Santa Margarita Postpones Cadiz Water Project Decision To Next Week

(July 27)  The governing board of the Santa Margarita Water District this week postponed until next week a vote on certifying the environmental impact report for the controversial Cadiz Valley Water Project.
Officially referred to as the Cadiz Valley Conservation, Recovery and Storage Project, if approved it would provide the Cadiz Land Company, also known as Cadiz, Inc. with permission to pump an average of 50,000 acre-feet of water per year out of the aquifer in San Bernardino County’s Eastern Mojave Desert and convey it in a pipeline to Riverside, Orange and Los Angeles counties to replenish the water supply there.
The Santa Margarita Water District, the second largest water district in Orange County that serves an area more than 200 miles from the Cadiz Valley, is the lead agency for the project, overseeing the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) review process for the project’s permitting.
After Cadiz, Inc. completes the project, which entails the sinking of 34 wells into the desert and construction of a 44-mile pipeline along a railroad right-of-way until it meets up with the aqueduct that carries Colorado River water to the Los Angeles and Orange County metropolitan areas, the company  will sell the extracted water to the  Santa Margarita Water District; Three Valleys Water District, which provides water to  the Pomona Valley, Walnut Valley, and Eastern San Gabriel Valley; the Golden State Water Company, which serves several communities in Southern California, including Claremont;  Suburban Water Systems, which serves Covina, West Covina and La Mirada; and the Jurupa Community Services District, which serves Mira Loma in Riverside County.
The San Bernardino County Board of Supervisors acceded to the Santa Margarita Water District’s assumption of lead agency authority over the project application and environmental certification and entered into a memorandum of understanding with Cadiz, Inc. and the Santa Margarita Water District that gave the county limited power to second-guess the district’s decision on the environmental certification and compliance with its own ground water management ordinance as well as requiring that Cadiz, Inc. defray the cost of any legal action taken by parties against the project or in reaction to its impacts. The project has garnered considerable opposition, particularly in San Bernardino County and the East Mojave Desert, where the Cadiz Valley is located. A brine mining operation in the desert, Tetra Technologies, has already filed a lawsuit against San Bernardino County over the memorandum of understanding.
On the evening of July 25 and early morning hours of July 26, the governing board of the Santa Margarita Water District met in Santa Margarita in the largest meeting room within the Norman P. Murray Community Center, which was filled to capacity. A two-way video and audio hook-up to the Bell Center Community Room at Copper Mountain College, where several dozen desert residents had gathered, was incorporated into the meeting.
An overview of the project was provided by Santa Margarita general manager Dan Ferons. Leslie Moulton, one of the employees of the Los Angeles-based firm, ESA, which prepared the environmental impact report, gave a Powerpoint summarization of the environmental impact report (EIR). Statements limited to three minutes were then heard from several of those gathered at Copper Mountain College. Most of those speaking from that location were opposed to the project and the environmental certification, though some said they endorsed the project and hailed it as one that would provide some level of economic revitalization to the desert. Notable among the speakers against the project at the desert location was current Needles mayor Ed Paget. His statements were countered by a statement by his predecessor as mayor, Jeff Williams, who is currently the Needles Chamber of Commerce president, which was read into the record by another individual.
After those speaking from the desert location were heard, the board heard statements from those on hand at the Murray Center. Many speaking at that venue, including Cadiz, Inc. president Scott Slater, Cadiz, Inc. chief financial officer Timothy Shaheen, former Rancho Santa Margarita city councilman Gary Thompson, former councilman and mayor Jim Thor and others endorsed the project, characterizing it as one that would ensure water availability to the community served by the Santa Margarita Water District into the future. Slater said his company had incorporated changes in the project plan based upon an earlier version of a water conservation and extraction plan in the East Mojave his company had proposed in conjunction with the Metropolitan Water District that had been abandoned a decade ago and input from project supporters and opponents. He called the current plan an innovative approach to dealing with the region’s water shortage. Shaheen dismissed as inaccurate claims that Cadiz, Inc. was being investigated by the Securities and Exchange Commission and the FBI for making misrepresentations to its investors and he said that it was not true that investors had lost faith in the company.
John Goss, a former assistant administrative officer with San Bernardino County who had worked for 18 months drafting the county’s desert groundwater management ordinance before it was adopted in 2002, said he was concerned that the memorandum of understanding between the county, Cadiz, Inc. and Santa Margarita Water District had been entered into before a groundwater management plan for the Cadiz project was adopted. He said this violated the terms of the 2002 ordinance.
Al Vogler, a Hesperia resident who had sojourned to Orange County to attend the hearing, questioned the viability of the water selling arrangement, saying the $1,127 per acre foot Cadiz, Inc. was seeking to sell the water to Santa Margarita for was far less economical than water available from the California Aqueduct at $400 an acre-foot.
Former Huntington Beach mayor Debbie Cook said that there were “incestuous relationships” between the district’s leadership and Cadiz, Inc. and that the district’s agreement to purchase the water from Cadiz, Inc. was made during an “illegal closed session” more than three years ago. She said the district had an inability to consider the full implication of the project because of “bureaucratic malaise.” She told the board, “You haven’t considered the risks to your agency if Cadiz goes bankrupt.”
Charles Collett, an attorney from Newport Beach who with his brother owns property in the Cadiz Valley on which a well is located, said he was opposed to the project because “it will be taking out more water than will go in. There are uncertainties in the hydrologic methods. There are representations that Cadiz, Inc. is taking the risk but a lot more scientific study needs to be accomplished before you consider the EIR and decide on it. “
Collett said that if pumping in the Cadiz Valley is initiated that make his well run dry “I will file a lawsuit and there will be other lawsuits that will affect the cost of your water.”
Ruth Musser Lopez of Needles said the Santa Margarita Water District serving as the lead agency on the environmental certification of the project was “an abuse of power” that made it so that the desert’s residents “do not have a say in this.” She said the district had involved itself in a criminal conflict of interest when it entered into an agreement with Cadiz, Inc. to be reimbursed for the processing costs for the environmental impact report and other work related to the project conditional upon its approval of the environmental impact report and the water purchase agreement.
In total, more than 80 individuals in Yucca Valley and Rancho Santa Margarita addressed the board throughout the evening and early morning.
The board was presented with voluminous written documentation from multiple individuals during the course of the hearing. Coincidentally, earlier in the day Governor Jerry Brown and Interior Secretary Ken Salazar unveiled a proposal to construct a massive $14 billion twin tunnel system to carry water from the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta to farms located as well as 25 million Californians living between the Bay Area and San Diego.
The board voted to postpone its consideration of the Cadiz project until a specially called meeting in a smaller room within the Murray Center on Tuesday July 31.
At the conclusion of the meeting just before 1 a.m. July 26, Slater told the Sentinel he “thought the meeting was open and transparent. I appreciate the opportunity this gave the public to express their points of view.”

FPPC Now Has County Campaign Law Sway

(July 27)  Governor Jerry Brown signed into law Tuesday a bill that provides for the California Fair Political Practices Commission to serve as the lead enforcement agency for a campaign finance ordinance now under consideration by San Bernardino County.
Third District Supervisor Neil Derry three years ago floated the concept of creating a county ethics commission that would have authority over possible campaign finance reform. Ultimately, the board rejected creating an ethics panel but last year First District Supervisor Brad Mitzelfelt and Second District Supervisor Janice Rutherford introduced a campaign finance ordinance.
In February, a majority of supervisors expressed support in concept for an ordinance imposing campaign contribution limits on county office candidates modeled after limits in state legislative races, allowing individuals to give no more than $3,900 per election cycle. Additionally, small contributor committees would be limited to $7,800. The ordinance would also prevent contributors from attempting to get around the limits by providing money to candidates through intermediaries. The ordinance would require committees that spend or raise more than $10,000 and participate in local elections to file statements electronically.
With the passage of Assembly Bill 2146, authored by Assemblyman Paul Cook, R-Yucca Valley, the Fair Political Practices Commission is now empowered to enforce contribution limits and disclosure requirements for county races. Supervisors said they would now bring the ordinance containing the $3,900 contribution limit proposal to an official vote, perhaps as early as August 21.
The state Fair Political Practices Commission, which employs 80 and is headquartered in Sacramento, investigates alleged violations of the state Political Reform Act, sending warning letters to offenders with regard to offenses deemed less egregious, and in more substantive cases levies penalties in the form of penalties or court actions that theoretically can remove an offender from office.
“This legislation provides the county with an effective and affordable means of policing campaign contribution and spending rules,”  Rutherford said in a press release. “Now the board can move forward with adopting campaign finance rules that limit campaign contributions and help thwart influence peddling by deep-pocket donors. I thank Assemblyman Cook for his leadership and support of San Bernardino County’s efforts to institute meaningful campaign finance reform. By contracting with the FPPC to police campaign finance regulations, the county can avoid the conflicts of interest and budget-busting costs of forming an internal ethics commission.”
“Without adequate enforcement, campaign finance rules are toothless,” Cook said. “This is a major victory for the public and for voters in San Bernardino County. The FPPC is a proven watchdog agency, with 40 years of experience in rooting out abuses and violations of campaign finance law. AB 2146 will assist the county in setting much-needed limits on political contributions to candidates running for county office, and it will help prevent corruption.”

Judge Rules “Parent Trigger” Makeover Of Adelanto School Can Proceed

(July 27)  The parents union at Desert Trails Elementary School this week became the first such coalition of parents and education activists to actuate the provisions of California’s Empowerment Act.
The Parent Empowerment Act, authored by former state senator Gloria Romero and passed by the legislature in 2010, enables a majority of parents at a school at which students score  as low-performers on state academic tests to force a district to implement significant reforms, ranging from replacing the principal and up to half the staff to reopening the school as a charter academy. That process is known by the colloquialism “parent trigger.”
At Desert Trails Elementary School in the Adelanto Elementary School District, a significant number of the students have parents whose first language is not English. For the last seven years, Desert Trails students have had the lowest scores within the district on state standardized academic tests. The school’s students have also collectively scored in the bottom 10 percent of all California elementary schools. In the school’s 2011 graduating sixth grade class 72 percent of students were not proficient with the English language and 70 percent were not proficient in math. Two-thirds of this year’s crop of graduating sixth-graders are unable to read or do math at grade level. Since 2007 Desert Trails has been classified as a failing school.
Pursuant to the Parent Empowerment Act, a parent union was formed by parents at Desert Trails Elementary last year, in large measure at the instigation of the Los Angeles-based nonprofit Parent Revolution, which is devoted to challenging the traditional authority of school districts.
On January 12, the parent union submitted 466 signatures on petitions asking the district to undertake a set of what the parents union maintains will be reforms at the severely underperforming school.
Those petitions, which called upon the district to sack the school’s principal, David Mobley, and surrender to the school’s parents authority in hiring his successor, infuse in the new principal hiring authority for the school’s faculty, reduce class sizes and increase the number of school days and instructional hours, and include more science, history and art in the curriculum, were sufficient to meet the requirements of the Parent Empowerment Act, parent union members believed. The parent union subsequently modified that agenda to request that the school be converted to a charter academy, offering an intensified curriculum.
A group of parents opposed to the parent takeover of the school formed and went to work obtaining rescissions of many of the signatures on the petitions.
In February, the school district, to whom the parent trigger petitions had been entrusted, announced that it had validated the signatures of only 317 of the 466 signatures on the petitions. The Desert Trails Parent Union, represented by a law firm on retainer with Parent Revolution, Los Angeles-based Kirkland & Ellis, demanded a recount and reconsideration of that invalidation of the petition effort. After the district conducted that recount, the board, on March 28, voted unanimously to give a final rejection to the reconsideration of the parent trigger petitions, finding they fell 20 signatures short of the 321 signatures needed.
In response,  Mark Holscher, an attorney with Kirkland & Ellis, on April 5 filed on behalf of five of the members of the parents union – Doreen Diaz, Kathy Duncan, Teresa Rogers, Olivia Zamarripa and Bartola Del Villar – a petition for a writ of mandate and a complaint in Victorville Superior Court seeking a court order that the district verify the signatures and allow the Parent Trigger process to advance, as well as asking for the  recognition of  the educational rights of students at Desert Trails.
While the parent trigger proponents said nearly 70 percent of the parents had signed the petitions, the district claimed that some of those signatures had been rescinded, that there were no signatures on file to verify some of the signatures, and that others were invalid because the signers did not know what they were signing. After discounting them on those grounds, the district claimed the petitions were 16 signatures short.
Holscher maintained that the district did not make an impartial tally of the signatures and “engaged in a systematic effort to invalidate the petitions. First, despite the clear legal mandate that the district must accept every parent’s petition absent proof that a petition was not valid, and the courts’ repeated instructions that any attempt to reject a citizen’s First Amendment protected right to petition must withstand the most ‘exacting scrutiny,’ the district refused to accept 25 parents’ petitions because the district could not find a signature in its files to compare to the petition signature. The parents’ first requested relief is for this court to reverse the improper rejection of these 25 petitions.
“Second, the district’s teachers as well as teachers from outside the district engaged in a campaign to coerce parents to ‘rescind’ their petitions, and the district then used 97 of these purported ‘rescissions’ to block the January 12th petition,” Holscher continued. “The parent trigger statute and its regulations do not allow for any ‘rescissions’ after a petition is filed. The parents’ second request for relief is for this court to rule that the district improperly rejected 97 petitions by rescinding the votes through this unauthorized ‘rescission’ process.   Moreover, not only are rescissions not permitted, the parents have uncovered smoking-gun proof that individuals who obtained the rescissions doctored and falsified rescission forms and engaged in a coercive campaign to block the petition.  Even if the parent trigger statute called for ‘rescissions’ after a vote, which it does not, the fraudulent rescission process here could not possibly survive the ‘exacting scrutiny’ that this court must apply to this rejection of the petition.  Third, the parents here request that the court grant a writ requiring the district to approve the March 6, 2012 resubmission of the petition by the parents.”
Judge Steve Malone, to whom the case was assigned, restored 97 of the signatures tossed out by the district, ruling that the district did not have the authority or a basis in law to discount signatures that proponents gathered and the district had abused its discretion in doing so. “Once the petition was submitted, the district and the trustees lacked authority to reject 97 signatures from the petition based on subsequent extrinsic evidence of rescission,” Malone ruled.  “The district and trustees have a mandatory legislative duty to include those signatures.”
By his ruling Malone raised the number of qualified signatures to well above 50 percent. He ordered the Adelanto Elementary School District to accept the petition as filed by the parent union within 30 days and seek proposals from charter school operators to take over Desert Trails.
The ruling makes the Desert Trails Parent Union the first group to successfully enact California’s 2010 Parent Empowerment Act.
Doreen Diaz, lead petitioner and the coordinator of the Desert Trails Parent Union commented, “In speaking for all the Desert Trails parents, this is a huge milestone in our struggle for our children to receive the basic education they are entitled to and deserve.”
Holscher said, “We appreciate the careful consideration Judge Malone gave the parents in this precedent setting case.   This ruling will pave the way for parents across California to secure their fundamental right to a quality education for their children.”
Adelanto Elementary School District Superintendent Darin Brawley told the Sentinel “We’re disappointed in the ruling. It is ironic that a statute provided to empower parents is actually disempowering parents.”
Brawley said he did not know whether the parent union would insist on restarting the school as a charter academy, turning it around,  seeking alternative governance for the school or shutting it down altogether.  “There has been a lot of speculation about what they will do. They are going to hold a news conference on July 27 to announce their next step. We’re waiting to see what they’ll do next. It would be premature to formulate how we are going to respond at this time.”

Call For Probe In Wake Of Bankruptcy Filing Boomerangs On City Attorney

More than two weeks after city officials in San Bernardino resolved to file for bankruptcy protection amid charges of widespread fraud and financial document falsification, the city council has declared a state of fiscal emergency exists at the county seat but no criminal charges against any city employees, current or past, have been filed.
Information that has surfaced in the intensive glare of scrutiny following the announcement that the city would play the bankruptcy card indicates some possible corruption of city procedures and cronyism at City Hall, but on a scale that does not  account for the city’s fiscal collapse, one that is unprecedented in San Bernardino County history.
Rather, the city’s dire economic condition appears to be one that has been building for years as businesses in the once-booming municipality have been steadily leaving, unemployment and poverty among the citizenry has been increasing, and short term fixes with ultimately negative and counterproductive long term implications have been applied.
In recent months, city officials have been particularly stingy with municipal financial information. As San Bernardino County’s other 23 municipalities were finalizing and presenting to the public their 2012-13 budgets, San Bernardino, the county’s largest city in terms of population and oldest municipality, had no budget to offer and would not even release a version of the tentative budget city officials were working on. Likewise, city officials were unwilling to release financial reports, audited or unaudited, despite the public nature of nearly all of those documents. Within several days of the council’s vote to seek bankruptcy protection, the firestorm of controversy and criticism forced the release of the most recently compiled audited financial report, a very unflattering snapshot of the city’s fiscal management.
Whereas into the 1990s, the city of San Bernardino had been sitting on comfortable reserves consisting of surplus revenue that municipal operations had been generating for decades, year after year of deficit spending, much of it hidden from public scrutiny, began to deplete that cushion. As early as the latter years of former city manager Shauna Clark’s tenure in the 1990s, expenditures were sometimes outrunning revenues. Under the subsequent 12-year duration management of Fred Wilson, efforts at fiscal discipline were made, including scaling down the size of city government to  bring operations into line with available income, although inevitably, the city was forced to draw on its reserves. Under Wilson, the city avoided taking money out of restricted funds to shore up operations funded by the city’s general fund, but did tap into reserves.
Upon Wilson’s departure for the city of Huntington Beach in 2008, he was succeeded by interim city manager Mark Weinberg and then Charles McNeely. Weinberg and McNeely made  borrowings from the city’s workers compensation and liability insurance funds to balance the budget.
In 2009, the city council supported a staff proposal to borrow $1.3 million from the city’s economic development agency to balance its books.
In 2007-08, the last full year Wilson was in place, the city’s general fund balance stood at $16.1 million at the end of the fiscal year in June 2008. By June 2009, the end of fiscal 2008-09, the general fund, including reserves, had been depleted to $2.7 million. By June 2010, the close of fiscal 2009-10, the general fund’s balance had dropped to $410,000.
Over the decade-long haul from 2002 to 2012, deficit spending continued apace through all of the city’s accounts – including the general fund, enterprise funds, reserve funds, special funds and redevelopment agency, with unrestricted net assets drawing down yearly to the point that the city had $181 million in unserviced debt by 2010.
With the downturn in the economy and the closure of shops, stores and restaurants throughout San Bernardino, sales tax revenues have declined by $10 million to $16 million per year every year for the last four years. .
Since 2008, the city has shed 20 percent of its workforce, either through layoffs or attrition. Within one week of the July 10 declaration of the intent to file for bankruptcy, fourteen more city workers made their exodus, perhaps to ensure that they would be able to receive full pensions rather than be constrained to future pension reductions if they remained employed by the city.
Though the city did not put its figures in concrete, officials were projecting a $45 million deficit in 2012, a consideration that led to the decision to file for bankruptcy protection.
There were suggestions that the city’s financial officers or those in other positions of responsibility had not acted forthrightly in monitoring the city’s financial condition or informing other officials or the public in a timely manner.
But the San Bernardino-based auditing firm Rogers, Anderson, Malody & Scott LLP, which was hired to carry out regular annual audits of the city’s books and operations, said its employees saw a deteriorating financial circumstance and some cause for alarm but no indication of criminal activity.  Rogers, Anderson, Malody & Scott noted the city’s tendency to log in and process information related to its income and expenditures slowly, but attributed that to the shortage of finance department workers. The most recent audit turned in by the company was for fiscal year 2009-10. The audit for fiscal year 2010-2011 has not been completed. The 2009-10 audit found that the city was operating in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles and that it was projected to remain a going concern at least through 2010-11, which indeed it did.
In the atmosphere of fingerpointing that ensued the council’s declaration on July 10, former city manager McNeely, city treasurer David Kennedy and the firm of Rogers, Anderson, Malody & Scott all maintained they had exercised due care in monitoring and reporting up and down the chain of command with regard to the city’s deteriorating financials. In this regard, an August 23, 2010 city council meeting was referenced.
At that meeting, Kennedy and one of the Rogers, Anderson, Malody & Scott auditors, Terry Shea, were in attendance in response to McNeely’s request. Kennedy and Shea briefed the council on the city’s worsening financial condition, including its mushrooming deficits.
“That pool (of available money) has shrunk by $40 million over the last three years,” Kennedy told the council. “We have been getting by with borrowing money from other funds and other magic accounting tricks.”
That evening, McNeely pointed out that that 13 of the 15 previous years, the council undertook each yearly budget discussion with a projected deficit.
Despite the claims by these high ranking city officials and the auditing firm that the city had made full and adequate disclosure of the city’s financial position all along, on July 10, city attorney James Penman alleged individuals affiliated with the city falsified the city’s financial documents in 13 out of the last 16 years. Those documents were doctored or otherwise altered to indicate the city was functioning in the black when it was actually running deficits, Penman said.
Without being specific, Penman seemed to indicate that he had brought the matter to the attention of the San Bernardino Police Department, the San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department, the San Bernardino County District Attorney’s office and the California Attorney General. But Rogers, Anderson, Malody & Scott said there was no data to confirm Penman’s charge. The state attorney general’s office would not confirm or deny that any such investigation was ongoing. Nor did the district attorney’s office. Indications from the sheriff’s and police departments were that there were investigations on issues relating to San Bernardino City Hall but that they pertained to matters separate from and predating the bankruptcy filing.
Since January, the San Bernardino police department’s economic crimes task force has been looking into allegations of bid-rigging favoring contractors and kickbacks to city employees in connection with city-sponsored construction projects. The names of two former city employees, Robert Lennox and Chris Evans, surfaced during that investigation. Neither Lennox, the city’s former parks and recreation division’s deputy director, nor Evans, the owner of Evans Construction Management and an independent contractor hired by Lennox to serve as the city’s recreation division’s construction manager, have been arrested or charged in the case. Both have denied any wrongdoing.
An affidavit in furtherance of the investigation signed by San Bernardino police  detective Frank Alvarez alleges “bid fixing… on projects which involved Lennox and Evans.”
The sheriff’s department, likewise, was involved in the inquiry into that matter and others that have come under investigation, with two investigators from the division’s white collar crime detail focusing on several allegations that have been made. Among those issues are preparation for and work done at the Hernandez Community Center and the Verdemont Recreation Facility, as well as business and banking accounts maintained by Lennox and Evans.
The amount of money involved in that portion of the investigation, which is yet ongoing, would not approach even one percent of the money at issue with regard to the bankruptcy.
Ironically, Penman’s reference to financial malfeasance at City Hall has resulted in an examination of a matter by the multi-agency task force in which Penman’s action is a consideration.  The task force has again taken up an inquiry into that circumstance, which was previously examined by the police department without a recommendation for prosecution.
At issue in that investigation were alleged improprieties in public works projects, the contracts for which ran into the millions of dollars.
Last October 11, San Bernardino Public Works Director Nadeem Majaj authored a memo to Penman that was widely distributed in which he said he was confronted and threatened by Penman after Majaj cancelled a $2.5 million city contract with the Matich Corporation.
The Matich Corporation and its owners have contributed thousands of dollars to Penman’s various campaigns for city attorney and San Bernardino mayor.
Majaj said in the memo he feared Penman would use his authority as city attorney to have armed investigators search his home and car to obtain a copy of the police report relating to the investigation of the city contract with Matich.
In the memo, Majaj stated that he was questioned in “an intimidating tone” by Penman during an October 5 meeting “as to why I terminated the Matich contract.” Majaj said Penman called the meeting in an effort to bring about “restoring the contract” and that he believed “it is inappropriate for you or any other elected official to be involved with ‘steering’ city staff toward contracting with one of your major contributors.”
Penman, who last fall was involved in an unsuccessful election campaign for mayor against incumbent Patrick Morris, characterized both the investigation targeting Matich Majaj had called for and the October 11 memo as politically motivated. In a memo to then-city manager McNeely, Penman defended the investigation of Majaj for delaying his provision of the police report to the city attorney’s office.
Majaj was reluctant to turn the report over to Penman because of Matich’s political support of Penman, the pressure he felt Penman was putting him under to restore the Matich contract, and his desire to protect the identity of witnesses.
The police report documented public works employees’ allegations that the public works director who preceded Majaj, Randy Kuettle, accepted gifts in the form of a leather jacket, a truck load of Christmas presents, 200 rib eye steaks and travel accommodations to Hawaii and fishing camps from the Matich Corporation. The report further related accusations that Kuettle then removed an inspector who questioned the quality of road paving done by Matich for the city, and inspected the work himself.
According to his memo, Majaj became suspicious after requests to increase the amount being paid to Matich on a 2009 contract came to his office.
Matich corporate officers maintain the company did not provide steaks, gifts or travel accommodations to Kuettle.
Kuettle, who had served in the position of interim public works director for two years, was replaced by Majaj in November 2010 when he was hired as public works director. Kuettle was then reduced in rank to deputy director, but on Feb.10, 2011, Kuettle was informed by Majaj that he was being terminated as of April 30. Kuettle took leave of that post, but remained employed by the city, working in the city attorney’s office until April 30.
The police department in 2011 determined that there was not enough information to proceed with a case against either Kuettle or Matich, but Penman’s accusation has now revived the matter, putting it under the eyes of the multi-agency task force.

Alexander Named President Of SBC African American Employees Group

(July 27)  The members of the San Bernardino County Association of African American Employees (SBCAAAE) have elected Diana Alexander to serve as their president for the 2012-13 year.
Formed in 1992, the association’s mission is to promote cultural awareness of the county’s – as well as the nation’s – rich, vibrant African American heritage while fostering interest in county government and employment related opportunities through educational and social outreach activities.
Working closely with members and staff, the elected board ensures coordination of African American observances, acts as advocates on issues, and assists the membership in their service as positive role models for African Americans in the county and the community.
Alexander begin her career in April 1993 as an eligibility worker and continued to progress through the ranks.  She now serves as Assistant Director for the county’s Transitional Assistance Department. She has earned a bachelor’s degree in business administration and is on track to earn her master’s degree  in public administration this year.
“I feel very honored and excited to have this opportunity to lead the association,” said Alexander.  “I look forward to continuing the great tradition of leadership that this association has modeled thus far.  We have amazingly gifted members that are ready to lend their talents towards not only furthering the goals of our association, but in working with our county and community in realizing the countywide vision. Together we can make it happen!”
Alexander replaces CaSonya Thomas, who had served as the SBCAAAE’s President for the past two years. Along with Alexander, the following members were elected to serve on June 28, 2012;
1st vice president: Carolyn Tillman, San Bernardino County Schools;
2nd vice president: Keisha Butler, Human Resources;
Treasurer: Tanya Bratton, Department of Behavioral Health;
Recording secretary: Sharon Chivis, Information Services Department;
Communications secretary: Kenneth Hall, Information Technology Services Division.
2013 represents the hallmark 20th anniversary for SBCAAAE. Dr. Terrence J. Roberts, one of the “Little Rock Nine” who desegregated Central High School in Little Rock, Arkansas in 1957, will be the keynote speaker for the 2013 Black History Month Celebration event. Dr. Roberts is a nationally renowned speaker who takes his audience on a journey through which they reflect on his experience and come to understand how he has used that experience to live a more socially responsible life.
The SBCAAAE meets on the fourth Thursday of each month. The next meeting  is on Thursday, July 26, 2012 from 12:00 PM to 1:00 PM at the San Bernardino Public Employees Association office, located at 433 North Sierra Way, San Bernardino.

Common Union Enemy Making Rivals Derry & Rutherford Allies

(July 27)  Over the last eighteen months, supervisors Janice Rutherford and Neil Derry have developed an oftentimes distant relationship that sometimes flared into an outright hostile political rivalry. Shortly after Rutherford was elected to the board in November 2010 and sworn into office the following month, she formed an alliance with supervisor Josie Gonzales, who like her had formerly served on the Fontana City Council, and supervisor Gary Ovitt, who had for a short time in 2009 and 2010 been aligned with Derry. On practically every issue where there has been a substantial difference among the board’s members, the Rutherford/Gonzales/Ovitt troika has prevailed, leaving the coalition of Derry and supervisor Brad Mitzelfelt politically outmuscled and on the outside looking in.
On a few occasions Rutherford and Derry made pointed verbal note of their differences, trading barbed comments or hurling insults at one another.
But last week, Rutherford and Derry found themselves thrown together, standing out in sharp relief as the targets of an attack by the largest public employee union in San Bernardino County.
The San Bernardino Public Employees Association represents over 18,000 of the county’s employees as well as workers with several of the county’s municipalities. Both Rutherford and Derry earned the union’s enmity by taking public stands calling for substantial public employee pension reform.
On July 18, Derry introduced an initiative he is proposing to place on the November 6 ballot calling for public pension reform to address the mounting costs of county employee retirement obligations.
Noting that pension costs as a percentage of total county expenditures had risen from three percent in 1999 to nearly ten percent of all expenditures in 2011 and that the county is currently shelling out $232 million per year to provide its former employees with pensions, Derry said the burden on the county and its taxpayers to sustain the pension fund will grow if the stock market, in which much of the pension fund has been invested, continues to do poorly.
“Simply put, actuarial and investment return assumptions have not lived up to projections and county taxpayers are subjected to an unabated and underfunded pension obligation that cannot be sustained under present conditions,” Derry, who represents the Third District, stated. The Third District includes Twentynine Palms, Joshua Tree, Yucca Valley, Big Bear, Yucaipa, Highland, Redlands, Loma Linda and a portion of the city of San Bernardino.
A problem with the system, according to Derry, is that the county and its taxpayers have guaranteed county employees a defined pension that will be provided to those retirees, even if the retirement fund through its investments does not perform adequately to make those retirement contributions, necessitating that the county in each of its yearly budgets take up the slack such that the budget for basic government services is reduced to make sure those who have retired receive their pensions.
The ballot measure Derry is proposing would increase the retirement age for new county employees, decrease the amount of money employees could earn each year towards their pension benefit, require all new and current employees to contribute to their pensions, and minimize steep increases in pension amounts, referred to as “spiking,” by averaging annual compensation over the final three years of an employee’s employment rather than the current single highest year, which often includes the addition of payouts for accrued vacation and leave time and educational, cell phone, clothing and travel allowances.
Currently, public safety employees are eligible to retire at the age of 50 and draw a pension equal to three percent of their highest year of pay including all of the add-on allowances used to spike their compensation times the number of years they have worked for the county. Non-safety employees are eligible to retire at the age of 55 and draw a pension equal to two percent of their highest year of pay including all of the add-on allowances used to spike their pay times the number of years they have worked for the county. Derry’s proposal calls for adjusting the retirement formula so that public safety employees would be eligible to receive two percent of their pay upon retirement and non-safety employees would not be able to retire until they reach the age of 62.
Derry’s proposal would also eliminate the obligation that the county guarantee the amount of the pensions provided to retirees when the pension fund’s investments generate less than 7.5 percent earnings calculated to provide full coverage to pensioners.
“It is unrealistic to expect the taxpayers to shoulder all the risk for these risk-free pensions at the same time they are bearing all the risk with respect to their own retirement accounts,” Derry said.
Before it can be submitted to the voters, the board of supervisors must vote to place it on the ballot by August 9.  Supervisor Derry said he will introduce the proposal to the board on July 31.
In a opinion piece published in the Inland Valley Daily Bulletin on July 19, Rutherford, who represents the Second District, which includes the cities of Fontana, Rancho Cucamonga and Upland, San Antonio Heights, Lytle Creek, Devore, and the mountain communities of  Mt. Baldy, Rim of the World, Crestline and Lake Arrowhead, cited what she said was $375 million the county is paying toward pensions for its retired employees in fiscal 2012-13 and future unfunded pension liabilities of $2.25 billion.
“That pension debt will crush our county’s ability to stay competitive when it comes to attracting businesses, and our children will be the ones who suffer most if we do not act now to restructure our pension system,” Rutherford wrote. She pointed out that over the last ten years the county’s pension system has only produced an average 4.8 percent investment return while the pension system’s solvency is relying on the assumption that investment returns will average about 7.75 percent. Rutherford said the debt the county is accruing in keeping the pension system afloat will “push local governments off the financial cliff and straight into bankruptcy court.”
Rutherford said “Communities with mammoth pension liabilities and no plan to rein them in will eventually have to raise taxes or dramatically cut services or both to meet their obligations to retired employees. The system needs an overhaul now.” She then referenced her earlier “proposal to place an initiative on the ballot that would require voter approval of any future increases to county employee retirement benefits” and played some of the same themes Derry explored. “In addition, county employees must contribute more of their own money toward their own retirements,” Rutherford said. “We also need to look at increasing the retirement age, which stands at 50 for safety employees and 55 for general employees. And the practice of “spiking” pensions with unused vacation, compensation time, and other perks to boost monthly payouts must end.”
Fiscal reality is making generous retirement packages for public employees untenable, Rutherford said. “The more taxpayers have to put into the public retirement system, the less is available to pay for the police and fire protection, roads, jails, landfills, parks, courts and other public services we need.”
On its website, the San Bernardino Public Employees Association lumped Derry and Rutherford together, posting in bright red an alert headlined “County Board Of Supervisors Attack (sic) Pensions,” which stated “Some members of the board of supervisors are preparing to launch another attack on the pensions of hard working county employees!”
The alert goes on to state that “Supervisor Janice Rutherford has scheduled the re-introduction of her previous initiative that would require voter approval of any future pension formula increases. Instead of negotiating at the table, Supervisor Rutherford believes the county should jam it down the throats of county employees and fight it out in court! What deficit? The county apparently has millions to spend on legal fees!”
The alert then turns to Derry, who is currently locked in a reelection effort against James Ramos, who has been endorsed by the San Bernardino Public Employees Association in the November election. The alert’s language obliquely states that Derry will not win reelection as supervisor.
“On July 31, 2012 at 10:00 a.m. outgoing Supervisor Neil Derry has agendized a new attack to show the level of his dislike for county employees! He will introduce an initiative that will make the formula for non-safety employees 2% at age 62, and safety employees would be 2% at age 55. If approved by the voters, his initiative would also reduce all county non-safety salaries by 7%, but not his own salary!”
The alert then commends the union’s members to “Prepare for action 7/32/2012!!!”
The union’s alert, approved by San Bernardino Public Employee Association President Paula Ready, while perhaps galvanizing the county’s rank and file, succeeded in forging what previously seemed an implausible alliance between Derry and Rutherford.
In his public announcement of his ballot proposal, Derry said his call for a vote on the matter “follows substantive dialogue by the board of supervisors over the last couple of years and is a natural extension of our recognition that reforms need to be implemented.  I particularly wish to praise supervisor Janice Rutherford for her leadership on this issue.”

Connector From 210 To South 215 Completed

(July 27)  SAN BERNARDINO –The San Bernardino County Transportation Agency on July 23 announced that the long-awaited connector road from the east 210 Freeway to the south 215 Freeway has been completed.  The opening of the road came later that day. The connector is part of the $723 million Interstate 215 Widening Project which was initiated in 2007. The transportation agency, known by its acronym, SANBAG, for San Bernardino Associated Governments, said the widening project will be completed by next year.
The project will add a general use lane and a carpool lane in both directions between 10 Freeway and the 210 Freeway and an auxiliary lane from approximately the 210 to just south of University Parkway in San Bernardino.
The project also call for ramps between the 215 and the 210 freeways, new on- and off-ramps and the reconstruction of all bridges and underpasses throughout the 7.5-mile project.
Previously, those travelling east on the 210 who wished to go south on the 215 had to exit at State University Parkway and go north to West Highland Avenue and take that east to Mount Vernon and Avenue south and follow a tortuous route to an onramp to the South 215.

Secret Service Arrests San Bernardino County Counterfeiting Principal

(July 27)  The U.S. Secret Service put the kibosh on a counterfeiting operation active in at least two San Bernardino County cities.
According to federal agents, Paul Hernandez, 32, was arrested on July 22 in Rancho Cucamonga, while members of the Secret Service were serving a search warrant in Big Bear Lake City relating to the printing of 5,000 counterfeit $100 bills.
According to Chris Butler, the resident agent in charge with the U.S. Secret Service’s Riverside field office,  “Paul Hernandez was the main target in an operation called ‘Bear Trap.’ worked by Secret Service agents based in Los Angeles in conjunction with the Los Angeles Police Department and the San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department. He was arrested without incident at around 10 a.m. Friday July 20 in the parking lot of the Bass Pro Shop in Rancho Cucamonga. Simultaneously, a search warrant was served at his residents in Big Bear, where his counterfeit plant used for the manufacturing of currency was located.”
Butler said that plant consisted of “a digital high quality copier. We did find the images on these particular notes to be of high quality. He did use a very good quality digital copier. What differentiates these notes is that in the place of the face plate number and the quadrant number all they had was a letter. For over $500,000 to have been passed, you know it is a pretty good note. We know there are more out there in circulation. We think he was in operation for two or three years.  We have determined that over $500,000 worth of these notes were passed in the greater Los Angeles area, Canoga Park, Moorpark, the Inland Empire and Nevada.”
Those victimized by Hernandez will be out of luck, Butler said. “If anyone has one of those bills, they will detect that when they try put it into their [bank] account. The bank will not accept it. The merchant will take the loss. If they try to deposit one, they will not slide through and go to the federal reserve. They will be caught at the bank level. They lack face plate numbers and quadrant numbers.”
Hernandez formerly had a counterfit plant set up in the San Fernando Valley, but moved to Big Bear when agents were closing in on him at the Los Angeles County location.
“He relocated to Big Bear and after we located him there we initiated the operation we called Bear Trap,” Butler said. “We  had him under surveillance and were watching him for a while.”
Butler said he could not disclose who Hernandez had been in contact with, but did say “There is the possibility of more arrests in the future.”
It has not yet been determined whether Hernandez will be prosecuted by federal or state authorities, Butler said. Counterfeiting is a federal crime but it can also be prosecuted by state prosecutors.
“He was taken to West Valley Detention Center,” Butler said. “He was interviewed there. He may be going locally. He may go federally. We do not know at this time. It looks like he is going locally at this point but that may change later. Bear Trap was an operation handled out of the Secret Service Los Angeles office.”
No matter who handles the case against Hernandez, Butler said, “He’s looking at some serious time, well over five years.”

Retired Sheriff’s Lieutenant Vindicated 16 Months After Indictment

(July 20)  All criminal charges have been dismissed against lieutenant William Maddox, the third highest ranking of seven current and former sheriff’s department employees indicted by a grand jury in March 2011 on charges relating to the falsification of training records.
According to documents filed with the Superior Court, theft and perjury charges that were previously lodged against Maddox have been withdrawn “in the interest of justice.”

Bill Maddox

Maddox, who was an executive officer at the Colorado River Station in Needles for the last portion of his 26 years with the department, was never interviewed by investigators and did not appear before the specially impaneled criminal grand jury that indicted him.
In the indictment, sheriff’s corporal David Pichotta, lieutenant Russell Wilke, retired assistant sheriff Michael Stodelle, retired captain Hobart Gray, custody specialist Angela Gray, training specialist Sallyann Christian and Maddox were accused of falsifying records for the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training, the state agency which certifies law enforcement officers with regard to skills and specific technique qualifications. By earning certificates, officers can have their pay level increased or otherwise qualify for advancement or promotion. According to the indictment, Angela Gray and Christian added the names of Pichotta, Wilke, Stodelle, Hobart Gray and Maddox to the rosters of training classes they never attended, enabling them to claim higher pay and retirement benefits.
The district attorney’s office has now acknowledged that Maddox was erroneously included in the indictment. Maddox’s attorney, Michael Scafiddi, proffered documentation and information to the district attorney’s office demonstrating Maddox  completed all of the training certification courses he was credited with completing and that he had followed proper department procedure in earning and claiming those credits. The district attorney’s office independently verified that information.
“For years the sheriff’s department had a program similar to programs of other police departments that allowed its employees to use their practical life experience to get college credits,” Scafiddi told the Sentinel. “For his dispatch class, Bill applied for certification based upon his work opening a dispatch center in the desert. Doing that required him speaking with other agencies throughout the state and researching both technical and procedural issues.  He was told by the sheriff’s academy staff that qualified him to audit the dispatch class. Auditing classes is a common occurrence and what students often do to get credits.  He relied upon the academy staff and never knew or was told there was anything wrong. He was instructed by his captain to apply for the advanced certificate ten months later. The case was mishandled by the sheriff’s department from the beginning. The sheriff’s department had a political agenda. If they had done a competent investigation and looked at the evidence before they took this to the grand jury to get a true bill, he would not have been charged. He was not given the opportunity to testify before the grand jury. There is no way he intended to hurt anyone or steal anything and he certainly did not commit perjury.”
Scafiddi said Maddox “served the public for 26 years with distinction and honesty and for the last 16 months he has been called a criminal and a liar. I am disappointed in the sheriff’s department but I have to give credit to the district attorney’s office. After they found out the truth they did the honorable thing and dismissed the charges. It is a shame a good person had to be put through this because of the unprofessional work of the sheriff’s department. It cost him thousands and thousands of dollars to restore his good name.”
Deputy District Attorney Dan Silverman, who is prosecuting the seven defendants, said that taking the information now available to the prosecutor’s office into consideration, he would no longer be able to prove Maddox had engaged in the actions previously alleged and that his office could not establish criminal intent on Maddox’s part.
The case against the remaining six defendants is still proceeding toward trial. All six have pleaded not guilty. A status hearing on the case is scheduled for September 14. Silverman maintains the information provided to prosecutors by Scafiddi, while vindicating his client, in no way mitigates the actions of the other six.

Lum Says He Will Buy Colorado Rriver Medical Center As Is

(July 20)  NEEDLES — Community Healthcare Partners, the newly formed non-profit that is seeking to buy the Colorado River Medical Center, will not insist on over a million dollars worth of repairs being made to the facility before the purchase, that company’s founder said.
Bing Lum, a doctor of pharmacology who grew up in Needles and is the principal of AM Pharmacy, which earlier this year was the runner-up in competition to take over the hospital, is also the principal and founder of Community Healthcare Partners.
Lum this week in an exclusive interview with the Sentinel said an earlier report that AM owns Community Healthcare Partners was in error and he further disputed previous representations that Community Healthcare Partners was insisting on the city undertaking what could run to more than a million dollars worth of repairs to the hospital before his group purchases it.
“Structurally, Community Healthcarer Partners is not related to AM Pharmacy at all,” Lum said. “It is a brand new company, its own company. It is a stand-alone non-profit. Basically, I formed it to be the entity that would own and operate Needles Hospital.
“We will purchase the hospital ‘as is,’” Lum continued. “We have done our due diligence with respect to the land, the building and the equipment. What we are set up to do as a company is operate hospitals. We are in the business of making sure they work and are providing a service and are able to continue as a business entity, make money, so they have long term stability. We know the Needles Hospital has a lot of deferred maintenance issues. It has been challenged operationally and therefore  financially for years. What it needs going forward is capital investments and to provide for the health needs of the community.”
The city took on ownership of the Colorado River Medical Center in April 2008 after Brentwood, Tennessee-based Lifepoint Hospitals, a for-profit corporation, embarked on an effort to move the institution’s equipment and personnel to Valley View Hospital, another facility it owned in Arizona, roughly 12 miles from Needles.
Because of long-running inadequate billing practices, including failures to invoice Medicare and Medi-Cal as well as insurance companies and patients in a timely fashion, the hospital has lost money, representing a financial liability to the city. The city created the board of trustees to oversee the hospital, and that panel, together with the city council, has come to a consensus that spinning the facility off to an independent operator is the best solution for ensuring that the community has adequate medical care without soaking the taxpayers.
In June 2010, Needles voters passed Measure Q, which called for keeping the hospital open and absolving the city of the financial burden of subsidizing the facility by having a non-profit entity selected to run the hospital.
In accordance with Measure Q, Needles Hospital, Inc. and AM Pharmacy, owned by Lum, along with other entities last year submitted competing proposals for the takeover of Colorado River Medical Center. After the other proposals were rejected, the hospital board on January 5 considered both Needles Hospital, Inc.’s and AM Pharmacy’s offers. The board seriously entertained AM’s overture, by which it proposed to buy the hospital and 5.71 acres of surrounding property without the accounts receivable for $3 million, with any debts deducted from the sale price. AM, which is a for-profit entity, had agreed to create a non-profit arm with which to operate Colorado River Medical Center, and have Lum, who was raised in Needles and graduated from Needles High School in 1979, oversee the hospital operation. The board, however, rejected AM’s offer by a vote of 2-4 before ultimately accepting Needles Hospital, Inc.’s offer on a 3-2 vote. On January 10, the city council followed the hospital board’s recommendation, and voted to approve the sale of Colorado River Medical Center and the 5.71 acres it sits upon to Needles Hospital, Inc. for $3,587,002. For that amount, Needles Hospital Inc. was to take possession of most assets and liabilities of the hospital, including accounts receivable, operating inventory in place, outstanding bills and unemployment obligations. Non-assumed debts were to be deducted from the purchase price, but the city was to keep any cash in the hospital’s coffers at the time of sale. Needles Hospital, Inc. was formed and headed by former Needles Councilwoman Rebecca Valentine.
On January 27, the city represented by Mayor Ed Paget, and the board of hospital trustees represented by chairman Jeff Williams, and Needles Hospital, Inc. represented by Valentine, signed a purchase agreement, opening escrow. Needles Hospital, Inc. was given until April 26 to show proof of funding for the purchase of the hospital and until May 25 to close escrow.
Needles Hospital, Inc. sought to arrange an $8.46 million loan through the U.S. Department of Agriculture that would allow the non-profit to purchase the hospital and make necessary repairs to keep it operational, including reroofing the building, structural upgrades,  and putting in new boilers and wiring. The non-profit was not able to produce proof of financing by the April 26 deadline, effectively ending Needles Hospital, Inc.’s chance of acquiring the institution. The city then entered into negotiations with Lum.
Lum’s offer through Community Healthcare Partners for the hospital came in at $500,000 less than the $3 million bid AM made last year. While the city had hoped Community Healthcare Partners, Inc. would offer something close to the $3.6 million figure featured in an appraisal of the hospital and the property it sits on obtained by the city last year, Lum said the $3.6 million figure is unrealistic and inflated, being applicable in a large urban area but not appropriate in an underpopulated rural setting.
Though Community Healthcare Partners is an entity legally distinct from AM Pharmacy, Lum said his experience with AM Pharmacy as a provider of  “outsourced” pharmacy services to existing for-profit hospitals gives him and his non-profit an advantage over Valentine and Needles Hospital, Inc.
“We have been operating for years as a successful company,” Lum said. “We have access to resources as a start up because of our access to our existing company’s capital. We can do that. That was a challenge for Mrs. Valentine. Her non-profit had never done business. It is very challenging to get financing or do something of that nature when you have not had any history.”
The city council is scheduled next week, on July 24, to consider entering into the purchase agreement with Community Healthcare Partners. If the hospital board, which has already approved the purchase agreement then acts quickly to ratify the management agreement for the hospital, Lum said he believes “We could conceivably be in there and working in one week.”
At present, the hospital has one doctor on staff, Ed Paget, who is also Needles mayor. Lum said he will enlarge the hospital staff.
“I am going to bring in doctors,” he said. “That is one of the big pieces of the operation that is missing. There is no specific number, but I will bring in whatever we need, whether it is one or ten specialists. Specialists are what the hospital has lacked for years and years. We are not looking to get rid of anybody. We will continue to employ the existing people and will be hiring new people.”
There will be capital investments as well, Lum said.
“There certainly are some stories about how Lifepoint took all the equipment to its new facility in Arizona,” Lum said. “The hospital was able to get some pieces back. For sure, they lost some stuff but did get some stuff back. One of the big things to replace is the CT scanner. Most likely, I would be taking on that project as soon as I walk through the door. Once we get into place and are up and running, we will start on making repairs to the HVAC [heating, ventilation and air conditioning] system, the boilers and the roof. We will need to apply to the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, which is the regulatory body that has 100 percent authority on anything a hospital does. We will need their approval, so I anticipate you will measure our progress in months rather than days.”