Rigney Appointed To Big Bear Wastewater Agency

Jeff Rigney, who is San Bernardino’s director of its special districts department, has been appointed to the Big Bear Area Regional Wastewater Agency.
Rigney was nominated to the post by Third District supervisor Neil Derry, in whose district Big Bear lies.
Rigney assumed the fourth seat on the wastewater agency board, which was occupied by former member Thomas Brandau, whose term expired on January 31, 2011 but had remained on the board until August 23, 2011. Rigney has been redesignated as the fifth seat on the board and his term will run for four years and expire on January 31, 2016.
Rigney is the son of the late Robert Rigney, who was San Bernardino County’s chief administrative officer from 1980 to 1986.
In appointing Jeff Rigney to the Big Bear Area Regional Wastewater Agency, the board of supervisors did not address any potential conflict his position on the board might present vis-à-vis his position as director of county special districts.

Opposition Forms Against Sending Desert Water To Orange County

Belated opposition is hurriedly forming to a plan that would pump an average of 50,000 acre-feet of water per year out of the aquifer in San Bernardino County’s eastern Mojave Desert and convey it in a pipeline to Riverside, Orange and Los Angeles counties to replenish the water supply there.
The Santa Margarita Water District, which services an area that is more than 200 miles from the Cadiz Valley, is the lead agency for what is called The Cadiz Valley Conservation, Recovery and Storage Project.  As the lead agency, the Santa Margarita Water District, the second largest water district in Orange County, will oversee the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) review process for the project.
Santa Margarita will work with the Cadiz Land Company in the proposed undertaking, which is a modified version of the Cadiz Water Project floated by Cadiz Land and the Metropolitan Water District more than a decade ago. The original project called for the Cadiz Land Company pumping water from the Colorado River during wet years, storing it in an underground aquifer beneath the Cadiz Valley, and selling as much as 60,000 acre-feet of the native groundwater and Colorado River water mix to the Metropolitan Water District (MWD) in Los Angeles during dry years.  That proposal was ultimately rejected by the Metropolitan Water District’s board of directors after conservationists raised concerns over possible environmental damage. The  MWD’s rejection of the project led to expensive litigation between the Cadiz Land Company and the MWD.
The concept lay dormant for six years but in 2008, the Cadiz Land Company, also known as Cadiz, Inc., revived the plan in modified form, emphasizing less the drawing of water from the Colorado River and instead proposing to obtain much of the water from sources feeding the area’s dry lakes that are subject to evaporation.  The revived project was given a tentative budget of $536.25 million and is to entail the sinking of 34 wells into the desert and construction of a 44-mile pipeline along a railroad right-of-way until it meets up with the aqueduct that carries Colorado River water to the Los Angeles and Orange County metropolitan areas.
Through the arrangement with the Cadiz Land Company, the  Santa Margarita Water District will receive the lion’s share of the water. In addition, Cadiz, Inc. has entered into agreements with Three Valleys Water District, which provides water to   the Pomona Valley, Walnut Valley, and Eastern San Gabriel Valley; the Golden State Water Company, which serves several communities in Southern California, including Claremont;   Suburban Water Systems, which serves Covina, West Covina and La Mirada; and the Jurupa Community Services District, which serves Mira Loma in Riverside County.
The Cadiz Valley is located just south of the Marble Mountains  and northeast of the Sheep Hole Mountains near the National Trails Highway. Cadiz is home to a former railroad stop along the Santa Fe line, 17 miles east of Amboy and 70 miles from Needles.
The public hearings related to the Cadiz Valley Conservation, Recovery and Storage Project were held in Yucca Valley, which is 85 miles from Cadiz, and in Rancho Santa Margarita, which is 217 miles from Cadiz.  Many of those directly impacted by the project, including the Bolo Station Water Company, which serves the Cadiz Valley and the property immediately adjoining that of the Cadiz Land Company, was not provided notice of the hearings.
Among those at the forefront of the movement to oppose the Cadiz Valley Conservation, Recovery and Storage Project is former Needles city councilwoman Ruth Musser-Lopez, who was previously employed as a Bureau of Land Management Archaeologist assigned to the California Desert District and was active in opposing the Cadiz Water Project in its first incarnation.

Ruth Musser-Lopez

Musser-Lopez decried the project as one that would confiscate a vital and rare resource from the desert region. She said the Cadiz Land Company and the Santa Margarita Water District had formed an unholy alliance of a rapacious corporation and a quasi-governmental agency that was abusing the approval and environmental certification processes to violate the rights of the region’s residents, and depriving future generations of desert dwellers of access to water.
Both the Santa Margarita Water District and the Cadiz Land Company have represented the project as one that is aimed at “conservation” of water otherwise lost to evaporation. A major selling point is that the project will represent a $138 million boon to the East Mojave’s economy that will directly or indirectly create 2,090 jobs for four years, involving $53 million in wages or salaries to workers or proprietorships involved in building the pipeline and other elements of the project.
Musser-Lopez, however, charged that “the Cadiz Land Company and the Santa Margarita Water District are promising the residents of the desert a short term gain in the form of temporary construction jobs in exchange for this huge long term detriment.  What this project is about is having water taken from San Bernardino County’s desert to be used in Orange County. Why should we allow a small company to utilize that water resource elsewhere?”
Musser-Lopez found particular fault with the manner in which the public hearing process for the project was conducted. She said those with the greatest stake in the region’s water supply were practically excluded from participation in the approval process when the hearings were conducted in Joshua Tree and in Santa Margarita at locations far removed from the Cadiz Valley and its residents and land owners.
She further suggested that utilizing the Santa Margarita Water District as the lead agency on the project was a violation of both the California Constitution, the California  Code of Regulations and the California Environmental Equality Act. In particular, she cited 14 CCR § 15051 (b) of the California Administrative Code which states, “If the project is to be carried out by a nongovernmental person or entity, the lead agency shall be the public agency with the greatest responsibility for supervising or approving the project as a whole. The lead agency will normally be the agency with general governmental powers, such as a city or county, rather than an agency with a single or limited purpose such as an air pollution control district or a district which will provide a public service or public utility to the project.”
Musser-Lopez told the Sentinel, “This law is binding. I believe this is grounds for an injunction.”
Accordingly, Musser-Lopez lodged a complaint with the San Bernardino County district attorney’s office’s public integrity unit as well as with the San Bernardino County grand jury, alleging “the public was misled to believe that they would get a real hearing with regard to the content of the environmental impact report as the California Environmental Quality Act provides for,” according to a draft of the grand jury complaint acquired by the Sentinel. In that complaint, Musser-Lopez makes much of the consideration that the logical and legal lead agency on the project,  San Bernardino County, had been bypassed.
At a hearing for the project held in Joshua Tree on February 1, 2012, Lopez-Musser notes in the draft grand jury complaint, the Santa Margarita Water District’s “chief engineer who was running the meeting made a statement on the record that San Bernardino County authorized the Santa Margarita Water District to be the lead on the California Environmental Quality Act document.  If this is true, I did not see this stated in the environmental impact report. There are many people who would like to know when the supervisors made this decision and in what forum.”
Musser-Lopez cited “the unreasonable burden of travel expense to attend meetings 200 and 85 miles from the project site” in her complaint to the district attorney’s office’s public integrity unit.
Moreover, Musser-Lopez alleged, allowing the Santa Margarita Water District (SMWD), the jurisdiction of which does not include the Cadiz Valley nor any portion of San Bernardino County, to serve as the lead agency and oversee the compliance of  the project with the California Environmental Quality Act, including processing and accepting the environmental impact statements and reports with regard to the project, is improper and a conflict of interest that was an outright corruption of the process.
“Since its jurisdiction is in Orange County, the SMWD inappropriately misidentified itself as the ‘lead agency’ on the project when the lead agency is obviously San Bernardino County, since our own elected county supervisors have the most authority to approve or disapprove a project which is totally encompassed within the county of San Bernardino,” Lopez-Musser said. “How does being a potential customer of Cadiz Water make SMWD a ‘participant’ in the Cadiz Corporation Project which would justify an Orange County water district being in a position to certify an EIR [environmental impact report] in San Bernardino County?  There are lots of potential customers, including San Bernardino County water districts.   Interestingly, the Metropolitan Water District, which was originally involved in the project, is not identified as a participant in the project and their Colorado River canal  absolutely is a necessary component of the project, making the MWD a key agency on this project.   Citizens of San Bernardino did not elect the SMWD board or vote on the formation of their district. SMWD has no right to come up here and try to shove this project down our throats after we already defeated it once.”
Furthermore, Musser-Lopez charged, “They are withholding evidence from the EIR. They are saying the desert’s aquifers are not a complex hydrological system and that the water table is not connected to the springs up above and that the water tables are not connected. There is no evidence to back that. The water tables are connected and there are fissures in the bedrock and granite separating them. What is done to one aquifer impacts the adjacent water tables. It is rightfully San Bernardino County who should be the lead agency and the county planning department should be the lead in the preparation of the environmental impact report.”
Musser-Lopez was highly critical of supervisor Brad Mitzelfelt, in whose First District the Cadiz Valley is located.
“He completely abrogated his responsibility as our county’s representative,” she said. “It was absolutely shameful. At those hearings there was no one from San Bernardino County representing us. They left it entirely up to water district officials from Orange County to run the show and dictate how our water is going to be used and where.”
Mitzelfelt has not dwelled on the environmental aspect of the project. His only public pronouncement with regard to the plan was to hail it as one that would provide “an immediate infusion of economic stimulus” to the Eastern Mojave.
Since Mitzelfelt was appointed to the board of supervisors in 2007, the Cadiz Land Company has been one of his major political backers, having contributed a total of $48,100 to his campaign fund.
On March 13, 2007, the Cadiz Land Company gave the Committee to Elect Brad Mitzelfelt $10,000. On June 30, 2007 the Cadiz Land Company gave the Committee to Elect Brad Mitzelfelt $12,500. On November 20, 2007 Cadiz, Inc. gave the Committee to Elect Brad Mitzelfelt $5,000.
On June 18, 2008 the Cadiz Land Company gave the Committee to Elect Brad Mitzelfelt $5,000.  On October 30, 2008, Cadiz, Inc.  gave the Committee to Elect Brad Mitzelfelt $5,000.
On May 14, 2009 the Cadiz Land Company gave the Committee to Elect Brad Mitzelfelt $4,000.  On July 30, 2009 Cadiz, Inc. gave the Committee to Elect Brad Mitzelfelt $1,000.
On April 12, 2010, the Cadiz Land Company gave the Committee to Elect Brad Mitzelfelt $1,600. On October 6, 2010 Cadiz, Inc. gave the Committee to Elect Brad Mitzelfelt $1,500. On December 10, 2010 the Cadiz Land Company gave the Committee to Elect Brad Mitzelfelt $2,500.

Brad Mitzelfelt

The Cadiz Land Company’s heavy political activity appears aimed at propounding its water resource and water rights accumulation agenda. Ostensibly, the company has represented itself as an agricultural concern, for which the accumulation of water rights was an ancillary aspect. But the company has not been able to sustain itself as an agricultural operation for well over a decade. Beginning in 1986, the company established vineyards, growing organic table grapes exclusively. In 1989, the vineyards were augmented with an organic citrus grove. Seasonal crops, including melons, peppers, squash, asparagus and beans are grown on the Cadiz ranch. The Cadiz Land Company owns, or has options on, 45,000 acres, which, according to the company’s website, are “underlain by high quality groundwater resources.” Roughly 9,600 acres of that property is zoned for agricultural use. In the environmental impact report for the the water plan, reference is made to “approximately 1,600 acres of active agricultural lands” serviced by  “seven groundwater production wells located in the central portion of the Cadiz Property that supply irrigation water for the existing agricultural operation.” According to the company’s website, however, the farming concern has yet to grow beyond the 500-acre footprint that was established more than two decades ago.
Despite the fact that since 1993 the company has been celebrating the Cadiz Ranch as “the largest agricultural operation in San Bernardino County,” it has not had a profitable year at least since 1999, and sustained losses exceeding $50 million since 2007.  The company’s lenders have propped it up through regular periodic infusions of cash.
In 2008, when the company publicly announced that it was looking to revive the water conservation project, it lost $16 million. At that point, the company’s operating capital had dwindled to $4.3 million. The following year, the company again turned to its longtime lender,  L.C. Capital Master Fund, Ltd., for an additional $10 million in operating capital. L.C. Capital agreed to provide that money, and another $5 million the following year.
In 2010, the company continued to operate at a considerable loss, although the company continued to issue stock, and stockholders recouped an annual 4 percent return. Nevertheless, the company courted controversy when its board of directors voted to increase chief executive officer Keith Brackpool’s compensation by 210 percent for fiscal year 2010 and chief financial officer Timothy Shaheen’s compensation by 149 percent.
On June 2, 2011, a majority of the company’s shareholders expressed their disapproval, voting against the company’s 2010 CEO and top executive compensation increases.
In July 2011, San Diego-based Robbins Umeda LLP, a shareholder rights litigation firm, commenced an investigation into possible breaches of fiduciary duty and other violations of the law by certain officers and directors at Cadiz, Inc.
The outcome of that investigation has not been publicly revealed, though it appears that L.C. Capital Master Fund, Ltd. may have lost  faith in the company. More recently, Altima Partners, a privately held hedge fund company in England, has emerged as a major investor, having zoomed to being the third  largest shareholder in Cadiz, just behind  Water Asset Management, which lists as the second largest stockholder in Cadiz. Two months ago, Cadiz saw yet another $11 million infusion of funds, as Water Asset Management provided Cadiz with $5 million and Altima Partners put up another $6 million.
These investors have been brought in, and have so far stayed the course, not because of a belief in the company’s potential as an agricultural concern, but because of representations that the company is on the cusp of transforming itself into a major producer and purveyor of water. Company officials and Santa Margarita Water District officials have openly maintained that they will have unfettered access to the Cadiz Valley’s groundwater and have hinted that they will eventually obtain access to Colorado River Water at Lake Mead.
Questions exist, however, as to whether the company has the right to draft the water it is looking to market to the Santa Margarita Water District, Three Valleys Water District, Golden State Water Company, Suburban Water Systems, and the Jurupa Community Services District as participants in the Cadiz Valley Conservation, Recovery and Storage Project, let alone draft water in the quantities some of the company’s investors have been led to believe the company will secure in the future.
Under the auspices of the Cadiz Valley Conservation, Recovery and Storage Project, Cadiz Land is projecting pumping 50,000 acre-feet of water from the aquifer in wet years.
An acre-foot is equal to the amount of water that would cover an acre to the depth of one foot, i.e., 43,560 cubic feet, or 325,851.43 gallons, approximately the amount of water used by a typical household comprised of four people in a metropolitan area over the course of a year.
While water rights have yet to be adjudicated in that portion of the East Mojave, the Cadiz Land Company under the law pertaining to water use in the state of California would not be able to assert a right to pump any more water than it has established a pattern of using over a several year period in all of its operations. Information on the amount of water being used at the Cadiz Ranch is not publicly available. Agricultural experts, however, have told the Sentinel that under the climactic conditions prevailing in the Cadiz Valley for the type of farming operation there, a 500-acre ranch is not likely to use more than 2,000 acre-feet of water per year on average.
According to charts, formulas and calculation provided to the Sentinel by Dr. Charles Burt of the Irrigation Training and Research Center with the Agricultural Department at California Polytechnic University at San Luis Obisbo, a 500-acre farming operation in the East Mojave combining equal parts of grapes, melons, tomatoes squash and peppers   would consume 1,965.2 acre-feet of water per year if sprinkler irrigation were used.
“It depends on the crops you grow, but for what you are talking about that would be a ballpark figure,” Burt said.
Cadiz Land Company  officials have privately said they are utilizing closer to 5,000 acre-feet of water per year.
According to the company, the project will proceed.
“The Cadiz Valley Water Conservation, Recovery and Storage Project is designed to capture and conserve billions of gallons of renewable native groundwater flowing beneath our property in  California’s Mojave Desert that is currently being lost to evaporation and salt contamination at nearby dry lakes. Through the active management of the aquifer system and a state-of-the-art groundwater protection program, the project will reduce the loss of groundwater to evaporation from the dry lakes, put this water to beneficial use and create a reliable water supply without adversely impacting the aquifer system or the desert environment,” according to a company statement. “The total quantity of groundwater to be recovered and conveyed to project participants will not exceed a long-term annual average of 50,000 acre-feet per year.”
According to Cadiz, Inc., the project is an environmentally responsible one that should not alarm environmentalists or local land owners.
“The water project will be implemented in two phases,” the company stated. “As part of the first phase of the project, wells would be constructed on our Cadiz Valley property to actively manage the aquifer system and minimize loss of groundwater.  The project wellfield will capture and conserve water that is naturally flowing into the system every year and recover water that is moving toward the dry lakes and would otherwise be lost to salt contamination and eventual evaporation.  The wellfield will change the hydraulic gradient by pulling water back from its natural downward flow.  Safe, established groundwater management techniques will be employed by the project operators to ensure the project is operated without causing harm to the local environment.
“The recovered groundwater would be conveyed to participating water providers from the water project area via a 43-mile pipeline to the Colorado River Aqueduct for delivery throughout the region,” the company statement continues. “The pipeline will be buried underground within an active railroad right-of-way that crosses the project area and the aqueduct. Participating water providers will also have the option to decrease or forego their water delivery in certain years, such as wet years, and carry it over to future years when it may be needed. This carry-over water would be stored in the aquifer system at the project area.”
The company statement hinted at Cadiz, Inc.’s future intention of securing drafting rights from the Colorado River.
“A second phase of the water project would make available up to one million acre-feet of groundwater storage space in the aquifer system for water imported to the project area,” according to the corporate statement. “Under the imported water storage component, water from the Colorado River or potentially the State Water Project could be conveyed to recharge basins on our property in wet years to percolate into the aquifer system, where it would be held in storage. In dry years, previously stored water would be returned to the Colorado River Aqueduct via the conveyance pipeline.”
The corporate statement makes no mention of the possibility of directing Colorado River Water stored in the Cadiz aquifer to the Los Angeles County and Orange County metropolitan area.
In its references to the water project, the Santa Margarita Water District referred to it as one that will draw upon “a potential new water source from a large, renewable aquifer located in the eastern Mojave Desert in San Bernardino County. If implemented, the Cadiz Project would diversify SMWD’s water portfolio and help drought-proof the district to ensure its water demands are met regardless of the state’s supply.”
Both Cadiz, Inc. and the Santa Margarita Water District have succeeded in having the public input period relating to the project closed down as of February 13. As more of those to be impacted by the project have become aware of it, they are seeking, like Musser-Lopez, to revamp the terms of the approval and CEQA processes, and removing Santa Margarita Water District as the lead agency on the project.
“I’m one of over 1,100 property owners in the Fenner watershed that has never been directly informed that the Cadiz project could impact my groundwater,” said Chris Ervin. “I have a well on my Round Valley property, as do many of my neighbors. The purpose of  Cadiz’s pumping is to induce water from the high country–where our properties are located–to flow downhill to refill the Cadiz Dry Lake aquifer. We are therefore concerned the Cadiz water project may affect the quantity and/or quality of our groundwater upon which we depend in the desert.”
Leigh Adams, who maintains a residence in the Los Angeles County community of Altadena but is also a desert landowner with property in Rimrock above Pioneertown, considers herself a desert stakeholder. She harvests storm water on both her desert property and her Altadena area property.
“I am vehemently opposed to the Cadiz project,” she told the Sentinel. “It is water piracy, a vile theft from desert wildlife and human beings.  The concept of water evaporating being “wasted water” is simply ludicrous! This is a lousy idea.  Orange County has lush lawns and swimming pools that are thirsty for water.  Let Santa Margarita use the money they propose for this project for education of home and business owners around the topic of conservation. Fifty percent of the water in our communities is used for watering lawns.  We buy water from other areas to replace the water we’ve allowed to run off into storm drains and gutters.  When those areas, the Sacramento Delta, the Colorado River, Owens Valley, run out of water, we propose to steal it from somewhere else.  Reprehensible!”
David Fick, of Joshua Tree, said that he was highly skeptical of the project in its present form.  “Going back ten to 12 years ago, it was a water banking scheme  to put water in and out of the aquifer and this time they are just going to be taking water out. The proponents of the project say there is 32,000 acre-feet of natural recharge into the basin, but they have not proven that and I do not think that is the case.”
Fick said removing that much water from an already parched environment was not a good idea.
“The desert flora depend on the humidity in the air,” Fick said. “The vast majority of moisture in the desert comes from the dew point, which becomes available to the plants as condensation. When the night temperature drops the air’s moisture-holding capabilities, down comes the life-giving water  and it is that cycle which waters the plant life. Removing 50,000 acre-feet of water will have a devastating effect on the Joshua Trees and the desert ecosystem altogether.”
Paul Collett, who with his brother owns 40 acres with a well near Bolo Station, which is west of Cadiz and overlies the same aquifer, called the project “a down and out illegal use of our water. This is a violation of our water rights. The Cadiz Company has an entitlement to some of that water but it belongs to all of us out here, including the Bureau of Land Management.  To take that water and sell it to somebody that far away is more than a violation of the law. It’s an abomination.  The supervisors should know better than to allow Cadiz Land to draw water from everybody and sell it to Orange County for their profit. It is astounding that it has gone this far. Nobody that I know of along the National Trails Highway – Route 66 – was notified of any meetings or the intent to take our water. All of a sudden, we do not have any assurance that the water table we use and which the landowners along this highway depend on for their livelihoods will have water in the future. Something is drastically wrong here.”
Seth Shteir of Joshua Tree is the field representative for the California desert office of the National Parks Conservation Association.  He said he had “concerns about the potential impact of this project on ground water resources,  air quality, the desert’s ecosystems and the future of the Mojave National Reserve. There are shortcomings in the EIR. It is a document almost 3,000 pages long that raises more questions than it answers. What will the long term effects of this project be on federally designated wilderness areas and what will it be on the Mojave Preserve?  How will this project impact regional ground water resources? What will be the effects on air quality? The association raised funds and hired our own hydrologist to look into and examine the Cadiz Company’s claims because we believe their EIR modeling is flawed. Cadiz is claiming the recharge into the Cadiz Valley is 32,500 acre-feet annually, which is greater than the combined recharge in the stream flow of the Big Pine-to Bishop area in the Eastern Sierra Nevadas.  Our hydrologist has looked at that issue and thinks the recharge is more around 14,000 acre-feet per year in terms of the closed basin’s desert watershed. Because the modeling is flawed, it is difficult to assess the impacts of the project. It is also difficult to assess those impacts because of the scope and magnitude of the project.”
The opposition to the project includes one of Orange County’s leading citizens, former Huntington Beach mayor Debbie Cook.
“This is one of the most outrageous proposals I have seen in my 25 years as an environmental activist,” Cook said.  “That in this day and age a private developer would come in and extract groundwater from an ecologically sensitive desert aquifer without any kind of recharge is unbelievable. That a water agency from the coastal area is going that far inland to take water out of the desert, as if the desert has no need for the water, makes no sense. What entitles them to pull that water out of the ground and sell it elsewhere?”
“The EIR has numerous flaws,” Cook continued. “Their recent statements at the hearing in Joshua Tree make it clear they have no intent to do recharge. The EIR makes it clear they will not do recharge and that they are interested only in pulling water out of the aquifer and will never achieve phase two, which they have left for some future unknown entity to do.”
Musser-Lopez said, ““What entitles one small, barely break-even farm, Cadiz, currently using only 2,000 to 5,000 acre-feet  of water per year for their operations, the right to sell 50,000 to 75,000 acre-feet per year of San Bernardino County’s water at a fluctuating price of  $300 to $700  per acre-foot, for a potential profit of $15 million to $50 million per year?   Cadiz claims that they are entitled to this massive amount of groundwater based on the harebrained idea that a small amount of water evaporating on a desert dry lake, after a seldom rain, is a waste of water, and that this small amount of evaporation justifies Cadiz Corporation to take all the groundwater before it has a chance to reach a spot where it might evaporate.  Demonstrating the unsound reasoning behind this scheme, Cadiz also proposes to reclaim excess water during wet years by putting it back in the very place they say water is being wasted by evaporation.”
Ervin, Adams, Fick, Collett, Shteir, Cook and Musser-Lopez said they are resolved to a complete reexamination of the project under different terms. “We want to move the hearing process out from under an Orange County quasi-governmental entity to before the San Bernardino County Board of Supervisors,” Musser-Lopez said. “We want individuals who represent us and who are answerable to us as part of the elective process to make this decision. We want to ensure an environmental review process that will not exclude data relevant to the conservation of the desert’s most precious resource and we want to have included in the environmental impact report by reference all of the data that was presented with regard to this project ten years ago, when it was rejected.”
Collectively, the project opponents are requesting a 90-day extension of the deadline for public input on the project.
Judie Panneton, a spokeswoman with the California Water Control Board in Sacramento, told the Sentinel, “Regarding the groundwater component of the Cadiz Valley Water Conservation, Recovery, and Storage project, based on the staff’s initial review, it does not appear that it is subject to the permitting authority of the State Water Board, Division of Water Rights. According to current law, the State Water Board does not have authority to issue permits for diversion of percolating groundwater.  In certain areas when groundwater is pumped,  it may be subject to regulation by a local entity, like the county or a groundwater management district, even if you do not need a water right permit. The law does require that anyone annually extracting more than 25 acre-feet of groundwater within the counties of San Bernardino, Ventura, Riverside, or Los Angeles to file an annual report of their extraction with either the State Water Board or a local groundwater agency.”

Dramatic Turns In Colonies Case

In less than a week there have been three developments with regard to the so-called Colonies political corruption case, two of which auger in favor of the defendants and one potentially benefiting the prosecution.
Last May, a specially impaneled criminal grand jury indicted the co-managing principal of the Colonies Partners, Jeff Burum, former county supervisor Paul Biane, former sheriff’s deputy union president and assistant assessor Jim Erwin, and Mark Kirk, the former chief of staff for supervisor Gary Ovitt, on conspiracy, extortion and bribery charges.
According to that indictment, Burum, who was then employing Erwin as a consultant, in 2006 arranged to have Erwin prepare mailers revealing Postmus’ drug use and homosexuality and Biane’s insolvency during that year’s election season, while Postmus, who was then chairman of the board of supervisors, was vying for assessor and Biane, who was vice chairman of the board of supervisors, was campaigning on behalf of a measure to boost supervisorial salaries. Ultimately, according to the indictment, Burum and Erwin withheld those mailers.

Bill Postmus

In late November 2006, after Postmus was elected assessor and the measure to up the supervisors’ salaries passed, Postmus and Biane joined with supervisor Gary Ovitt to approve a $102 million settlement of a lawsuit the Colonies Partners had filed in 2002 over flood control issues at the Colonies Partners’ Colonies at San Antonio and Colonies Crossroads residential and commercial developments in northeast Upland. Between February 2007 and June 2007, Burum then provided separate $100,000 checks to each of three political action committees (PACs) founded by or which prosecutors allege were secretly controlled by Erwin, Kirk and Biane, known as the Committee for Effective Government PAC, the Alliance For Ethical Government PAC, and the San Bernardino County Young Republicans PAC, respectively. In June 2007, Burum provided two separate $50,000 checks to two political action committees founded or co-founded by Bill Postmus, Republicans for a Conservative Majority PAC and the Inland Empire PAC. The latter political action committee was, prosecutors maintain, created by Postmus in conjunction with his business partner and political associate, Dino DeFazio. Upon becoming assessor, Postmus appointed Erwin to the post of assistant assessor.
Prosecutors allege that the contributions to the political action committees constituted bribes paid in exchange for the vote to approve the settlement. In a previously filed case, DeFazio was charged with six felony counts of perjury pertaining to what prosecutors allege were lies or misrepresentations DeFazio made when he was brought before a grand jury in October 2009 and said that the Inland Empire PAC was controlled by himself and two others, Mike Gallagher and Jeff Bentow, and was independent of Postmus. Gallagher and Bentow told investigators they were unaware that they had been designated as directors of the Inland Empire PAC.
In March 2011, Postmus pleaded guilty to conspiring to receive bribes, soliciting and receiving bribes, and conflict of interest pertaining to charges in an February 2010 indictment relating to the Colonies Case, along with other charges relating to corruption of the assessor’s office’s function and drug possession. Under the terms of that plea, he agreed to cooperate with authorities and testify against the other five defendants at trial in exchange for reduced charges. His testimony before the grand jury in April 2011 was a key factor in the May 2011 indictment of Burum, Biane, Erwin and Kirk.
On Monday February 6, Upland-based attorney Cory Briggs filed a lawsuit on behalf of two non-profit groups, the Inland Oversight Committee and Citizens for Responsible Equitable Environmental Development seeking reimbursement from the Colonies Partners for the $102 million 2006 settlement of the lawsuit.
The premise of the suit is that Postmus’s admission of bribe taking in his March guilty plea established a violation of California Government Code Section 1090 occurred in the forging of the settlement. Government Code 1090 prohibits public officials from having a financial interest in any decisions they make in their official capacities and provides for all money paid out as the result of such financial conflicts to be reimbursed to the governmental body that made the payment.
Briggs, whose most notable cases have consisted of lawsuits filed against various municipal governments over their ratifications of environmental impact reports for WalMart supercenters, on February 7 called upon the county board of supervisors to “help us get the money back from the developer and give it back to the taxpayers.”
The use of the discovery process in Brigg’s prosecution of the civil suit could conceivably assist prosecutors in the criminal case. But whatever advantage may accrue to prosecutors from Briggs’ suit was counteracted by two separate setbacks on February 7 and February 8.
On Tuesday February 7, DeFazio and his attorney, Victorville-based Rick Ewaniszyk, rejected prosecutors’ offer of a plea deal that would  have reduced the six felony charges against DeFazio to a single misdemeanor that would have resulted in a 90-day county jail sentence. Instead, Ewaniszyk informed Superior Court Judge Michael Dest that DeFazio would go to trial on all six counts and risk a sentence of up to nine years in state prison if convicted.
Ewaniszyk did not respond to questions posed in the wake of the decision to go to trial. It was widely suspected that prosecutors have misgivings about relying upon the testimony of Postmus and are worried that he might not hold up under cross-examination by Ewaniszyk during the DeFazio trial, leading to an erosion of the case against the other four.  The preliminary hearing for the case commenced yesterday, February 9.
The very next day, prosecutors’ misgivings about Postmus were given public demonstration when it was publicly disclosed that in October the FBI  learned that Postmus, while cooperating with the San Bernardino County district attorney’s office and the California state attorney general’s office, was continuing to use illicit drugs.
Selected statements taken from an interview Postmus had with FBI agent Jonathan Zeitlin and assistant U.S. attorney Jerry Behnke and Joseph Widman were posted on the San Bernardino Sun’s website late Wednesday.
According to that report, Postmus told those federal authorities that he had used methamphetamine “a couple dozen times” during 2011.
Postmus’ admission of continuing drug use while cooperating with prosecutors and under their guidance and protection as well as other statements made during that interview were turned over to defense attorneys for Burum, Biane, Erwin and Kirk two months ago because the interview contained what might be construed as exculpatory evidence. The drug use admission will perhaps strengthen the defenses’ contentions that Postmus is an unreliable witness. Other statements made during the interview were less clear cut, with Postmus librating between confirmations that he had an understanding with Burum before the November 2006 vote about receiving future financial support for his political career and indications that he wasn’t explicitly told that the $100,000 in contributions to his PACs were coming until after the settlement was voted on.

Curious Departure For Assistant City Manager

CHINO – Chino’s assistant city manager and community development director, Pat Griffin, inexplicably and unexpectedly departed from his post over the weekend.
Griffin, was last seen at his office on February 2, functioning in his normal capacity. On Friday, February 3, he was away from City Hall for a routine day off, referred to as a flex leave. He did not return to work on February 6, having apparently let himself into his office at some point over the weekend of February 4-5, at which point he slid his letter of resignation under the door of city manager Pat Glover’s office.

Pat Griffin

There was no immediate explanation of the reason for Griffin’s departure. His desk had been cleaned out when other employees arrived for work on February 6.
There was some speculation that Griffin may have been miffed that he was passed over for elevation to the city manager’s position.   Glover announced the first week of January that he will depart as city manager on February 27. The council undertook to recruit Glover’s replacement through a nationwide search to be conducted by the headhunting firm of Bob Murray and Associates. The council gave no consideration to the option of promoting from within to replace Glover, spurning both Griffin and Jose Alire, the city’s former public works director who was promoted to assistant city manager last year.
Griffin had been with the city of Chino for 18 years, having begun in 1994 as controller. In short order his duties were widened to include the position of deputy treasurer in 1995. A few months later he was made finance director and in April 1997 he became the city treasurer. Six months later he was promoted to assistant city manager. In 2009 he took on the added duties and title of community development director.
Brent Arnold, the city planner who had been serving in the capacity of Griffin’s deputy director of community development, will serve as interim assistant city manager and community development director.
On February 7, the city council designated  police chief Miles Pruitt as interim city manager.

San Bernardino Firefighters Union Proposing Election For Fire Chief

Asserting that San Bernardino city officials have politicized the operation of the fire department, the union representing the city’s firemen is proposing a change in the city’s charter that would make the position of fire chief an elected one.
The San Bernardino City Professional Firefighters Local 891, which represents 126 of the city’s firefighters, said it will seek the change through the ballot initiative process.
Firefighters said they saw no inconsistency in their complaints that elected officials and high level municipal administrators had injected politics into the running of the department and their own effort to subject the fire chief to the elective process.
The firefighters union offered a summary of the proposed ballot initiative that called for “an elected fire chief, who is a resident of the city, to be elected at the general election in 2014 and every fourth year afterwards.”  Candidates for fire chief would “be required to have an educational background consisting of California state chief officer certification, the equivalence of an associate degree in fire technology or related field, 16 years’ experience in fire suppression and at least five years’ experience as a company officer or higher.”
In the face of dwindling revenues, the city has made painful cuts to the fire department, which fared worse than the more politically powerful police department. Since 2009, 25 firefighters have been laid off or eliminated by attrition and the department’s fire engines are now manned by three-member crews rather than four-member ones. Union members believe that by creating an elected fire chief, they will be able to concentrate their political efforts on that election rather than diffusing their support among multiple candidates for city council and mayor and therefore have more impact on how the department is run. While the union said its members were looking toward “granting the fire chief power and authority over the fire department independent of the mayor and the city manager,” the  summary said the proposed amendment would also require the fire department to include an assistant fire chief and a chief of staff, “both appointed by the fire chief with the consent of the mayor and council.”
The proposal also calls for the assistant chief to “have the same qualifications as the fire chief” who “must be an existing employee of the San Bernardino Fire Department.”  The proposal further stipulates that the fire chief’s salary be set “at $1 over the assistant chief’s salary.”

PonTell Now Heading Burum’s Affordable Housing Nonprofit

RANCHO CUCAMONGA – National Community Renaissance, the non-profit corporation founded by Jeff Burum to provide affordable housing to low and moderate income homebuyers, has hired Steve PonTell to serve as its president and chief executive officer.
PonTell, founder of the think tank La Jolla Institute,  replaced Orlando Cabrera in early January.
Also known as National CORE, the company had faltered during the recession, and was unable to fully deliver on its commitment to make  affordable housing available to those in need. National Core’s board members struggled through the collapse of the housing market with Cabrera leading the non-profit while many properties being targeted for use in the program were being lost to foreclosures.
Last September, the FBI and IRS served search warrants at National CORE headquarters as part of an effort to obtain documentation relating to the business dealings of its founder, Burum.
PonTell, the founder and president of the La Jolla Institute, has been chosen to succeed Cabrera, who left National Core of his own volition a month ago, and will be a “very different” leader of the nonprofit, board members said.
An Ontario resident for the last quarter century who was very close to Gary Ovitt when he was mayor of Ontario, Pontell has maintained his relationship with Ovitt over the last eight years while Ovitt has been a member of the board of supervisors. Pontell was born in Loma Linda and raised in Big Bear Lake, where he continues to have some business interests. At one point he was the director of the Ontario Chamber of Commerce and he also headed the  Inland Empire Economics Council. Over the last two years, Pontell and the La Jolla Institute have completed, at a cost of $240,000, what is referred to as  a community indicators report, otherwise known as a vision project, for  San Bernardino County. That indicators report purports to provide a blueprint for the future of the county.
PonTell has been brought in to head National CORE at a crucial point, where its survival as an entity is being challenged. The nonprofit was previously dependent in some measure on subsidizations from redevelopment agencies and the state of California has now eliminated the charter of municipal redevelopment agencies throughout the state. In Rancho Cucamonga, where National CORE has its headquarters, it has received $46 million in subsidies through the Rancho Cucamonga Redevelopment Agency for the provision of low to moderate income and senior citizen housing.
National CORE, which is a national organization overseeing more than 9,600 affordable housing units in California, Texas, Arkansas and Florida, may end up closing shop in California.
National CORE is now scrambling to devise alternative funding for six projects on the drawing boards in California communities.

Public Should Scrutinize College Board Decisions, Lake Arrowhead Resident Says

Point Of View

A Sentinel Reader Opinion Piece
The primary job of the board of trustees of the San Bernardino Community College District is to oversee district spending and provide accountability.  There is scant evidence the trustees are doing their job.  In 2011, the trustees spent about $45,000,000 on about 199 different items.  Each of the votes was unanimous.  Not a single trustee voted “No”.  Were the costs on any of the $45,000,000 inflated? Was there not a single dollar of waste in any of the 199 spending projects?  If not, then the San Bernardino Community College District must be the most well run government agency in California, and perhaps the entire the United States.  Sadly, that doesn’t appear to be the case.  The district has had to cut classes due to lack of funds and tuition is going up by 33%.  The projects approved by the trustees included $300,000 for a “wellness pond.”  I’ve attended five colleges and have over 200 semester credits, never once using a “wellness pond.”
On December 8, 2011, I attended the trustee’s meeting and observed the lack of consideration they give before spending taxpayer dollars.  In about 15 minutes, they hurriedly voted to spend over $9,000,000 without any comments, questions to staff or even discussion among themselves. Every vote was unanimous, including one to make it easier to raise taxes. The taxpayers, students and faculty deserve more than a “rubberstamp” on every spending project. Instead of rushing through every spending project, the trustees should make sure each dollar is spent wisely. Pawning off the responsibility on a citizen’s committee doesn’t remove the trustee’s fiduciary duty to the taxpayers.  At the January 19th meeting, I addressed the board on these issues.
Our community college district is vital to the San Bernardino Valley.  Many high school graduates need an associate’s degree before they can attend a four year college due to finances and family responsibilities.  Other high school graduates aren’t seeking a four year degree, but need vocational classes offered at Valley and Crafton to learn the skills needed for good paying jobs.  About 20,000 students yearly attend our community colleges.  Recently reforms have been recommended cutting the  fat and instead focusing on the primary goals; assisting students to a four year degree and teaching vocational/ occupational skills.  It is questionable that the trustees are up to the job.  For example, instead of courses that prepare students for a four year degree or a good job, they recently approved classes like “walking” for four semesters (course #PE/I 127×4).  After graduating from “walking,” a student can take two semesters of “tap dancing” (course  # DANCE 107×2).  While billions are being cut from community college budgets, the trustees are walking away from their fiduciary responsibilities and tap dancing around the needs of students, faculty and taxpayers.
Since 2003, taxpayers have authorized $690,000,000 dollars in spending for new construction projects.  So far about $450,000,000 has been spent.  Based upon the trustees’ rubberstamping every spending project that comes before them, it’s questionable if the taxpayers’ money is being well spent.  Every property owner in the district is assessed $37.30 for every $100,000 in value of the property.  A typical homeowner pays about $100 or more each year.  In the last ten years, many homeowners have paid over $1,000 for these construction projects.  Are we getting our money’s worth?  We can’t be sure when the trustees rubberstamp each spending item without even asking a single question.
There’s other evidence of a lack of accountability.  Recently, four high ranking administrators have been placed on paid leave and relieved of their duties.  The trustees won’t say why.  Community colleges in San Diego and Los Angeles have been rocked by allegations of fraud and mismanagement of construction projects.  We don’t know what these four administrators did, but based upon the lack of oversight and accountability shown by the trustees in rubberstamping $45,000,000 of spending in the last year, there’s no reason to be confident that there hasn’t been an abuse of power.  The president of Valley College has left for a new job out of state. We don’t know if there’s been unethical conduct, but we do know that the combination of lack of accountability and oversight, combined with large amounts of money breeds corruption; especially in San Bernardino County.
How does such a lack of accountability occur?  The trustees’ bureaucratic structure could be one reason.  There are seven trustees, who are all elected at large.  The district serves hundreds of thousands of residents.  Instead of seven at large positions, trustees should be elected from districts with an equal number of residents.   Dividing the district into seven districts would increase the accountability.  Each trustee would get to know, and become known to, the voters of a much smaller district.  This common sense initiative would increase transparency and empower the citizens.  Another reform is to increase the number of meetings.  Currently, there is only one business meeting each month. Meeting for a few hours once a month is woefully inadequate to manage $690,000,000. Another reform would be timely posting of agendas and minutes.  The minutes for the December meeting weren’t posted online for 30 days after the meeting.  The agenda for the January meeting wasn’t posted on line until one week before the meeting.  Each agenda is hundreds of pages.  Less than two weeks to scrutinize the agenda is totally inadequate.  Without  adequate time to examine the agenda, meaningful debate is impossible. Increasing the number of meetings would decrease the volume of the agenda.  Copies of the agenda need to be available at the meetings for citizens to study.
I urge all citizens who share these concerns about the trustees spending habits to attend the next meeting and be ready to speak on agenda items.

John Wurm
Lake Arrowhead

 

LA And Ontario Are $400 Million Apart On Airport Sale Price

Ontario and Los Angeles are $400 million apart with regard to a sales price for Ontario International Airport, according to an analysis of information available to the Sentinel.
For more than two years Ontario city officials have been growing increasingly frustrated over the rejection of their overtures to have the city of Los Angeles, to whom Ontario deeded the airport in 1985, relinquish ownership and control of the aerodrome back to Ontario.
At varying points, Ontario officials have suggested that Los Angeles should merely deed it back to them at no consideration. While Los Angeles officials have refrained from making public statements that have conveyed their dismay, sources tell the Sentinel some of those officials within the division devoted to airport operations, known as Los Angeles World Airports, have been so insulted by what they consider to be the city of Ontario’s presumptuousness that they have refused so far to carry on a serious dialogue with Ontario over the matter. In particular, Los Angeles World Airports executive director Gina Marie Lindsey is  incensed with Ontario and its officials.

Gina Marie Lindsey

In the meantime, with a general contraction of the airline industry,  Los Angeles World Airports (LAWA) has instituted billing practices and operational policies that have made it more expensive for airlines to operate out of Ontario as opposed to at Los Angeles International Airport (LAX), resulting in an even further decrease in ridership out of Ontario Airport.
In Ontario and surrounding San Bernardino County communities, there has been growing concern that the downturn in passengers at Ontario Airport is harming the local economy.  Officials have suggested that by returning the airport to local control, policies can be put in place that will reduce costs for the airlines to operate out of Ontario. Nevertheless, the efforts to achieve that end have further alienated Los Angeles officials, exacerbating the situation.
A series of decisions over the last 45 years, each considered a practical and logical step toward resolving an exigent problem at that time, has led to the current circumstance.
Founded as Ontario Municipal Airport in 1929, the facility in 1946 had changed its name to Ontario International Airport because at that point it had begun to handle transpacific cargo flights. Nevertheless, it remained pretty much a small regional field. In 1949, the facility took a step forward when Western Airlines began flying into and out of Ontario, with sporadic flights to Palm Springs, Los Angeles, San Francisco and Sacramento. An east-west runway was built in the 1950s to augment the original northeast-to-southwest runway, and in 1955 Bonanza Airlines, with flights to and from Los Angeles and Las Vegas, set up operations in Ontario.
In 1957, well under 30,000 passengers passed through Ontario Airport. Over the next decade, use of the facility would increase, but at not much more than a glacial pace.  In 1959, Ontario was designated an alternative to Los Angeles International Airport when LAX was fogged in. By 1966, passenger traffic had increased to just under 200,000 passengers per year, but the prospects for further expansion seemed dim.
The main runway was dilapidating, with spots on the tarmac that were caving in. FAA inspectors issued warnings that repairs to the main runway would need to be made or the airport would be shut down. The facility did not feature a paved parking lot, but rather a gravel one. Efforts to lure other airlines to Ontario had been ongoing for years, but were unsuccessful, as airline executives saw insufficient financial reward to scheduling flights into or out of such a remote location.
The Ontario City Council formed a committee composed of then-mayor Howard Snider and then-councilman Sam Crowe to approach Los Angeles municipal officials and the L.A. Department of Airports to negotiate a “merger” that would result in upgrades to the airport and an increase in passenger traffic.
A deal was worked out  and accepted by the Ontario City Council on March 1, 1967 by which the city of Ontario and the city of Los Angeles created a joint powers authority for the purposes of managing, operating and enhancing the airport. The Los Angeles Department of Airports and LAX pledged to use their influence with the airlines to induce them to establish flights into and out of Ontario. Furthermore Los Angeles, through its Department of Airports committed to making improvements worth at least $20 million in 1967 dollars, to include the refurbishing of the east-west runway and the addition of a second heavy duty runway, the expansion of taxiways and improvements to the terminals and the purchase of 350 acres of vineyards to allow for expansion on the airport’s east end. The Los Angeles Department of Airports, which would later transform into the entity now known as Los Angeles World Airports, took on management of the airport on November 1, 1967. Under the terms of the deal, title on the airport itself was to be transferred to the city of Los Angeles after the achievement of several designated milestones, including passenger traffic levels, runway improvements, and terminal construction.
By 1969, flights out of Ontario dramatically increased. Continental started nonstop flights to Denver and Chicago, Air California started runs to San Jose, and PSA started flights to San Francisco. Western added flights to Salt Lake City. In 1970 United initiated flights to and from  Chicago.  American Airlines began flights to Dallas and, later, to Chicago. Nevertheless, a benchmark of 10 million passengers at the airport by 1975 was not  achieved as John Wayne Airport in Orange County expanded dramatically, becoming the second busiest airport in the region after LAX, a spot coveted by Ontario. In 1981, a modern, second east-to-west runway was built, necessitating the removal of the old northeast-to-southwest runway. Sometime thereafter, Los Angeles officials stepped up pressure on Ontario officials to have them cede ownership of the airport in total to Los Angeles.
Ontario, at that time led by mayor Robert  Ellingwood, resisted, maintaining that all of the criteria specified in the transfer portion of the 1967 agreement had yet to be met. Tensions mounted between the cities when Ontario began levying a parking tax at the airport, which L.A. objected to as unwarranted and illegal. That led to a lawsuit filed by Los Angeles against Ontario and a countersuit from Ontario. Ellingwood pressed for the recission of the joint powers agreement and for Ontario to take full control of the airport. Los Angeles, however, had at that time  control over the revenue being generated at the airport and was bankrolling the cost of operations there. Los Angeles threatened to itself stand down from the joint powers agreement, leaving Ontario in the position of paying all operational costs.  His four council colleagues differed with Ellingwood over the issue of Ontario reasserting control at the airport, believing the city did not have the financial means to operate it. On February 19, 1985, at a council meeting when Ellingwood was too ill to attend, the council voted 4-0 to transfer title to the airport to the city of Los Angeles. Ellingwood refused to endorse the transfer documents with his signature. Instead, the documents carried the signature of mayor pro tem Faye Myers Dastrup.  Los Angeles took over ownership officially on July 1, 1985.
In 1987, the departure runway was extended to the east.  In 1997 and 1998, Los Angeles built two modern 530,000-square foot terminals at the airport at a cost of $270 million. In 2005-2006, the airport’s departure runway was repaved, received storm drains,  and  runway lighting was improved. The airport’s taxiways were widened. The same year Aeroméxico started seasonal flights to Guadalajara and Mexico City, making Ontario a true international airport.  The airport was also renamed Ontario/LA International Airport, ostensibly to avoid confusion with an airport in Canada.
In 2007, use of the airport peaked, with 7.2 million passengers enplaning there and using its terminals. In recent years, Ontario Airport has seen its use decline. In 2008, 6.2 million passengers took flights from the airport, a drop of 13.5 percent compared to 2007. In 2009, the airport had 4.95 million passengers pass through it. That trend continued in 2010, with 4.8 million travelers flying from Ontario International. Simultaneously Los Angeles World Airports undertook a flurry of improvements at LAX intended to make traveling in or out there more convenient to passengers.
In the last year, passenger volumes in Ontario continued to decline, with travel at Los Angeles International Airport picking up. Just under 4.6 million passengers took flights out of Ontario International in 2011.  At Los Angeles International this year, passenger traffic has increased by nearly 6 percent.
In 2009, Ontario officials began a dialogue with Los Angeles World Airports officials about combating the downward trend in passenger traffic at Ontario. But  Los Angeles airport officials were not keen on surrendering any share of the market Los Angeles International had captured in the aftermath of extensive improvements to that airport.
Ontario officials gravitated toward the conclusion that reacquiring the airport was paramount and that not leaving its destiny in the care of Los Angeles officials, whose first loyalty consisted in keeping Los Angeles International Airport thriving, was the only realistic approach to the problem.
They began pushing Los Angeles to allow a public agency-to-public agency transfer of the airport at no consideration, reversing the 1985 action.
Los Angeles officials balked at that.
“Over the past 45 years, Los Angeles World Airports has made significant investments to modernize Ontario Airport,” said Gina Marie Lindsey, the executive director of Los Angeles World Airports. “Over $560 million in airport capital improvements have been made utilizing funds from a combination of Los Angeles and Ontario airport revenues, Federal Aviation Administration grants and bond proceeds secured by Los Angeles World Airports.”
Without publicly stating so, Lindsey and other Los Angeles World Airport Officials were privately advising members of the Los Angeles City Council to seek to recover as much of the money put into improvements at Ontario Airport since 1967 as possible.  One unconfirmed report that reached the Sentinel was that LAWA was prepared to write down $110 million of the cost of improvements but was insisting that the airport be sold for no less than $450 million.
Ontario has not received an official offer or proposed sales price from L.A.
Ontario city manager Chris Hughes dismissed as “untrue” and “not factual” the assertion that Los Angeles had invested $560 million at Ontario Airport.

Chris Hughes

“The city of Los Angeles has not spent a dime at Ontario Airport,” Hughes said. “If they could show me proof, I’d love to see it. What it takes to operate an airport is the money the airlines put up. The money consists of passenger facility charges and federal grants. It is a closed system. That is absolutely not the city’s revenue.”
Los Angeles taxpayers had not subsidized the operation of Ontario Airport, Hughes said, and did not deserve to be paid back for relinquishing control of the airport. On the contrary, he said, Ontario has spent its own money in uses dedicated to improving the airport.
“The city of Ontario has spent well over $100 million in federal grants and local matching funds dedicated to ground access projects to make the airport more accessible,” Hughes said.
He said he could not speak to the advisability of the past city council’s decision to cede the airport to Los Angeles. “We started our partnership with LA in 1967 with the joint powers agreement,” he said.” In 1985 we amended the JPA and transferred the property to the city of Los Angeles. I was not here at the time, so I cannot really comment on that.”
Hughes said the exchange could be made as a public agency-to-public agency transaction, at no consideration.
“A public-to-public transfer is done without any monetary exchange,” he said. “There is no value to the airport. The land is worth zero. By definition, the FAA controls airports.”
Hughes would not discuss reports that Ontario had offered Los Angeles $50 million for the airport.
“I have been very clear that what we’re doing is submitting a proposal to their elected officials in confidence and we will not discuss our proposal before the decision makers have a chance to discuss and vote on it,” Hughes said. “I do not feel it is appropriate to discuss the details of our proposal at this time. Negotiations are in closed session and behind closed doors for a reason.”
Hughes did acknowledge, however that “Ontario has made a proposal to the city of Los Angeles for the transference of title, management and operations of the airport that is comprehensive and fair.”
Hughes insisted that Ontario Airport is being mismanaged under the stewardship of Los Angeles World Airports.
“The airport continues on a downward spiral,” he said. “The marketing budget for Ontario Airport, which was one million dollars a year, is now in the range of $300,000 to $400,000. Why is it the most expensive medium hub airport in the county?  They are not marketing it. We are back to the same levels coming through there when we had the old terminal.
“I disagree with LAWA officials when they say LAX is not competing with Ontario,” Hughes stated.  “Ontario continues to lose flights and yet there are 1.3 million more people driving into Los Angeles annually because they are flying out of LAX instead of Ontario.  That should not be, and it is because Ontario is losing flights to LAX.  It is a health and environmental concern.”
Hughes continued, “The region has lost half a billion dollars since 2007 and lost 9,000 jobs.  Los Angeles World Airports has done nothing to stop the bleeding and improve passenger traffic at Ontario.”
Currently, airlines are paying nearly a third again as much in enplaned passenger rates at Ontario International as at LAX. At Ontario, that charge is $14.50 per traveler, including a passenger facility charge. The  cost per enplaned passenger at LAX is $11.
Hughes said that if Ontario had control of the airport it could immediately make it competitive pricewise with LAX.
“The city of Los Angeles imposes an administrative fee of 15 percent,” he said. “If Ontario took over, we could eliminate that and reduce the passenger facilities fee by four bucks.”
Hughes said Los Angeles World Airport’s neglect is threatening to kill Ontario Airport.
“We need an airport to sustain the economy. When LA and John Wayne fill up to capacity, we need to have it to handle the growth of southern California in the future,” Hughes said. “What is concerning Ontario is we are in a downward spiral and we are losing passengers. We have not hit bottom. What is the tipping point? Our relationship was fine until they started ignoring Ontario Airport. I don’t take our 40-year relationship lightly but I don’t take a half billion loss to our economy lightly, either. The airport is one of the largest economic drivers of this area. Why is it that every other local airport under local control fared better in the recession?”
Lindsey fired back at Hughes.
“As aviation industry data supports, LAWA has not mismanaged the airport as has been implied by the city of Ontario,” Lindsey said. “The airport is built to a capacity that is far above what the current economy of the Inland Empire can support.  Combined with airline response to the economic recession, including cutbacks in the number of flights and available seats along with airline consolidation and wholesale withdrawal from medium-hub airports, you have a situation that will not improve in the near future.   It is ridiculous for any governmental body to presume that an airport developed and modernized at the expense of another city is entitled to a ‘transfer’ of that asset.  Ontario has enjoyed decades of benefit from LAWA’s time and investment in Ontario Airport, and now with a slump in the economy, expects to wrest the asset back for a sum far below its real worth.
“LAWA has refrained from criticizing the City of Ontario because we continued to hope our consistent invitations (three to be specific) for them to participate in marketing ONT would be accepted,” Lindsey continued. “It is now clear they have only one objective:  to take the asset the city of L.A. built, at a foreclosure price.”
On January 23, the board of Los Angeles World Airports ruled out making a sale of Ontario Airport to Ontario and indicated that it would not entertain any transfer or change of operating and managing authority at the airport for at least two years.
On January 24, however, Los Angeles councilmen Dennis Zine and Bill Rosendahl called for a study of how to return LA/Ontario International Airport to Ontario. Their motion, which was not voted upon by the full council but instead referred to the council’s Trade, Commerce and Tourism Committee, requested the city’s Department of Airports, along with the city administrative officer and chief legislative analyst, perform a study within 90 days to “determine the fair market value of Ontario Airport, including the land, facilities, financial assets and liabilities, then report on the process by which a sale of this facility could occur between the city of Los Angeles and the city of Ontario.”
Hughes said he was heartened by Zine and Rosendahl’s motion.
“Ontario is optimistic and we are looking for an opportunity to revive our talks and sit down  with Los Angeles and effect a transfer,” he said.

McKeon Ethics Probe Ongoing

The action of Congressman Buck McKeon is now under review by the House Ethics Committee, the Sentinel has learned.
Following revelations that McKeon  received a discounted mortgage for his personal residence from the former Countrywide Financial Group, the House panel took up the matter.
“Congressman McKeon appears to have obtained a significant discount on his VIP loan as a direct result of personal intervention by [then-] Countrywide CEO Angelo Mozilo,” Rep. Elijah Cummings, D-Md., ranking member of the House oversight panel, wrote in a letter released last month.
The House Ethics Committee has been asked to look into the matter and determine whether the loan amounted to an improper gift.
Countrywide Financial has been at the epicenter of the subprime mortgage crisis. In June 2009, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission charged Angelo Mozilo with insider trading and securities fraud. Since that time information has surfaced showing that large numbers of influential business executives and government officials received so-called “VIP” or “Friends of Angelo” loans from the mortgage lender,  in which loans were granted at lower rates than were available to the public.
In reaction to the House Ethics Committee’s action, McKeon told the Sentinel,  “I remain committed to transparency on this matter. I too want to get to the bottom of what Countrywide did to my loan 13 years ago. I chose a life of public service and ran for Congress because I believe that elected officials must live by the same rules as the people we serve.   That is why I was shocked and angered to learn that a loan I took out over a decade ago was supposedly given a special designation that I knew nothing about.  Countrywide’s actions are inconsistent with my principles, with my record, and with the expectations of the people of the 25th District.”
Of note with regard to McKeon and his political circumstance is that in January 2011, his California Republican House colleague Elton Gallegly was reported to have received a “Friends of Angelo” loan. Gallegly is also under investigation by the House Ethics Committee.  Gallegly, who has been in Congress since 1987, denied knowing that he was part of Countrywide Financial’s special loan program, but last month announced he would not seek reelection.
McKeon’s 25th Congressional District spans from Antelope Valley to the Nevada border, and includes parts of San Bernardino County, including Victorville and Barstow.  The district also runs through the Santa Clarita Valley, and  Inyo and  Mono counties.

HUSD Board Supports Superintendent In Firing Of Police Chief

HESPERIA—A divided school board last night sided with superintendent Mark McKinney, voting 3-2 to fire Hesperia Unified School District’s chief of police Mike Graham.
Graham chose to have a public hearing over issues relating to his ouster. In testimony before the board this week, McKinney maintained Graham had been insubordinate.

Mike Graham

Graham insisted that his firing was retaliatory and that he is being punished for speaking out against reductions the police department was forced to sustain earlier this year as well as for his efforts to get to the bottom of an alleged embezzlement of associated student body funds at Sultana High School more than two years ago. McKinney said that diminishing revenues required that the district make cuts and that the police division was a logical place to make those economies. He said that Graham had proven intransigent in carrying out that policy.
Graham, a  former San Bernardino County sheriff’s deputy, a one-time deputy marshal with  San Bernardino County, and a former security officer with the Air Force, was supported by the testimony of one of his subordinates in the school district police department, Hesperia city councilman Bill Holland, himself a former sheriff’s deputy. Holland told the board that it was he, rather than Graham, who had ridiculed as “absurd” the directives in one of McKinney’s memos to Graham calling upon him to reduce the activity and authority of the district police department.
Graham’s insistence that he had attempted to comply with McKinney’s instructions did not convince the board majority that he had not defied the superintendent. During his oftentimes public feud with McKinney, Graham occasionally made deprecating remarks about board president Chris Bentley.
When the board came out of a closed session Thursday evening, it was Bentley who announced, “The board hereby terminates Mr. Graham’s employment with the district, effective immediately.
Graham was joined in his vote to confirm McKinney’s firing of Graham by board members Eric Swanson and Niccole Childs. Board members Hardy Black and Anthony Riley voted to  sustain Graham’s appeal.
Graham hired on  with the district police department in 2001 and was promoted to chief in April 2008.