Feds’ Presence In County Betrays DA’s Prosecutorial Malaise

Federal prosecutors have horned in on an unprecedented number of high profile political corruption cases that would otherwise be handled by the district attorney’s office in San Bernardino County. In some matters, the U.S. Attorney’s Office has wrested from district attorney Mike Ramos prosecutorial authority or has opened with the FBI parallel investigations into issues Ramos or the San Bernardino County Grand Jury have delved into without reaching a successful conclusion. In at least three matters, federal prosecutors and investigators have taken on probes or investigations of elected officials or political donors with whom Ramos was politically aligned.

In total, five matters in which current or former elected officials are alleged or suspected to have engaged in bribery or some other form of wrongdoing are being prosecuted by the U.S. Attorney or being reviewed for their prosecutorial potential by the FBI.

The U.S. Attorney’s Office in February and March 2011 obtained from a federal grand jury indictments in the Upland corruption case, in which former mayor John Pomierski, his appointee to the Upland Housing Authority, John Hennes, and their associates Anthony Orlando Sanchez and Jason Roy Crebs have been charged with participation in a bribery and extortion scheme allegedly involving using Pomierski’s authority at City Hall to shake down businessman with permit applications pending before the city. Pomierski and Ramos were political allies. Ramos endorsed Pomierski in his successful runs for mayor in 2004 and 2008. In 2010, Pomierski endorsed Ramos in his run for reelection for district attorney. Two days after Ramos held back two challengers in the June 8, 2010 election, the FBI and IRS served search warrants at Pomierski’s home and at Upland City Hall, seizing documents and other evidence used to convince a federal grand jury in Los Angeles to indict him a little less than nine months later. Part of the formula Pomierski and Hennes were allegedly able to apply in extorting money from their victims was the claim that Pomierski functioned under an umbrella of protection provided by the district attorney’s office. And indeed, Pomierski had enjoyed an uncommon degree of tolerance from San Bernardino County’s highest law enforcement authority in perpetuating his alleged depredations. Despite widespread whisperings heard as early as 2006 that Pomierski was on the take, Ramos went out of his way to endorse him in his electoral effort against councilman Ray Musser in 2008.

In addition to accusations that Ramos deliberately obstructed justice in curtailing the investigative and prosecutorial processes from running their course with regard to his political ally Pomierski, there is further information to suggest that Ramos acted to prevent the wheels of justice from churning through several top county officials who had been accused of bastardizing the function of the county hospital, which is intended to provide care for the county’s indigent population. Located in Colton and known as Arrowhead Regional Medical Center, the county hospital has allegedly been exploited by current and former hospital officials for their own personal and financial benefit, as well as by elected officials, who used their position of authority over the hospital’s administrators to obtain free medical care.

As early as 2007, Ramos, his public integrity unit and the grand jury were informed of a circumstance which involved the city of Colton in a highly questionable acquisition of an eleven acre parcel from Retail Development Group, an outfit owned by Gary Schafer. The $3.65 million purchase was championed by then-Colton assistant city manager Mark Nuami, who justified the acquisition as a strategic move that would satisfy the U.S. Fish & Wildlife’s requirements that habitat for the endangered Delhi Sands Flower Loving fly be preserved, and thereby allow other development in the area to proceed. But the property Colton acquired from Schafer was not prime Delhi fly habitat. Nor did the city do an adequate appraisal of the property, as was legally required, and instead, Nuami substituted a $3.8 million offer on the property, which was of unsubstantiated provenance, as justification for the sum paid. It would later turn out that the property was coveted by Dr. Dev GnanaDev, Arrowhead Regional’s medical director, who was looking to have the city of Colton write down the cost of the property and sell it to him so he could house his own surgical group’s operations there.

Dr. GnanaDev, who in addition to being the medical director at Arrowhead Regional, owns and controls Arrowhead Regional Surgical Group, Inc., with which the county hospital has a $1.343 million annual contract for the provision of administrative, supervision, secretarial and directorship services for the hospital’s general surgery division, including the trauma, otolaryngology, burn surgery, oral surgery, neurological surgery, plastic surgery, opthalmologic surgery and transplant surgery departments.

GnanaDev’s actions in his capacities as both medical director and provider of service to the hospital, like his involvement in the questionable land deal involving the city of Colton and Schafer, was widely perceived by doctors working at the hospital as improper, involving a conflict of interest they felt compromised the quality of medical care and patient safety at the institution. Like the land deal, that conflict became the subject of complaints to the district attorney’s office’s public integrity unit and the county grand jury.

According to doctors and other staff members at the hospital, Dr. GnanaDev not only wrote the contract for his own surgical group, he has his own medical billing company which he utilizes to divert large amounts of money from the operations at the institution into his own accounts. Some of those doctors maintain that GnanaDev improperly used his status as medical director and his domination of the man who is supposed to oversee his function for the county, Arrowhead Regional executive director Patrick Petre, to punish doctors who refuse to use his billing company by having those doctors’ contracts with the hospital terminated.

Doctors and other medical professionals allege that in his rush to enrich himself, GnanaDev compromised the quality of care, and his policies resulted in scores of lapses in professionalism and medicine jeopardizing the well being of the patients at the facility. On multiple occasions, that negligence and malpractice resulted in severe injury and death, they say.

A report consisting of a “stack” of 40 to 50 cases was prepared by several doctors at Arrowhead Regional and delivered to Petre, in which specific acts of medical malpractice involving the action of several doctors including those in the obstetrician unit and Dr Guillermo Valenzuela, the head of the ObGyn department, were alleged. Petre then turned the information over to Dr. GnanaDev, who, according to several doctors, attacked the doctors who had prepared the report. At least four of the cases involved patient deaths. After Petre took the matter no further, several of the doctors went to the district attorney’s office and the grand jury with the report.

Those doctors were frustrated in their quest, however, when the district attorney’s office and the grand jury, which is advised by a prosecutor from the district attorney’s office, took no action.

Doctors and other professionals at the hospital have pointed out that Dr. GnanaDev uses some of the proceeds from his business and work for lobbying and making sizeable contributions both directly and through others to members of the board of supervisors as a means of compromising them.

According to Arrowhead Regional personnel, high ranking county officials, including members of the board of supervisors and former county administrative officer Mark Uffer, who prior to being elevated to the senior administrative position in the county had served as the hospital director, received treatment at the hospital to which they should not have been entitled. Both Petre and GnanaDev facilitated this or allowed it to take place to ingratiate themselves with the county’s decision makers and benefit themselves and the institution, those doctors alleged.

According to those doctors, GnanaDev bent or broke hospital rules, protocol and the law when he provided free care to former supervisor Paul Biane, current board of supervisors chairwoman Josie Gonzales and Uffer and at least one other member of Uffer’s family. In addition, those doctors have alleged, GnanaDev instructed hospital personnel to generate no records with regard to this specialized treatment and no bills were sent. The treatment included MRIs and surgeries, the doctors said.

According to doctors, GnanaDev, who was president of the California Medical Association from October 2008 to October 2009, arranged to have Petre remove a clause from the contracts of full time physicians working at Arrowhead Regional which prohibited those doctors from working at other hospitals. While president of the California Medical Association, Dr. GnanaDev maintained his role as medical director and chief of surgery while spending no more than three to four days per month at the hospital, those doctors said. He delegated very few of his responsibilities to others, physicians reported, reducing oversight of the doctors working at Arrowhead Regional to a dangerously low level.

By allowing a large number of the physicians who were the heads of the various medical groups at Arrowhead Regional to work at other sites, doctors report, GnanaDev facilitated them in receiving hospital subsidy money directly. Those heads of the individual groups were then able to pay lesser-experienced physicians who work for them bottom dollar for their services, increasing the profitability of the head physicians, the doctors reported to the grand jury and district attorney, leading to an absence of physician presence and an absence of quality physicians at the county hospital. In this way, the doctors alleged, GnanaDev had shirked his responsibility as medical director to audit the work of the groups the hospital contracts with to ensure the hospital’s operating funds are properly dispersed and that the hospital was getting the quality of care taxpayers were paying for. This has led to a situation at Arrowhead Regional, the doctors alleged, where it is common for respiratory therapists, nurses, and other personnel to function like physicians throughout the hospital, practicing, on a daily basis medicine without a license. In some cases, the doctors charged, the unlicensed staff members were teaching the student and resident physicians how to take care of patients.

It was also alleged that Dr. GnanaDev allowed the doctors employed by his surgical group to monopolize most of Arrowhead Regional’s 19 operating suites, such that a large backlog of orthopedic and urology patients developed, so they had to wait months for their surgeries. This led to the state citing the hospital for the backlog of orthopedic patients awaiting surgery.

Doctors who complained to the district attorney and grand jury about GnanaDev were also critical of his policy of accepting all trauma patients even though Arrowhead is not equipped to handle pediatric and major chest trauma. Doctors said they had witnessed incidents in which Dr. GnanaDev, who is recognized as a surgeon of considerable skill, perform surgeries on children less than two years of age using adult laparoscopic equipment and on other occasions using adult equipment on very small children. Doctors said that GnanaDev resisted transferring pediatric patients to other hospitals that were better equipped to operate on them because he was seeking to enhance the earnings of his own surgical group. Having pediatric patients in Arrowhead Regional’s intensive care unit in many cases resulted in injury or damage to patients through improper management and improper care, doctors reported, and in some cases children with severe brain injuries or other trauma who were improperly treated at Arrowhead died.

Between 2004 and 2010, at least 95 complaints pertaining to Arrowhead Regional were filed with state regulators, of which 28 were determined to be substantiated.

Jorge Valencia, the official spokesperson for Arrowhead Regional, said attacks on Dr. GnanaDev alleging he puts profit above safety, utilizes equipment that is not suitable for the operations he or others are performing or does not adhere to professional medical standards are unfounded. Reports that GnanaDev is involved in any form of conflict of interest or being investigated along those lines is also inaccurate, Valencia asserted. Valencia further denied any relationship between Arrowhead Regional and GnanaDev’s billing company. And though Valencia did not dispute that a number of deaths had occurred at the county hospital, he insisted that “concerns regarding patient care are handled by the medical staff through the peer review process. He said that the review was “comprehensive” and “governed by the bylaws of the medical staff and various other rules and regulations.”

But in the perception of many of the medical professionals working under GnanaDev, there had been inexcusable deviations from medical standards driven by the profit motive that had resulted in deaths and injuries and crossed the line into criminal conduct.

It is believed by at least some of those knowledgeable about the situation that Ramos was reluctant to act with regard to these issues because one of those implicated in the scandal at Arrowhead Regional is supervisor Josie Gonzales, a key Ramos supporter on the board of supervisors.

In the late winter of 2010, after the San Bernardino County district attorney’s office had failed to take action on the matter, doctors approached the FBI, passing along much of the same information to the federal agents that had been provided to the district attorney’s office and the grand jury. On November 4, 2010, a team of FBI agents, armed with search warrants, swooped down upon the county hospital, seizing documents relating to its operation and GnanaDev’s role in overseeing the 456-bed facility, in particular.

As of this week, no charges have been filed in that matter.

In November 2006, after litigation between the Rancho Cucamonga-based development company Colonies Partners and the county over flood control issues at the company’s Colonies at San Antonio development in Upland had dragged on for four years, a three member majority of the board of supervisors – then supervisors Bill Postmus and Paul Biane and supervisor Gary Ovitt – voted to settle the case by conferring a $102 million payment on the company.

More than three years later, in February 2010, the district attorney’s office joined with the California attorney general’s office in obtaining an indictment against Postmus and his one-time political associate, Jim Erwin, which alleged a criminal conspiracy involving an effort by Colonies Partners’ managing principals Jeff Burum and Dan Richards to first extort Postmus and Biane, and then bribe them to obtain the settlement. Prosecutors alleged that Ovitt’s chief of staff, Mark Kirk, was also bribed. While Postmus and Erwin were criminally charged, Burum, Richards, Kirk, Biane and the Colonies Partners’ public relations consultant, Patrick O’Reilly, were identified as unnamed and unindicted co-conspirators.

In May of this year, less than two months after Postmus pleaded guilty as charged and then testified in April and early May along with 44 others before a specially-impaneled grand jury, Burum, Kirk, and Biane were indicted, along with Erwin, who was reindicted. That indictment alleged that separate $100,000 contributions Burum and Richards made in 2007 to each of three political action committees founded, controlled or secretly controlled by Erwin, Biane and Kirk were bribes, and two $50,000 contributions made to political action committees controlled by Postmus also constituted bribes made in return for the settlement vote. Burum, according to the indictment, had served as an aider and abettor in the delivery of the bribes.

At once, the timing of the indictments fell under question. The original case against Postmus and Erwin had not been filed for more than three years after the November 2006 vote. And the superseding indictment came nearly four-and-a-half years after the vote. A major technical legal issue in the case was the elapsing of the statute of limitations, an issue seized upon by the lawyer for Burum, former U.S. District Court Judge Stephen Larson, who pointed out in court papers that “the prosecution is improperly attempting to charge Mr. Burum under conspiracy and aider and abettor theories because the statute of limitations had run on direct charges of bribery,” which Larson pointed out, “if timely brought would not have been precluded under the allegations of this indictment.”

Thus, the more than four-year delay in obtaining the indictment against Burum appeared to be a trap door built into the charges that in time will bring about the collapse of the case.

While the district attorney’s office’s temporizing appeared inexplicable to many, an examination of Ramos’s campaign financing records provided a possible explanation of the delay which appeared to be a fatal flaw in the case. Burum, over the first six years Ramos was district attorney, was a major contributor to Ramos’s electioneering fund. On May 14, 2003, a little more than four months after Ramos became district attorney, one of Burum’s companies, Jeffrey Burum Enterprises, provided Ramos with a relatively modest $1,500. On September 10, 2003, Burum provided Ramos with another $1,000. On November 22, 2005, another of Burum’s companies, Diversified Pacific, donated $10,000 to Ramos’s political war chest. On July 13, 2007, Diversified Pacific endowed Ramos’s campaign fund with another $5,000. On May 27, 2008, Diversified Pacific provided Ramos with $7,000.

In addition, over the last eight years, the Colonies partners and Burum donated over $400,000 to the political action committee controlled by SEBA, the San Bernardino County Safety Employees Benefit Association, which serves as the union for San Bernardino County’s sheriff’s deputies and district attorney’s office investigators. In 2010, the SEBA PAC gave Ramos $42,947.41 toward his election effort that year.

Unwilling to simply allow Ramos’s office and the state attorney general to usher what was increasingly viewed as a flawed case through state courts, the U.S. Attorney’s Office in September obtained search warrants that targeted the offices and/or homes of Burum, Kirk, Biane, Erwin, and O’Reilly, as well as the home and office of former state assemblyman and state senator Jim Brulte, a Colonies Partners consultant whose aggressive lobbying of Postmus and Biane and other county officials in an effort to obtain the settlement had been overlooked by Ramos’s investigators. Those warrants were served on September 15, signaling that federal authorities are now second guessing the district attorney’s office and the state attorney general’s office with regard to the Colonies settlement case.

In Victorville, a series of actions widely characterized as mis- or malfeasance by public officials has garnered the attention of citizens for some time. In response to citizen complaints, the 2009-10 first took up a probe of that city’s handling of its finances, along with the mismanagement of an effort to build an electrical generating plant, the misapplication of sequestered project funds, securities fraud, and improprieties with regard to a foreign investment program. When the 2009-10 grand jury concluded its session without taking any action with regard to Victorville or delivering a report about its investigation, the 2010-11 grand jury took that matter up where its predecessor had left off. But at the conclusion of its term on June 30 of this year, the 2010-11 grand jury had not come to closure on any of the Victorville issues. Likewise, the district attorney’s public integrity unit, which had also been vectored into Victorville to look at the situation there, took no action. On October 31, 2011, Ted Burgnon, the foreman of the 2011-12 San Bernardino County Grand Jury, in writing informed Victorville city officials the current grand jury is extending the two-year running probe into city finances and actions.

Well before Burgnon’s announcement, however, it was known around Victorville City Hall that federal officials have taken an interest in reports of violations of the public trust that have allegedly occurred within its confines.

Victorville delayed for two years an audit pertaining to its 2007 operations, leading to suggestions that city officials were seeking to hide information that was embarrassing, incriminating or both. Upon release, that audit showed the city had mounting financial problems. Another audit, completed by the firm of Mayer Hoffman McCann and released in March of this year, indicated those problems had worsened, and its authors expressed “substantial doubt about the city’s ability to continue as a going concern.” According to Mayer Hoffman McCann, it uncovered tens of millions of dollars in internal loans that were never approved, three funds that were $180 million in the hole and dwindling cash reserves.

As of March 2011, Victorville’s utility fund was $78 million upside down, while cash in the water district had dropped from $15 million in 2009 to $8 million as of June 30, 2010 despite a $20 million loan made to the district from the Southern California Logistics Airport Authority, the entity that oversees the effort to convert the former George Air Force Base into a civilian airport.

City officials have now reluctantly acknowledged that Victorville has lost an amount approaching $200 million on two abandoned power plants, an outgrowth of the city’s effort to create an electrical utility division, the Victorville Municipal Power Authority.

The Foxborough power station, which the city initiated in 2004 as what was supposed to be a $22 million, 14-megawatt electrical generating plant that would bypass the state power grid to provide affordable energy to industrial users and thus attract employers to the city and spur economic growth, has cost the city a whopping $126 million without being completed. Mismanagement of the project came in multiple stages, first at the hands of community services director Richard Bunnell; then deputy city manager Doug Robertson; followed by Wayne Campbell, who was hired as the plant manager in 2005; and then Glen Casanova, who was hired to replace Campbell as municipal utilities director in 2007.

By October 2006 the price tag for the project had escalated to over $54 million.

Construction delays and changes in state law that mandated that at least 20 percent of all energy produced in California by 2010 come from renewable sources resulted in the city jettisoning earlier plans for gas-fired combustion turbines, the pricey components for which were already purchased, and substituting in even more costly generators capable of running on biodiesel. The unused original equipment had to be sold at a substantial loss.

In addition to the initial and then follow-on equipment acquisition and construction costs, the utility division in 2005 incurred an operating deficit for the plant of $4.5 million. That hemorrhaging of red ink increased each year thereafter such that it had reached an annual operating deficit of $8 million by fiscal 2007-08. By 2007, the city began borrowing from its general fund to shore up the project. The city council, as quietly as it could get away with, issued $90 million in bonds to cover the entire cost of Foxborough. By May 2008, all of the bond money had been eaten up by the Foxborough power plant project and another $5 million beyond that was consumed, bringing the total cost on the facility to $95 million even before the facility’s permanent turbines had begun to generate electricity. At that point the city abandoned its initial intention of having the plant bypass the state power grid and avoid the imposition of a ten percent energy delivery fee being tacked onto the price of the power. Instead, the project was then scheduled to be hooked up to the state power system, canceling in the process the delivery of low cost energy, which had been the justification for the project in the first place.

Seven years after the project was undertaken, the city has failed to see that project through to fruition and the city council abandoned it altogether, after having sunk $126 million into the project.

The city is currently in default on an $83 million bond for Foxborough.

The city was simultaneously pursuing the development of another, much larger power plant, dubbed Victorville 2. The city was assisted in developing that plant by Newport Beach-based Inland Energy, which had successfully developed the 830-megawatt High Desert Power Plant with Baltimore-based Constellation Energy Group a decade ago. The High Desert Power Plant is now referred to as Victorville 1. Inland Energy had also served as a consultant with regard to the development of the Foxborough plant.

In November 2007 the Victorville city council authorized a $173 million purchase of natural gas-fired turbines from General Electric for the 563-megawatt Victorville 2 plant.

The city, which owed $126 million to General Electric for equipment for the Victorville 2 power project, fell into arrears on its payments to General Electric and in May 2010, simply surrendered a $50 million deposit it had made with the company for components. The Victorville 2 project was originally scheduled to include a 513-megawatt natural gas-fired generating plant on 133 acres coupled with an adjohining 250-acre solar power field capable of producing 50 megawatts of electricity. The solar component of the project has since been entirely abandoned and the remainder of Victorville 2 shelved, although in recent months some discussion has taken place between the city and Massachusetts-based QGEN about that company taking on the completion of the project.

Robertson has since been promoted to Victorville city manager.

In the summer of 2010, the Securities and Exchange Commission opened an investigation focusing on Victorville’s issuance of bonds and how that bond funding was spent. In May of 2010, the board of supervisors acceded to a grand jury request that the county retain the forensic auditing firm of Kessler International to review the city’s finances. The board did so, authorizing $195,000 for that audit. Kessler has not said whether the audit is yet concluded.

In making his announcement on October 31, grand jury foreman Burgnon indicated the grand jury has retained the independent San Francisco-based auditing firm of Harvey M. Rose Associates to go over both the city’s books and those of the Victor Valley Economic Development Authority, a joint powers authority involving the county, Victorville, Apple Valley, Hesperia and Adelanto which is involved in the provision of infrastructure to support Southern California Logistics Airport. It is not clear to what extent the ground covered by Kessler will be revisited by Harvey M. Rose.

It is known is that more than $80 million of the $300 million in outstanding bonds floated specifically for airport operations actually funded city of Victorville operations or projects off Southern California Logistics Airport property, including $1.8 million utilized to acquire land for a city library. According to Mayer Hoffman McCann, at least $21.8 million was not spent in accordance with the bond covenants. Other airport money was used toward work on the Victorville 2 power plant. The city also loaned $20 million in 2007 airport bond proceeds to the water district to help build a wastewater treatment plant. Those expenditures were made without informing or getting the consent of the bonds’ insurer, Radian.

The Southern California Logistics Airport Authority (SCLAA) has accumulated debt of $102 million, twice the burden it had in 2009-10.

Mayer Hoffman McCann reported that Victorville officials have not properly documented and sought city council approval for the city’s numerous interfund loans. The city had nearly $90 million in outstanding interfund loans as of last June. But only $30 million in loans had been formally approved by the council, according to the audit report.

Another issue dogging Victorville is its now-dormant EB-5 program. The EB-5 program is a federal one that allows entities such as cities or redevelopment agencies to arrange for the provision of visas for foreigners who invest at least $500,000 in projects pre-qualified by the federal government. In April 2008, the city entered into a relationship with CMB Export, LLC to manage an EB-5 program for Victorville at and around Southern California Logistics Airport. The city, however, abrogated that contract in June 2008 and in December 2008 CMB filed a $33 million lawsuit against the city claiming breach of contract, fraud, unfair competition and business interference. CMB refiled the claim in February 2009, including charges of misrepresentation and fraud by former city manager Jon Roberts and former mayor Terry Caldwell.

In April 2010, the city settled that lawsuit with CMB for $200,000. The following month, however, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Service suspended Victorville’s EB-5 program, stating that city officials had misrepresented the projects to be funded by the investment program. It was the first time the federal government had moved to terminate an entity’s EB-5 authority.

The U.S. Attorney’s office, alarmed at the wholesale squandering of financial resources in Victorville’s municipal operations as well as blunders with regard to federal law governing securities and its foreign investment programs and further dismayed by the inability of the local district attorney’s office and grand jury to take action, leapt into the breach and has now assigned FBI agents to examine Victorville with a scrupulously mean eye.

On September 21, 2011 the FBI served as the lead agency in serving search warrants at the headquarters of the San Bernardino International Airport Authority [SBIAA] and the Inland Valley Development Authority [IVDA], the joint powers agencies involving the county and the cities of San Bernardino, Colton, Loma Linda and Highland in the conversion of the former Norton Air Force Base into a civilian airport and the redevelopment of the surrounding property. Warrants were also served at the offices of the San Bernardino Million Air Franchise; three hangars, including Hangar 763, where two companies affiliated with the airport’s contract developer, Scot Spencer, Norton Aircraft Maintenance Services and SBAM Technics, are located. According to the search warrants, the authorities were seeking information regarding suspected misuse of federal funds, bribery, mail fraud, wire fraud and conspiracy.

Of interest to investigators were Spencer; SBIAA executive director Donald L. Rogers, who has since resigned; assistant SBIAA executive director Michael Burrows; aviation director Bill Ingraham; former SBIAA and IVDA director and current SBIAA and IVDA consultant T. Milford Harrison; San Bernardino International Airport Authority counsel Tim Sabo; San Bernardino mayor and SBIAA and IVDA board member Pat Morris; county supervisor and SBIAA and IVDA board member Josie Gonzales.

Spencer entered into the agreement with SBIAA and the Inland Valley Development Authority to oversee what was supposed to be a $38 million renovation of the airport’s passenger terminal and a $7 million development of its concourse. Spencer undertook that appoinment amid confident predictions that upon completion of those assignments the airport would attract at least one passenger carrier and as many as a half dozen airlines. The cost of the passenger terminal and the concourse escalated to $142 million and the airport has yet to host any commercial airlines, although corporate jets and other private pilots have been landing at the Million Air corporate aviation facility, for which Spencer is the franchisee, since last year.

The cost overruns for the terminal project, the failure of San Bernardino Airport to attract commercial airlines and Spencer’s relationship with Rogers, Harrison and SBIAA and IVDA counsel Timothy Sabo have raised eyebrows and brought SBIAA and IVDA under increasingly critical scrutiny.

On June 30, the San Bernardino County 2010-11 Grand Jury delivered a report that questioned several elements of Spencer’s performance and that of Rogers, calling into question what was characterized as lax oversight of the airport’s operations and favorable treatment accorded Spencer with regard to leasing arrangements.

Spencer’s influence over operations at the airport, where several companies he owns are housed, is increasingly perceived as being in conflict with and counterproductive to the goal of bringing in aeronautics oriented companies interested in remaining at the airport for the long term. In some cases, Spencer’s pursuit of his own imperatives conflicted with the corporate aims of others companies functioning at the airport, resulting in those companies departing.

Spencer now owes the county more than $604,000 in unpaid taxes on property and equipment at the airport since 2005. The county had made no effective effort to collect on those unpaid taxes until three weeks after the September 21 FBI raid.

The FBI’s action at the airport was taken as yet another indication of federal prosecutors’ lack of confidence in the San Bernardino County district attorney’s ability, willingness and resolve to aggressively act with regard to issues involving malfeasance on the part of local governmental officials.

At the San Bernardino County district attorney’s office, Ramos and other officials were reticent about what the federal government’s active interest in local political and public agency corruption cases signifies. “That sounds like a question for the FBI,” district attorney’s office spokesman Christopher Lee told the Sentinel. “We’re not going to speak about another agency’s handling of cases in our county.”

Lee said he could not say whether information churned up by the FBI will be used exclusively by the U.S. Attorney’s Office in any criminal cases it elects to pursue or whether the information might be provided to his office for potential prosecutions in state court.

“I don’t have that knowledge,” he said.

California Style The Scoop On Black Friday

What is fashion all about during the holiday season? It’s about color and shopping, of course! Black Friday is starting before the turkey gets cold this year. There’s no time for shut eye. With the extreme competition these days when it comes to retailers and holiday sales, it’s too soon to tell who really has the best deals. Here’s the fashion scoop for you Black Friday seekers and adventurers:

Nordstrom: will be opening at 8 a.m. (BF) and the Clinique department will offer a free Tracy Reese gift with any purchase of $25. They are offering free shipping on entire orders.

The Nordstrom Rack: will open at 7 a.m. (BF) and they have a 25% off coupon toward one item.

Macys: Opens at 12 a.m. (BF) and is having throughout the store discounts from kitchenware to men, women, and children’s shoes, clothes, jewelry and accessories.

Kohls: Opens at 12 a.m. (BF) and their feature is the home sale from 30 to 40 percent off selected comforters and sets.

The Gap: Opens at 12 a.m. (BF) and will feature their winter accessories at discounted prices.

Old Navy: Opens at 12 am (BF) and their sales will go into the weekend. Friday will feature all the winter accessories (pea coats, jackets, and sweaters) at 50% off. They will give away limited amounts of Free Kodak easy-share Sport Digital Camera bundles with a $40 purchase. On Saturday the entire store will be on sale: Kids jeans $10, and Adult jeans $15.

Jcrew: Opens at 12 am (BF). Almost everything is marked down to 60% off, the schoolboy blazers are 40% off, winter accessories 40% off, and ballet flats are 20% off.

The Ontario Mills has a Nordstrom rack, Gap, Old Navy, and JCrew if you want to make a one stop shop. At a time where every penny matters, some deals may be hard to pass up.

Look for big fashion statement pieces this season, like the beautifully adorned knitted jackets and wraps. Another statement piece is the sleeveless fur jacket. Whether belted or worn loosely, they work beautifully and no question about it: these are in. Whether you’re into BF or not, enjoy the magic time of the holiday season by catching a glimpse of some autumn color, even if just in fashion. I love this time of the year because everywhere I go there are people wearing colorful scarves, just walking their dogs or simply entering the local library and they are all beautiful people. Enjoy the whole thing and I will be back next week after your turkey meal.

“Above all, remember that the most important thing you can take anywhere is not a Gucci bag or French-cut jeans; it’s an open mind.” -Gail Rubin Bereny

Murillo Observatory At Cal State University San Bernardino Dedicated

Refreshments were served at the November 18 opening of the Murillo Observatory on Badger Hill at California State University San Bernardino.

The facility, which features two telescopes, was made possible in large measure through a $500,000 contribution by George and Pauline Murillo.

A condition of the bequest was that the observatory be open to the public. Accordingly, the university will make viewing of the heavens available on certain nights.

A life-sized statue of the Murillos by sculptor Bernard Edmunds adorns the entrance to the observatory.

Victor Valley Transit Authority Moves Into New $19 Million Headquarters

HESPERIA—Victor Valley Transit Authority employees on Monday began moving into their new headquarters.

The 28,820-square-foot administration and operations building was completed at a cost of $19 million, which is less than half the $42 million price projected for the facility in the engineer’s estimate in 2006.

By relocating the project from Hesperia Road and Ottawa Road to Smoktree Street and E Avenue and availing themselves of the reduction in construction costs made possible by the economic downturn of the last four years, agency officials were able to achieve the $23 million savings.

Located on a 10-acre parcel, the headquarters matches the modernity of the transit authority’s recently completed 15,750 square foot maintenance facility and its compressed natural gas fueling station.

Victor Valley Transit Authority provides local bus service for the communities of Adelanto, Apple Valley, Hesperia, Victorville, and the unincorporated portion of San Bernardino County in the Victor Valley, serving over 1 million passengers a year.

Barstow Police Chief Burns Still On Leave

BARSTOW—Barstow police chief Dianne Burns remains away from her post at police department headquarters, four months after she took an extended vacation and more than three months after she was placed on administrative leave August 4.

Burns was scheduled to return from a two-week vacation on July 18, but had not returned to her office by that date. City officials have not specified the reason for her extended leave. Previous statements provided by city manager Curt Mitchell indicated Lt. Albert Ramirez is serving as acting police chief in Burns’ absence but Burns has not been relieved of her post as Barstow police chief and she yet retains her title and is receiving her full salary.

It was previously anticipated that negotiations to extend her tenure with the city would begin in the fall. By the terms of her contract, Burns serves entirely at the pleasure of Mitchell, who can terminate her for any reason he alone deems acceptable or for no stated cause whatsoever. The contract provides her with a 90-day severance package upon termination.

More than 90 days have elapsed since she was placed on leave. Mitchell would not comment on unconfirmed reports that Burns’ leave was medical in nature. He would not go beyond saying she remains on leave. “There is no change on the status of chief Burns,” Mitchell said. “That is pretty much it.”

BLM Approves Right-Of-Way For Victorville-To-Vegas Bullet Train

The Federal Bureau of Land Management on November 17 issued a record of decision that approves the right-of-way for the Desert Express, a proposed high-speed rail line linking Las Vegas and Victorville.

Much of the route for the high speed train parallels Interstate I-15, with one significant deviation in the Mountain Pass area, where the grade is too steep to accommodate the track over which the train will pass at roughly 145 miles per hour.

According to DesertXpress Enterprises LLC corporate officers, the 185 mile rail corridor will cover 3,621 acres, of which 2,800 acres are privately held property ad 821 acres are public land. The project proponent will also need to use another 95 acres during the construction phase of the project.

DesertXpress Enterprises LLC, which has already assembled $1.7 billion in financing, is in the process of qualifying for a $4.9 billion federal loan to complete the $6.5 billion project.

The Federal Rail Administration, which approved the project in concept 11 months ago, is the lead agency overseeing the loan application.

If DesertXpress Enterprises LLC lines up that financing, corporate officers have indicated that construction on the project will start by late next year and DesertXpress will begin transporting passengers in 2016.

Feinstein Signaling Opposition To Joshua Tree Indian Casino

Senator Diane Feinstein has gone on record as being opposed to the Twentynine Palms Band of Mission Indians’ proposal to establish a casino in Joshua Tree.

The Twentynine Palms Tribe’s members abandoned previous plans to develop what they hoped to call the Nüwü Casino on 160 acres of tribal land on their reservation south of Baseline Road and west of Adobe Road bordering Joshua Tree National Park in Twentynine Palms in favor of a 130-acre parcel on the north side of Twentynine Palms Highway west of White Feather Road east of downtown Joshua Tree and just east of Desert View Homes’ metal dinosaurs.

Both proposals called or call for a complex with spacious gaming rooms, a buffet, banquet room, shops, bowling lanes, an outdoor amphitheater, RV park, golf course and other resort-oriented improvements.

But the proximity of the Twentynine Palms Marine Corps base and its 8,400 plus service members and dependents, which tribal officials considered a factor that would favor the casino’s success, incited strong resistance from the Department of Defense. When the National Park Service and Twentynine Palms residents registered their opposition, the tribe, led by Darrel Mike, substituted the Joshua Tree site, which is roughly 23 miles away from the reservation.

The 130-acres in Joshua Tree does not lie on what is recognized as the tribe’s ancestral land. To establish an Indian gaming facility there would require filing an application with the Bureau of Indian Affairs to place the land in a public trust. In getting that blessing, the tribe will need to transfer its right from its tribal property to the new site and make a case that the tribe had ancestral roots in the Joshua Tree area, where it had an historical relationship to the property in question by virtue of aboriginal activity, which included hunting, foraging and trading, in particular. This will likely entail an anthropological study to demonstrate the tribe’s ancestors ranged into Joshua Tree.

But even before that filing has been made, the Joshua Tree proposal has met local opposition. Far more Joshua Tree residents oppose the proposal than favor it. Among those opponents is Mark Butler, the superintendent at Joshua Tree National Park, and David Fick, a member of the Joshua Tree Municipal Advisory Council who is a member of the Morongo Basin Conservation Association and a political ally of San Bernardino County Third District Supervisor Neil Derry. Derry to is opposed to the casino locating in Joshua Tree.

That array of opponents was joined this month by the senior senator from California.

On November 10 Feinstein penned a letter to Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar registering her opposition to a proposed casino in Joshua Tree. “Placing a casino less than a mile from the (Joshua Tree National) park’s visitor center and park wilderness will forever change the nature of the desert treasure,” she told Salazar in the letter. Feinstein noted Butler’s opposition to the proposed casino being sited so close to the park. She said park officials had expressed concern a high intensity use such as a casino at that location “would impair the Park Service’s ability to preserve natural resources, cause significant noise and light pollution, obstruct scenic viewsheds and adversely impact the desert tortoise population within the park.”

Moreover, Feinstein in the letter to Salazar cited the overwhelming opposition to the casino by Joshua Tree residents, and she said their consensus included a “wide array of concerns about the impacts on regional tourism, crime, poverty, alcoholism and gambling addiction.”

Meanwhile, tribal leader Mike and the band’s chief financial officer, Steve Gralla, insist their proposal makes sense not just to the tribe but to the community as well.

They said local opposition will transform into support once the populace is given to understand the casino will bring in needed economic development to the area, improve and modernize infrastructure near downtown and provide the town with an attraction that will enhance its ambience. Moreover, they point out, the property is near other citified uses and developments and is not hamstrung by the presence of endangered species or flora, such as the desert tortoise.

Mike, Gralla and the tribe are promoting the proposed resort as having, “all the excitement of Las Vegas only minutes away.”

Church Of The Woods Plan Jars Residents

Many residents of the Twin Peaks community expressed wariness over the proposed sports and worship complex to be built by the Church of the Woods along Highway 18 in Rimforest.

Church of the Woods is proposing to clear forest land on the east side of Rim Forest west of Daley Canyon and to fill in the marsh that exists at the headwaters of Little Bear Creek to accommodate the development.

Some local residents and members of the Save our Forest Association object to the plan to remove 350,000 cubic yards of dirt from the area and to cover with soil the wetlands and natural spring, which feeds the blue line creek flowing into Lake Arrowhead.

A preview of the project, which is to be considered by the county planning commission next month, was provided to interested Twin Peaks and Rim Forest residents recently as the public input deadline for the environmental impact review of the project approaches.

Of concern is that the grading and leveling that will be done for the project, which includes filling in a natural depression in the forest will result in potential landslides and increased run-off downstream, together with erosion, flooding and debris saturation into Agua Fria and Blue Jay during rainstorms.

Historically, there has been difficulty with unstable slopes in Rimforest. Less than a quarter mile from the sports and worship complex site, a large scale landslide took out homes in 1993. One issue embraced by opponents of the project was inadequate focus on the impact to endangered species, such as the Southern Rubber Boa, in the environmental impact study. The environmental impact report calls for those matters to “be dealt with later.”

Flow of Little Bear Creek is subject to regulation by the Department of Fish and Game and the U.S. Forest Service.

Judge Allows Prem Reddy To Move Toward VVCH Acquisition

VICTORVILLE—Victorville Superior Court Judge Steve Malone this week turned back California Attorney General Kamala Harris’s effort to prevent Dr. Prem Reddy and his for-profit corporation, Prime Healthcare Services, from moving into a position that will facilitate an eventual takeover of the non-profit and now bankrupt Victor Valley Community Hospital.

For reasons that have not been entirely publicly specified, Harris has taken a stand against Reddy in his effort to acquire Victor Valley Community. Reddy’s Prime Healtcare Services Corporation is the largest operator of for-profit hospitals in Southern California.

Victor Valley Community has been on the financial rocks for some time and last year, staggering under more than $20 million in debt, the institution filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. In the same time frame, the 101-bed hospital was put on the auction block, attracting two bidders: KPC Global Care and Reddy’s Prime Healthcare, which runs 14 acute care hospitals in California. KPC Global outbid Prime Healthcare in November 2010 with a $37 million offer at an auction. KPC obtained the state attorney general’s approval for the takeover, but then failed to finalize the acquisition and that deal fell apart. Subsequently, a federal bankruptcy court judge approved an agreement allowing the non-profit arm of Reddy’s for-profit venture, known as Prime Healthcare Service Foundation, to purchase the hospital for $35 million.

On September 20, however, the state attorney general’s office intervened, blocking Reddy, who is the owner and chairman of the board of Prime Healthcare, from absorbing Victor Valley Community into his portfolio. A major consideration was that Victor Valley Community was founded and set up as a non-profit institution. The attorney general’s office had moved to ensure that the High Desert preserve at least one non-profit hospital in an area with a multiplicity of for-profit medical centers, including one already owned by Reddy, Desert Valley Hospital.

“We have concluded that this proposed sale is not in the public interest and will likely create a significant effect on the availability or accessibility of health care services to the affected community,” acting chief deputy attorney general Michael Troncoso said in September.

Victor Valley Community Hospital’s status as a non-profit had seemingly doomed it to insolvency. Its financial outlook was damaged by excessive amounts of uncompensated care to uninsured and low income patients in recent years. According to the hospital’s recently departed CEO, Catherine Pelley, 70 percent of the hospital’s patients are on Medi-Cal, Medicare or charity care.

With Victor Valley Community teetering on the brink of financial collapse, Reddy on October 14, 2011 proffered $6 million in the form of loans and a consulting arrangement to prevent the hospital from having to close its doors. That assistance was codified in the form of what was called a “post-petition revolving credit and security agreement between Victor Valley Community Hospital as borrower and Prime Healthcare Management, Inc. as lender.”

Hospital officials have said Prime Healthcare’s offer is the only way Victor Valley Community Hospital [VVCH] can continue to operate.

Under the terms of the deal, both Reddy and Prime Healthcare are to provide what was referred to as “temporary” financing to keep the hospital up and running. That plan was given backing by a few federal healthcare regulatory agencies. And On October 20, U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Catherine Bauer tentatively signed off on the arrangement.

A day earlier, on October 19, a letter was sent by the state attorney general’s office to Victor Valley Community Hospital’s legal counsel stating that the credit, security and consulting agreement was subject to approval by the attorney general’s office under California Corporations Code Section 5194 et sequitur. On October 19, the hospital’s legal counsel responded that the attorney general’s approval is not required.

According to a complaint for injunctive relief filed by the attorney general on October 28, “The consulting agreement transfers control of a material amount of the operations of VVCH to Prime Healthcare management. The loan agreement conveys and transfers a material amount of VVCH’s assets to Prime, Inc. Accordingly, both agreements are subject to approval by the attorney general. Defendants violated the Corporations Code sections 5914 and 5915 by failing to submit written notice and failing to get written consent of the attorney general prior to entering into this agreement. By entering into this loan agreement without the attorney general’s consent, VVCH will incur additional administrative costs by $6 million, thereby increasing the amount of cash necessary for other potential buyers to purchase VVCH. By increasing VVCH’s debt, the parties will be manipulating the market value of the hospital. The loan agreement also subjects VVCH to default. The loan agreement provides that if VVCH subsequently defaults on the loan agreement, all of Prime Inc.’s loan must be paid in full, in cash immediately.”

The attorney general’s office petitioned the court for “temporary, preliminary and permanent injunctive relief enjoining VVCH, its board members, officers, employees, agents, servants, representatives, successors, and assigns, any and all persons acting in concert or participation with it, and all other persons, corporations, or other entities acting, under, by, through or on its behalf from executing or otherwise entering into the postpetition revolving credit and security agreement between VVCH as borrower and Prime Healthcare Management, Inc., as lender, dated as of October 14, 2011; performing any acts under the postpetition revolving credit and security agreement, including, but not limited to, incurring any debt under that agreement; [and] executing or otherwise entering into the consulting services agreement between VVCH and Prime Healthcare Management, as consultant.”

Harris maintained that in representing Prime Healthcare as a consultant, both entities – Prime Healthcare and Victor Valley Community – were engaging in a ruse to avoid the oversight of the state attorney general’s office in a ploy that would ultimately result in the transference of control and ownership of the hospital to Prime Healthcare.

On November 23, Malone dismissed the attorney general’s assertions, ruling that Victor Valley Community had the autonomy to enlist Prime Healthcare as an independent contractor and that Victor Valley Community is still governed by an independent board of directors, which will have decision-making power over the future of the hospital.

The attorney general’s office has been less than fully explicit in explaining the reasons for opposing Prime Healthcare’s takeover bid for Victor Valley Community, asserting only that Reddy’s ownership of the hospital is “not in the public interest.” Harris has suggested without directly stating that Reddy has a monopolistic motive in seeking to acquire Victor Valley Community since he already controls Desert Valley Hospital. In conferences with her office’s attorneys, Harris has stated that Reddy’s domination of a given region’s medical facilities could deprive the indigent of health care options. In a brief, the attorney general noted Prime Healthcare’s propensity for canceling HMO contracts.

There has been some suggestion that Harris’s opposition to Reddy’s takeover effort is tainted by political considerations. Reddy’s for-profit corporation has had a bruising set of battles with nurses and other health care professionals over wage and benefit concessions. Harris was endorsed by a labor union that represents nurses in her election last year.

Among the contingent of lawyers from the state attorney general’s office was a lawyer for the Services Employees International Union (SEIU), which has represented health care workers in labor disputes with Prime Healthcare and which opposes Reddy’s takeover of Victor Valley Community. When that lawyer sought to go on the record to endorse the attorney general’s call for an injunction against Reddy and Prime Healthcare, Malone denied the request, ruling that the union does not have standing.

While Malone allowed Prime Healthcare to remain involved in the current operation of Victor Valley Community as a consultant and lender, the long term ownership of the facility remains an unresolved issue. KPC Global has now tendered an offer to purchase the hospital, reduced from $37 million to $31.1 million. Victor Valley Community has lodged a suit, asking the court to reduce the attorney general’s barrier to Prime Healthcare’s purchase offer of $35 million.

Malone scheduled the hospital’s lawyers and the representatives from the attorney general’s office to return to his courtroom on December 15 for further briefing of both sides’ positions.

California Style Fun Rings

This weekend I visited Las Vegas. I couldn’t help noticing all the women wearing fun rings. There’s something really nifty about them. They are a fun accessory. I knew I had to have one. Upon my return to California, I found a unique cocktail ring that fit my personality. The cocktail ring is an oversized affair that covers up to four of your fingers but is only worn on one. They have been around for about seventy years.

Stunning cocktail rings are big this year and make the perfect holiday accessory. They are a gorgeous number for any occasion. Some are embellished with diamonds, colorful stones, and some come in shapes of animals. The fun ring can add tons of pop to any ensemble. You can find cocktail rings just about anywhere (Nordstrom, H&M, JCrew, Macys, Target, etc…). Prices vary from as low as $4 up well into the $100 range. Some fun/cocktail rings are topped with large single stones or other patterns. These rings add boldness and sparkle to any outfit.

The point is to find one you can have fun with and wear it with your favorite dress, jeans, suit, etc… Cocktail rings are fabulous because you can actually find them for less than five bucks. The trend never goes out of style, they’re versatile, they add the sparkle that another accessory can’t replace, and they’re plain fun. If you don’t have your fabulously fun unique cocktail ring yet, it’s time you go out and seek the one for you. Off we go!

“A ring is a halo on your finger.” -Doug Coupland