Departing Villaraigosa Seeks Renewed Dialogue With Ontario Over Airport

(June 21)  Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa earlier this month sent a letter to Ontario Mayor Paul Leon offering to reopen negotiations over the transfer of ownership and management of Ontario Airport from Los Angeles to Ontario.
The letter, dated June 6, came three days after Ontario filed a lawsuit against Los Angeles claiming the larger city has been purposefully mismanaging the facility. The lawsuit seeks the return of the airport to Ontario’s possession.
In the letter, Villaraigosa stated, “I stand ready to resume negotiations between our cities upon withdrawal of the city of Ontario’s lawsuit against the city of Los Angeles.”
Villaraigosa’s term as mayor will end in less than a month. He held out hope that the airport ownership and management differences separating the two cities could be ironed out expeditiously and perhaps before he leaves office. He said he had a “continuing interest to work with you and your colleagues to facilitate transfer of the LA/Ontario International Airport (ONT) to the city of Ontario (or its designee, such as the Ontario International Airport Authority). I have always believed, and continue to believe, that if we work together in good faith, we can achieve such a transfer.
“I continue to support regionalization of air traffic, with the long-term growth of ONT as a viable alternative to Los Angeles International Airport (LAX),” Villaraigosa continued. “While these are difficult times for medium and small airports across the nation, I agree that focused marketing of ONT can and should help grow ONT over the long-term.”
Villaraaigosa said he and Los Angles were taken aback by the lawsuit.
“With all of the above in mind, I was quite perplexed that the city of Ontario would file a claim and subsequent lawsuit,” Villaragoisa said. “Given the urgency you and other stakeholders have expressed, it would be more productive to continue our negotiations with the shared goal of identifying a mutually acceptable way to accomplish the transition. Both sides should sit down again and hammer out a mutually agreeable arrangement.”
Ontario maintained that Villaraigosa’s letter had not been received until June 12.
While noting that he partially appreciated the gesture, Ontario Mayor Paul Leon in a letter in response to Villaraigosa said his city was not prepared to abandon its litigious  stance. Leon noted that Villaraigosa will leave office on July 1, and said there is “very little time for the parties to bridge a considerable gap in their respective settlement positions within a very narrow window of time.  Nevertheless, as always Ontario is deeply interested in any settlement discussion that is in good faith and meaningful. However, a legitimate settlement meeting cannot be subject to an unreasonable condition precedent.”
Leon then rejected Villaragoisa’s call for Ontario to drop the lawsuit. “That is not a reasonable demand,” Leon wrote. “Ontario filed the lawsuit after all other avenues of relief were exhausted.  Having been forced to file the case, it is not going to withdraw it as a prerequisite to a settlement meeting, especially given that the current Los Angeles mayoral administration will be transitioned out of existence in a little more than two weeks. With your administration’s professed desire to seek a negotiated resolution before you leave office, it should withdraw the demand that the lawsuit be dismissed prior to any such discussions.”
In 1967, when Ontario Airport had a gravel parking lot and was servicing fewer than 200,000 passengers per year, Ontario and Los Angeles entered into a joint powers agreement to allow Los Angeles to use its clout with airlines to increase flights into and out of Ontario. Under Los Angeles’ guidance, the airport grew, more airlines began flying out of the facility and improvements were made to its runways and terminals. In 1985, after all of the conditions set down in the 1967 joint powers agreement had been met, Ontario deeded the airport to Los Angeles for no consideration.
In 2007, the airport achieved its high mark in terms of passenger traffic, when 7.2 million passenger enplaned there. But since that time, passenger traffic through Ontario Airport has diminished to 4.2 million per year and Ontario officials maintain that Los Angeles World Airports, the corporate entity that Los Angeles utilizes to run LAX, Van Nuys Airport and Ontario Airport, has stifled Ontario International in a deliberate effort to benefit Los Angeles International, where improvements have been made and passenger traffic has continued to rise for the past seven years. In its now-three-year-long campaign to have Los Angeles deed the airport back to Ontario, Ontario officials have publicly insisted that LA should relinquish the airport for no consideration because the airport is considered a public benefit property which has no sale value. Privately, however, Ontario has offered Los Angeles $246 million for the airport. Simultaneously, Los Angeles has sought potential private and public buyers for the aerodrome at reported prices ranging from $225 million to $650 million. Last year Los Angeles revealed the existence of Ontario’s $246 million offer, embarrassing Ontario officials with an exposé of the discrepancy between their public and private statements. Last year, Ontario, with the county of San Bernardino, formed the Ontario International Airport Authority, an entity intended to take over ownership and operation of the airport once Los Angeles relinquishes it.
Los Angeles officials attribute the decline in passenger traffic through Ontario to the recession that has persisted since 2008 as well as widespread changes in the airline industry in which air carriers have reduced flights to outlying airports or non-centralized hubs. They say the airlines have proven resistant to LAWA’s earnest efforts to lure the airlines back to Ontario.  The terms of the 1967 agreement remain in place and Los Angeles maintains it has consistently lived up to that agreement.
In January, Los Angeles offered to sell the airport to Ontario for $475 million. In April, Ontario rejected that offer.
In his letter to Villaraigosa, Leon emphasized that Ontario believed Los Angeles was overpricing the facility, saying that “Ontario would be very interested in siting down with the current administration to discuss a potential resolution” but only if the Los Angeles “administration is willing to consider terms materially less dramatic to Ontario than its prior demand of a $475 million payment for the return of ONT.”

Victorville Makes Motion To Dismiss SEC Fraud Charges

(June 21)  LOS ANGELES—The city of Victorville, its airport authority, and assistant city manager Keith Metzler have responded to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s April 29 charges of fraud and demands for restitution with motions seeking to dismiss several of the allegations and request for payment.
Terree Bowers of the Los Angeles-based law firm Arent Fox represents Victorville, the Southern California Logistics Airport Authority (SCLAA), and Metzler, who fills the dual roles of assistant city manager and  executive director of the airport authority, all of whom were charged in April by the SEC.  Also charged were  Kinsell, Newcomb & DeDios Inc., the underwriter for bond offerings sold in conjunction with the effort to develop the airport, that company’s owner, Jeffrey Kinsell, and Kinsell, Newcomb and DeDios investment banker Janees Williams.
The airport authority was formed by the city of Victorville to facilitate the conversion of the former George Air Force Base, which was shuttered by the Department of Defense in 1992, into a civilian airport. SCLAA, which has as its board of directors all five members of the Victorville City Council, issued bonds which were sold to investors to generate revenue to be used in making the base’s civilian use conversion.
The SEC alleges that fraud was committed by the defendants when the proceeds from those bond sales were diverted to uses other than was specified in the bond documents and representations made to the bond purchasers, specifically with regard to proceeds from bonds issued between 2006 and 2008.
The complaint consists of nine claims for relief and one prayer for disgorgement. The authority is named in the first two claims for relief. Kinsell, Newcomb and DeDios (KND) is named in the third, fourth and eighth claims for relief. KND and Jeffrey Kinsell are named in the fifth and sixth claims for relief. Victorville, Kinsell, Williams and Metzler are named in the seventh claim for relief.  Jeffrey Kinsell and Williams are named in the ninth claim for relief.
In the prayer for disgorgement, which is a request for restitution of ill-gotten profits from security law violators, all the parties are named.
On behalf of the city, the authority and Metzler, Bowers last week filed a motion to dismiss the first, second, and seventh claims for relief, and to dismiss the prayer for disgorgement. In his filing Bowers asserted “the complaint fails to state a claim for these violations.” The SEC’s first and second claims cite fraud in connection with the purchase or sale of securities; the seventh claim alleges aiding-and-abetting violations of the Exchange Act.
According to Bowers, a former U.S. Attorney, Metzler “did not violate the federal securities laws.”
The case involves four airport hangars that Victorville stated in the official statement for the April 2008 bond offering were worth $65 million. The county assessor later valued the hangars at $27.7 million. The SEC alleges that the authority used the inflated estimated values to mislead the investors.
“Even if its allegations were true, the alleged $37.3 million inflated value ultimately boils down to only a $200,000 differential in tax increment, less than 1% of the $22.6 million tax increment used as security for the bonds,” according to Bowers. “The authority’s alleged misstatement was not material. The SEC cannot state a claim of aiding and abetting against the city.”
The next hearing on the matter is set for September 16 before Judge John A. Kronstadt in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles.

Upland Unified’s Financial Woes To Mean 30 Percent Cuts For District Teachers

(June 21) The Upland Unified School District is asking its teachers to accept salary and benefit cuts in the upcoming school year of roughly $26,000 each on average, according to the union representing those teachers.
The district maintains the salary and benefit reductions will be somewhat more modest than the union is representing.
While the union claims the drawdowns are tantamount to one third of the teachers’ total benefit packages, the district maintains the cuts are closer to a one-fifth reduction.
The discrepancy consists largely of how the parings are to be structured.
Those reductions, whatever they amount to in terms of percentage, are needed if the district is to overcome a projected deficit in the neighborhood of $9 million in 2013-14.
The Upland Teachers Association has countered with a proposal by which each teacher would agree to make $20,400 in concessions on average to help the district ride out the current financial storm.
Currently, teachers in Upland Unified are paid from $37,758 to $78,575 per year, depending on educational level, certification, and seniority.
In 2007, Upland Unified boasted $20 million in reserves. But in the six years since, a stagnating economy, declining property values and dwindling income into the district, together with increases in teacher and other employee pay have eaten up that surplus and left the district, according to projections, in the position of spending nearly $9 million more than it will take in during the next school year if it does not trim its expenses from its operational budget from the just concluded 2012-13 school year.
Gary Rutherford, the district’s superintendent until his abrupt departure in January to assume the superintendent’s position with the Desert Sands Unified School District in Riverside County, had overseen a gradual decline in the district’s financial condition.
The San Bernardino County Superintendent of Schools issues ratings of the fiscal conditions of districts throughout the county on a regular basis, using a three tier system. Those districts that have revenue exceeding their operational costs and can maintain reserves are designated “positive.” Those that essentially break even with regard to their revenues and expenditures are pegged as “qualified.” Those that take in less money than they spend are rated “negative.”
In fiscal year 2010-11, both the first and second interim financial ratings for Upland Unified were positive.  In 2011-12, the first interim report was positive and the second was qualified.  In 2012-13, while Rutherford again sought a positive rating, the first interim report rated the district as qualified. For the second interim report, Rutherford sought a qualified rating, only to be met with the news, just as he was departing the district, that the rating was negative.
In the aftermath of Rutherford’s departure, Sherrie Black was enlisted to serve as interim superintendent. Though she has been credited with being more forthcoming to both the school board and the public about the district’s financial circumstance than her predecessor, Black has been struggling with the district’s financial situation her entire tenure as interim superintendent.
Two months ago, the district hired a new superintendent for the upcoming 2013-14 school year, Dr. Nancy Kelly, who is in the process of leaving as Redondo Beach Unified School District human resources director.
It is yet to be seen if Kelly will have the necessary wherewithal to map the district out of its financial doldrums.
Last December, Rutherford and Black, who was then assistant superintendent of human resources for the district, were anticipating a 2013-14 deficit of $4.5 million. In the last six months, that projected deficit has doubled, even as efforts to redress it have intensified.
According to Black, 91 percent of the district budget consists of personnel costs and the only solution to the fiscal crisis is to rein in those costs, which means significant concessions from the district’s collective bargaining groups with regard to contracts that have already been put into place and which will need to be renewed in upcoming years.
Already, the unions have given an indication they are willing to bend substantially in deference to  financial reality. The question remains, however, whether that will keep the district solvent.
In a letter to teachers, the negotiator for the Upland Teacher Association, Debbie Glenn, said that in response to the district’s proposal that teachers collectively accept $5.8 million in cuts, she countered with accepting $4 million in cuts.
The district wanted increased class sizes and caseloads, furlough days, salary freezes and rollbacks as well as increases in the teachers’ contributions to their health care plans. The teachers’ association’s counterproposal called for no change in class sizes but allows furlough days, salary freezes and a more modest employee contribution to health care than the district is requesting.
According to Black, the district has hitherto covered in its entirety the health care plans for teachers’ and their family members, translating to an insurance cost of roughly $15,000 to $16,000 per employee per year.
The association is now willing to have its members pick up $6,000 of those costs.
Overall, the association is prepared to see individual teacher’s monthly compensation packages lowered by $1,500 to $1,900 per month. The association has indicated it is willing to abide by these reductions for two years, until June 2015, if the district’s financial condition does not approve, and one year, until June 2014, if the state restores funding by that point.
Despite the association’s flexibility on the salary and benefit issues, no actual agreement has been made. Last week, the district threatened to declare an impasse and enforce its dictates unilaterally. Further discussions are on tap this week but had not been concluded by press time.
The district maintains its problems stem less from past fiscal mismanagement on the part of Rutherford and former assistant superintendent of business services Deo Persaud than the state’s practice of deferring payments to school districts.
Just under 79 percent of its revenue comes from the state of California, but at present and for the last three years, the state has been paying Upland Unified and other districts an average of 77 cents per dollar owed to it on time. The rest of that money has been deferred, resulting in the district, at its own financing cost, making arrangements to borrow money against that future revenue, using what are referred to as Tax Revenue Anticipation Notes, a type of short term bond. According to auditors, dependence on those bonds and the financing costs associated with them have snowballed on the district. Moreover, the state has made no cost of living adjustments for the district since 2008.

15-Ton Weight Restriction Removed From Barstow’s First Street Bridge

(June 21) BARSTOW—The city of Barstow and the California Department of Transportation have removed the 15-ton weight restriction on the First Street Bridge.
Built in 1930, the bridge is a key route of ingress to and egress from Barstow’s Railyard, the largest in the world. Connections from the railyard to the major roads and highways in the area have been hampered since 2010, when the city and Caltrans instituted weight limits on vehicles using the bridge, with the maximum load for a four-axle vehicle being 15 tons, well under the normal legal weight limit for most bridges of 40 tons.
Problems with the bridge, precipitated by an earthquake or trucks bearing excessive loads over the structure, were first recognized in 2003, triggering a directive from Caltrans that refurbishing and shoring up of the bridge be immediately undertaken. No repairs were ever made, however, and in 2010, Caltrans imposed the current weight restrictions. The Barstow City Council at that point approved repairs to a column and bracing  supports at a cost of $190,000. In 2011, an inspection uncovered further damage to support beams.
In essence, traffic across the bridge had been restricted to non-commercial vehicles such as cars, pickups, and SUVs, and small load commercial vehicles such as four-wheel stakebeds and the like. Larger vehicles such as 18-wheel tractor-trailers cannot use the bridge. Moreover, large public transportation vehicles including busses and public safety vehicles like fire engines must route themselves around the bridge. In the case of fire emergencies in north Barstow, this represented a potential safety hazard, as fire battalions are delayed by five-to-eight minutes in their responses as the heavy engines had to be rerouted to Highway 58 and Interstate 15 to reach emergencies on the northwest side of town.
Secondary upgrades to a structural column and a support brace were completed in January, at which time Caltrans signed off on the weight limit being removed. This week the city council voted to remove the weight restriction.
The city has applied for federal assistance in undertaking a future total reconstruction of the bridge, which is estimated to cost in the neighborhood of $45 million. That project will not begin, at the earliest, until 2015 for a target completion date of 2017.

Eight Law Firms Split $5.75 Million In County Workers’ Comp Contracts

The board of supervisors this week approved contracts worth an aggregate total of $5.75 million with eight law firms to provide legal defense services for the county’s self-insured workers’ compensation program over the next three years.
Under the terms of the contract the county will pay an hourly rate of $145 for partners and senior associates, and $95 for paralegals and law clerks.
The contracts are with the firms of Bradford & Barthel, LLP; Hallett, Emerick & Wells, PLC; Kegel, Tobin & Truce, APC; the Law Offices of C. Robert Bakke; the Law Offices of Louis D. Seaman; the Law Offices of Malmquist, Fields and Camastra, ALC; Michael Sullivan & Associates, LLP; and  Morse, Giesler, Callister & Karlin, LLP, and are to run from July 1, 2013 through June 30, 2016.
According to a staff report to the board of supervisors from Hueston Whiteside, the county’s director of risk management and the county’s top in-house attorney, county counsel Jean Rene Basle, “The department of risk management has managed the county’s self-insured workers’ compensation program since 1972. During that time, risk management has contracted with outside law firms to provide legal defense for workers’ compensation claims for the county, its board-governed special districts and county service areas. Currently, two full-time deputy county counsels are assigned to manage workers’ compensation claims in-house. However, due to the large number of cases, claims must also be assigned to outside specialized workers’ compensation defense firms, which are under contract with risk management. These legal firms manage continuing, companion or reopened older cases, as well as new cases and any other claims where a conflict would exist if they were assigned to county counsel.”
The report continues, “On July 13, 2010, the board approved three year contracts with eight legal defense firms to provide legal defense of workers’ compensation claims. These contracts are scheduled to expire on July 30, 2013. On January 2, 2013, the department of risk management released the request for proposals for legal defense of workers’ compensation claims. The request for proposals was posted on the county of San Bernardino Procurement Network website (ePro), and eleven vendors submitted proposals. Staff from county counsel, purchasing, and risk management evaluated the proposals based on compliance with requirements, experience and expertise in defending public entities. The evaluation committee selected the top eight most qualified firms; and risk management successfully negotiated an hourly rate of $145 for partners & senior associates, and a rate of $95 for paralegals & law clerks. The previous hourly rates of $130 and $80 respectively, had not been increased since July of 2007. The new rates represent an increase over the previous years’ contracts of $15 per hour, in each category, or 11.5% for partners and senior associates, and 18.75% for paralegals and law clerks. The new rates and/or contracts shall be effective from July 1, 2013 through June 30, 2016, with either party able to terminate with thirty days’ written notice.”

SCLA Defaults On Most Recent Bond Payment

(June 21) VICTORVILLE— The Southern California Logistics Airport Authority failed to make all of a $1,155,961 interest payment for a capital improvement bond that was due June 1, Victorville city officials have acknowledged.
The Southern California Logistics Airport exists on the grounds of what was George Air Force Base. George was shuttered by the Department of Defense in 1992. Victorville worked with the city of Hesperia, the town of Apple Valley and the county of San Bernardino under the aegis of the Victor Valley Economic Development Authority (VVEDA) in the 1990s to put together a civilian conversion plan for the air base which prevailed over a competing plan put forth by the city of Adelanto. To a considerable degree, Victorville has shuffled off the coil of VVEDA. The airport authority, an adjunct to the city of Victorville, is now the lead development agency at the airport.
The Southern California Logistics Airport Authority, known by its acronym SCLAA, has relied in major measure on bond financing for making improvements at the airport. Bonds are issued and then sold to investors. The proceeds from the bonds are used to finance the construction of infrastructure or other improvements to facilitate the function of the airport. Bondholders are supposed to be paid back upon the escalation of property value in the area around the airport, which is intended to increase property tax revenue into the city. That increase in property tax revenue that results from the improvements is referred to as tax increment and is dedicated to debt servicing the bonds.
Development of the airport has stalled in recent years, however. SCLAA in a statement to its bondholders on June 1 notified them they would not receive the interest payment due them on the SCLAA Subordinate Tax Allocation Revenue Bonds, Series 2007.
“SCLAA will use the remaining reserves of $491,331 for interest payment and default on interest of $664,630,” Adele Mosher, the airport authority’s  financial officer, told investors.
City officials maintained that the default occurred because there is insufficient tax increment being generated at and around the airport to pay the bondholders. Increment is down because property values have consistently fallen in recent years, both at the airport and elsewhere.
The default complicates the legal positions of the city of Victorville, SCLAA and SCLAA Director Keith Metzler, who is also assistant Victorville city manager, all of whom have been named in a complaint by the Securities and Exchange Commission alleging they defrauded the purchasers of airport bonds SCLAA issued and sold between 2006 and 2008.
It is unclear how long the bonds will remain in default. The bonds do not fully mature for another 24 years, meaning the city is contractually committed to paying those bondholders an annual percentage of the value of the bonds they hold – usually between 4.75 and 5.35 percent annually, for the life of the bonds plus the original full cash value of the bonds on their date of maturity.
$42 Million in the 2007 Subordinate Tax Allocation Revenue Bonds were issued.

Chino Defiant In Face Of Attorney Briggs’ Watson Complex Approval Test

(June 21) The Chino City Council has rejected attorney Cory Briggs’ challenge of that city’s planning commission’s approval of the Watson Land Company’s industrial complex project at the corner of Kimball and Mountain avenues.
According to Briggs, there were shortcomings and defects in the planning commission’s findings for its April 29 approval of the project. The commission failed to advertise the hearing properly, Briggs maintained, and did not properly inform the public about changes to the general plan’s provisions for an environmental impact report for the project.
According to city officials, Briggs’ challenge was not discussed by the city council in closed session June 4 prior to the council, without any open public hearing, simply rejecting Briggs’ challenge. The council did so on the basis of city attorney Jimmy Gutierrez’ assertion that Briggs’ procedural challenge of the project approval was not an issue that  merited the council’s revocation of the commission’s action.
Briggs, who in 2012 prevailed in a challenge of what he detailed as deficiencies in the city’s general plan and garnered $215,000 in legal fees in so doing, was required to post a $2,400 fee to make the appeal the city council rejected.
Briggs hinted that he would be willing to accept a compromise from the city on the Watson Land Industrial Complex approval if the city would refund his hearing fee, recompense him for his hours devoted to the appeal and incorporate a solar energy component into the project.
The council rejected that offer, risking further legal action by Briggs and his firm.

Sheriff Adds Nearly A Quarter Million For Car Repair Before Close Of Fiscal Year

(June 21) Just prior to the close of the 2012-13 fiscal year, the county is augmenting the sheriff’s department’s auto repair budget with  an additional $240,000 to increase five purchase orders from $500,000 to $740,000 with five automotive repair services.
According to sheriff’s captain Steve Higgins, the department wanted “additional purchasing authority of $240,000 for automotive repairs to be completed through June 30, 2013. Historically, the department seeks board of supervisors approval for its annual automotive procurement in the first quarter of the fiscal year. However, in 2012-13 the annual item was delayed due to the completion of a request for proposals to award multiple purchase orders for automotive repair services. Shortly thereafter, vacancies occurred in the department’s procurement and accounts payable sections. This resulted in the department’s internal tracking measures failing to identify it had exceeded its purchasing authority with one vendor, Citori in Hesperia. The department’s position vacancies in the accounts payable section are being filled to ensure improved tracking in the future.”
According to Higgins, the department had contracts with five automotive garages –  Hesperia-based Citori, which is also known as G&M Automotive; Rancho Cucamonga-based Inland Empire Stages; Highland-based Peta’s Car Care; San Bernardino-based Pride Automotive; and San Bernardino-based McCray Enterprises – to do $100,000 worth of automotive repair work for the department in 2012-13. As of this week, according to Higgins, Citori/G&M Automotive had actually done $188,760 worth of work. He asked for the Citori/G&M’s 2012-13 expenditure limit to be increased to $225,000. He said that Inland Empire Stages had to date completed $99,664 worth of work and he asked for the expenditure limit for Inland Empire Stages to be upped to $115,000.
Peta’s Car Care had completed $94,524 worth of work and Higgins requested spending authorization with that concern be increased to $120,000. Pride Automotive had billed for $97,282 and Higgins requested that the department be authorized to have that company complete $130,000 worth of work by June 30.
McCray Enterprises had completed $94,845 worth of work as of earlier this week. Higgins sought and obtained spending authority with that entity be increased to $150,000.

Ontario-Montclair Teachers Reject Conditional Two Percent Salary Increase

(June 21) ONTARIO—Teachers with the Ontario-Montclair School District have rejected the district’s offer of a two-percent salary increase, asserting the condition that they work an increased workday amounted to a four percent increase in their workload.
In May, when the Ontario-Montclair Teachers Association was presented with a contract that called for teachers to work a 15-minute-longer workday in return for a two percent raise, the union’s members opposed it.  It was pointed out that the 15 minute extension would represent a four percent increase in each teacher’s time on the job.
At present, teachers with the district are paid from $38,240 to $82,034 annually, depending on educational levels, certification and seniority.
With 1,177 teachers, Ontario-Montclair is one of the largest districts in San Bernardino County.
The district’s current contract with its teachers, which was approved more than eight months ago, will remain in place.

Administrative Judge Rules Against Chino Hills Line Undergrounding

(June 14) Administrative Law Judge Jean Vieth this week delivered a crushing blow to the city of Chino Hills and residents there advocating the undergrounding of high-voltage powerlines through that city.
In 2009, the California Public Utilities Commission, over the city of Chino Hills’ protest, granted Southern California Edison clearance to erect a series of 197-foot high power transmission towers through the heart of the upscale, 44.7-square mile city at the extreme southwest corner of San Bernardino County along a long-existing power corridor easement owned by the utility.
That line is intended to facilitate the Tehachapi Renewable Energy Project to connect what is planned as the world’s largest windfarm, consisting of thousands of electricity-producing windmills in Kern County, with the Los Angeles metropolitan basin.
Fearing a host of problems from the imposition of the towers, including significant negative impacts on property values in the city, the Chino Hills City Council authorized the expenditure of millions of dollars of taxpayer money to employ attorneys and make other efforts to contest the Public Utility Commission’s action, including filing suit against Southern California Edison, alleging the company had “overburdened” the power line easements. That legal effort failed when West Valley Superior Court Judge Keith D. Davis ruled the California Public Utilities Commission has exclusive jurisdiction regarding the route used by Edison, and the suit was thrown out. Chino Hills appealed Davis’s ruling to the 4th District Court of Appeal, asserting the city had the right to have the case heard by a jury, but in September 2011 the appeals court affirmed Davis’ decision.
In 2011, Edison, which has long had a 150-foot wide right-of-way for its power lines that runs for 5.8 miles from Tonner Canyon to the Riverside County line, erected 18 of the towers within Chino Hills before a city appeal to the California Public Utilities Commission (PUC) and Public Utilities Commission Chairman Michael Peevey in particular succeeded in obtaining a temporary halt to the towers’ construction in November 2011 while a potential undergrounding alternative was explored for 3.5 miles of the roughly five miles over which electrical lines are to transit the city. Early last year, a determination was made that the lines would remain above ground through that section of Chino Hills known as Oak Tree Downs, primarily because the topography of the land, which includes rolling hills, would render undergounding prohibitively expensive.
Simultaneously, Vieth was designated as the arbiter of still-remaining issues between the utility company and the city and its undergrounding advocates.
In her decision released on June 11 Vieth weighed in with her analysis of the matter, which relates to the city’s request to force Southern California Edison to install the line below ground the 3.5 mile span from the end of Eucalyptus Avenue  to Pipeline Avenue and the 71 Freeway.
Vieth, in taking up the petition and determining it “should be considered on the merits,” nevertheless rejected the city’s request to have Edison de-erect the towers in favor of a single circuit double cable line along that length of the  Tehachapi line through Chino Hills, which is known as Segment 8A.
“Proposed Decision denies the city of Chino Hills’ petition for modification of Decision (D.) 09-12-044 regarding Segment 8A of the Tehachapi Renewable Transmission Project,” Vieth wrote. “The proposed decision finds that while underground construction of a single circuit, two cables per phase design is feasible and could be completed on a timely basis, the cost is prohibitive and should not be borne by ratepayers at large for the benefit of the city and its residents. The proposed decision concludes that actual cost of undergrounding would be either a low of about $268 million (without reactive compensation) or a high of about $296 million (with reactive compensation).”
Previously, Chino Hills said it was willing to contribute $70.45 million to $76.7 million to offset Southern California Edison’s costs in carrying out the undergrounding. That contribution, the city said, would include real property that is necessary for the construction of an underground transmission line which the city is prepared to convey to SCE in fee; future  revenue which the city would have derived which will now be available to SCE through ownership of such properties; increased expenses that the city will incur due to its loss of the use of the contributed properties; and costs associated with the landscaping and maintenance of those properties that are located in the right-of-way.
The proposed decision does not assign a value to Chino Hills’ proposed real property offset but concludes that the actual value is a much more modest amount than Chino Hills’ estimate.
“As petitioner, Chino Hills has the burden of proof to establish by a preponderance of the evidence that its petition, filed October 28, 2011, should be granted; accordingly, Chino Hills must show that the design approved for Segment 8A should be changed to require construction of Chino Hills’ preferred alternative instead,” Vieth wrote. “Because we find that Segment 8A is not dissimilar from several other sections along the project route and that undergrounding Segment 8A at ratepayer expense is not reasonable, Chino Hills’ petition, filed October 28, 2011, should be denied. Because we deny the October 28, 2011, petition, Chino Hills’ subsequent petition (the additional request for a stay), filed October 31, 2011, should be denied also. The construction stay on Segment 8A should be released. This order should be effective immediately to avoid delay in completion of the Tehachapi Renewable Transmission Project.”
Vieth provided some of the calculations that went into her decision for denial, stating that the cost benefit ratio was too lopsided. “On a per mile basis, these estimates represent a high approaching $85 million per mile and a low approaching $77 million per mile,” she stated. Along the 3.5 mile span, according to Vieth, 220 houses were directly impacted by the towers. The cost of sparing them from the visual blight of the towers would essentially exceed the cost of the homes themselves. “For each of the 220 houses that borders the right-of-way, the cost is on the order of $1.2-$1.3 million per house,” according to Vieth.
Vieth, while serving as the administrative law judge on the case, does not have final say in the matter.  On the same day Vieth’s decision was publicly released, the Public Utlities Commission also released an alternative proposed decision by PUC President Michael Peevey which endorses Chino Hills’ remaining request for 3.5 miles of the single circuit line  to be buried below ground.
Peevey’s  alternate proposed decision  stood in stark contrast to  Vieth’s ruling, and differed by at least $46 million in its cost analysis.    Peevey estimated the undergrounding  cost  at $224 million.
A thirty-day comment period is to now ensue. The full California Public Utilities Commission Board, of which Peevey is a voting member, will take up the issue on July 11 and render a final, binding ruling as early as that date and no later than July 30.
Bob Goodwin, the leader of the Chino Hills-based group Hope For The Hills, which was instrumental in lobbying the PUC to revisit the undergrounding issue, was able to find a silver lining in Vieth’s ruling.
“The California Public Utilities Commission issued two contrasting proposed decisions in the Tehachapi Renewable Transmission Project (TRTP),” he told the Sentinel. “The full commission will determine which decision becomes effective following a vote at the commission meeting on July 11, 2013,” Goodwin said. “CPUC Administrative Law Judge Jean Vieth issued her proposed decision, which would lift the stay on construction of the partially completed overhead lines within Chino Hills and allow the line to be completed as originally approved by the CPUC in 2009. The judge noted the high cost to ratepayers of the proposal to underground the lines and the fact that the overhead transmission lines are close to residences in other portions of the TRTP project.
“While we were not surprised by her conclusion, we feel she made two significant points: 1) underground construction is feasible and 2) project could be completed on time,” Goodwin continued. “Judge Vieth did her job given the scope of the original petition she was ruling on.  Also included in the documents is a alternate proposed decision drafted by Michael Peevey which grants the city of Chino Hills’ petition and orders SCE to construct an underground system. He sites two main reasons: 1) unfair burden imposed on Chino Hills and its residents and 2) the project is contrary to community values. He concluded that based on this and the estimated cost it warrants undergrounding.”
Goodwin sounded confident the entire Public Utilities Commission Bboard will go with Peevey’s proposal rather than Vieth’s.
“While this does not finalize anything, we feel strongly that with Mr. Peevey’s alternate proposal and Administrative Law Judge Vieth’s comments, our foot is a little further in the door. This matter is not over by any means and no one should feel we have won anything. We still have work to do and are prepared to see this to the victorious end.”