(June 14) NEEDLES —David Brownlee may be in the final phase of his tenure as city manager with the smallest city in San Bernardino County.
The city council on May 28 approved advertising for the city manager position and designated council members Linda Kidd, Jim Lopez and Tom Darcy to serve on a subcommittee to review responses from candidates.
Brownlee, who was elevated into a caretaker city manager post in 2010 when the previous city manager, Bill Way, was released, was the city’s assistant city manager and utilities service manager at the time. At present, the council is seeking a city manager who is connected politically, can bring economic development to Needles and can write grants.
The council set a $1,000 limit on its advertising costs for the position, suggesting the recruitment would be mainly staged through a public notice in the Califorria League of Cities monthly publication.
Brownlee’s current contract runs from June 1 of this year through May 31, 2014. The terms of that contract give him retreat rights to return to being a city employee with the title of assistant city manager/utilities general manager.
There was no outward show of contention between Brownlee and the council, although the council did rebuff Brownlee in his recent effort to get clearance to hire an associate planner. The city council’s move comes as the economy is continuing to stagnate and businesses are vacating Needles and no new businesses are coming in to the town located on the western bank of the Colorado River. The city itself is making payroll and bond payments. The city is in a relatively fortunate position in that it owns the electric, water and wastewater utilities which give it some semblance of financial stability. Needles has challenges, including significant going-concern issues, according to the San Bernardino County Local Agency Formation Commission, most of which are beyond the city’s control.
Needles, with a population of 4,844, is the county’s smallest city population-wise. The budgeted range for the city manager in Needles is $129,000 to $132,000 per year. Brownlee is not paid according to that schedule, however, and receives $50.47 per hour based on furlough-truncated annual hours of 1,976. All employees in Needles are required to take furloughs. Brownlee’s annual salary is therefore $99,728.72. If the furloughs were to be discontinued and he were to work a full 2080-hour work year, he would be earning $104,977.60 per annum.
In Limbo, 29 Palms Fire Department Down To Five Men To Serve 88 Sq. Miles
(June 14) TWENTYNINE PALMS — More than a year after the county local agency formation commission recommended that the Twentynine Palms Water District divest itself of the fire department, the water district has yet to relinquish it, and the fire department’s future remains in limbo.
A takeover of the department by the county fire department fell through earlier this year and the department, which boasts seven personnel functioning out of two fire stations to serve a jurisdiction of 88 square miles, is set to be downscaled to five firefighters and one station.
Last month, the most recently drafted version of the department’s 2013-14 budget was presented by fire chief Jim Thompson to the water board. That spending plan earmarks $1,209,525 for department operations from July 1, 2013 to June 30, 2014 and will salt away $52,775 in a reserve account. The department, which is funded entirely by a special tax, is slated to receive $1,244,800 in the upcoming fiscal year.
The Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO), which oversees jurisdictional issues throughout the county, in its five-year service review of Twentynine Palms delivered on May 7, 2012 stated that the demands of operating the fire district have for some time been outrunning the water district’s funding ability. The report, authored by LAFCO executive officer Kathleen Rollings-McDonald, assistant executive officer Samuel Martinez and project manager Michael Tuerpe, said LAFCO’s review of the water district’s financial books “identifies a significant deficiency in funding” such that “the water district’s fire operations are unsustainable as presently financed.”
Rollings-McDonald on May 24 told the water district’s board members that the district would have to overcome the financial challenges facing the fire department, or cede control of the department to another entity by July 1, 2013. She said the water district could either hand the downtown station over to the city of Twentynine Palms and the Lear Avenue station to the county fire division and thereby surrender the special tax to both of those entities or in the alternative invite the county fire division to expand its sphere of influence and annex the water district’s territory for the purpose of providing fire service, complete with an arrangement to have the county inherit the special tax.
On June 27, with director Nicholas “Bo” Bourikas not present but voting in absentia in writing, the water board moved to file an application with the San Bernardino County Local Agency Formation Commission to sever fire service from the district. On July 12, 2012 at a joint meeting of the Twentynine Palms Water District, including its legal counsel and staff, Twentynine Palms Fire Chief Jim Thompson, the Twentynine Palms City Council and its legal counsel, county fire chief Mark Hartwig and Rollings-McDonald, a decision was made to have the county’s fire department subsume the fire department. Ultimately, however, that takeover has not been consummated.
Since that time, officials have gone back and forth over whether the operation of both existing fire stations will be maintained. There have been differing proposals to close out one of the fire stations and other cost-cutting moves which some elements of the community vociferously protested.
At one point, Hartwig proposed reducing the department to three firefighters and one station and utilizing volunteers/paid call personnel to function within the $1.2 million financial model. Eventually, the water board, under increasing pressure from members of the community, rejected the concept of handing the department off to the county, whose unionized firefighters draw higher pay and benefits than the current department’s members.
Twenty-nine years before the city of Twentynine Palms incorporated in 1987, the water district extended its responsibilities to include fire protection after the California Department of Forestry ceased providing local fire service to the area in 1958. When the city incorporated, it did not do so as a full-service municipality, and it left responsibility for fire service to the water district, which likewise remained independent from the city.
Under the water district’s guidance, the fire department grew to boast two fire stations, Station 421 on Adobe Road, which provides first response to the 59-square mile incorporated portion of Twentynine Palms and some unincorporated pockets close to town, and Station 422 on Lear Avenue, which is the first logical responder to fire and medical emergencies in most of the 29-square mile unincorporated, outlying communities of Twentynine Palms, including the Desert Heights area. The fire department’s service area is thus not coterminous with the 29 Palms city limits. The city does not contribute to, participate in or subsidize the fire department’s operational budget. Under the arrangement that has been in place since 1958, fire department finances have been held independent of the water district, with water rates totally devoted to the provision of water to customers. Fire department operations are defrayed entirely by a special fire tax on properties throughout the service area of the water district.
In April 2012, residents within the water district’s service area were presented with a ballot initiative, Measure H, which would have levied an added special fire service assessment on all water district customers. The voters rejected that initiative. Thompson at that point said that the fire department’s only option in balancing its books was to shutter one of its two fire stations.
That prediction is about to become reality. And two firefighters will also be casualties of the economies that must be imposed. Thompson’s working plan is to consolidate fire operations and maintain five paid personnel — himself as fire chief, two captains and two engineers — and augment that skeleton crew with three reserve volunteer firefighters daily. The Lear Avenue station will be closed and all operations will be run out of the 1,800-square foot downtown Adobe Road station.
Like last year, all maintenance or capital acquisitions will be deferred, at least until next year. Most of the $1,244,800 in revenue the water district will receive that is earmarked for the fire department will be eaten up by the anticipated $1,209,525 for salaries and fuel and basic operations, leaving $52,775 in reserves, which will eventually be used, Thompson hopes, for maintenance or acquisition at some indefinite point in the future.
County Approves Balanced $4.4 Billion 2013-14 Budget
(June 14) The San Bernardino County Board of Supervisors on June 12 approved a $4.4 billion budget for Fiscal Year 2013-14, which the county’s chief executive officer, Greg Devereaux touted as balanced and forward looking.
Board of Supervisors Chairwoman Janice Rutherford said, “Despite the ongoing effects of the economic downturn, the county budget is balanced and incorporates major investments in key priorities, including road maintenance, public safety, and efforts to streamline the county’s land use approval processes.”
The fiscal year runs from July 1 through June 30. The county will place 155.1 million more into its general fund in the upcoming year than it will utilize in the nearly ended 2012-13 Fiscal Year.
It is notable that the largest line item in the budget is that devoted to the county’s Human Services division, which will eat up $1.6 billion of the revenue that will be coming into the county over the next 12 months. A portion of that outlay will go toward hiring 158 new employees in the Transitional Assistance Department.
The county’s law and justice group, consisting of the sheriff’s department, district attorney’s office, probation department, and public defender’s office, will utilize $825.7 million over the course of the next 12 months.
The county will devote a whopping $37.9 million to staffing and further expansion work on the Adelanto Detention Center. The county will also spend $18 million for other jail upgrades, $15.7 million for a new crime lab and $360,000 for medical marijuana enforcement. The budget also has provided $150,000 for improvements to sheriff’s department resident posts, which consist of resident deputy housing at various locations throughout the county.
Other notable elements of this year’s county budget are a $4.5 million increase for pavement management programs and transportation projects; $4.5 million for the relocation of the sheriff’s department’s aviation division at Rialto Airport, located at 1776 Miro Way in Rialto to San Bernardino International Airport; $4.5 million for a buildings acquisition and retrofit project to acquire existing office space near the Victorville Courthouse to locate general funded departments currently in leased space; $1.6 million to the Land Use Services Department to begin updating the county’s general plan; and $524,276 for the Homeownership Protection Program, which will identify all housing funding mechanisms and programs to help families keep their homes.
The budget also sets aside funding for expenditures in future years, including $18 million for future jail upgrades, $13 million for future upgrades to the county’s financial accounting system, $10 million for future upgrades to the county animal shelter, $5.9 million for the upcoming Rimforest Storm Drain Project, $5.4 million for future activity by the Land Use Services Department, $4 million for future acquisition efforts and retrofit projects on county buildings, and $200,000 for future updates to the county code and county charter.
The county’s general fund spending authority totals $2.5 billion, only $498.9 million of which, according to Devereaux “is truly discretionary.”
Slightly more than $1.9 billion of the county’s budget lies outside the general fund.
Latino Population Now Eclipses All Other Ethnic Groups In San Bernardino County
(June 14) San Bernardino County within the last two years passed a significant demographic milestone, as the number of Latinos living within its borders grew to become an outright majority of the population.
According to U.S. Census data released yesterday, June 13, Hispanics now account for 50.5 percent of San Bernardino County’s population. According to the U.S. Census, 32.7 percent of the county’s population is white, 9.6 percent is African-American, 6.9 percent is Asian and two percent is Native American.
San Bernardino County has joined the ranks of a growing number of cities and counties with a Latino majority. Among counties specifically, it is the second largest in the country where Latinos outnumber all other ethnic groups combined. Miami-Dade County in Florida, where 64.3 percent of residents are Hispanic, holds the distinction of being the largest such county. Miami-Dade and San Bernardino are the only two counties nationwide with a population exceeding 2 million where Latinos form a majority.
According to the U.S. Census, the number of those identifiable as Hispanic in San Bernardino County eclipsed the half way mark sometime in late 2011 or 2012.
For accounting purposes, the government defines its years on a fiscal calendar, which runs from July 1 to June 30. In the year ending June 30, 2012, San Bernardino County’s Latino population edged upward by nearly 2 percent over the previous year, from 1,030,213 in 2011 to 1,050,372 in 2012. At the initiation of the 2011-12 Fiscal Year in July 2011, Latinos registered as 49.9 percent of San Bernardino County’s total population of 2,064,511. By July 2012, they accounted for 50.5 percent of the county’s total population of 2,081,313, according to Census figures.
The increase in the numbers of Latinos in the local population over the years has been reflected in political representation across the county. At present, two of the members of the San Bernardino County Board of Supervisors are Hispanic or of Hispanic ancestry. Half of the county’s 24 cities – Chino Hills, Chino, Ontario, Fontana, Rialto, Colton, Grand Terrace, Redlands, Needles, Barstow, Adelanto and Victorville – have at least one Hispanic councilmember. In Colton, the only city where Hispanics form a majority of the council, six of its seven members are Latino.
Like most of California, San Bernardino County has long had a significant Hispanic population. That base has grown considerably in the last several decades. In 1990, Latinos were 26.7 percent of the county population. By 2000, their ranks had grown to 39.2 percent. In 2010, that number eclipsed 48 percent.
In San Bernardino County the Hispanic demographic is a relatively young one. The median Latino age in San Bernardino County is 27. By contrast, the median age of Caucasians in San Bernardino County is 45.
Local Opposition Fails To Overturn Joshua Tree Dollar General Approval
(June 14) JOSHUA TREE— Over the strenuous objections of dozens of Joshua Tree residents, the county board of supervisors upheld the county planning commission’s previous approval of Dynamic Development LLC’s application to build and operate a 9,100-square-foot Dollar General retail store in this desert community..
Many in Joshua Tree pride themselves on the rustic character of their town. They resisted the Dollar Tree proposal, maintaining the presence of a national corporate retail establishment would compromise the Old West ambience of a desert town that relies on tourism. In January the planning commission by a 4-1 vote approved the proposal by Dynamic Development in conjunction with the Goodlettsville, Tennessee–based Dollar General Corp. to establish the store at the corner of Twentynine Palms Highway and Sunburst Avenue in Joshua Tree. Locating the outlet in Joshua Tree is part of a larger business strategy of the corporation which has established a Dollar General store in Yucca Valley and has already obtained approval for a Dollar General store in Twentynine Palms. Having three stores along State Route 62 will create a synergy and economy of scale with regard to supply and delivery, corporate officers believe.
Mark Ostoich, an attorney representing Dynamic Development, said the project met all the criteria of an acceptable property use.
Gus Romo and Ernie Perea, planners with the county’s department of land use services who previously recommended that the commission approve Dynamic Development’s conditional use permit application, set the groundwork for their boss, Terri Rahhal, the planning director for the county, who was tasked with reiterating the planning division’s earlier analysis and findings and building a case to justify the store at its proposed location after several town residents together with the Joshua Tree Downtown Business Alliance filed a timely appeal of the planning commission’s approval.
Romo and Perea maintained the 1.45 acre site is compatible from a land use standpoint with the applicant’s plans. “Surrounding land uses consist of single-family residential uses located within commercial zoning to the south across 29 Palms Highway, single-family residential uses within multi-family zoning to the north across Commercial Street, vacant commercial land to the east across Sunburst Avenue, and vacant commercial land to the west across Mountain View Street,” Romo and Perea stated in a jointly authored report and recommendation. “This area of 29 Palms Highway is designated for commercial development and intended to cater to pedestrian and vehicular traffic. The project is considered a general retail use permitted within the Joshua Tree Community Plan zoning designation subject to approval of a use permit. Therefore, the proposed development and retail use are considered compatible with the surrounding land uses and general plan land use designations.”
Last year, before the project came before the planning commission, local residents militated against the project proposal, objecting to the imposition of corporate “cookie cutter” forms in the rural desert area, resulting in the county land use services division upping the “minor” permit required of Dynamic Development to a conditional use permit. The project opposition culminated in the public comment period for the January 17 hearing before the county planning commission. That opposition included residents, property owners and business operators from the Joshua Tree community.
This time around, the board of supervisors held a hearing that incorporated a video hook-up with the meeting room at the Joshua Tree Community Center, allowing Joshua Tree residents to lodge their protests without having to make the 200-mile round trip to the county seat to be heard.
Peggy Kennedy contradicted Romo, Perea and Ostoich, insisting the project was “inconsistent with the goals and policies in our Joshua Tree Community Plan.”
Levon Kazarian, the owner of Crossroads Café, said the influx of corporate retailers in Joshua Tree would destroy the community’s “unique rural character.”
Tom O’Key, who owns 20 commercially zoned acres in Joshua Tree, said the county would force an end to the non-corporate ethos of the Joshua Tree business community with the approval of the Dollar General.
Joshua Tree Chamber of Commerce President Eva Soltes said the county was giving Joshua Tree a “black eye” by approving the project and local artist Shari Elf said the Dollar Tree represented “a cancer” that would metastasize to consume the town.
One of the appellants, George Kopp, said that Joshua Tree is a vestige of the past that offers a window on the American West before it was besmirched by corporate influence.
“Joshua Tree was targeted by a different type of investor that was focused on quality of life,” Kopp said. “We created a vibrant downtown district. This chain store is out of scale, out of character and out of compliance with our community plan.”
Douglas Carstens, an attorney with Chatten-Brown & Carstens, reminded the board, “The Joshua Tree Community Plan protects independent, privately-owned business in the downtown district.”
Third District Supervisor James Ramos, in whose jurisdiction Joshua Tree lies, joined in with the project’s opponents in criticizing the size and nature of the proposal. “Joshua Tree’s economic plan says to encourage and support small businesses,” Ramos said. “I believe a community has its own right and destiny.”
There were local residents, however, who supported the project. A number of them, including a few who acknowledged they were being paid by the proponent to attend the meeting, wore yellow shirts bearing the slogan, “Dollar General Supporting Local Families.”
One area resident, Julian Gonzales, called the opponents a bunch of namby-pamby “imbecilic personalities” consumed by a “not in my back yard” mentality. He accused them of being anti-growth. Gonzales said the Dollar General would be a convenience to local residents and would represent a positive economic step for the community. “If you don’t move forward, you die. The Dollar General would provide much-needed services to the low-income people of Joshua Tree,” said Gonzales.
Rahhal said that the county was not bound by the Joshua Tree Community Plan and its precepts, and that it could not be cited as the grounds for keeping a business such as Dollar General from locating in Joshua Tree. “The Joshua Tree Community Plan articulates a vision of the community,” Rahhal said. “lt sets their vision. It is not the sole source of regulation for land use, though.”
Ramos vote was the sole one to overturn the planning commission decision. All four of his board colleagues voted to uphold the January approval of the project.
County Raises Water Rates In 3 Desert Areas
SAN BERNARDINO — Water rates will increase in the county areas of Morongo Valley, Landers and Pioneertown next month.
The board of supervisors ratified San Bernardino County Director of Special Districts Jeff Rigney’s call for those residents served by the county to shoulder the increased cost of providing water. Morongo Valley, Landers and Pioneertown lie within County Special Districts jurisdiction. Under law, a protest vote was held preparatory to the board’s vote. An insufficient number of residents objected to the increases, allowing the county to up the fees, which Rigney said will cover the cost of providing the service to the communities.
The increases will go into effect on July 18.
The hikes will be graduated over the next four years, amounting to a 50 percent increase.
The Morongo Basin boasts four county water districts. The monthly fees those districts charge vary from to $29.36 to $58.78 on a 3/4-inch meter. The county will initially impose a 19 percent increase on water customers in Landers and Pioneertown. Prolific water consumers in Morongo Valley will be hit with a 51 percent increase once they use water beyond a threshold amount.
Yucca Valley Airport District Schedules Assessment Vote For July 2
YUCCA VALLEY — The Yucca Valley Airport District has called a special election for July 2 proposing a tax to augment operations and maintenance at the airport.
Yucca Valley Airport is located in the town of Yucca Valley, 3224 feet above sea level, the closest civilian aviation facility to Joshua Tree National Park. Yucca Valley Airport is open to the general public and to visiting aircraft 24 hours a day. It does not have any commercial passenger services but does provide services such as aircraft maintenance and flight training.
Currently, the airport runs on an annual $10,000 endowment from a Caltrans fund that distributes aviation gas tax money as well as the proceeds from private use fees. If the taxing proposal, known as Measure Z, passes, property owners in the district will be assessed 2 cents per square foot annually, an amount to be adjusted annually for inflation. This will entail an assessment annually of about $250 for typical property owners in the district, depending on parcel size. There are 43 registered voters in the district at present. The measure must be approved by two-thirds of those to pass.
The tax would generate roughly $146,000 annually, allowing the airport district to soldier on. If Measure Z fails, the airport district will need to disincorporate for lack of a stable revenue source. The airport will be able to continue as a private corporation under that scenario.
Yucca Valley is operated with one primary runway, oriented in an east-west direction. Yucca Valley Airport offers parking for transit aircraft at the west end of the airport. As a public facility, it is used by government agencies utilizing aircraft for firefighting and search-and-rescue operations, as well as by medical teams and medical transport helicopters.
Redlands Planning Commission Rejects CVS Architectural Proposal
The Redlands Planning Commission on June 11 balked at giving its blessing to the architectural plans for a drive-through CVS drugstore in the already approved shopping center to be built at Lugonia and Wabash avenues.
After considering the plan put forth by the architect on the project, Frank Fraga, the commission directed him to return on July 9 with a more imaginative draft. The CVS will be the secondary tenant at the center to be anchored by a Stater Bros. supermarket. The project was approved by the planning commission in October and the first phase of construction on the property is now under way.
Members of the commission said that the property is a highly visible one that will represent the city to outsiders. A report by the city planning department called for CVS to incorporate architectural details found elsewhere in Redlands.
City planner Manuel Baeza was somewhat deprecating in sizing up Fraga’s proposed design, referring to it as a “typical prototype building with no distinctive features.”
Fraga took umbrage at that, contradicting city staff and maintaining the building is aesthetically coordinated with other elements of the shopping center design. He pointed out that he has had considerable dialogue with city staff over the last six months and that CVS had agreed to change its recognizable corporate color scheme usually provided for its drugstores. He had also augmented the building with a stone veneer and his current plans include a textured stucco exterior, stone accents, wainscoting and a porte-cochere, as well as a portico feature over the pick-up window.
The planning department requested five changes to the architectural plan, to include a tower with Spanish-style roofing at the building entrance, covered walkways with open, wooden beams, and trellises planted with vines. Fraga said some of the conditions could be incorporated and the commission scheduled him to return with those plans in hand next month.
Upland City Council Authorizes $1,000 Per Day Code Enforcement Fines
(June 14) UPLAND –A divided city council on Monday approved the schedule of fees and charges for the controversial administrative citation ordinance the council ratified in April which gives the city the authority to fine an offending resident or business up to $365,000 per year.
Given a second required reading on April 22, the ordinance went into effect on May 22. The city’s action this week provides guidance to city staff on what penalties are to be assessed against code violators, although the council simply voted to approve staff recommendations on what those charges will be. The ordinance specifies two classes of violations, those classified as “general” and “building and safety.”
General violations, which relate mostly to the maintenance of property, will entail fines of $100 for a first offense, $200 for a second offense and $500 for a third offense.
Building and safety violations, which cover unpermitted structures, unsecured pools, sewage outflows or buildings in a severe state of disrepair, trigger a $500 fine for a first offense, $750 fine for a second offense and $1,000 fine for a third offense.
In making a case for the ordinance, city officials made two contradictory arguments on its behalf. One rationale was that the stepped up fines would allow the city to force offenders into compliance. The second rationale was that it would allow the city to recover its costs in making the enforcement effort.
Opponents of the ordinance countered that residents without the resources to maintain their own property would likely be unable to pay the fines. Unpaid fines are recorded as a tax lien against the offending property, giving the city the right, after five years, to confiscate and sell the property. The accumulated fines in such cases would far exceed the costs of enforcing the code in each specific instance. City officials initially wanted to charge an hourly rate of $92.50 for staff time in processing code enforcement actions but under the ordinance passed this week dropped that to $55, according to the staff report on the matter. .
Mayor Ray Musser, who with his official municipal advisor Tom Mitchell initially championed the ordinance and voted for it upon its first reading on April 8, voted against it on April 22. Councilman Glen Bozar opposed giving city staff members administrative citation authority on both April 8 and April 22.
Opponents cited constitutional grounds in seeking to persuade the council to reject the ordinance, saying it violates due process by allowing the city to serve as the citing authority, arbitrating authority, hearing authority and fining authority. Musser, after his turnaround, acknowledged this.
“I’m all for good code compliance and saving the city and its taxpayers money,” he said, “but I see now the ordinance gives us too much authority. We are giving out the citations and we are collecting the fines. We say we are putting in the added check and balance of an independent hearing officer but that hearing officer will be getting paid by the city of Upland to resolve the matter and I feel that is just not an arm’s length transaction.”
Bozar and Musser’s votes were not sufficient to keep the ordinance from passing on April 22, as council members Debbie Stone, Gino Filippi and Brendan Brandt supported it. This week, Stone Filippi and Brandt supported the fine schedule. Bozar opposed it and Musser abstained.
Ontario Files Suit Against Los Angeles For Return Of Ontario Airport
Jjune 7) As has been anticipated for the last two months, the city of Ontario this week filed suit against the city of Los Angeles as part of an effort to regain ownership of Ontario Airport, alleging Los Angeles has in recent years failed to live up to all of the provisions of the joint operating agreement for the aerodrome, exacerbated by the larger city’s alleged deliberate mismanagement of the critical Inland Empire economic asset due to a political and regional conflict of interest.
The lawsuit calls for the return of the airport, which has seen a 40 percent decline in passenger traffic over the last five-and-a-half years, to the city of Ontario. The suit also seeks the abrogation of the 1967 agreement that transferred management of the airfield to Los Angeles as well as a reversal of the 1985 transfer of title on the airport property and its facilities from Ontario to Los Angeles.
Represented by the Washington, D.C.-based law firm of Sheppard Mullen Richter and Hampton, Ontario lodged the suit in Riverside County Superior Court, naming the city of Los Angeles, the Los Angeles Board of Airport Commissioners and Los Angeles World Airports (LAWA), the entity which operates Los Angeles International Airport (LAX), Ontario Airport, which is known by its Federal Aviation Administration acronym ONT, and Van Nuys Airport for the city of Los Angeles, as defendants.
According to Roy Goldberg, a partner at the law firm of Sheppard Mullin Richter & Hampton “Los Angeles World Airports Chief Executive Officer Gina Marie Lindsey decided to abandon the regionalization objective that previously had united the interests of the two cities to their mutual benefit. Los Angeles is focused on growth and development at Los Angeles International Airport, not Ontario Airport, and the result has been an accelerating decline in Ontario Airport’s fortune.”
Claiming that LAWA’s management of Ontario International has neglected marketing while imposing on airlines still operating there exorbitant enplaning and servicing fees that have resulted in the number of passengers flying into and out of Ontario dropping from 7.2 million in 2007 to 4.2 million last year, Ontario asserts the airport has reached “a crisis point.”
“We were disappointed that Los Angeles rejected our administrative claim without addressing the specific and detailed grounds for relief in the claim,” said Ontario City Councilman Alan Wapner, who also serves as president of the Ontario International Airport Authority. “The rejection leaves us with no choice but to exercise our fiduciary duties by filing a lawsuit as we press our campaign for control of the Inland Empire’s No.1 economic engine. Anyone following Southern California airport conditions over the past five years can only conclude that as long as Ontario International Airport’s fate lies within Los Angeles’ control, the airport’s condition will continue to deteriorate to the detriment of the entire region,” Wapner said.
Los Angeles’ continuing ownership and operation of Ontario Airport represents a conflict of interest, such that LAWA has promoted an agenda to favor Los Angeles International Airport, and has thus proven unwilling to ensure that air traffic is evenly distributed to the regional airports it controls, Ontario maintains. This violates the joint operating agreement’s mandate that Ontario’s interests be served, according to the suit.
“Ontario Airport’s survival is now in jeopardy because Los Angeles has for too long caused ONT’s costs to skyrocket compared with other secondary airports in Southern California and nationwide, has focused on developing LAX’s capacity as an international airport, and has refused to market ONT as a convenient alternative to LAX,” Ontario councilman Jim Bowman, also a member of the Ontario International Airport Authority, said.
“The current administration at LAWA decided to focus its financial and other resources on renovating and promoting LAX, especially to retain and attract more international service, while allowing passenger levels at ONT to dip dangerously low,” Bowman said. “The result is LAWA has breached its contractual and fiduciary duties by failing to promote and expand air service at ONT.”
Furthermore, Ontario represents in the suit’s pleadings, Los Angeles did not live up to a commitment made by Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa to provide Ontario Airport with up to $7.3 million per year realized by LAWA’s 2008 closing of the Palmdale Regional Airport.
At the time Ontario and Los Angeles entered into the joint powers agreement to allow Los Angeles to use its clout with airlines to increase flights into and out of Ontario International in 1967, the airfield had a gravel parking lot and was servicing fewer than 200,000 passengers per year. Under Los Angeles’ guidance, the airport grew, more airlines began flying out of the facility and improvements were made to its runways and terminals. In 1985, after all of the conditions set down in the 1967 joint powers agreement had been met, Ontario deeded the airport to Los Angeles for no consideration.
Since the airport achieved its 7.2 million passenger high mark six years ago, Ontario officials maintain that LAWA has stifled Ontario International in a deliberate effort to benefit Los Angeles International, where improvements have been made and passenger traffic has continued to rise for the past seven years. In its now-three-year-long campaign to have Los Angeles deed the airport back to Ontario. Ontario officials have publicly insisted that LA should relinquish the airport for no consideration because the airport is considered a public benefit property which has no sale value. Privately, however, Ontario has offered Los Angeles $246 million for the airport. Simultaneously, Los Angeles has sought potential private and public buyers for the aerodrome at reported prices ranging from $225 million to $650 million. Last year Los Angeles revealed the existence of Ontario’s $246 million offer, embarrassing Ontario officials with an exposé of the discrepancy between their public and private statements. Last year, Ontario, with the county of San Bernardino, formed the Ontario International Airport Authority, an entity intended to take over ownership and operation of the airport once Los Angeles relinquishes it.
Los Angeles officials attribute the decline in passenger traffic through Ontario to the recession that has persisted since 2008 and widespread changes in the airline industry in which air carriers have reduced flights to outlying airports or non-centralized hubs. They say the airlines have proven resistant to LAWA’s earnest efforts to lure the airlines back to Ontario. The terms of the 1967 agreement remain in place and Los Angeles maintains it has consistently and continues to live up to that agreement.
In January, Los Angeles offered to sell the airport to Ontario for $474 million. In April, Ontario rejected that offer.
Maria Tesoro, the spokeswoman for Los Angeles World Airports, on Wednesday told the Sentinel, “We haven’t reviewed the lawsuit, and would not be able to discuss its contents. However, it has been our hope that instead of a divisive relationship, we would have a partnership with the city of Ontario, to the benefit of all. A new advertising campaign, ‘Together, the sky’s the limit. Fly ONT!,’ will soon be encouraging people to keep spreading the great news about the Inland Empire’s economic engine and what ONT is best known for – Southern California’s most convenient airport.”
In a seeming contradiction to Ontario’s assertions in the lawsuit, last night Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa met Chinese President Xi Jinping at Ontario International Airport after the latter flew into Ontario for his scheduled summit with President Barack Obama today and tomorrow relating to cybersecurity.