San Bernardino International Airport Authority is chartered to oversee the conversion of what was formerly Norton Air Force Base to a civilian airport. The Inland Valley Development Authority is an agency devoted to the redevelopment of property around the airport. The airport authority, known by its acronym SBIAA, is a joint powers authority involving the county of San Bernardino and the cities of San Bernardino, Loma Linda, Colton and Highland. Its sister agency, known as IVDA, is made up of the same entities with the exception of Highland.
Since their inceptions, SBIAA and IVDA have had as their county representatives the Fifth and Third District supervisors. In November, former Third District Supervisor Neil Derry was ousted by challenger James Ramos. In December, after Ramos was sworn in as supervisor and elevated to that office and Derry simultaneously left it, vacancies on the IVDA and SBIAA boards ensued, as appointments to those positions are not automatically made but rather are voted upon by the board of supervisors.
Notably, the board did not move to substitute Ramos in as one of the county’s two SBIAA and IVDA representatives upon his succeeding Derry as supervisor.  Thus, during December and at the IVDA board meeting on January 9 and the SBIAA board meeting on January 23, Fifth District supervisor Josie Gonzales was the only county representative on those boards eligible to participate.
The delay in filling the gaps created by Derry’s departure appears to revolve around legal questions concerning Ramos’s ability to assume the SBIAA and IVDA board positions and vote on matters that come before those entities.
Two law firms, Los Angeles-based Prata & Daley and Sacramento-based DLA Piper, have authored briefs asserting that Ramos cannot take on the IVDA or SBIAA board posts without running afoul of the law.
In their briefs,  Prata & Daley and DLA Piper propound the theory that Ramos’s personal financial interests at the former Norton Air Force Base and any role he would assume with regard to directing IVDA and especially SBIAA as a board member bring him head on into a clash with California Government Code Sections 1090 and 1092.
Ramos is a member of and the former chairman of the San Manuel Band of Mission Indians, which operates a casino on its reservation in Highland. That casino generates roughly $400 million in gambling and other proceeds per year. As one of 167 tribal members, Ramos is the recipient of an annual stipend of over $1 million and he owns a share of the investments the tribe makes collectively. Among the tribe’s investments and holdings are properties and other assets within the purview of the Inland Valley Development Authority. Even more pointedly, the tribe has made purchases of property and facilities located on the former Air Force Base. The tribe now owns the areas of the one-time military installation that were used for on-base housing and the facility and property occupied by the U.S. Air Force Combat Camera Operation.
The tribe further is currently party to an agreement with Majestic Realty to develop the former base housing property.
Intrinsic to the conflict highlighted by Prata & Daley and DLA Piper is the convergence of the San Manuel Tribe’s real estate holdings and the authority of IVDA and SBIAA. Government Code Section 1090 prohibits an elected official from participating in any decision or vote, the outcome of which will have an impact on his personal financial circumstance.
It is Prata & Daley’s contention, as it is that of DLA Piper, that given the degree to which the prospects for the growth in the valuation or viability of some of the tribe’s assets and holdings are subject to the direct or indirect control of the IVDA and SBIAA boards, Ramos will have, as a SBIAA or IVDA board member, an unequivocal conflict given the degree to which his material financial interests can be impacted by his decisions in office. These conflicts will be so substantial, according to Prata & Daley, that they will be incapable of being cured by either recusal or abstention.
Under California law, an elected official can involve himself in the governmental decision making process if his interests to be impacted by those decisions are deemed remote. With regard to Ramos and the tribe’s property at, near and around San Bernardino International Airport, however, Ramos’s interests are not remote, but material as the law specifies, according to both Prata & Daley and DLA Piper. As such, any decision affecting the wealth of the tribe impacts Ramos’s interests, such that, according to the law firms, Ramos cannot be installed as an IVDA or SBIAA board member.
The Sentinel’s inquiries made of both San Bernardino County Chief Executive Officer Greg Devereux and San Bernardino County’s senior in-house lawyer, County Counsel Jean-René Basle, with regard to the dilemma presented by Ramos’s financial interests at the airport went unanswered as of press time.
According to the clerk of the board of supervisors, Laura Welch, there will be an item on the January 29 board agenda pertaining to the appointment or reappointment of SBIAA and IVDA board members. The full agenda was not available for release at press time, being scheduled for posting at 5 p.m. today, January 25.
There was no indication whether the item called specifically for the appointment of Ramos to the IVDA and SBIAA boards or whether appointing one of the other supervisors – either First District Supervisor Robert Lovingood, Second District Supervisor Janice Rutherford or Fourth District Supervisor Gary Ovitt – was being contemplated. San Bernardino International Airport lies well beyond the First, Second and Fourth Districts.
County spokesperson David Wert bypassed making a substantive response to the gist of the Prata & Daley and DLA Piper briefs, saying he was unaware of any conflicts, potential or real, besetting Ramos in his capacity as supervisor.
Wert indicated that on January 29, Ramos will be appointed to both the SBIAA and IVDA boards.
“I have not heard that the appointments will be made any differently than they have been done in the past,” Wert said.
While the appointment of a full complement of decision makers on the SBIAA and IVDA boards is pending, the airport’s management team, headed by executive director A.J. Wilson, is engaged in an effort to revitalize the facility in the wake of a scandal that involved the airport’s contract developer, Scot Spencer. Spencer, an airline industry insider who was hired on the basis of his perceived ability to bring in airlines and aviation-related companies as tenants, instead used his position to extend favorable contracts and leases at the airport to companies he owned or had an interest in. SBIAA  reassessed its relationship with Spencer after a scathing grand jury report of his management of the facility was released in June 2011 and the FBI in September 2011 served search warrants seeking evidence of  bribery, conspiracy, money laundering and fraudulent use of federal funds at SBIAA headquarters and the offices of companies controlled by Spencer at the airport.
SBIAA, now being guided by Wilson, has terminated nearly all of its contracts with Spencer and is  undertaking an effort to market the facility to developers, entrepreneurs, aeronautics and aerospace companies and logistics and transportation service providers.

CRMC Sale Escrow Date Extended

NEEDLES—As determined as ever to unburden the city of the financial liability of operating the Colorado River Medical Center, the Needles City Council in recent weeks has taken several steps to ensure the proposed buyer will be able to complete the deal.
On January 8, the city council extended Community Healthcare Partners Inc.’s escrow closing deadline for the hospital purchase. The council also removed two of the members of the hospital board of trustees.
The escrow extension provides Community Healthcare Partners with a further incentive to create  interim lease and management agreements for the operation of the hospital to further facilitate the transfer of responsibility over the institution. It was previously intended that Community Healthcare Partners would come into full possession of the hospital by now, but complications with regard to the transfer of the land upon which the hospital is located have delayed that.
Community Healthcare Partners, Inc. entered into a $2.577 million purchase agreement for the hospital on August 22, 2012 after a previous sale arrangement to non-profit Needles Hospital, Inc. fell through in April.
The city took back ownership of the Colorado River Medical Center in April 2008 after Brentwood, Tennessee-based Lifepoint Hospitals, a for-profit corporation which had obtained the hospital after the dissolution of the public hospital district that previously operated the facility, embarked on an effort to move the institution’s equipment and personnel to Valley View Hospital, another operation it owned in Arizona, roughly 12 miles from Needles.
Because of long-running inadequate billing practices, including failures to invoice Medicare and Medi-Cal as well as insurance companies and patients in a timely fashion, the hospital has lost money, representing a financial liability to the city. The city created the board of trustees to oversee the hospital, and that panel, together with the city council, has come to a consensus that spinning the facility off to an independent operator is the best solution for ensuring that the community has adequate medical care without soaking the taxpayers.
The purchase agreement with Community Healthcare Partners, Inc., which was founded by Bing Lum, called for an escrow closing deadline of January 3. The full application process for the land transfer has not been completed. The city holds title to the land as well as the hospital itself. However, the hospital was built on what had been Bureau of Land Management Property that had been transferred to the city of Needles under a proviso that the Bureau of Land Management retained a reversionary interest in the property allowing it to reclaim the land if the property is not used for what is deemed “a charitable purpose.”
Indications are that the full land transfer to Community Healthcare Partners will not take place until later this year.  Thus, January 3 came and went without Community Healthcare Partners closing escrow. However, according to city attorney John Pinkney, language in the original purchase agreement allows the January 3 escrow closing requirement to be eliminated based upon any government-related delays. That provision of the agreement was invoked and the council extended the escrow closing deadline to February 22.
The Bureau of Land Management is insisting an appraisal of the property be done at  Community Healthcare Partners, Inc.’s expense.
Lum indicated his company will carry out whatever needs to be done to effectuate the transfer and that Community Healthcare Partners, Inc. will proceed with each of the tenets of the August agreement. On the fly, Pinkney has crafted an arrangement by which Community Healthcare Partners is to acquire the hospital property as a land lease until the full transfer takes place. During the gap between the city’s reassignment of the hospital property to Community Healtcare Partners, Lum’s company will serve as the interim manager of the hospital. Community Healthcare Partners will not charge the city for its services in this regard and will instead realize revenue from the hospital’s operation just as if it owned it in full.
Pinkney is to streamline the process and draft the documents for the interim lease and management arrangement in such a way that it does not compromise the original sale agreement or the prospects of the Bureau of Land Management consenting to the land transfer. Community Healthcare Partners will hand over the lion’s share of the $2.577 million to the city to effectuate the hospital purchase to close escrow with the city, though a portion of the purchase price – pertaining to the land purchase – will be withheld. When BLM ratifies the land transfer, the additional money to equal the full $2.577 million will be paid to the city.
The hospital board of trustees joined with the council in the vote to undertake the arrangement and extend escrow to February 22.
The council at the same January 8 meeting on its own voted to remove hospital board members Jeff Williams and Dr. Robert Strecker, effective as of January 11. Williams, a former Needles mayor, and Strecker, a physician whose expertise in medical matters is valued but whose professional standing at times created financial conflicts that prevented him from participating in some votes, were replaced by Georgia Breault and Bob McKeever
The council has also instructed Jon Freeberg, the interim chief executive officer for the hospital, to look into fashioning a “fiduciary and accounting firewall” between the city and Colorado River Medical Center that would prevent financial liabilities at the hospital from having a deleterious impact upon the city’s economic circumstance. This so-called firewall is likely to consist of the city chartering a public corporation or hospital district to oversee the medical center.

R.C., Church, Diocese & Verizon Relent On Cell Tower Next To Playground

Verizon, The Diocese of San Bernardino, Sacred Heart Catholic Church and the city of Rancho Cucamonga have all made a strategic retreat in the face of parental opposition to the Rancho Cucamonga Planning Commission’s January 2012 approval of the placement of a cellular phone tower next to the playground of the Sacred Heart Parochial School.
All four entities have now agreed to instead place the soon-to-be-erected tower at the northern end of the church parking lot. Sacred Heart Church and its parochial school are located near the northeast corner of Foothill Blvd. and the I-15 Freeway.
Parents of students attending the school grew irate when they learned in November that the Diocese of San Bernardino and the church had closed a deal with Verizon to turn a profit by hosting the tower and had not consulted with or notified them before making that commitment. Some parents expressed concern that the tower’s electrical field could negatively impact the health of the students attending Sacred Heart.
Studies done in Scandinavia show a relation between the proximity of high intensity electrical fields and elevated levels of leukemia in children. Other studies completed at the University of Colorado at Boulder show that continuous exposure to electrical fields can have deleterious health consequences.
Verizon was faulted for considering locating the tower so close to where children congregate. The city of Rancho Cucamonga and its planning commission were criticized for approving the erection of the tower next to a school. The Diocese of San Bernardino and its bishop, Gerald Barnes, fell under criticism for their action in the matter. The diocese has staffed the parish with priests from Nigeria, who it has been alleged, were not sophisticated enough to recognize the potential for harm to the students posed by the cellular tower.
The parochial vicar at Sacred Heart, Father Augustine Amadi, referred questions about the circumstance to the church’s pastor, Father Benedict Nwachukwu-Udaku. Father Nwachukwu-Udaku was busy preparing for and celebrating Mass on Tuesday, January 22, was involved in a meeting at the diocese headquarters all day on January 23 and could not be reached despite more than a half dozen attempts on January 24.
A phone call to Bishop Gerald Barnes was referred to diocese spokesman John Andrews.
Andrews confirmed that proposals for the placement of the tower varied over time and that the city had a part in dictating the tower location that had led to the controversy.  “We were having informal discussions and in the process of that the setbacks became an issue for the city, so another location was selected and eventually approved,” he said. “That was not the first place it was going to be put.”
Andrews insisted the location approved by the planning commission last year was a suitable location that represented no health risk to Sacred Heart’s students.
“There is no way we would have agreed to put that there if we thought that location would be a health threat to the children or anyone else who would be on that property,” Andrews said. “The issue was studied and the conclusion was the emissions from the tower would be about ten times below the limit set by the Federal Communications Commission.”
As to the suggestion that Father Nwachukwu-Udaku’s naïveté had been exploited to the potential detriment of the children at the Sacred Heart Parochial School, Andrews said, “I think that is completely off base and insulting to the priest. If you know the pastor of the church, he is a brilliant man. He is a published writer and has several degrees. That is just a cheap shot. This decision was made before he became pastor by the man who was at that time serving as the pastoral coordinator of the church, who is no longer there.”
That the positioning of the planned tower is going to be modified, Andrews said, “is not a vindication of their [the complaining parents’] position [that the earlier intended location of the tower represented a health threat to their children].  You need to understand that we had made plans to expand the school and it was discovered at some point that where the tower was to be was in the footprint of where we want to expand.”
With regard to the parents’ concerns, he said, “While we did not feel there was any health threat to the children, the ministry of the parish and the school is to be hospitable and receptive to the concerns the members of church and the parents express.”

Crowe Back Aboard As Ontario-Montclair School District Trustee

ONTARIO–Sam Crowe has been returned to the Ontario-Montclair School Board, just two months after he was defeated for reelection.
On November 6, Crowe, an incumbent, captured 10,621 votes or 24.49 percent of the vote and was turned out of office by voters who selected J. Steve Garcia, who received 13,208 votes or 30.45 percent, and Maureen Mendoza, who received 11,638 votes or 26.83 percent. A fourth candidate, Elizabeth Ricci, received 7,903 votes or 18.22 percent.
On the same day, however, another incumbent who had two years remaining on his school board term, Paul Vincent Avila, was elected to the city council.
Avila’s departure created a vacancy, which last week the four members of the school board chose to fill. By a vote of 3-1, with Garcia dissenting, Crowe was selected to replace Avila.
The board, consisting of Kristen Brake, Elvia Rivas, Mendoza and Garcia interviewed Crowe and five other candidates – Robert Anthony Ortega, an 18-year-old student; Sandra Kaye Escamilla, a retired district employee; Flora Martinez, parent and community activist; and two college professors,  Michael Cory Flores and Joseph J. Laponis.
Crowe, who lives in Ontario,  was challenged by Garcia, who suggested that his defeat in November constituted a rejection by voters. Others, as well as Garcia, suggested that the board should select someone from Montclair to sit on the board, as currently all of the members are from Ontario. Moreover, it was alleged, it turned out inaccurately, that Crowe has a hidden agenda to terminate the district superintendent, James Hammond. In actuality, Crowe was a key supporter of Hammond’s hiring and the two had worked closely on district issues over the last two years.
Crowe, a lawyer who was formerly the city attorney in Ontario, Rancho Cucamonga and Hesperia, was on the Ontario City Council four decades ago. He commanded the respect of his fellow board members, who had elevated him to the position of board chairman. Over the last four years, Crowe had championed several education programs, including creating academic classes in science, history and mathematics that double as Spanish immersion classes for non-Spanish speaking students, revamping special education and including in that curriculum a cooking class for special education students, priority class selection for graduates of the Ontario-Montclair School District at several colleges, including Chaffey College, Cal State San Bernardino, Cal State Bakersfield, Cal Poly and the University of La Verne, and a program to teach English, math and computer skills to the parents in the district who do not speak English.
Crowe, as a well-established local attorney long involved with the Inland Empire’s business community, had also founded a nonprofit corporation dedicated to raising money for scholarships for district students.
A program Crowe was pursuing but had not completed when he was defeated in November was a joint educational class involving a video link-up with instructors and students in Africa.
Crowe’s appointment was supported by the Ontario-Montclair Teachers Association and the Ontario-Montclair Classified Employees.
“We welcome Mr. Crowe back,” said school board president Rivas.

Four Dems And Two GOPs In Special 32nd District Race

Four Democrats and two Republicans have filed candidacy papers in the special March 12 election to replace Gloria Negrete-McLeod as state senator in the Democratic-leaning 32nd District.
Negrete-McLeod, who was elected to a four-year state senate term in 2010, successfully ran for Congress last year against incumbent Joe Baca in the newly redrawn 35th Congressional District. She resigned as state senator to go to Washington, D.C.
Because of the voter registration advantage Democrats hold over Republicans in the 32nd District, it is widely assumed Negrete-McLeod’s successor will be a Democrat. But the catfight that is brewing between at least two of the four Democrats, along with the larger number of Democrats vying overall, raises the possibility that a Republican could emerge victorious.
If one candidate fails to garner a majority of the vote – meaning at least fifty percent plus one vote on March 12 – then a run-off between the two top vote-getters will be held.
The four Democrats in the race are Assemblywoman Norma Torres, San Bernardino County Auditor-Controller-Treasurer Larry Walker, Ontario Councilman Paul Vincent Avila and Rialto Unified School District Board Member Joanne Gilbert. The two Republicans are Ontario Mayor Paul Leon and Pomona Planning Commissioner Ken Coble.
Already, a rivalry between Torres and Walker has developed over the circumstances that brought Walker into the race. He was, essentially, recruited by Negrete-McLeod to run, it has been reported, to prevent Torres from stepping into Negrete-McLeod’s shoes. Torres, who was formerly the mayor of Pomona, offended Negrete-McLeod when she endorsed Baca in last year’s Congressional race. Baca, like Negrete-McLeod is a Democrat.
Reportedly, Negrete-McLeod is in the process of making money remaining in her state electioneering fund available to Walker, himself a former county supervisor and Chino mayor. It thus appears that Walker and Torres will be better funded than Avila or Gilbert. Both Leon and Coble are looking forward to the prospect of a knockdown drag-out fight between Walker and Torres involving multiple negative ads targeting one another that might have the effect of dividing the Democratic camp and vectoring some of the Democratic vote toward Avila and/or Gilbert. In this way, the prospect of Leon and Coble, the two Republicans in the field, qualifying for the run-off could be increased.
Avila, a former Ontario-Montclair School Board member who was elected to the city council in November, has cultivated significant name recognition among voters by running for office, sometimes successfully and sometimes unsuccessfully, consistently each election cycle for the last 20 years. Coble vied unsuccessfully against Torres for her current assembly position. Should Torres, Walker, Leon, Avila or Gilbert win, their victories will likely result in the need for another election to fill the vacancy that will be created by that victor’s leaving of the office he or she presently holds.
The 32nd District entails all of Pomona in Los Angeles County, and all of Bloomington, Fontana, Montclair, Muscoy, Ontario, and Rialto as well as parts of Colton and San Bernardino in San Bernardino County. It is a peculiarity of the California electoral process that the lines of some State Senate districts remain intact four years after the U.S. Census is conducted while others change two years after the census is completed. In the case of the 32nd District, its boundaries, drawn up after the 2000 Census, will remain until the four year term that Negrete-McLeod was elected to in 2010 elapses.

Two November Candidates Among Four Current Chino Hills Hopefuls

Two of the four candidates vying to replace Wilburn “Bill” Kruger on the Chino Hills City Council in the upcoming special mail-ballot election were candidates in the just concluded November 2012 city council election.
Both Rossana Mitchell, an attorney, and Ray Marquez, a retired firefighter and current real estate broker, were among the five candidates in the November race, in which two positions were at stake. Art Bennett and Cynthia Moran prevailed in that contest. Two months before the election, Kruger abruptly resigned, creating a vacancy that could not be filled by appointment. That was because at that time, two of the incumbents – Bennett and Gwen Norton Perry – had themselves been appointed to the council in 2008 when they had been the only candidates in the race and the city council had decided to forego the election and elevate them by fiat. A state law prohibits a majority of the members of what is normally an elected body from being appointed.
Kruger’s September resignation had come too late to schedule the special election to select his  replacement to coincide with the general election last November. His unfinished term is set to expire in 2014.
Rather than hold an election administered by the county registrar of voters at the city’s normal precinct polling places that would cost in excess of $200,000, the council has opted to hold the mail-in polling on March 5, at a cost of $135,000.
Mitchell attended and graduated from John Rowland High School and UC Irvine, where she majored in Social Ecology. She graduated from Western State University of Law. She is a practicing attorney. Divorced, she has two children. She has lived in Chino Hills for 22 years.  She previously served on the Chino Hills City Council, having won a special election to replace James Thalman after his death in 2003. The following year, she lost to Kurt Hagman. Mitchell has also served four years on the Chino Valley Unified School Board.
“I think one of the major challenges the city council has is building our economic base,” Mitchell told the Sentinel in September. “We’ve brought some good businesses in but we need to bring more small businesses into the community, which will bring in jobs for our city. We also have to retain our rural atmosphere. We have been good at preserving our rolling hills. When it comes to zoning, we need to look at the densities and how many homes should be built in any given area.  We want a balance. We want to keep the rolling hills but bring in a sufficient economic base so we can prosper.”
Mitchell said she believed the council had erred when it had taken property that was traditionally zoned institutional and rezoned it to multi-dwelling. She said the city should no longer count  on developer fees as a major source of revenue and that upping density for a short term influx of cash would have untoward long-term consequences for the community.
“I do not believe it was proper for that property to be rezoned multdwelling,” Mitchell said. “That decision will come back to haunt us every time someone wants to build apartments in the city. The city was built along the lines of a certain vision and philosophy. That is being challenged now. We need people on the council who will stand firm and not sway. When Chino Hills was incorporated, it relied heavily on developer fees. Now, as we are getting closer to build-out, those developer fees are starting to decrease and there is pressure to change density and allow more intense development. There is a conflict because the city wants funding from the development. I think we need a council that will stand firm when it comes to our philosophy. We have always maintained a family-oriented, rural community. We have maintained that balance, but in the last year-and-a-half there have been decisions that reverse that.”
Mitchell maintains that her previous experience on the council, her experience on the school board which oversees a larger budget than that of the city and her legal acumen render her the most qualified in  the field of candidates.
Marquez is a graduate of John Glenn High School in Norwalk and he attended Rio Hondo, Cerritos and Pasadena City colleges, where he studied fire science. Married with three children, he has lived in Chino Hills since 1984. Marquez is a retired firefighter who worked for 28 years with the Santa Fe Springs Fire Department. He is currently on the Chino Valley Independent Fire District’s board of directors.
In 1990 and 1991, Marquez was  involved in the Chino Hills incorporation drive,  and was appointed to the city’s first planning commission, serving on it for one term. He served three terms on the city’s park and recreation commission. An airport commissioner for San Bernardino County, Marquez serves on the advisory council for the Frontera Women’s Prison. He is also on two state legislative committees, the California Special District Legislative Committee and the California Special District Finance Committee.
“I am concerned about community facilities districts, which are entities that exist to provide services and infrastructure,” Marquez told the Sentinel last year.  “When a developer comes in, they spend money to put in things and we have to pay them back, so the city forms a district to do that. There are assessments the residential property owners pay over 20 to 25 years. Chino Hills has millions of dollars going into these CFDs [community facilities districts]. There is an overhead that pays certain city department staff salaries. My concern is about the impact on the general fund budget once the assessments expire and the revenue no longer exists and we have to come up with new income or lay off people. I want us to think about that before it happens.”
“Another main concern I have is open space in Chino Hills and what is going to happen to it,” Marquez said. “I know that right now city officials are trying to figure out a way to make money as revenue sources are drying up. They are figuring on ways of selling off that open space. I think we have to keep our open space, keep it as oak trees and rolling hills covered with grass. I don’t want it to become windmills or solar panels or even orchards.”
Marquez said he merits serious consideration by the voters of Chino Hills because “experience counts. If you look at any of the others, seriously look at all of the others, they have no more experience, meaningful experience, than I do. I can bring that experience to bear on issues that the city faces,” he said. “We have to go to work on revising the city’s general plan. We want to provide better customer service for the community. We have issues with pension reform.”
The recipient of a hefty public agency, taxpayer-supported pension himself, Marquez said he has the stature to bring about change. “I think pension reform needs to be done. We need to set aside money to offset future expenses. We did a lot of pension reform when I was president of the firefighters union in Santa Fe Springs. We need to get rid of many existing retirement benefits for new employees. If we are carrying extra people, we can go to fewer employees, since paying overtime to our other employees will not entail greater pension costs down the road.”  In his advocating of  pension reform, however, Marquez stopped short of endorsing a proposal of having current pension recipients unilaterally give back or surrender a percentage of their entitlements.
Debra Kay Hernandez attended Pasadena Community College, where she studied economics and business law. She is married with one daughter and has been a Chino Hills resident  since 1995. She is employed as a certificated facilities manager. Hernandez is the chairwoman of the Chino Hills Public Works Commission. She is also a member of the Chino Hills Community Foundation, a charter member of the Citizens for the Alternate Routing of Electricity (CARE), which has evolved into the grassroots group Hope for the Hills, and a member of the Friends of the Chino Hills Library. She recently has been active in the opposition to the maternity hotels established in Chino Hills, specifically with the group NotInChinoHills.org.
With regard to Southern California Edison’s approved but now suspended plan to utilize 197-foot-high towers to convey electricity from the Tehachapi Renewable Energy Project across Chino Hills, Hernandez told Chino Hills.com, “This isn’t just a battle for Chino Hills. It is a battle for communities across the United States. It is a precedent-setting project that allows far too high a level of electricity in too small a right-of-way. If they do it in Chino Hills, they are setting a precedent to do it anywhere they want.”
She said she will embody “an independent voice and common sense leadership” on the city council if elected.
Twenty-six-year-old Jesse Singh has lived 22 years in Chino Hills. A UCLA graduate who completed law school at Loyola and is now a practicing attorney, Singh said that if elected to the city council he will strive to “practice strong financial stewardship that acknowledges both our long and short-term financial goals and utilizes innovative ideas to increase city revenue without penalizing current or future residents, ensure the availability of resources and programs for our schools and police and fire personnel so that they can carry out services vital to our city, and protect our open spaces and public land without impeding quality and sustainable development.”
Singh further stated he will “champion residents’ property rights, including those impacted by the unprecedented, proposed power lines and improve infrastructure to meet the needs of our residents and businesses and explore strategies for effective infrastructure-sharing.”
He said he will “promote small business growth by streamlining certain processes, actively recruiting quality businesses, and opening channels of communication between local government and businesses. I want to facilitate the growth of our city and preserve our resources through collaborative efforts within our city and with surrounding municipalities.”

Kelly To Exit As County’s Top Planning Official

San Bernardino County Land Use Services Director Christine Kelly will retire, effective March 15, twenty-five months after she assumed the position of the top planning official overseeing building and development in the unincorporated county areas.
Kelly was the city of Chino Hills’ development director when she was hired by the county in February 2011.  Kelly had drafted much of the city of Ontario’s current general plan while she was working for a consulting firm that provides planning and economic development guidance and assistance to cities.
Previously, Kelly had 18 years experience in the planning, community development and building divisions in the cities of Pomona, Brea and Cypress.
The County of San Bernardino Land Use Services Department includes the divisions of current planning, advanced planning, building and safety, code enforcement, and environmental health services.

Amidst Heavy Local Opposition, County Okays Joshua Tree Dollar General

SAN BERNARDINO—Over the organized vocal protests of more than four dozen opponents, the San Bernardino County Planning Commission last week voted 4-1 to give approval for a conditional use permit of a 9.100-square foot Dollar General store at the corner of Twentynine Palms Highway and Sunburst Avenue in Joshua Tree.
Gus Romo and Ernie Perea, planners with the county’s department of land use services, recommended that the commission approve Dynamic Development’s conditional use permit application, asserting that the 1.45 acre site is compatible from a land use standpoint with the applicant’s plans.
“Surrounding land uses consist of single-family residential uses located within commercial zoning to the south across 29 Palms Highway, single-family residential uses within multi-family zoning to the north across Commercial Street, vacant commercial land to the east across Sunburst Avenue, and vacant commercial land to the west across Mountain View Street,” Romo and Perea told the planning commission in their report and recommendation with regard to the proposal. “This area of 29 Palms Highway is designated for commercial development and intended to cater to pedestrian and vehicular traffic. The project is considered a general retail use permitted within the Joshua Tree Commuity Plan zoning designation subject to approval of a use permit. Therefore, the proposed development and retail use are considered compatible with the surounding land uses and general plan land use designations.”
For months, however, local residents have been militating aginst the project proposal, objecting to the imposition of corporate “cookie cutter” forms in the rural desert area, resulting in the county land use services division upping the “minor” permit required of Dynamic Development to a conditional use permit. The project opposition culminated in the public comment period for the January 17 hearing before the county planning commission. That opposition included residents, property owners and business operators from the Joshua Tree community.
Peggy Kennedy said that the project was “inconsistent with the goals and policies in our Joshua Tree Community Plan” and that assertions the store would elevate the local economy were specious, given Dollar General’s reputation for providing minimum wage employment and no benefits, as she said was documented in complaints lodged with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.
Levon Kazarian, the owner of Crossroads Café said the advent of corporate retailers in Joshua Tree would ring the death knell of the community’s “unique rural character” and damage the viability of the traditional businesses that have maintained a rustic desert aesthetic. “I think the more chain stores you bring in, even with western architecture, you start to dilute the unique character,” he said.
Tom O’Key, who owns 20 commercially zoned acres in Joshua Tree, said the county should perpetuate the non-corporate ethos of the business community rather than forcing it to end with the approval of the Dollar General, which he called “an abomination.” He said the county’s land use services division was not applying the desert community’s standards to the development of the area and was instead using citified standards where they were not appropriate.
“You don’t know what a gem we’ve got,” O’Key told the planning commission “If I wanted, I could put 17 of these stores on my land and the zoning would permit me to do it, but I would never even consider it.”
One area resident, Julian Gonzales, called the opponents a bunch of namby-pamby  “imbecilic personalities” consumed by a “not in my back yard” mentality.  He accused them of being anti-growth. Gonzales said the Dollar General would be a convenience to local residents and would represent a positive economic step for the community. “If you don’t move forward, you die,” said Gonzales.
Mark Ostoich, an attorney representing Dynamic Development, said the project met all the criteria of an acceptable property use. Romo said the Dollar General was “not a big box retailer” and as such was of the sort and intensity of use that would blend well with the town’s rural atmosphere. While Romo acknowledged that the store did not appear to be favored by a majority of the residents in Joshua Tree, he said the project complies with the county’s development code and its standards and there was not sufficient evidence of harm to the community or a meaningful clash with the  Joshua Tree Community Plan to prevent the  Dollar General from being approved.
For the Dollar General Corp., which is based in Goodlettsville, Tennessee, locating in Joshua Tree is part of a larger business strategy. It has established a Dollar General store in Yucca Valley and has already obtained approval for a Dollar General store in Twentynine Palms. Having three stores along State Route 62 will create a synergy and economy of scale with regard to supply and delivery, corporate officers believe.
Opponents said they plan to appeal the Planning Commission’s decision, sending the final review of the project to the board of supervisors.

Rialto City Council Unable To Agree On Vacancy Appointment

RIALTO—The Rialto City Council was not able to reach a consensus on an appointment to fill in the void created when Deborah Robertson was elected mayor in November with two years remaining on the council term she was elected to in 2010.
Robertson defeated incumbent councilman Ed Scott, whose council term elapsed in December, after both vied for the position formerly held by Grace Vargas, who chose not to seek reelection. The council considered several candidates, including two who were nominated and seconded and two who were nominated but failed to receive seconds.
Councilman Ed Palmer made a motion to appoint former councilwoman Lynn Hirtz. Councilman Shawn O’Connell seconded that motion, but neither councilman Joe Baca, Jr. nor Robertson supported that choice.
Baca then nominated Rafael Trujillo, a member of the city’s Parks and Recreation Commission who had run for council in November but was edged out by Palmer and O’Connell. Robertson seconded that motion but both Palmer and O’Connell refused to endorse Trujillo.
Robertson then nominated Melissa Morrison, who did not garner a second. She then offered Dennis Barton as an alternative candidate, but that motion likewise died for the lack of a second.
Notably, no one considered Scott, who was a fixture on the council for 20 years.
The five member panel thus remains one member short. Three options remain: finding by February 9 a candidate at least three of the council members can support, allowing Governor Jerry Brown to make an appointment or holding an election, at a likely cost of more than $250,000 in the city with a population of 99,171, to choose a new council member.

SoCal Edison Won’t Underground Power Lines Through Oak Tree Downs

Southern California Edison has not prepared plans to underground that portion of the Tehachapi Renewable Energy Project power line  through the Oak Tree Downs area of Carbon Canyon at the  west extension of Chino Hills, according to an application on file with the California Public Utilities Commission (PUC).
Over the city of Chino Hills’ protest, Southern California Edison obtained permission from the PUC in 2009 to proceed with the Tehachapi line to include 197-foot high towers to support high tension 500 kilowatt lines carrying electricity generated at what is to be the world’s largest wind farm in Kern County to the Los Angeles Basin. After further legal challenge by the city which ended in West Valley Superior Court Judge Keith Davis ruling the project could proceed, Edison erected 15 of the towers through Chino Hills. The PUC led by chairman Michael Peevey, however, in November 2011 ordered work on the towers to cease while alternatives to the above ground placement of the towers through Chino Hills were considered by Edison.
On December 18, 2012 Southern California Edison through its lawyer Laura Godfrey applied with the PUC for permission to proceed with that portion of the project that “would not be affected by the potential underground construction,” which is identified as the Oak Tree Downs area, where the master plan provides for  custom homes on large residential lots. That roughly 1.5-mile span into Carbon Canyon represents thirty percent of the five mile portion of the Tehachapi line through Chino Hills.
Previously, it was assumed that Southern California Edison was being compelled by the PUC to draw up an undergrounding alternative for the full five miles. The December 18 filing reveals that the undergrounding alternative, the precise details of which have yet to be fully made public, will run only 70 percent – 3.5 of the five miles –  of the way through the incorporated portion of Chino Hills. The line runs another eight-tenths of a mile through Chino Hills’ designated sphere of influence. Notably, Edison had given earlier cryptic reference to its intention to proceed with the erection of towers in Oak Tree Downs, such as when it placed before public officials calculations of undergrounding costs that pertained to just 3.5 miles.
The city of Chino Hills in response to Edison’s December 18 filing asked the PUC to delay the construction resumption through Oak Tree Downs until the entire issue with regard to the undergrounding of the lines through the city is resolved.
On January 8, CPUC Administrative Law Judge Jean Vieth turned back Edison’s request to allow the work in Oak Tree Downs to proceed immediately, directing the utility to confer with Chino Hills officials to clarify what efforts will be made to mitigate the impact of the towers. This gives Chino Hills officials and Oak Tree Downs residents an opportunity to importune the PUC for reconsideration.
Many Chino Hills homeowners are wary of potentially significant negative impacts the towers will have on property values in the city. That concern was shared by the Chino Hills City Council, which authorized the expenditure of over $2.3 million to employ attorneys and make other efforts to contest the Public Utility Commission’s action in permitting the towers to be erected. That effort included a suit against Southern California Edison alleging the company had “overburdened” the power line easements. That legal effort failed when Judge Davis ruled the California Public Utilities Commission has exclusive jurisdiction regarding the route used by Edison.
Edison has long had a 150-foot-wide right-of-way for its power lines through upscale Chino Hills from Tonner Canyon to the Riverside County line. In 2011, Edison erected 15 of the towers within the heart of the city before Peevey imposed a moratorium on further erection activity in the city. On November 15, Peevey asked Edison to provide the commission by December 3 with a detailed report cataloging the costs and scope of the materials and service contracts associated with the undergrounding alternatives, along with Edison’s cost recovery proposals.
Edison, which has been tasked by Peevey to provide its assessment of undergrounding options  by February 28, 2013, previously calculated the cost of trenching out a six-foot wide and six-foot deep, 3.5-mile long swath through town and undergrounding a single line to be $300 million to $473 million, and undergrounding a double-circuit line to be $703 million to $1 billion. In early December, the company revised those figures to $486 million to $807 million. Edison maintains it could erect the towers along the same span and string the cables between them for an estimated $172 million.
Some of those opposed to the placement of the towers in Chino Hills have questioned the undergrounding cost figures, calling them inflated.
Of some moment in the still unfinished discussion about the Tehachapi line is who will bear the cost of the undergrounding of the lines through Chino Hills. Chino Hills councilman Ed Graham and the leader of the Hope For The Hills grassroots group opposing the towers, Bob Goodwin, have expressed the view that Southern California Edison should bear the cost of burying and insulating the cables. By passing that cost on to consumers statewide, individual ratepayers would see a yearly impact on their electricity bills of under $5, Goodwin said.  Edison and its  ratepayers elsewhere favor having the city of Chino Hills or its ratepayers defray the undergrounding cost.
Christopher Chow, a spokesperson for the California’s Division of  Ratepayer Advocates, which has its office in the PUC’s San Francisco office, told the Sentinel, “The people in Chino Hills want those lines buried rather than having those very high towers, which may impact their property values. They think Edison should bear the cost for having ignored them when the application was made. Then there are other ratepayers in the state who see that as Chino Hills’ problem and they do not want to pay for their problem.”
With regard to calls for the city of Chino Hills to pay for the undergrounding by issuing bonds which would then be debt serviced by the city’s property owners, Chow said, “That sounds like a trial balloon and we do not comment on trial balloons.”