RANCHO CUCAMONGA–The shuttering of Rancho Cucamonga’s redevelopment agency has resulted in 17 municipal employees losing their jobs.
Like all cities up and down the state, Rancho Cucamonga was forced to phase out its redevelopment authority, which used a variety of financing mechanisms to eliminate blight and spur economic development. The redevelopment agency employed nine full-time workers and 11 part-timers.
Pursuant to two bills put forth by Governor Jerry Brown and passed by the legislature last year which were challenged by a coalition of cities but upheld by the California Supreme Court, the agencies were closed out and their funding routed to law enforcement and education.
Rancho Cucamonga, which covers 39.8 square miles and boasts a population of 165,269, lost well over $3.4 million as a consequence of the state’s action. The city was able to move three of the 20 displaced employees into other municipal posts.
Rancho Cucamonga is not alone in having to conflate its workforce in the aftermath of redevelopment’s demise. In Montclair, for example, the dissolution of its redevelopment agency will entail the loss of at least $1.3 million and will result in the loss of 11 full-time employees at the close of the current fiscal year. Other cities in the county are bracing for instituting similar economies.
Chino Converting Former Home Depot Into Police Department Headquarters
The Chino police department will soon transfer its headquarters from the 28,4000 square foot facility it has occupied since 1978 to one more than three times that size.
Chino is expending $21. 5 million to adapt the former Home Depot building off Walnut Avenue between Central and Benson into a 102,700 square foot edifice that will be more than large enough to house the police department and all related operations, even after the city achieves build-out.
According to city officials, the police department’s base of operations will not need to be expanded again. The city’s detective bureau, which is currently operating out of the county-owned Chino Courthouse, will transfer to the new headquarters.
The police operations center will feature energy efficient lighting and heating, 9,400 square feet of storage capacity, interrogation rooms, a gymnasium and a hangar to accommodate the city department’s mobile command center.
The city paid $9.9 million for the building.
The makeover of the empty Home Depois represents the city’s last redevelopment project, as its redevelopment agency was abolished last year by the state.
Highland Council Continues Paramedic Assessment
The Highland City Council voted last week to perpetuate but not raise its 26-year-running paramedic tax.
The city will continue to collect the $19 per residence and $38 per business fee, which will generate roughly $351,000 in the 2012-13 fiscal year beginning July 1.
City officials maintain that the paramedic program provided through the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, with which the city contracts for fire protection, costs $1.2 million. The tax first imposed on Highland residents in 1986 before the city’s 1987 incorporation was intended to entirely defray the cost of the emergency medical service. The population within the city limits has doubled in the last quarter century to 53,104 and the cost of the program has escalated as well.
The city council last week discussed increasing the fee, with Mayor Larry McCallon most strongly in favor of raising the tax rate and asking voters to consider doing so on the ballot. Councilman John Timmer and councilwoman Jody Scott appeared to be the least enthusiastic about calling an election on the matter.
Scott said she thought more money to support the program could be recouped by having the paramedic vehicles transport patients to a hospital if further medical attention is necessary rather than allowing private ambulance companies to reap a profit by taxiing the patients to medical centers and then billing their insurance carriers.
The council voted unanimously to continue to levy the $19 and $38 annual charges.
Ramos Latest Third District Candidate Accused Of Disclosure Violations
The acrimony in the race for Third District county supervisor ratcheted up a notch with a Fair Political Practices Commission filing last month by a supporter of the incumbent, supervisor Neil Derry, charging one of Derry’s opponents, former San Manuel tribal chairman James Ramos, with having previously failed to disclose all of his income and real property interests on state campaign reporting forms.
The complaint was lodged with the commission on April 12, alleging that in serving as a board member with the San Bernardino Community College District, Ramos withheld information pertaining to property he owns in Big Bear Lake, along with Pfizer Inc. and General Electric stock he owns, and that he did not report any income from his tribal stipend, interest in the tribe’s affiliated holdings and any income or loss from two of his San Bernardino-based holdings, Yum Yum Restaurant and Pepito’s Restaurant on any of the statements of economic interest he was required to fill out as an elected official, known as California Form 700s.
As a member of the college district board, to which he was first elected in 2005 and elected to again in 2010, Ramos was required to complete the forms. He also had reporting requirements relating to having been appointed to the state Native American Heritage Commission and the state Board of Education.
The information contained in the complaint and upon which the reporting violation was alleged was gleaned from Ramos’ most recent filing of a Form 700, made in March in conjunction with his candidacy for supervisor. In that document, Ramos disclosed his stock in Pfizer is worth between $10,000 and $100,000 as is his stock in General Electric. The dates Ramos acquired the stock is not provided. Collectively, the Dum Dum and Pepito’s restaurants are valued between $100,000 and $1 million and together produce over $100,000 in revenue per year, according to the filing. The property in Big Bear is valued at over $100,000 but less than $1 million, according to the filing.
This week, the FPPC informed Marge McDonald, who had filed the complaint, that the discrepancies between Ramos’ earlier filing and the one for supervisor “appropriately reflect the different disclosure requirements to each position he holds,” and that the commission would carry out no further investigation.
Derry was himself charged last year with failure to properly disclose a $5,000 campaign donation from developer Arnold Stubblefield in 2007 during the lead-up to the 2008 election. Derry last summer entered a no contest plea to failing to properly disclose a campaign contribution.
In McDonald’s complaint, she said, “Mr. Ramos is aware of this [reporting] requirement and has failed to file the appropriate amendment.”
Pomierski Enters Guilty Plea To Single Bribery Count
UPLAND – Former Upland Mayor John Pomierski yesterday pleaded guilty to bribery, a move that will likely bring to an end the federal government’s prosecution of charges against him contained in a 11-count indictment handed down by a grand jury last year.
In the plea signed by all parties on April 7 which Pomierski entered in court on April 26, he admitted taking a $5,000 bribe in return for helping a business obtain a conditional use permit from the city.
Pomierski, 58, pleaded guilty to count 7 of the March 2, 2011 indictment which named him and Upland contractor John Hennes, who had been Pomierski’s business partner and appointee to the Upland Building Appeals Board.
That indictment painted a picture of a conspiracy involving Pomierski and Hennes, who worked in conjunction with two others indicted separately, Anthony Orlando Sanchez and Jason Crebs, to shake down individuals with pending developments or business applications for permits before the city. Hennes, Sanchez and Crebs would represent themselves to applicants as consultants who for a fee could ensure, by means of their connection to Pomierski, city approval of projects or applications.
All four of those involved in the conspiracy originally entered not guilty pleas but since that time have entered into plea arrangements with federal prosecutors. Crebs, in April 2011, pleaded guilty as part of an arrangement with prosecutors. Sanchez signed a plea agreement early on but fled to Costa Rica. He returned to the U.S. in January and remains in custody. He is scheduled to plead guilty on Monday, April 30 at federal court in Riverside. In December it was revealed by Hennes’ attorney, Kenneth White, that Hennes had been cooperating with the FBI and the U.S. Attorney’s office prior to his indictment and that Hennes had pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit bribery and making false statements to federal agents as part of a sealed plea agreement.
Count 7 of the indictment pertains to the delivery of a $5,000 bribe to Pomierski from what is described as “Business A,” an entity known to have been the now-defunct Chronic Cantina through Crebs and Sanchez. The Chronic Cantina restaurant opened in 2007 but was forced to shut down in April 2009 in the aftermath of vigorous city code enforcement at the establishment. Pomierski on Thursday acknowledged accepting $5,000 from “Business A” in exchange for assisting the business in obtaining a new conditional use permit. Court documents filed in conjunction with Pomierski’s plea say that between August 2009 and October 2009, Pomierski was in contact with Crebs, 39, regarding the restaurant/nightspot. Pomierski consented to using his authority as mayor to obtain a new permit for the tavern in exchange for money, according to the plea documents.
During a meeting with one of the Chronic Cantina’s owners on October 26, 2009, Crebs and Sanchez, 36, were given a $10,000 check. When the bank at which the check was deposited put a two-day hold on it, an impatient Pomierski sent Crebs a text message asking, “Where’s the beef?”
Crebs attempted to reassure Pomierski that the money would soon be available. Pomierski responded with another text message. “We’re running out of time 4 me 2 hit my bank! What[s] up…” Crebs responded that he was still working on getting the check squared away. When the check finally cleared, Crebs provided Pomierski’s business, JP Construction, with a $5,000 check.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Jerry Behnke, who prosecuted Pomierski, offered no public statement.
In response to a request for comment, Pomierski tersely said, “Not now.” Later in the day, the phone at his home office for J P Construction was left off the hook for several hours. Neither his criminal attorney, H. Dean Steward, nor his personal attorney, Robert Schauer, returned repeated phone messages seeking comment.
Ray Musser, who twice ran unsuccessfully against Pomierski for mayor in 2004 and 2008 and succeeded him by being elevated to the mayor’s post after Pomierski’s resignation last year a week in advance of his indictment, refused to dance on his one-time political rival’s grave.
“I feel so sorry for his family and JP, as well,” Musser said. “I really don’t have anything more to say except that this went on so long, it is good to see this come to a conclusion and get it behind us.”
Pomierski faces a maximum of ten years in federal prison and a fine/restitution of up to $250,000. Steward has asked Judge Virginia Phillips, who is scheduled to sentence Pomierski on August 6, that Pomierski be given 24 months in a minimal security facility intended for white collar offenders.
The plea arrangement does not vacate the other nine counts lodged against Pomierski and they will remain on the docket pending resolution until August 6, at which time Phillips will have the option of dismissing them upon a motion by Steward if the U.S. Attorney’s Office does not object.
Needles Hospital Stanching Flow Of Red Ink
NEEDLES—The Colorado River Medical Center’s timely reception of Medicare money is keeping it afloat, according to Jon Freeberg, the hospitals interim chief administrative officer.
The hospital’s very existence has been threatened by the contracting economy as well as past failures to bill properly and defray the cost of its operation.
While Medicare is the medical center’s economic mainstay, Freeberg said the institution also is making a go of it from the influx of Medi-Cal payments. Money from that state medical program is more sporadic than Medicare payments, he said. Medicare normally pays within 30 days of a claim being filed on behalf of patients eligible for the federal program, Freeberg said. Medi-Cal payments come in within 45 days of a bill being posted, but those billings are subject to greater scrutiny by the state, which routinely disallows payments for some services rendered, Freeberg said.
The hospital is far less efficient in collecting on accounts with self pay patients and those with non-governmental associated medical coverage, according to Freeberg.
The city took on ownership of the Colorado River Medical Center in April 2008 after its previous for-profit owner, Brentwood, Tennessee-based Lifepoint Hospitals, embarked on an effort to move the institution’s equipment and personnel to another hospital it owned in Arizona, roughly 12 miles from Needles.
Because of long-running inadequate billing practices, including failures to invoice Medicare and Medi-Cal as well as insurance companies and patients in a timely fashion, the hospital had consistently lost money, representing a financial liability to the city. The city created a board of trustees to oversee the hospital, and that panel, together with the city council, came to a consensus that spinning the facility off to an independent operator is the best solution for ensuring that the community has adequate medical care without soaking the taxpayers.
In June 2010, Needles voters passed Measure Q, which was intended to keep the hospital’s doors open and absolve the city of the financial burden of subsidizing the facility. Measure Q mandated that a non-profit entity be selected to run the hospital.
The city council in January voted to sell the Colorado River Medical Center and the 5.71 acres it sits upon to Needles Hospital Inc. for $3,587,002. For that amount, Needles Hospital Inc. will purchase most assets and liabilities of the hospital, including accounts receivable, operating inventory in place, outstanding bills and unemployment obligations. Unassumed debts will be deducted from the purchase price but the city is to keep any cash in the hospital’s coffers at the time of sale.
Freeberg said that in the meantime, the hospital is hemorrhaging considerably less red ink than before, as billing and record keeping practices have improved and some grants have been obtained. In briefing the hospital’s board of trustees on April 19, Freeberg noted Medi-Cal recently ratified $274,000 in billing claims by the hospital, another $30,000 will come in from the so-called Disproportionate Hospital Program and the hospital is set to receive an $8,000 grant from the Small Rural Hospital Improvement Program that will be used for upgrades on computers and different radiology equipment.
A renewed effort is being made to collect on aging self-pay accounts and unpaid bills outstanding to insurance carriers. The hospital is currently seeking a full-time lab supervisor, Freeberg said.
After Nine Years, Curley Out As Upland City Attorney
UPLAND—The tenure of Bill Curley as Upland city attorney drew to a close this week as the city council, discontented with mounting legal costs, moved to seek bids on a new contract for legal services.
In response to the city’s action, Curley and his firm, Richards Watson & Gershon, resigned. The city council moved immediately to hire Jimmy Gutierrez, who is currently serving as city attorney in Chino and Rialto. He will serve as interim city attorney while the city conducts its search for a legal firm to represent the city on an ongoing basis.
Curley has been Upland city attorney since 2003. He succeeded another member of the Richards Watson & Gershon law firm, James Markman. Richards Watson & Gershon had been Upland’s legal counsel since 1993.
The city has paid Richards Watson & Gershon over $8 million since Curley took over as city attorney in June 2003. In recent years, the city’s legal bills have escalated, with $6 million of those legal fees having accrued over the last four years.
The costliest of the litigation the city is involved in is a lawsuit brought by the county of San Bernardino against it, Caltrans and the county’s transportation agency, San Bernardino Associated Governments, known as SANBAG. That lawsuit relates to Upland’s approval of the Colonies at San Antonio residential and Colonies Crossroads commercial developments and the $102 million settlement cost the county sustained when the developer, the Colonies Partners, sued the county over flood control issues after the county built the 20th Street storm drain at Upland’s behest in conjunction with Caltrans’ extension of the 210 Freeway across property owned by the Colonies Partners. More than four years ago, the county offered to settle the case with Upland for $2 million. The Upland City Council, upon the advice of Richards, Watson & Gershon, declined that offer. The city has paid $4.9 million in legal fees to Richards Watson & Gershon to defend against the suit, nearly two-and-a-half times the amount of the settlement offer.
The city has also paid Richards Watson & Gershon over $575,000 to defend it in a case brought against it by Robert Mills and Scott Schaller, the owners of the Chronic Cantina, over the city’s April 2009 effort to revoke that restaurant’s operating permits. The city was guided by Curley in its decision to yank that consent. It has since been publicly disclosed that former mayor John Pomierski was extorting the Chronic Cantina’s ownership and was receiving laundered fees in return for assurances by his business associates that the mayor could ensure that the nightspot would have clearance to operate. A federal grand jury indicted Pomierski on conspiracy, extortion and bribery charges on March 2, 2011. Pomierski maintains his innocence and his lawyer has demanded that the city cover his legal costs in defending himself in the lawsuit brought by Mills and Schaller.
The city has expended just over $420,000 in an effort to prevent G3 Holistics, a marijuana clinic which opened in 2009, from operating in Upland. The city’s legal efforts in this regard had little impact on the collective and in the view of many have now proven to be superfluous and a waste of money as the federal government, in the form of the Drug Enforcement Administration and the U.S. Attorney’s Office, have taken steps against such operations throughout the state, including a November raid of the G3 clinic in Upland. Drug Enforcement Agency officers told G3’s owner in January that he is in violation of federal law and will be subject to federal prosecution if he persists in operating the clinic.
In 2011, Richards Watson & Gershon posted monthly bills to Upland ranging from a low of $117,403 to a high of $213,794.
Richards Watson & Gershon’s legal representation of the city had also become problematic on another score. In November, former Upland city manager Robb Quincey filed a wrongful termination claim against the city, asserting he had been fired in large measure because he had questioned what he characterized as excessive billings to the city by Richards Watson & Gershon. Quincey’s attorney, Joseph Wohrle, has petitioned the court for arbitration in the matter and with the prospect of Curley and his firm becoming a focus of the case, the city was obliged to get another law firm to represent it against Quincey, who, ironically, was once on good terms with Curley.
Repeated attempts by the Sentinel to reach Curley for comment were unsuccessful.
The city’s legal subcommittee, which consists of councilman Brendan Brandt, himself an attorney, and councilman Gino Filippi, are now evaluating all of the litigation involving the city and sizing up the city’s options with regard to resolving those cases or hunkering down for potentially bruising court battles. An obvious concern is that with the resignation of Richards Watson & Gershon, the investment the city made in having lawyers with that firm familiarize themselves with the issues involved in the litigation the city is involved in has been lost. For example, on the single litigation matter of the San Bernardino County Flood Control District against the City of Upland, in the month of September 2010 alone, Richards, Watson & Gershon racked up charges of $105,830 for the time of seven partners and employees who charged up to $348 per hour. The total hours billed were 367.3 at $288 per hour.
In the meantime, Gutierrez will steer clear of undertaking any work with regard to that ongoing litigation. His duties will apply strictly to holding down the fort until a new city attorney is hired. His work for Upland will consist primarily of attending the council meetings and certain meetings of the city’s department heads, and providing advice on routine matters.
He will be compensated at a rate of $225 per hour.
Carrier To Fill In As Upland Fire Chief
UPLAND—Dave Carrier, who retired as Ontario’s fire chief in December, has been brought in to serve as Upland’s interim fire chief as that city recruits a permanent replacement for former chief Michael Antonucci. Carrier was fire chief in Ontario for 22 months, having replaced his boss, Chris Hughes, who was tapped to serve as Ontario city manager in February 2010. Carrier was with the city of Ontario fire department for 31 years of a 36-year firefighting career.
Carrier, 55, who continues to pull his pension from Ontario, will be provided with a $12,000 per month salary and no other benefits but workers compensation. His salary will be roughly $3,000 less than what was paid to Antonucci, who left as chief in September but remained in place for six months as a contract fire chief.
Since April 1, police chief Jeff Mendenhall has served in the capacity of fire chief.
Spencer Makes Interference Complaint Against SBIAA In Federal Bankruptcy Court Filing
RIVERSIDE—Attorneys representing Scot Spencer, the figure at the center of the burgeoning scandal at San Bernardino International Airport, are maintaining that airport officials have interfered with Spencer’s legitimate business activities at the aerodrome by cutting off his access to the airport’s fueling facilities. They filed a complaint on April 17 in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Riverside on behalf of one of Spencer’s businesses, the now-bankrupt SBD Airport Services, to have that business again be provided access to the San Bernardino International Airport fuel farm.
Spencer once exercised an ironclad grip over operations at San Bernardino International Airport, where beginning in 2007 he served as the contract developer of the facility. In hiring Spencer, the airport board, consisting of representatives from the county of San Bernardino and the cities of San Bernardino, Highland, Loma Linda and Colton, overlooked the consideration that Spencer had spent four years in federal prison following his conviction for bankruptcy fraud in connection with his failed effort to revive Braniff Airways in the early 1990s. The board, gambling that Spencer’s extensive connections throughout the aviation industry would translate to success in transforming the former Norton Air Force Base into an international airport, provided him with autonomy in directing operations at the airport.
Over the last several years, however, airport officials have been driven to the conclusion that their trust in Spencer was misplaced. Spencer’s management of what was supposed to be a $38 million renovation of the airport’s passenger terminal and a $7 million development of its concourse was dogged by cost overruns, boosting the combined cost of the passenger terminal and the concourse to $142 million. No commercial airlines agreed to fly out of the airport upon the completion of those improvements, as Spencer had confidently predicted and the major beneficiary of the project was the corporate jet-servicing company, Million Air, for which Spencer was the franchisee. Million Air terminated its relationship with Spencer earlier this year after the company claimed Spencer had failed to pay it hundreds of thousands of dollars he was in arrears on. In controlling airport operations, Spencer showed favoritism toward companies he owned or controlled, including SBD Aircraft Services, Norton Aviation Maintenance Services, Unique Aviation, San Bernardino Airport Management, SBD Properties LLC, KCP Leasing and Services, SBAMTechnics, and SBD Aircraft Services, to the detriment of other aviation-related companies located at the airport, such as Aeros Aeronautical Systems Corp and BaySys West. Aeros and Baysis were making substantial lease payments for hangar space at the airport before they were essentially forced to leave.
Questions mounted when Spencer formed at least two business partnerships with T. Milford Harrison, who had formerly served as the executive director of the San Bernardino International Airport Authority (SBIAA) and its sister agency, the Inland Valley Development Authority (IVDA), which is dedicated to the development of the property surrounding the airport. While Spencer allowed vendors to go unpaid and the aviation fuel stores at the airport to deplete to levels that threatened the continuing operation of the airport as a host to corporate jets, Harrison ran up non-aviation related charges of $63,043.45 on an American Express Business Platinum card issued to him through the authority and another $4,642.86 on a second Starwood Preferred Guest Business credit card he secured through the airport authority. Meanwhile, by the summer of 2011, Spencer owed the county more than $604,000 in unpaid taxes on property and equipment at the airport since 2005 and was in arrears on interest and principal payments on $1.2 million in loans to him through the airport authority.
The coup de grace came on September 21, 2011 when federal authorities, in the person of FBI and IRS agents, together with state law enforcement officers descended upon San Bernardino International Airport, serving search warrants at five offices, businesses or facilities there as part of a comprehensive investigation into allegations that millions of taxpayer dollars were illegally diverted, mismanaged, laundered, misappropriated or siphoned off by officials or individuals affiliated with the airport’s development. Targeted in the raid were SBIAA and IVDA headquarters, the San Bernardino Million Air franchise; three hangars, including Hangar 763, where two Spencer-affiliated companies were located; a storage facility at the airport, and Spencer’s Riverside residence. According to the search warrants, the authorities were seeking information regarding suspected misuse of federal funds, bribery, mail fraud, wire fraud and conspiracy.
On September 28, 2011, Don Rogers, who had served as the executive director of SBIAA and IVDA during Spencer’s tenure as contract developer, resigned. On November 9, the SBIAA board hired A.J. Wilson, a municipal manager with an extensive list of top administrative assignments inside and outside of California, to the position of interim executive director of San Bernardino International Airport.
The no-nonsense Wilson conducted a crash review of the operations at the airport and on November 30, the SBIAA and IVDA boards took a tentative step toward removing Spencer as the contract developer of San Bernardino International Airport. Noting that Spencer had not properly managed the airport’s billing, the board transferred management of the remaining project work from Spencer to itself and Wilson. The board also moved to authorize paying subcontractors for work done on a U.S. Customs and Border Protection facility after their bills had gone unpaid by Spencer for months.
On December 23, 2011, the airport board terminated the airport management and development agreement it had with Spencer’s San Bernardino Airport Management, LLC.
Earlier this year, airport officials became alarmed when they learned Spencer had allowed the fuel level in the tanks at the airport’s fuel farm, which have a capacity of 150,000 gallons, to dwindle to 1,100 gallons as of February 1. Under the authority’s contract with SBD, a minimum of 20,000 gallons of aviation fuel was to be maintained in the fueling system at all times. The fuel farm supplies aviation engine rated kerosene to the private jets that fly out of San Bernardino International Airport.
On February 7, the authority sought to end its contract with SBD and on February 17, Superior Court Judge Brian McCarville ruled that the airport authority was legally entitled to assume from Spencer and his company, SBD Properties, control of the airport’s fuel farm.
On February 21, Million Air Interlink, the Texas-based provider of landing and take-off services for operators of private and corporate jets that had already sued Spencer for $837,290 in long past due franchise fees, revoked Spencer’s franchise. That move significantly attenuates Spencer’s primacy at the airport. Because of previous contractual commitments, Spencer’s Million Air franchise was given exclusivity of use at the plush private jetport, described by one pilot as “opulent beyond anything I’ve ever seen.” The contract between the airport authority, Spencer and Million Air Interlink had provided Spencer’s franchise with exclusivity at the jetport but it also provided the authority with the ability to separate from Spencer if the jetport remained tenantless for 30 days. When Spencer failed to find a replacement for Million Air by March 22, the airport authority sought to remove him and his companies from the terminal altogether.
In seeking bankruptcy protection in March, Spencer hoped to preserve what little of his dwindling presence at the airport is left. In the bankruptcy filing for SBD Airport Services, Spencer’s legal team claimed San Bernardino International Airport’s leaders were aiming to cripple Spencer’s business operations and that his loss of the Million Air Franchise was a direct result of Spencer having lost access to the fuel farm. In the April 17 filing, Spencer’s attorneys maintain SBD Aircraft Services sustained $20 million in damages after the company lost access to the fueling facilities. “Defendants’ wrongful conduct, including but not limited to the purported termination of the fuel agreement will cause great and irreparable injury,” according to the complaint, which seeks SBD’s reinstatement as the manager of the fuel farm.
Airport officials maintain the fuel agreement was legally terminated when Spencer breached his end of the arrangement by allowing the fuel stores to dwindle to the point that in early February a 727 pilot was unable to fuel his jet to the required level.
Land Swap Paves Way For Mojave Cross’s Resurrection
The 12-year running Constitutional battle over a veterans group’s use of a Christian symbol to honor war dead at Sunrise Rock in the Mojave National Preserve was settled on April 23.
The California Veterans of Foreign Wars and the American Civil Liberties Union reached a settlement that was endorsed by U.S. District Judge Robert Timlin that will allow the Mojave Cross to return to its original site by having the National Park Service transfer title for the one-acre parcel where the cross was formerly mounted to the Barstow Chapter of the Veterans of Foreign Wars in exchange for five acres of donated land.
In 2001 the American Civil Liberties Union filed a lawsuit on behalf of then-assistant superintendent of the preserve Frank Buono, a Vietnam veteran who argued that the Christian religious symbol was unconstitutionally located on government land.
A practicing Catholic, Buono despite his own religious faith objected to the presence of the cross on public land, saying he did not think it proper for any religious symbol to be displayed on government property.
Buono’s case cut a tortuous path through federal courts, where it was twice ordered that the cross be removed. Shortly after a federal court ordered the removal of the cross the first time, Congressman Jerry Lewis, in an effort to circumvent the court’s authority, arranged a land transfer in legislation he had passed in 2003, by which the five acres of privately owned property was delivered to the federal government in exchange for the acre beneath and surrounding the cross being given to the Veterans of Foreign Wars. That legislative solution was indistinguishable from the land exchange at the heart of the settlement reached this week.
Further legal challenges prevented that legislation from being actuated. Lower federal courts in California ruled that deeding the land to make it private through such a transfer approved by Congress did not separate the religious from the governmental. In 2007 the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals held that “carving out a tiny parcel of property in the midst of this vast preserve — like a donut hole with the cross atop it — will do nothing to minimize the impermissible governmental endorsement” of a religious symbol.
When the case finally reached the nation’s highest legal authority, the U.S. Supreme Court in 2010 undid that standard, stating such a land swap if codified through legislation would suffice. In writing his opinion for the ruling majority on the Supreme Court, Justice Anthony Kennedy noted that the government, faced with an injunction to remove the memorial, had been put in a difficult position. The transfer of land was a reasonable solution, Kennedy said, writing that the government “could not maintain the cross without violating the injunction, but it could not remove the cross without conveying disrespect for those the cross was seen as honoring.”
Nevertheless, the decision to allow the cross to stay was a divided one, reflected in the 5-4 outcome on the issue among the justices. In the decision overturning the past rulings by lesser courts to the effect that the cross had to be taken down, Kennedy asserted for the majority that the memorial, even though it is in the form of a cross which alludes to the crucifixion of Jesus Christ, was originally intended to serve as a war memorial, and was not meant as a religious icon.
The American Civil Liberties Union opposed the land transfer on other grounds, but this week the settelment was brought before Timlin, who signed off on it.
Erected in the 1934 by a group of veterans of what was then known as the Great War as a tribute to their colleagues who had fallen in World War I, the cross seven decades later became a lightning rod of controversy because of its religious significance. While some saw it as a symbol intended to honor soldiers who had made the ultimate sacrifice on behalf of their country, others saw in it a reference to Christianity. The presence of a patently religious symbol on public land, it was argued, violated the spirit and letter of the U.S. Constitution and the ideal of not blurring the distinction between Caesar and God.
The five acres to be traded for the monument site were donated to the Veterans of Foreign Wars by Henry and Wanda Sandoz of Yucca Valley.
The one-acre parcel surrounding the original site of the cross encompasses Sunrise Rock, in the community of Cima, roughly 12 miles south of Interstate 15 in the 1.6 million acre Mojave National Preserve, which was dedicated as a park in 1994. The transformation of the property into public land eventually led to the legal action.