(March 15) Democrat Assemblywoman Norma Torres and Paul Leon, the Republican mayor of Ontario, will square off in May to determine who will succeed Gloria Negrete-McLeod as state senator in California’s 32nd Senatorial District.
Torres and Leon fought to the top of the heap of six candidates in the Tuesday March 12 special election that was held because Negrete-McLeod, who was reelected to a four-year term in the state Senate in 2010, resigned that post to depart to Washington D.C. after she was elected to Congress in November.
Torres proved the top vote-getter with 13,295 votes or 43.6 percent throughout the district, which spreads into both Los Angeles and San Bernardino counties. Leon polled 8,064 votes or 26.4 percent in both counties. Since no candidate captured a majority of the vote, a run-off will be held on May 14.
Democrat Larry Walker, the San Bernardino County treasurer-tax collector/auditor/controller, ran a distant third, with 4,232 votes in both counties or 13.9 percent. Rialto School Board Member Joanne Gilbert, also a Democrat, received 2,134 votes, or seven percent. Pomona Planning Commissioner Ken Coble, a Republican, pulled in 1,989 votes, or 6.5 percent. Ontario City Councilman Paul Vincent Avila, a Democrat by registration who was disowned by his own party after he engaged in the highly unorthodox move of endorsing Leon, a Republican and his opponent in the race, brought in 785 votes in both counties, or 2.6 percent.
Torres had her best showing in Los Angeles County, where she was previously mayor of Pomona. According to the Los Angeles County Registrar of Voters, she captured 2,925 votes there, or a whopping 57.02 percent. Leon captured 1,031 votes in Los Angeles County, or 20.1 percent.
Conversely, Leon had his strongest showing in San Bernardino County, though he still ran behind Torres. In San Bernardino County, Torres received 10,370 votes, or 40.88 percent. Leon captured 7,033 votes in his own county, or 27.72 percent.
The odds and circumstance would appear to favor Torres in the May 14 run-off. The 32nd District, which includes all of Pomona in Los Angeles County, and parts of San Bernardino County, including all of Bloomington, Fontana, Montclair, Muscoy, Ontario, and Rialto, and parts of Colton and San Bernardino, is a heavily Democrat-leaning jurisdiction, with 48 percent of its voters registered as Democrats and 28 percent registered Republican. On March 12, the four Democratic candidates – Torres, Walker, Gilbert and Avila – received 67 percent of the votes cast. The two Republicans – Leon and Coble – captured less than half of that at 33 percent. Torres, who is a serving member of the state legislature, having been reelected to a third term in the Assembly in November, has a political fundraising advantage as well.
On March 13, she told the Sentinel, “I’m very happy with the results. We think we had a very good showing at the polls although the overall voter turnout was not as high as I would have preferred. We did our best to get out the vote. I am now looking toward moving and representing an even larger area.”
As for the May 14 showdown with Leon, Torres said “I’m very confident and not just because of the huge Democratic registration lead in the district but I am confident because of the number of votes I got this time around. If you look at the percentage by which I won, I outperformed both of the Republican candidates by a substantial number.“
Torres said that on one level moving up to the Senate “is going to be twice as much work as being in the Assembly” but that she welcomes the challenge. “I have already invested time in conducting polls and reaching out to the voters in the district, a part of which I have represented in the Assembly for a long time. There is a lot of work to do out there and I am anxious to start.”
Leon told the Sentinel, “I think we did quite well. We were able to get into the run-off without drawing on funding from throughout the state. My contributions came pretty much from local sources, friends, acquaintances who like what the campaign had to say, people who support my positions on the issues. We are now in the position we wanted to be in. We made it through the primary and have made it into the run-off. It’s the dawn of a new day and we’re ready to get going with the next phase of the campaign.”
Leon says he is unfazed by Torres’ relatively strong showing, which he said was in some measure an outgrowth of the million dollars she poured into the campaign. He said he would pound the pavement to “knock on doors” in making his pitch that he deserves to go to Sacramento to represent the people of the 32nd District. He said he would wage “a classic, standard campaign. We will raise money, put mail in people’s mailboxes, make phone calls, spread the message. We will maximize the funding we have by being smart with the money we collect.”
Leon said he believed he could overcome the Republican Party’s registration disadvantage in the 32nd District by “showing people can benefit from our philosophy and our approach to government. I think I will be seen as the better candidate if people look at what we have accomplished in the city of Ontario with balanced budgets, creating jobs by increasing economic opportunity, and reducing crime. My qualifications proceed me. I have built up the trust of people with what I have done in city government. I want to take that trust to the state level.”
The Republican Party has a stake in the outcome of the race in the 32nd Senatorial District, as last November the GOP suffered its worst electoral showing in California history. The Democrats, who already had the advantage of holding the governor’s position and majorities in both the Assembly and Senate, achieved supermajority status in both houses of the legislature, meaning the Democratic delegation in Sacramento can impose new taxing authority over the state’s businesses entirely without any Republican support. Electing Leon, an anti-tax, anti-regulation Republican who happens to be Hispanic, would represent an inroad into the Democratic domination of Sacramento politics, though it is unclear whether the Republican Party, which is still reeling from the loss in November, has the wherewithal to mount a well-financed campaign on Leon’s behalf to assist him in overcoming Torres’ apparent advantage.
The winner of the May 14 race will serve out the remainder of Negrete-McLeod’s Senate term, which expires in December 2014.
$51M Later, County Drops Colonies Recovery Lawsuit
After the expenditure of more than $50 million in public funds by all four entities, the county of San Bernardino this week dropped the litigation relating to the Colonies settlement it has been pursuing for nine years against the city of Upland, the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) and the county’s own transportation agency, San Bernardino Associated Governments, known by its acronym SANBAG.
The suit was filed by the county in 2004 after the county and its flood control district were sued in 2002 by the Colonies Partners over drainage issues at the Colonies at San Antonio residential and Colonies Crossroads commercial subdivisions in northeast Upland. The county’s lawsuit against the three other governmental agencies was filed as a precaution before the Colonies Partners’ lawsuit went to trial, on the assumption that the other entities had some level of liability with regard to the issues involved in the underlying lawsuit. The Colonies Partners, which had obtained approval for its residential and commercial projects from the city of Upland, sued the county because its flood control division had diverted stormwater collected in what was known as the 20th Street Storm Drain onto its property. The 20th Street Storm Drain was a project built by the county at the city of Upland’s behest to alleviate flooding originating at the northwestern corner of Upland. The storm drain ran along the periphery of the 210 Freeway, which was built by Caltrans in part with money provided by SANBAG. It was the county’s contention that Upland’s commissioning of the stormdrain and its failure to spell out in the approval of the Colonies projects which entities bore responsibility for the provision of infrastructure and the mitigation of developmental impacts contributed in large measure to the circumstances which led the Colonies Partners to file suit, as did Caltrans’ and SANBAG’s designing of the freeway. The county’s lawsuit for two years was a relatively inexpensive formality until a November 26, 2006 vote by the county board of supervisors to settle the Colonies lawsuit with a $102 million payout to the Colonies Partners. The 3-2 vote to settle the suit was favored by then-supervisors Bill Postmus and Paul Biane as well as Gary Ovitt, who remains on the board. Since that time, the legal war between the county and the three defendants has escalated, to the point that the county expended roughly $26 million in pursuing the suit, while Caltrans has spent $11 million defending itself, SANBAG spent $8 million and Upland about $6 million.
In addition to the seemingly interminable legal squabbling and the expense that entailed, other events and factors at last convinced the county to abandon the lawsuit.
In 2010, Postmus and the former president of the San Bernardino County sheriff’s deputies’ union who had served as a consultant to the Colonies Partners, Jim Erwin, were indicted, charged with bribery and extortion with regard to the 2006 settlement vote that conferred the $102 million on the Colonies Partners. The following year, Postmus pleaded guilty to 14 of the counts contained in that indictment, including accepting a bribe from one of the managing principals in the Colonies Partners, Jeff Burum, as well as engaging in a conflict of interest, fraud and conspiracy. Postmus then went before another grand jury as a star witness and that grand jury issued a superseding indictment alleging conspiracy, bribery, extortion, fraud and misappropriation of public funds against Erwin, who had previously pleaded not guilty; Paul Biane, who had joined with Postmus in the 2006 vote to approve the settlement with the Colonies Partners; Mark Kirk, the chief of staff to Gary Ovitt, who had also voted for the settlement; and Burum. The indictment referenced three separate $100,000 donations made by Burum to political action committees controlled by Biane, Kirk and Erwin in addition to two $50,000 donations made to two political action committees controlled by Postmus. Prosecutors allege those donations were in fact bribes. Kirk is alleged to have influenced Ovitt to support the settlement and Erwin is alleged to have assisted Burum in threatening Postmus and Biane prior to the vote. That criminal case is yet ongoing.
The county’s civil case against Upland, Caltrans, and SANBAG had been removed to the San Diego Superior Courtroom of Judge Ronald Prager. On February 5, Prager entered a finding that dismissed a major portion of the suit against the three civil defendants. Prager ruled that the county cannot compel Upland, SANBAG, and Caltrans to pay for a settlement that violated state law. He referenced both the state’s conflict of interest code, Government Code Section 1090, and Penal Code Section 182, the prohibition against bribery.
“Postmus’ guilty plea is evidence of a violation of section 1090,” Prager noted, which he said rendered the settlement with the Colonies Partners null and void. “SANBAG presented evidence that Postmus pled guilty to conspiracy to accept a bribe, in violation of penal code section 182 and having a conflict of interest in violation of section 1090 by accepting bribes from Jeff Burum to vote in favor of the settlement agreement,” Prager wrote. The activity Postmus and others engaged in was “unseemly… disgusting” and representative of the “worst of the worst” in government, Prager said, making it “fundamentally wrong to perpetuate this case.” Prager all but directed the county to seek to recover the money from the Colonies Partners rather than pursuing redress from the three governmental entities it had sued. “I don’t understand why the county of San Bernardino is not going after the Colonies and getting their money back,” Prager said.
The board of supervisors on March 12 met in closed session and voted to finalize bringing an end to the county’s effort to recoup from SANBAG, Upland and Caltrans the $102 million it paid to the Colonies Partners as a result of the November 2006 settlement. This week’s vote was made pursuant to an understanding among all four litigants that none of the parties would seek legal fees from each other in the case. The parties immediately informed Prager of the agreement.
Prager then issued an order that executed a dismissal with prejudice of the entire lawsuit and all of its causes of action.
County Tab With Law Firm Working Rialto Perchlorate Case Now Exceeds $2 Million
(March 15) The county is set to increase by another $455,000 the $1.87 million it has already paid the law firm of Gallagher & Gallagher for assistance in staving off lawsuits relating to water contamination in northern Rialto.
The board of supervisors this week deferred upping Gallagher & Gallagher’s retainer to $2,325,000 while paperwork pertaining to the firm’s work is processed. The firm for four years has provided legal services to the county related to the former Broco facility closure at the Mid Valley Landfill and other actions related to perchlorate contamination in Rialto’s aquifer.
In the late 1990s, a plume of contaminants containing perchlorate was found to be migrating through the local water table.
It is believed that five corporate entities – Pyro Spectaculars, Ken Thompson Inc., Chung Ming Wong, BF Goodrich, and Emhart Industries – were engaged in manufacturing activities that resulted in the accumulation and release of the perchlorate.
Water agency officials, state officials and federal officials believe the county of San Bernardino may have engaged in activity that exacerbated the perchlorate problem.
The county runs the Mid-Valley Landfill in north Rialto.
Officials with the Rialto-based West Valley Water District and their lawyers have alleged that San Bernardino County razed and buried a hazardous waste-disposal facility at the site, an act those officials maintain was not only illegal but has worsened the contamination of the groundwater below Rialto.
Broco Inc. maintained the hazardous-waste disposal operation in northern Rialto from the mid-1960s until the late 1980s. The county purchased the property in 1994 and used it in the expansion of the Mid-Valley Sanitary Landfill.
According to attorney Barry Groveman, who represents the West Valley Water District, it appears the county simply knocked the hazardous waste facility down and spread the debris around before burying it. That action was against the law, Groveman said.
Groveman said the county was in violation of state hazardous waste handling regulations and the federal Resource Conservation and Recovery Act.
Burying hazardous waste and storing it without a permit is illegal.
In the area around the Broco site, Pyro Spectaculars, Ken Thompson Inc., Chung Ming Wong, BF Goodrich and Emhart Industries had operations that were ongoing in the 1940s, 1950s, 1960s, 1970s and 1980s. Public health officials have identified that area as the origin of the plume of perchlorate.
Perchlorate is a product used in the manufacture of both fireworks and ordnance. In very minute quantities perchlorate can wreak havoc on the thyroid gland.
The site has been designated by the Environmental Protection Agency as one of its Superfund sites, which makes federal funding for the remediation available but also carries with it a requirement that the parties responsible for the contamination assist in the effort. Simultaneously, the EPA will apply the Superfund money toward the remediation. Eventually, if any of the parties deemed responsible for the contamination refuse to sponsor or otherwise pay for a share of the remediation, the EPA will sue and under federal law, any party proven responsible will be required to pay triple the cost of that portion of the clean up for which it was the contaminating party.
The ability to impose triple damages serves as an incentive for the responsible entities to undertake the clean-up on their own or participate in funding an EPA-sponsored remediation.
Previously, the city of Rialto sued BF Goodrich over the contamination issue. Rialto dropped that lawsuit after the company agreed to undertake a remediation effort. BF Goodrich did pay a total of $4 million – $1 million each to the cities of Fontana, Rialto and Colton as well as to the West Valley Water District. That money was used to treat specific wells that were producing perchlorate-laden water but did not redress the underlying problems in the aquifer. BF Goodrich, like the other companies, will yet likely be on the hook for millions of dollars more in decontamination efforts.
An EPA-designed program of remediation, consisting of contaminated water being pumped out of the ground to then be treated and distributed to water districts, is underway. It will likely take two decades or more for the perchlorate levels to be reduced to acceptable limits.
Rialto officials had initially resisted the call to have the area declared a Superfund site, largely because doing so could have a deleterious impact on property values in the area. As the expense of completing a remediation of the problem has been driven home to city officials, it is now accepted that the Superfund designation is the only realistic way of coming to terms with the problem.
The county of San Bernardino, nevertheless, has committed several million dollars to a court battle to obtain a finding that it is not responsible for the contamination.
In May 2009, then-county counsel Ruth Stringer convinced the county board of supervisors to retain Gallagher & Gallagher at a cost of $710,000. The legal services Gallagher & Gallagher was to provide pertained to allegations against the county for perchlorate contamination in connection with particular matters that fall outside of the defense work covered by the county’s insurance. Gallagher & Gallagher currently represents the county in connection with the federal and state court litigation and federal and state agencies’ investigations of the perchlorate groundwater contamination in the Rialto-Colton Basin.
The board of supervisors previously approved three amendments to the Gallagher & Gallagher contract, in the amounts of $560,000 on March 23, 2010, $250,000 on December 10, 2010, and $350,000 on February 14, 2012.
Available records show Price Postel & Parma, another firm representing the county with regard to perchlorate contamination lititgation, had been paid $4 million by the county as of December 2009.
In a report to the board of supervisors dated March 12 from Jean-Rene Basle, the current county counsel, and Gerry Newcome, the county director of public works, it is stated, “Currently, outside legal services and consultant services remain necessary to assist county counsel and the solid waste management division with issues concerning implementation of the Broco Closure Plan, with continued legal services connected with the Zambelli settlement and to address continuing allegations of damages from third parties claiming that the county’s actions in the Rialto-Colton Basin have resulted in harm to certain parties not involved in the federal perchlorate litigation. Therefore, a further amendment to the contract is needed at this time in order for Gallagher & Gallagher to continue to provide necessary legal services and legal-consultant services to complete these matters. The other related matters that are outside the defense work covered by the county’s insurers include: (1) assistance with the implementation of the now-approved final closure plan for the Broco facility under submission to the Department of Toxic Substances Control, including: (a) technical support from a specialized technical consultant, Geo-Logic Associates, who provides professional geologists, certified engineering geologists and certified hydrogeologists to address technical implementation questions; and (b) addressing the continuing vigorous opposition to the county’s proposed plan by the West Valley Water District; (2) coordination, communication, and meetings with other interested agencies and parties concerning other perchlorate issues in the basin; (3) assistance with the defense of the Stout and Zambelli parties as required by the county’s settlement agreements with each of these parties and; (4) various settlement issues to the extent not otherwise covered by county insurance policies.” Stout and Zambelli are entities named in the litigation.
The board of supervisors held off on Basle’s request to increase the contract amount by $455,000, from $1,870,000 to 2,325,000, until a future date when billing and other documents from the firm have been provided.
Leading GOP Legislators Want XpressWest High Speed Rail Loan Killed
(March 15) XpressWest, a proposed high speed train to be built from Victorville to Las Vegas, has encountered a severe test this month, with two leading Republican lawmakers calling upon the Obama administration to reject a $5.5 billion loan to facilitate the project.
Until recently, the effort to establish the United States’ first bullet train as a park-and-ride project that would convey several hundred thousand travelers from Southern California to the Nevada gambling Mecca yearly appeared to be chugging along nicely. All of the environmental work for the project had been completed and most of the right-of-way acquisition accomplished. Nevada-based XpressWest was in the ultimate design stage for the project and awaiting finalization of federal loans to begin work on the undertaking, which promised to be a substantial boost to San Bernardino County’s economy during the construction phase of the project.
On March 6, however, House Budget Committee Chairman Paul Ryan and Senator Jeff Sessions, the ranking member of the Senate Budget Committee, sent a letter to Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood in which they characterized the federal government’s provision of loans to complete the project a risky application of taxpayer money.
“We are deeply troubled by the prospects of subsidizing another costly, wasteful and risky high-speed rail project, particularly when our nation is facing a debt crisis,” Ryan and Sessions wrote. They said they wanted the government to cancel making the loan or at least postpone a decision on it until the Government Accountability Office, the investigative arm of Congress, makes an assessment of the viability of the project and the risk to taxpayers.
Ryan and Sessions’ call for the administration to back away from its support for the project was unexpected. Many of those connected to the project are themselves Republicans who have celebrated the project as a shining example of public-private participation in American innovation. There is, as well, some political implication in the emergence of the Republican Congressional leadership’s opposition to the undertaking, in that the strongest backer of the project is Democratic Nevada Senator Harry Reid, who is also the Senate Majority Leader, and a lightning rod of controversy in the partisan bickering between the GOP and his party.
Reid, whose state stands to reap a long-term benefit from the project, reacted immediately to Ryan and Sessions’ letter, stating “We shouldn’t allow Tea Party-driven ideology to limit much-needed investments in our infrastructure that create thousands of direct and indirect jobs.”
XpressWest CEO Anthony Marnell II in short order fired off a letter to Ryan and Sessions, expressing “disappointment” in their letter, which he said relied “upon a report that was formulated using outdated information and faulty data.”
Marnell said, “The fact is that the XpressWest project would generate a wide array of benefits for Nevada, the western region and the nation at large.” Among these, Martell said, was that the train would “provide an efficient new transportation option in a corridor with a growing population, now served by highly congested highways and airspace” and that the project would “create approximately 80,000 direct and indirect jobs during the construction phase in a region with unemployment rates significantly above the national average” and “upon completion, provide approximately 2,100 long-term permanent operational jobs, with an estimated economic output of $7.8 billion in the region.”
Marnell, a contractor whose large-scale projects include the Bellagio and Wynn hotel-casinos in Las Vegas, further touted XpressWest as a venture that will “launch a new generation of U.S. rail travel in a region desperate for alternative forms of transportation” as well as “lay the groundwork for future connectivity to other high-speed rail networks in the Pacific and Mountain West.”
A further benefit, Marnell said, would be that the system will “reduce the number of automobile trips and cut carbon emissions, thus reducing air pollution problems.”
Marnell said that pulling the plug on the project was a shortsighted move that would delay or eliminate crucial progress.
“The XpressWest project is perhaps the nation’s best current example of a public-private partnership,” Marnell said. “The rail will be financed through a combination of private capital and Railroad Infrastructure Financing funding. Under the terms of the Railroad Infrastructure Financing program, the XpressWest plan of finance demonstrates that the loan will be repaid in full over 35 years, including payment of interest. Our ridership study, conducted by the premier analysts in that industry, clearly supports our financing structure and the viability of the project. It is time to approve a viable project that has met every federal permitting requirement and stands ready to begin construction immediately upon financial approval. XpressWest is the only high-speed rail project in the United States positioned to jump-start a new industry that will have lasting public benefits and produce tangible near-term benefits that satisfy and achieve the government’s goals and priorities. There is no more worthy rail transportation infrastructure project in the United States.”
Foster, Quincey’s Shadow Manager In Hesperia & Upland, Departs Colton
(March 15) COLTON–Rod Foster, who held key administrative positions with four cities in San Bernardino County, including a just-concluded three year stint as city manager in Colton, has departed to become city manager in the Orange County municipality of Laguna Niguel.
Foster, who worked for the city of Chino early in his career in a mid-level management position, served as the de-facto city manager with the cities of Hesperia and Upland, though he was not officially elevated to that position, instead being designated at the assistant city manager in both the City of Progress and the City of Gracious Living, as Hesperia and Upland are known.
As deputy city manager in Hesperia, Foster was temporarily elevated to interim city manager in 2001 following the departure of David Berger as city manager there. At that time, Robb Quincey, representing Western Water, had sought to convince the Hesperia City Council to sell off its water division to that company. The council declined to make that sale, but was so impressed with Quincey’s presentation that its members hired him to serve as city manager, despite Quincey having no previous municipal management experience.
For four years, Foster mentored Quincey, his boss, in how to run a city. When Upland, led by its then-mayor John Pomierski, equally impressed by Quincey’s outward appearance, lured him away from Hesperia to become city manager, Quincey insisted upon Upland hiring Foster as his next-in-command. A week after Quincey’s arrival in Upland, Foster signed on with Upland, where, for the next four years, he essentially ran that city. In November 2009, Colton hired Foster as city manager.
Foster’s value as a public administrator was starkly illustrated by his absence from Upland. After he departed, the Upland ship of state foundered and in 2011, Pomierski was indicted, and then pleaded guilty to bribery charges in 2012. Quincey followed Pomierski into infamy, being unceremoniously shown the door by the Upland City Council two months after Pomierski’s indictment. He has since been criminally charged by the district attorney’s office with several felonies, including unlawful misappropriation of public money, gaining personal benefit from an official contract, and giving false testimony under oath. The case against him is still being pursued.
Foster, on the other hand, has been given accolades for his performance as a public administrator.
Though Colton ranks 13th in population among San Bernardino County’s 24 cities with 52,154 residents, it boasts the seventh largest overall budget of the county’s municipalities, taking in during 2012-13 $130,256,698 through all of its funds and spending $132,088,336 through those funds, including $34,021,995 in revenues into the general fund and $33,640,484 in expenditures from the general fund. Colton is the only city in San Bernardino County with its own electrical utility, and as such, has a more elaborate operation than many of the county’s cities. Though the size of the city’s payroll has decreased in recent years, it still boasts 254 full time employees.
Foster came into Colton at an extremely difficult and challenging time, several months after the departure of former city manager Daryl Parrish, who left Colton to become city manager with the city of Covina, taking with him the city’s finance director, Dilu DeAlwis. Shortly after their departure, the council learned that confident budget projections Parrish and DeAlwis had made previously were in error and that the city in fact had a $5.8 million deficit.
Foster immediately set about imposing several rounds of belt tightening, including substantial layoffs and salary and benefit cuts for remaining employees. This triggered virulent personal attacks on Foster, who with aplomb blunted and deflected those challenges by imposing upon himself an even heftier salary reduction than was being assessed against the rest of city staff.
He energetically pursued state and federal grants, even as the economy was contracting, consolidated city departments, radically reduced spending out of the city’s general fund, and beefed up the city’s general fund reserves from the $50,000 contained therein in 2009 to $2.3 million at present.
He also overcame the disadvantage of having to manage a city that was being ruled by a sharply divided city council, which involved a 4-3 ruling coalition headed by former mayor Kelly Chastain. In 2010, Chastain was defeated by former Colton Community Development Director David Zamora, who had been a casualty of Foster’s staff downsizing. This put Zamora into political ascendency, but Foster deftly made himself indispensible to Zamora, as the city continued in its effort to turn a corner in stabilizing its finances. When David Zamora died in the summer of 2011 and was succeeded by his wife, Sara, Foster maintained his status as the technocrat leading the city.
That job was taking a toll on Foster, however, who was often working 50 to 56 hours per week to stay abreast of the challenges that continue to dog Colton. It was known that he was looking to find another city manager assignment more than 14 months ago.
“We’re losing a good administrator,” said councilman Frank Gonzales, who returned to the council in 2010, after last having served in 1994. Gonzales was first elected to the council in 1966 and was mayor of Colton in the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s.
“It’s been a wonderful journey,” Foster told the city council at his official farewell to the city last week. “Thank you for having faith in me and for the opportunity to serve.” Foster’s last day with Colton was yesterday.
In Laguna Niguel, where there were 65 applicants for the city manager’s post, Foster will be paid an annual salary of $220,000, a 6 percent increase over his self-imposed reduced salary in Colton.
Joint Caltrans Barstow Project To Replace 83-Year-Old First Street Bridge
(March 15) BARSTOW—Deemed barely adequate by current standards following a California Department of Transportation inspection, the 83-year-old First Avenue Bridge will be entirely replaced within the next six years.
Federal funding for the replacement, which is being administered through the state, has now been made available, city officials announced last week. The replacement project will begin by 2017 at the latest. The decision to make a wholesale replacement of the wooden-braced cement and steel truss bridge comes after a series of stopgap repairs on the structure were made between September and November last year.
Problems with the bridge, precipitated by an earthquake or trucks bearing excessive loads, were first recognized in 2003, triggering a directive from Caltrans that refurbishing and shoring up of the bridge be immediately undertaken. The bridge, built in 1930, is a key route of ingress and egress at Barstow’s rail yard, the largest in the world. Despite the Caltrans directive, no repairs were made and in 2010, the city of Barstow and Caltrans instituted weight limits on vehicles using the bridge, with the maximum load for a four-axle vehicle being 15 tons, well under the normal 40 ton legal limit for most bridges.
In essence, traffic across the bridge was restricted to non-commercial vehicles such as cars, pickups, and SUVs, and small load commercial vehicles such as four-wheel stakebeds and the like. Larger vehicles such as 18-wheel tractor-trailers could not use the bridge. Moreover, large public transportation vehicles including busses and public safety vehicles like fire engines had to be routed around the bridge. In the case of fire emergencies in north Barstow, this represented a potential safety hazard, as fire battalions were delayed in their responses.
The work done on the bridge last year, which included repairs to a structural column and support bracing, has theoretically returned it to the 40-ton carrying capacity. The clearance for it to be redesignated to allow passage of 18-wheelers, busses, fire engines and the like is anticipated later this month. Nevertheless, in a Caltrans inspection completed after the repairs were made, the bridge was given a sufficiency rating of 3 out of 100.
Caltrans has put a priority on replacing the bridge, which will entail an overall project cost of $44.5 million. Caltrans said it would make $39,382,500, or 88.5 percent of the cost of the project available, utilizing Caltrans Highway Bridge Program funds, most of which originate with U.S. Department of Transportation. Barstow will be counted upon to provide the remaining 11.5 percent, or $5,177,500.
The city last week selected Simon Wong Engineering to do the bridge design.
Supervisors’ Approval Of Raves At Amphitheater Triggers Objection
(March 15) The San Bernardino County Board of Supervisors has authorized Live Nation Entertainment to hold four rave events per year at the San Manuel Amphitheater beginning in April.
In granting the permission, the board amended the 25-year contract with the theater to allow it to stay open until 2 a.m. Live Nation will pay the county $1,500 per event, for a total of four raves per 12 months.
Valerie Henry, the president of the Devore Rural Protection Association, was highly critical of the county’s action, saying there had been inadequate noticing of the hearing at which the board made its vote as part of the consent calendar, which is reserved for what are considered to be noncontroversial issues.
“I never got notification of this issue being considered,’ she said. “This is a huge impact for Devore and the surrounding areas. Apparently the only concern was the infusion of cash into county coffers. I find it very difficult to understand the county being willing to subject the residents to such impacts for a mere $6,000.”
Henry said the county clearly realized raves created problems in the community, saying raves held at the Orange Show in San Bernardino last year generated complaints from residents in San Bernardino, Loma Linda and Grand Terrace. “Is that why the venue was relocated to Devore?” she asked, stating that the Devore residents were being “throw[n] to the wolves. Does the county have the resources to protect these same residents from the drug use, drug sales and the crime that will inundate the area? I am totally opposed to these type events.”
Spencer Uses Corporate Shells To Insinuate Himself Back Into Airport
(March 8) Nearly five months after a federal judge ordered what was widely hailed as Scot Spencer’s departure from San Bernardino International Airport, he appears to have insinuated himself once again into operations at the aerodrome.
Upon the shuttering of Norton Air Force Base in 1994, local officials in their civilian reuse strategy for the property sought to transform it into an international airport. After more than a decade, no success toward that goal was achieved, and in 2007, the board for the San Bernardino International Airport Authority, composed of representatives from the county of San Bernardino and the cities of Colton, Highland, Loma Linda and San Bernardino, hired Spencer, largely on the strength of his status as an airline industry insider, to serve as the contract developer of the base. Spencer was given that assignment despite his 1994 conviction for fraud that ensued after he and financier Jeffrey Chodorow sought to utilize the remaining assets from Braniff International Airways, which went bankrupt in 1982, to create Dallas-based Braniff International Airlines, Inc. Spencer and Chodorow were both convicted of fraud for absconding with $14 million of the company’s funds and Spencer served a four-year prison term from 1995 until 1999 as a result of that conviction.
Spencer had come to the airport authority’s attention when in 2005 he leased from the San Bernardino International Airport Authority the lion’s share of property at the airport, where several companies he was an owner or investor in set up shop.
Under Spencer’s guidance as contract developer, however, the airport fared no better than before in attracting major airlines, despite mammoth increases in taxpayer money spent in that effort. After four years of this hemorrhaging of red ink, the San Bernardino County Grand Jury in 2011 delivered a scathing report concerning Spencer’s mismanagement of the airport. This was followed by an FBI investigation into fraud and embezzlement, which involved a September 2011 raid by the FBI in which agents served search warrants at SBIAA headquarters and the offices of companies controlled by Spencer at the airport as well as his Riverside residence, the Loma Linda home and office of T. Milford Harrison and at the home and business office of Spencer’s father in Florida, seeking evidence of bribery, conspiracy, money laundering and fraudulent use of federal funds.
Spencer and several of his business associates as well as local officials remain targets of interest in the Justice Department’s examination of the matter.
As the airport’s contract developer between 2007 and 2012, Spencer oversaw the expenditure of hundreds of millions of tax dollars applied to transform the one-time base into a thriving civilian airport. Spencer’s management of what was supposed to be a $38 million renovation of the airport’s passenger terminal and a $7 million development of its concourse was dogged by cost overruns, boosting the combined cost of the passenger terminal and the concourse to $142 million. No commercial airlines have yet flown out of the airport, despite the completion of those improvements. Instead, Spencer exploited his position at the airport, showing favoritism toward companies he owned or controlled and set up at San Bernardino International Airport, including SBD Aircraft Services, Norton Aviation Maintenance Services, Unique Aviation, San Bernardino Airport Management, SBD Properties LLC, KCP Leasing and Services, SBAM Technics, and SBD Aircraft Services, to the detriment of other aviation-related companies located there. Spencer’s action resulted in decisions by Aeros Aeronautical Systems Corp. and BaySys West, both of which were making substantial lease payments for hangar space at the airport, to leave San Bernardino. Spencer also became a franchisee of the corporate jet-servicing company, Million Air, which was based at San Bernardino International Airport. Million Air terminated its relationship with Spencer last year after the company claimed Spencer had failed to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars he owed it.
Spencer also formed at least three business partnerships with T. Milford Harrison, who had formerly served as the executive director of the San Bernardino International Airport Authority and its sister agency, the Inland Valley Development Authority (IVDA), which is dedicated to the development of the property surrounding the airport.
By the summer of 2011, Spencer owed the county of San Bernardino more than $604,000 in unpaid taxes on property and equipment at the airport since 2005 and was in arrears on interest and principal payments on $1.2 million in loans to him through the airport authority.
Don Rogers, a certified public accountant and the founder of one of the Inland Empire’s most prestigious accounting firms, had been the executive director of the airport authority durng most of Spencer’s tenure there. Rogers found himself under fire for his tolerance of Spencer’s depredations. To replace Rogers, board members hired A.J. Wilson, who had previously served as the chief administrative officer of St. Louis, the city manager of Portland, Maine, Santa Ana, Pomona and Norco, as well as the executive director of the St. Louis County Municipal League, the Pomona Valley Educational Foundation, the Western Riverside Council of Governments, and the International Association of Arson Investigators.
Wilson was effective in prying the airport and its operations from Spencer’s grip. Largely on the strength of that accomplishment, the board in November extended Wilson’s contract at least through November of this year, increasing his original annual contract from $315,000 to $351,000.
Under Wilson, the San Bernardino International Airport Authority (SBIAA) reassessed its relationship with Spencer and the airport authority board moved to terminate nearly all of its contracts with Spencer. Simultaneously, the airport authority has placed the effort to woo airlines on a back burner and is now undertaking to market the facility to developers, entrepreneurs, aeronautics and aerospace companies and logistics and transportation service providers.
Spencer maneuvered to resist Wilson, declaring bankruptcy and dragging his feet with regard to vacating the premises he occupied, relying upon the convolutions contained in his leasing arrangements. Wilson utilized close to $500,000 to engage lawyers on the authority’s behalf, succeeding in the legal battle to dislodge him, or so it seemed, when on October 19, Federal Bankruptcy Judge Deborah Saltzman ruled that Spencer and his companies that remained at the airport had to depart in the face of revelations that two Spencer-owned and managed companies are no longer insuring their operations and indemnifying SBIAA. Spencer was forced to surrender his keys to the premises.
Spencer made an outward show of complying with Saltzman’s order, steadily shuttering his company’s operations at the airport until the only vestige of his presence there was repair work on a Boeing 767, owned by EL Management, being carried out by one of his companies, SBAM Technics, at bay 3 in the Hangar 763 complex. Spencer was able to keep SBAM Technics in place by sleight-of-hand. After naming SBAM Technics as the “successor in interest” to two other Spencer-owned concerns, Norton Aircraft Maintenance Services and Southern California Precision Aircraft, he substituted himself out as president of the corporation, and installed Jim Thompson, one of his associates, as president and CEO.
Recently, after FAA inspectors made their rounds at bay 3, SBAM Technics was determined to be deficient with regard to its licensure and was forced to surrender its certificate. The Boeing 767, however, remains on jacks at bay 3.
Into the void stepped Pulsar Aviation Services, Inc., which lacks FAA certification. Despite that lack of certification, the company has been accepted as a tenant at the airport. Pulsar Aviation Services, Inc., was a “shell” company, founded in 2003 by Spencer and Harrison, with Harrison designated the chief corporate officer. In October, Pulsar, which had lain dormant for more than six years with its only point of contact being a perpetually unanswered phone number, became active again as what its operators claimed was a “certified 145 Repair Station.”
Another Spencer corporate entity, Montana-based Aerospace Technologies, Inc., was brought into the mix. Aerospace Technologies, Inc., as another “successor in interest” to SBAM Technics, was sued by EL Management because of SBAM Technics failure to complete the work on the 767, despite the payment of $1.8 million for that work.
While airport authority officials are under the impression that Pulsar Aviation Services is being operated by David Reed, Ted Reed and Tim Reed, the company is actually owned by Spencer and Harrison. Moreover, Pulsar Aviation Services is using the same address, location, tooling and aircraft equipment in its operations that was formerly utilized by SBAM Technics, which is identical in nearly every respect to Norton Aircraft Maintenance Services before it and Southern California Precision Aircraft before it.
Thus, it appears, Spencer remains active at San Bernardino International Airport.
Mike Harding, an aviation professional with interests at the airport, is the publisher of Airport Watch: SBD, which monthly reports on developments at San Bernardino International Airport. Harding told the Sentinel that the shell game involving Southern California Precision Aircraft, Norton Aircraft Maintenance Services, SBAM Technics, Pulsar and Aerospace Technologies “is further evidence of Spencer’s and Harrison’s continued corruption of airport activities. It would appear that Scot Spencer, instead of skulking his way out the back door of San Bernardino Airport has instead retained the services of yet another willing front man to move yet another of his corporations in the front door.”
Harding said Spencer was doing his best to get “lost in the corporate shuffle” involving shell corporations he had created with Harrison.
Word this week was that Wilson is currently preparing to seize the Boeing 767 being serviced at bay 3 of Hangar 763 in lieu of the payments to the airport authority which Spencer is in arrears on. Efforts to obtain comment from Wilson were unsuccessful.
Strip Club’s Departure Hits Nearby Brothels Hard
(March 8) More than four months after the Déjà Vu strip club in the unincorporated county area between Montclair and Chino closed, activity at nearby brothels has noticeably diminished, though those illicit businesses remain in operation.
In November, the party came to a close at the locale billed as “where the party never ends,” pursuant to the county planning commission’s vote last August to enforce a 2002 legal settlement between the club and the county over the club’s location and activities.
Established in the 1980s at the northwest corner of Mission Boulevard and Central Avenue within the city of Montclair’s sphere of influence as an adult venue with a liquor license and nude female dancing, the Déjà Vu early on became the focus of intensive efforts by both the county and Montclair to shutter it. After more than a decade of legal and procedural skirmishing, in 2002 the parties reached a legal settlement that provided the club’s owners the right to continue to operate as a strip club for another decade pursuant to some changes.
One of those changes was that the gaudy pink “Always Inn” motel adjacent to the strip club, which was owned and operated by the Déjà Vu’s management and charged its customers by the hour, was closed down and razed. The county also obtained the ownership’s agreement to paint over the pink and lime green exterior of the club itself with a much more sedate white. Eventually, the club would utilize a tinted light projector that at night constantly transformed the walls from red to violet to green to white.
Years ago, a constellation of satellite businesses – houses of ill repute – functioning under the cover of legitimate service providers such as massage parlors or health salons cropped up within easy walking distance of the Mission/Central intersection. An inadvertent result of the forced closure of the Always Inn was that those businesses flourished, with a significant portion of their clientele being drawn to the area by the Déjà Vu, the marquee for which, celebrated the club as one where a never ending party offered “Hundreds of Beautiful Girls & 3 ugly ones.”
The demise of the Déjà Vu has had an impact on the illicit enterprises surrounding it, or so it would appear, based on the cessation of foot traffic from the strip club altogether. Fewer vehicles are observed in the remaining establishments’ parking lots than previously. Their lights remain lit well into the evening, on weeknights as well as on weekends. Only on Friday and Saturday nights does it appear that they are doing any business to speak of, but with nothing approaching the intensity they exhibited when the Déjà Vu was there to serve as a magnet.
Durand, Michigan-based Tollis, Inc., which specializes in the production of adult movies and live entertainment, owned and operated the Déjà Vu. Tollis last year resisted, through its attorney, Alicen Wong, the effectuation of the closure of the facility as a strip club, accepting only with reluctance a “compromise” that allowed it to continue to serve alcohol and remain open as a comedy club or sports bar. After its closure in the fall, however, the venue has remained shuttered and there does not appear to be any movement to transitioning it into a stand-up/improvisational stage or a sports theme tavern.
While the brothels remain in place, there longevity at this point is questionable.
Both Montclair and county officials are looking forward to their eventual demise. There has been an ongoing effort to transform the area, which features wrecking yards, used car lots, marginal commercial uses, derelict motels, low class bordellos and light, medium and limited heavy industrial uses, into new residential units and commercial uses, and clean industrial operations functioning out of business parks and upgraded buildings.
From 1998 until 2011, Montclair spent $11 million to make public improvements within the Mission Boulevard Corridor Improvement Project area, which spans along Mission from the Los Angeles County line, a little over a mile-and-a-half west from the Déjà Vu, to Benson Avenue, a little less than a half mile east.
In a letter dated August 21, 2012 from Montclair’s community development director, Steve Lustro, to Chris Warrick, the planner at the county’s land use services division with oversight responsibility for that portion of the unincorporated county area in Montclair’s sphere of influence, Lustro stated that the sexually oriented operations in the area have hindered the type of development officials are seeking to encourage. “The mere existence of the adult oriented business at the subject location has been an ongoing ‘red flag’ for at least two prospective developers interested in developing property within the city of Montclair’s corporate boundaries proximate to the property,” Lustro wrote.
The Sentinel has obtained an interoffice memo dated October 10, 2012 from San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department Captain Steve Smith, who oversees the patrol division covering the county area bordering Montclair, to Warrick, pertaining to the Déjà Vu site and the proposal to convert it to a sports bar or comedy club. That memo skirts the issue of illicit satellite uses around the 1.22 acre site, concentrating on the adult oriented business transitioning to a more traditional drinking establishment, with reference to the new facility’s liquor license and the conditions attached thereto, along with lighting, security, video monitoring, enforcement and remodeling,
With regard to the remodeling of the building, Smith wrote, “A remodel of the establishment should be made to ensure that the operation has converted from an adult only establishment with nude or topless entertainment. Remodeling the interior to better represent a sports bar environment would be highly recommended. The remodeling should include removal of private booths and brass poles. Having private booths invites behavior that leads to prostitution. The sheriff’s department lacks the manpower to conduct ‘sting’ operations for this type of activity. The planning and resources for a one day sting operation can involve several employees and is not a practical remedy for this problem. It is important to have a significant change to the interior so the environment and adult nature activities at the location do not revert back to undesirable conditions.”
With regard to video monitoring, Smith told Warrick, “The establishment must have working video surveillance. Video surveillance should be both inside and outside the location and should be digital and color quality.”
Warrick, for legal reasons, declined to discuss with the Sentinel whether the closure of the Déjà Vu was purposefully intended to damage the viability of the nearby sexually-oriented businesses.
PUC Tells SCE To Make Plans To Bury 70 Percent Of Chino Hills Power Lines
The California Public Utilities Commission on February 28 directed Southern California Edison to proceed with its plans to bury its transmission lines for the Tehachapi Renewable Energy Project along a 3.5 mile portion of the five mile length the lines will run through Chino Hills.
The commission gave that direction, despite the consideration that a final decision on whether the electrical cables will be undergrounded will not come until July.
Chino Hills residents who have long been opposed to the already-approved but on-hold means of conveying that electricity through the city, namely via 197-foot high towers from which the transmission lines are to be strung, hailed the commission’s directive as a major victory in their effort to achieve an alternative to the towers.
The commission’s directive contained a provision for Southern California Edison to recover its costs in proceeding with the planning for undergrouning the cables in the event the commission this summer elects to remain with the already approved game plan of utilizing an above-ground conveyance of the electricity.
Over the city of Chino Hills’ protest, in 2009 the board of the California Public Utilities Commission granted Southern California Edison clearance to erect a series of 197-foot high power transmission towers through the heart of 44.7-square mile Chino Hills along a long-existing power corridor easement owned by the utility. That approval came as part of the commission’s endorsement of Southern California Edison’s Tehachapi Renewable Transmission Project, to consist of what will be the world’s largest windmill-driven electrical generating field near Tehachapi in Kern County together with the lines to convey that power to the greater Los Angeles metropolitan area. The $2.1 billion project is part of Southern California Edison’s effort to meet state-mandated renewable energy goals.
Fearing a host of problems from the imposition of the towers, including significant negative impacts on property values in the city, the Chino Hills City Council authorized the expenditure of over $2.3 million to employ attorneys and make other efforts to contest the Public Utility Commission’s action, including a suit against Southern California Edison alleging the company had “overburdened” the power line easements. That legal effort failed when West Valley Superior Court Judge Keith D. Davis ruled the California Public Utilities Commission has exclusive jurisdiction regarding the route used by Edison, and the suit was thrown out. Chino Hills appealed Davis’s ruling to the 4th District Court of Appeal, asserting the city had the right to have the case heard by a jury, but in September 2011 the appeals court affirmed Davis’ decision.
Beginning last year, Edison, which has long had a 150-foot wide right-of-way for its power lines that runs for 5.8 miles from Tonner Canyon to the Riverside County line, erected 12 of the towers within the city limits and another 5 in Carbon Canyon before a city appeal to the California Public Utility Commission (PUC) and Public Utility Commission Chairman Michael Peevey in particular succeeded in a temporary halt to the towers’ construction being granted in November 2011 while a potential undergrounding alternative is explored.
With its order last week, the California Public Utilities Commission gave Edison assurance it can accelerate the pre-construction activity it is undertaking aimed at actually burying the transmission lines through roughly 70 percent of Chino Hills without financial risk. The commission signaled that Edison can begin engineering efforts in earnest and make land purchases to facilitate the completion of the project by a December 2015 project completion target date.
In the document co-authored by Peevey approved by the full commission on February 28, it is stated, “SCE [Southern California Edison] should be directed to submit a proposal that clearly defines the ‘reasonable assurance’ it requires that the commission will support rate recovery of the costs incurred for undergrounding the Tehachapi Project through Chino Hills should the commission later decide to reject the undergrounding modification. The rate recovery proposal that SCE has filed expressly recognizes that jurisdictional authority to set the Tehachapi Project’s transmission rates lies with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC). SCE states that it ‘expects that all costs associated with the project will be recovered at [FERC] … through existing rate recovery mechanisms on file’ there. However, while FERC holds the authority to determine the prudency of costs expended by a utility, SCE argues that under the unique circumstances of a situation like this one, a state commission’s assessment is particularly likely to inform FERC’s determination. Accordingly, though SCE is not an undergrounding proponent, SCE’s rate recovery proposal seeks a finding from this commission that it would be in the public interest for SCE to undertake certain activities now – essentially to accelerate them – in advance of our decision on the merits of undergrounding Segment 8A.” Segment 8A refers to that section of the line through Chino Hills.
The commission complied with Edison’s request to be able to charge its ratepayers up to $33 million to recover its costs if the commission decides in July against burying the cables through Chino Hills.
A subdivision of the California Utilities Commission, its Division of Ratepayer Advocates, Peevey said, “disagrees that accelerating pre-construction activities is reasonable or necessary, and therefore contends that doing so cannot be in the public interest. In the Division of Ratepayer Advocates’ view, ratepayers should bear no additional cost responsibility prior to a commission determination on whether or not to underground Segment 8A. Moreover, the Division of Ratepayers Advocates argues that any costs SCE has incurred in responding to the Chino Hills’ petition for modification must be recovered under the cost cap for the project.”
Ultimately, Peevey and his colleagues on the commission overruled the Division of Ratepayer Advocates’ objections.
“The Division of Ratepayer Advocates, like SCE and other parties, is correct that authorization of accelerated pre-construction activities requires a public interest finding. We recognize, as the parties do, that direction to a utility to engage in pre-construction activities is unusual – we would much prefer to wait until we are in the position to issue a decision on whether or not to underground Segment 8A following full development of the record. But in this unique situation, if we wait, we certainly will delay commercial operation of the Tehachapi Project. That clearly is not in the public interest,” Peevey wrote.
Bob Goodwin, president of Hope For The Hills, an organization militating against the above-ground power lines in Chino Hills, told the Sentinel, “The Public Utility Commission’s vote is the first step in the process, but it is a big step since it sets us on the path to our ultimate goal of saving our families, homes and community. We are beyond ecstatic over this vote.”
It is clear from SCE’s filings that the undergrounding will only run below a 3.5 mile portion of Chino Hills and that Southern California Edison intends to utilize the towers to extend the line through the 1.5 mile span of the city known as Oak Tree Downs.
Goodwin said that Hope For The Hills had not entirely resigned itself to the inevitability of the towers remaining along that mile-and-a-half-long corridor. Still, he said, the likelihood is that the towers will become a permanent part of that landscape.
“While the recent information regarding The Oak Tree Downs section of the project is not positive, we want to emphasize this information has been known to all concerned since early 2012,” Goodwin said. “Hope For The Hills learned, at that time, that SCE had always maintained undergrounding would not be feasible in that area. We continue to support Oak Tree Downs and options are being researched.”
On February 28, Leslie Starck, Southern California Edison’s senior vice president for regulatory affairs, notified the commission that the utility had revised the cost of undergrounding the transmission line through Chino Hills upward. At the very least, Starck indicated the undergrounding project along the 3.5 mile stretch would cost $700 million and it could range as high as $893 million.
Goodwin was somewhat skeptical of that estimate.
“As for the higher costs – never be surprised that costs go up when SCE is building something,” Goodwin said. “First, they have done a lot of things to get the costs higher – one being adding the 35% contingency fee to the numbers that the bidders provided them. Bidders already build a contingency into their numbers. So these numbers reflect a contingency on a contingency.”