School Lunch Money Thefts Continued To Hide Previous Embezzlements

(October 10) Judith Oakes’ theft of Rialto Unified School District lunch money was so substantial, according to investigators, that once she had begun she could not stop because to do so would have given indication of her past thefts.

Judith Oakes

More than two months after her arrest by Rialto Police, Oakes was charged by the San Bernardino County District Attorney’s Office on October 8 with eight counts of embezzlement by a public or private officer and eight counts of a public officer crime.
Officials believe an audit has confirmed that Oakes, who was an accountant for the district overseeing the school lunch program for nearly 14 years, stole more than $1.8 million since 2005.
According to investigator Jeff Stewart, who was hired by the district to look into the thefts, it is likely that Oakes stole more than $3.1 million since 1999. On top of the $1.8 million in cash Oakes is now documented as having taken in the past eight years, another $1.3 million is unaccounted for in the years between 1999, the year Oakes is believed to have begun her depredations, and 2005. The examination of the disappearance of district money prior to 2005 was less rigorous because those crimes fall outside the statute of limitations.
Oakes was married to Jack Oakes, an educator who eventually rose to the position of school principal in the San Bernardino City Unified School District. In the mid-1990s, Judith Oakes was working as an accountant at the Bank of Redlands, which is now known as Community Bank.
In 1997, she went to work in the Rialto Unified School District as an accountant. Eventually, she was given virtually unfettered oversight of the cash receipts from the district’s school lunch program. Not only did she oversee the crew that had physical custody of the money, she was given ultimate accounting authority over the funds.
Beginning in 1999, Oakes began pilfering roughly $4,000 a week from the batches of bills collected and processed by the district’s money-counting machines prior to bank deposit. Having begun the thefts, it seems Oakes was obliged to continue stealing approximately the same amount of money every week – an average of between $4,100 and $4,300 weekly – so that the pattern of thefts would remain undetected.
According to Stewart, sometime after she was put in charge of the staff counting and bundling the lunch money and then depositing it into a school district account and after she had begun her thefts, Oakes was entrusted with security arrangements in the office where the money was counted, as well as the loss control procedure devised for the money counting function. “The [district nutrition] department has a money-counting machine that counts bills, and informs workers when there’s enough to ‘strap’ into batches,” Stewart said. “Ms. Oakes was involved with the installation of the camera system and was aware of what areas in the room were visible to it,” according to Stewart.
Oakes engaged in two levels of sleight-of-hand in first secreting the money she took out of the money counting room and then obfuscating the books that tallied the lunch receipts district-wide.
In the first instance, according to Stewart, “Oakes reportedly would bind the bills up at the back counter of the room, rather than on the table next to the computer, where she couldn’t be seen on camera. Ms. Oakes would then quite frequently take a strap or two of twenty-dollar bills or other denominations and stuff them down her top after checking to make sure the person at the computer was not looking.”
Oakes, who had an overview all of the money flowing in from all of the district’s schools, at which a total of  26,408 students are now enrolled, would then provide falsified deposit slips after the money was bundled and ready for deposit. Oakes overcame the scrutiny of the district staff member responsible for reconciling the bank statements with the district’s deposits by falsifying a spreadsheet which she substituted for ledgers containing entries related to the checks and cash collected from each school.
On occasion, it appears, some staff members noted inconsistencies and irregularities with regard to the total amount of money counted and the amount deposited, but Oakes was able to use her position and authority to override any questions and staff  members did not, at least until relatively late, make an effort to report those irregularities out of fear of getting on Oakes’ bad side.
The roughly $210,000 Oakes was stealing from the district yearly augmented an already very comfortable $190,000 yearly household income she and her husband pulled down. Jack Oakes, who had ascended to the position of principal at Ramona-Alessandro Elementary School, made $119,771 during the 2009-2010 school year. Judith was making over $70,000 at that time.
In April 2010, Jack Oakes was severely injured in an off-roading accident in the desert and died of a trauma-induced heart attack.
After her husband’s death, Judith Oakes continued the thefts from the district she had previously been engaged in for over a decade. By the end of 2011, it is believed that she had begun a relationship with Harold Cebrun, who had been superintendent in the Compton and Lynwood school districts prior to being hired as superintendent with the Rialto district in March 2009.
In May, discrepancies with regard to the receipt and depositing of district lunch money was suspected. Video cameras showing perspectives from different angles than those Oakes had previously established were installed in the money counting room unbeknownst to Oakes and Cebrun. She was caught on video stuffing money into her brazier on at least two occasions.
When she was arrested on August 7, Oakes had two packets of $2,000 in $20 bills in her possession. More packets were found at her San Bernardino home later when it was searched pursuant to a warrant. Oakes made incriminating statements to police officers, characterized as a confession. She immediately posted $50,000 bond and was released.  She resigned her post on August 8. While the Superior Court’s on-line record shows that a case – number 1308340790 – had been opened against Oakes involving a single charge of PC 459 filed against her on August 12 and that a $50,000 bond had been deposited in conjunction with case 1308340790, the action notation for the following day, August 13, reports that the district attorney was notified but that no case was filed, a seeming contradiction to the previous reference of a PC 459 charge. PC 459 refers to burglary.
That confusion was rendered moot this week, with the 16 charges filed against her. Her bail was raised to $1.8 million, the amount of money she is alleged to have stolen. She was immediately whisked into custody at her arraignment in Fontana Superior Court on October 9 and she remains at West Valley Detention Center in Rancho Cucamonga.

Hi-Desert Medical Center Leads Morongo Valley In H2O Treatment Standards

(October 10) JOSHUA TREE — The Hi-Desert Medical Center, a nonprofit 59-bed acute primary care hospital that is the primary provider of health services in the Morongo Basin, took on another leadership role late last month when it initiated operation of what is the Morongo Basin’s first wastewater treatment plant outside of Twentynine Palms.
At the initiative of the health care district, the medical center entered into a partnership with the Joshua Basin Water District for the construction and operation of the plant. Originally budgeted as a $2.4 million project, the contractor, Twentynine Palms-based Van Dyke Pipeline Contracting, completed the project at roughly $200,000 under budget. The water district, which supervised the project, obtained permits and licensing for the undertaking. The Morongo Basin Health Care District is picking up the entire cost, construction and operational, of what is dubbed the  Joshua Basin Treatment Plant No. 1.
Located on the east side of White Feather Road, it is capable of handling the current 52,000 to 73,000 gallons of effluent currently discharged per day from the hospital and the nearby Continuing Care Center. It will be able to expand to process the 104,000 to 146,000 gallons of wastewater  per day that it is anticipated will flow from the hospital after its scheduled 23,500-square-foot expansion.
Pipes carry the effluent to the facility’s holding tanks, separators, equalization basin, sludge pre-thickener pumps, and then to the bioreactor and accompanying blowers. In the bioreactor, microorganisms feed on the sludge to break down the sewage, at which point it undergoes further processing and filtration.
The plant provides a model, at both the physical/operational and administrative/financial levels, for the town of Yucca Valley. In Yucca Valley, where the population has grown to 20,700, the entire town and its population utilize septic systems. According to the United States Geological Survey, 880 acre-feet of septic discharge currently reaches the groundwater below the town every year. According to the USGS,  nitrates are accumulating beneath Yucca Valley in ever increasing concentrations and at depths that pose a threat to the groundwater. The California Regional Water Quality Control Board, the state agency responsible for protecting water quality, adopted a resolution identifying the town of Yucca Valley as one of 66 communities throughout the state with groundwater threatened by the continuing overuse of septic systems. The board further declared Yucca Valley as a top priority for eliminating the use of septic systems, meaning Yucca Valley’s is one of the five most seriously threatened water supplies in the state. After local officials resisted taking immediate action and refused to impose any kind of building or development moratorium that would stabilize the problem, the Regional Water Quality Control Board and the Hi-Desert Water District in 2011 forged a memorandum of agreement to allow the city to continue to issue interim permits for new septic systems while imposing state-mandated  septic discharge prohibitions due to be triggered as of May 19, 2016. Under that mandate, phase 1 of a wastewater system must be completed or significantly on its way to completion by that date or the state will initiate enforcement action. The first phase of the project is to cover the downtown area of Yucca Valley, the area most proximate to the heart of the groundwater basin.  Similarly, phase 2 must be completed or nearly completed by May 19, 2019 and phase 3 must be completed by May 19, 2022. The last two phases lie further out where future concentrated development is most likely to occur.
With the May 19, 2016 deadline looming, the Hi-Desert Water District is pushing for the creation of a financing mechanism to pay for the water treatment system, consisting of a municipal sized treatment plant and over 400,000 linear feet of pipe.
Officials believe the system can be built for $125 million. One analysis is that each Yucca Valley  parcel’s share in the debt burden for the creation of the sewer system would be $16,700.
If the $125 million cost of the project could be defrayed over 30 years, households in Yucca Valley would be called upon to pay between $20 and $40 per month for sewer service, according to one calculation.

DA To Occupy SB “303” Courthouse Upon Closure

(October 10) What is known as the 303 Building, which has served as an adjunct to the county’s historic central downtown courthouse for much of the last decade, will be adapted to become the new headquarters for the district attorney’s office  when the new central county courthouse is completed.
The county board of supervisors, which had previously committed $1 million toward making that conversion, this week increased the conversion project budget by $5,300,000 to $6.3 million.
According to Carl Alban, the director of the county’s architecture and engineering division, “The 303 Building is currently occupied by the district attorney on the upper two floors, public defender on the ground level floor, and state courts for courtrooms and administrative space in the remaining five floors. Upon completion of the new State Justice Center located at the southeast corner of W. Third Street and Arrowhead Avenue, court operations will no longer be conducted in the 303 Building.”
Alban said his division is proposing “the demolition and remodel of the areas occupied by the state courts to provide needed office space to relocate DA personnel and operations from multiple locations throughout San Bernardino to a central location as established by the county buildings acquisition and retrofit project implementation plan. This project will also include parking improvements to increase the number of parking spaces from 177 spaces to approximately 300 spaces by the addition of a parking deck over the existing parking lot. Dedicated parking will help to minimize parking burdens created by increased vehicle loads generated by the State Justice Center and Superblock Master Plan, as well as maximize district attorney personnel parking within close proximity to offices and courts.”
According to Alban, “The revised project budget of $6,300,000 is comprised of the following components: project management and inspection costs of $360,000; construction costs of $5,400,000; and a construction contingency of $540,000. The funding source is discretionary general funding approved by the board of supervisors as part of the county buildings acquisition and retrofit project in the 2012-13 and 2013-14 capital improvement program budgets.”
The board of supervisors authorized Alban to release a design-build pre-qualification package, which Alban said will allow the project costs to be identified much earlier in the process; allow design and construction activities to be performed concurrently, reducing the amount of time required to complete the project, and allowing building occupancy at the earliest possible date; reduce the project cost as a result of the close working relationship between the designer and the construction contractor; the incorporation of efficient and economical construction methods into the design; and eliminate disputes and the need for dispute resolution between the design and construction contractor, resulting in the reduction of the likelihood of  litigation and contract modifications.
“The purpose of the pre-qualification package  for the selection of a design-build contractor for this project is to solicit preliminary information from interested design-build contractors,” Alban said. The information submitted will be evaluated by a committee that includes representatives from the county administrative office, district attorney’s office, and architecture and engineering. The evaluation process is intended to identify three design-build firms who, in the opinion of the county, are best qualified to execute successfully the design and construction of the project based on the criteria identified in the pre-qualification package.
Following selection of the three finalists, architecture & engineering staff will return to the board to seek approval to proceed on to the second step of the procurement process. The second step will provide significantly more detail regarding the project requirements and expectations, allowing the three design-build contractors to submit a best and final proposal. The selection of the successful design-build contractor, Alban said, will be based on “best value,” as determined by the evaluation committee.

County Extends 8 Water Pipeline Franchises

(October 10) The county board of supervisors has signed off on granting franchise extensions to eight separate entities operating water pipeline systems at various spots throughout the county.
In each case, the eight companies had previous consent to operate their respective systems to transport water in the county rights-of-way. In all of those cases, the franchise agreements were approved and entered into in 1998, and all are set to expire on November 20, 2013.
In September  the board of supervisors adopted resolutions declaring the board’s intent to grant  franchises to the Center Mutual Water Company, the Jubilee Mutual Water Company, the Terrace Mutual Water Company, the Bar-H Mutual Water company, the Sky Forest Mutual Water Company, the Crystal Lakes Property Owners Association, the Baseline Gardens Mutual Water Company and the Alpine Water Users Association to operate  pipeline systems to transport water in county of San Bernardino public rights-of-way for the period from December 19, 2013 through December 18, 2028.
Center operates a pipeline system for the distribution of water in the unincorporated area of Lucerne Valley. The pipeline system consists of approximately 4,374 feet in county road right-of-way and transports water to local residents in the Lucerne Valley area.
Jubilee operates a pipeline system for the distribution of water in the unincorporated area of Lucerne Valley. The pipeline system consists of approximately 246 feet in county road right-of-way and transports water to local residents in the Lucerne Valley area.
Terrace operates a pipeline system for the distribution of water in the unincorporated area of Colton. The pipeline system consists of approximately 28,286.74 feet in county road right-of-way and transports water to local residents in the Colton area.
Bar-H operates a pipeline system for the distribution of water in the unincorporated area of Lucerne Valley. The pipeline system consists of approximately 6,600 feet in county road right-of-way and transports water to local residents in the Lucerne Valley area.
Sky Forest Mutual Water Company operates a pipeline system for the distribution of water in the unincorporated community of Sky Forest. The pipeline system consists of approximately 11,245 feet (2.13 miles) in county road right-of-way and transports water to local residents in the Sky Forest area.
The Crystal Lakes Property Owners Association operates a pipeline system for the distribution of water in the unincorporated area of  Newberry Springs. The pipeline system consists of  approximately 500 feet in county road right-of-way and transports water to local residents in the Newberry Springs area.
Baseline Gardens Mutual Water Company operates a pipeline system for the distribution of water in the unincorporated area near the city of Highland. The pipeline system consists of approximately 11,880 feet (2.25 miles) in county road right-of-way and transports water to local residents in the San Bernardino/Highland area.
The Alpine Water Users Association operates a pipeline system for the distribution of water in the unincorporated area of Twin Peaks. The pipeline system consists of approximately 52,246 feet (9.9 miles) in county road right-of-way and transports water to local residents in the Twin Peaks area.
In accordance with County Code Section 14.0701, the county is authorized to grant franchises along and over public roads and rights-of-way for all lawful purposes, upon such terms, conditions and restrictions as deemed necessary and proper. In general, a franchise is an agreement between a municipality and a utility or cable provider that outlines requirements that must be met in order for the utility or cable provider to use the municipality’s public right-of-way.
There will be a roughly one month delay between the expiration of the current franchises and the official continuation of the new ones. The delay in presenting a recommendation to the board to approve a new franchise agreement resulted from internal county administrative delays. The entities will continue to operate their pipelines in the county road rights-of-way and have made all franchise payments in full and on time.
The franchise fees made to the county by the separate entities correspond to some degree but not absolutely in rough proportion to the linear feet of public right-of-way used for the pipelines in question.
Jubillee will pay franchise fees of approximately $12 annually.
Terrace Mutual will pay franchise fees of approximately $6,800 annually.
Bar H will pay franchise fees to the county of approximately $200 annually.
Sky Forest Mutual will pay franchise fees to the county of approximately $700 annually.
Crystal Lakes will pay franchise fees to the county of approximately $60 annually
Baseline Gardens Mutual will pay franchise fees to the county of approximately $7,000 annually

County Purchases New Bulletproof Vests For Probation Officers

(October 10) The county will buy 450 bulletproof vests for the probation department at a total cost of $150,522.
In making the purchase upon the recommendation of chief probation officer Michelle Scray Brown and deputy chief probation administrator Scott Frymire, the board of supervisors agreed to go with the high bidder for the provision of the vests, based upon Brown and Frymires’ conclusion that the company’s product offered advantages other vests do not.
According to Frymire, “The department determined that due to an increase in equipment that probation officers are now carrying on their person, an additional load bearing device was needed. After extensive consultation, it was decided that a load-bearing ballistic vest cover would be the most effective and practical way of addressing this need. The vest covers being recommended for purchase will allow a probation officer to retain immediate access to his/her equipment and thereby enhance personal safety.”
In May, the department solicited bids from Lawndale-based The Vest Man, Prescott, Arizona-based ProForce Law Enforcement and BPS Tactical, Inc., which is based in Mentone, asking them to provide samples of their load bearing vests for testing and the accompanying costs for 450 of the items.
The Vest Man was the low bidder at $112,039. ProForce Law Enforcement bid $123,730. BPS Tactical, Inc.’s bid came in at $150,522
“After a department review group conducted an extensive review and field testing of the offered products, BPS Tactical, Inc. was selected as the preferred vendor due to the superiority of their product, excellent warranty, individualized fit, and the customer service offered,” Frymire told the board of supervisors. “While BPS Tactical, Inc. is the most expensive of the three vendors, its cost is a reflection of the superior quality of the product. These vest covers are expected to last for a minimum of five years.”
BPS also offers the advantage of being located within San Bernardino County.

Orange County DA Raids Upland Office Of Lackie Dammeier McGill

(October 10) In an operation rife with far reaching implications, the Orange County District Attorney’s office, assisted by Orange County Sheriff’s Department detectives and officers, served a search warrant at the Upland law office of the now-dissolving law firm of Lackie, Dammeier, McGill & Ethir.
Investigators carted off scores of boxes full of documents and other materials after descending upon the Lackie, Dammeier, McGill & Ethir Building, located at 367 N 2nd Avenue in Upland.
Officers and district attorney’s office investigators and personnel were observed at the offices mid-morning on October 10. Despite the open display of law enforcement activity in San Bernardino County, the Orange County District Attorney’s Office was tight-lipped with regard to the operation.
“We are not confirming that activity took place or that we are involved in it,” said Susan Kang Schroeder, the chief of staff to Orange County District Attorney Tony Rackauckas.
Lackie, Dammeier, McGill & Ethir employed several attorneys who had formerly served as police officers and the firm specialized in representing police officers and their unions in labor related actions, contract negotiations, disciplinary actions, firings, reinstatements and criminal defense.
The firm had established a reputation for fierce representation of its clients, who often obtained favorable outcomes in their respective legal and procedural matters.
Last year, however, things began to unwind for the firm, culminating ultimately in a decision in August to disband it.
As tense contract negotiations were proceeding in 2012 between the city of Costa Mesa and the Costa Mesa Police Association, the Lackie Dammeier firm, which represented the union, advised members to step up pressure on the city’s elected leadership. Shortly thereafter, a private investigator under retainer by Lackie Dammeier, Christopher Lanzillo, began tailing members of the Costa Mesa City Council. On August 22, 2012, Lanzillo followed Costa Mesa Mayor Jim Righeimer to a bar, Skosh Monahan’s, owned by another city councilman, Gary Monahan. Lanzillo followed Righeimer after he left Skosh Monahan’s as the mayor drove home, and en route called 911 to report Righeimer was drunk and driving erratically. When police came to Righeimer’s home, they found that he appeared sober but subjected him to a field sobriety test, which he passed. Righeimer subsequently produced a time and date-stamped credit card receipt for two Diet Cokes he had consumed while at Skosh Monahan’s. Information then emerged that the police association had also been seeking, at Lackie Dammeier’s suggestion, to entrap Monahan and another council member, Steve Mensinger.
Soon thereafter, the Costa Mesa Police Association ended its relationship with Lackie Dammeier but not before other Orange County municipal officials, including city council members from Buena Park, Fullerton and Irvine, came forward to tell how the Upland-based firm and its clients engaged in efforts to harass them as they headed into elections and contract negotiations with their cities’ police unions, which were represented by Lackie Dammeier.
So brazen was the law firm in its pro-police union strategies that it posted on its website a political activity playbook that advised police unions on how to intimidate and twist the arms of politicians and lobby the public in a way that associates police pay raises with higher levels of public safety. In the brouhaha that ensued, Lackie Dammeier removed that posting.
While the firm represented hundreds of associations and officers from around California, its major client was the Peace Officers Research Association of California, a statewide legal defense fund for law enforcement officers. Over the last several years, Lackie Dammeier had won several notable cases for the organization, known by its acronym PORAC, and was considered the organization’s most potent legal tool.
But in August of this year, PORAC, which has 99,000 members culled from the ranks of law enforcement agencies up and down the state, informed its members that improprieties were found in Lackie Dammeier’s billing practices. The firm, PORAC said, had  charged 4,200 hours in one year for a single attorney, averaging 11.5 hours per day for every day of the year.
Shortly thereafter, PORAC dropped Lackie Dammeier as one of its legal representatives. Within two weeks of that development, the firm announced that it was dissolving, although its attorneys continued to work on the cases it was handling. Several of the firm’s lawyers signed on to work with other firms. In the meantime, the firm remained active, and continued to function out of the 367 N 2nd Avenue location.
While no official explanation of the purpose of the Orange County District Attorney’s Office’s raid was forthcoming, it is widely believed the search was an outgrowth of the firm’s activity on behalf of the Costa Mesa Police Association and other police unions. The district attorney’s office has previously obtained search warrants and subpoenas to further its investigation into the tactics used against Costa Mesa politicians.
The raid of the Lackie Dammeier office by a law enforcement agency is of special sensitivity, given that attorney-client privilege extends to all range of legal documents and communications between lawyers and those who hire them and that many of the cases handled by the firm pertain to criminal charges, potential criminal charges or disputes between the firm’s clients and law enforcement agencies and their managements.
When she was reached by the Sentinel while investigators were still at the law office, law firm partner Sakunthala  Ethirveerasingam, who goes by the professional name of Saku Ethir, said, “We just don’t have any comment right now.”

GLIMPSE OF SBC’S PAST: Old Railroad Gems: Restoration And Reuse (Part I)

(October 10) By Ruth Musser-Lopez
Our county is graced from east to west with old precious railroad gems in the form of magnificent historic structures financed by railroad corporations to serve as depots and service stops as well as destination points along its rail lines.  Here in San Bernardino County we know how to take to the extreme the Mediterranean romantic architectural splendor with parapets, arches, colonnades and red roof tiles, maximizing that exotic flair that one would expect on the Spanish Riviera or in a Moroccan oasis.   In Spain, castles exemplify the grandeur of romantic architectural style; in San Bernardino County it’s our railroad stations and depots that serve as the bulwark of our vintage romantic structural design knowhow.
In Spain, Moorish influence is found at its southern boundaries at the enchanting Alhambra Palace of Granada.  Here, our county seat holds the claim to one of the crown jewels of precious railroad gems near its western entry. This enchanting gateway, the 1918 San Bernardino County Station was designed in the Mission Revival Style with Moorish Revival and Spanish Colonial Revival features which add to its magnificence and complexity. The structure served as the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe (ATSF) Railroad depot with additions of living quarters and a Harvey House added a few years later, replacing the 1886 two-and-a-half-story wooden structure that burnt down in a 1916 fire. Construction was made at the behest of San Bernardino local politicians to replace what preceded it on a much larger scale…and it came at greater expense.  Previous to 1886, a converted boxcar served as the depot so obviously, big strides had been made to return some railroad capital into San Bernardino County since the California Southern Railroad’s cross-continent route was bridged to the Pacific in 1884.
The new station designed by architect W. A. Mohr was built at a cost of $800,000, which adjusts to $12 million or so today, although it is doubtful such a triumphant edifice could be built for that sum now.   It was at the time the largest railway station west of the Mississippi River.   Including hollow clay blocks within its walls, a red tile roof and stucco exterior, the new depot was fashioned to withstand fire.  High beams, coffered ceilings and decorative column capitals all were handcrafted and a 330-foot arcade extended between the depot and the tracks. (http://www.sanbag.ca.gov/about/santa-fe_depot.html)
Unfortunately however, as is the case of any structure not properly maintained, the 1918 architectural centerpiece began to fall into decline.  Through a $15.1 million acquisition and rehabilitation effort shared by the San Bernardino Associated Governments (SANBAG) and the City of San Bernardino, the Santa Fe Depot was acquired by SANBAG in 1992, restoration began in 2004 and today the fine “county gate” has been restored to its former beauty.  Since June of 2004, SANBAG has been occupying and reusing offices upstairs in the depot located at 1170 W. 3rd Street, between Mt. Vernon Avenue and I Avenue, west of Interstate 215.
In 1908, ten years earlier than the new Harvey House in San Bernardino was built, a “Crown Jewel” had been constructed on the east gate of San Bernardino County; in Needles the “El Garces” named after the Spanish padre/explorer, had put the old wood structure depot in the county seat to shame.  Originally used as the Santa Fe Depot and Harvey House restaurant and hotel in historic downtown Needles, it was built by the Fred Harvey Company on contract with the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe Railroad.  The hotel was designed by architect Francis W. Wilson in an elegant Neoclassical and Beaux-Arts style and was considered to be the supreme “Crown Jewel” of the entire Fred Harvey chain.   After construction of Route 66 was completed in the 1920s, passenger traffic on the Santa Fe drastically declined and even though the traffic on Route 66 passed by the station, the restaurant and hotel were closed permanently by 1949.
Afterward, the original imported Italian tiles and chandeliers, along with other precious appurtenances, furnishings and fixtures “disappeared” over the years.  The structure fell into disrepair; rooms were trashed by squatters or given over to bats, rats and pigeons.  In 1988 Amtrak stopped using the station and the Santa Fe made plans to demolish it. The city of Needles, however, stepped in to purchase the property and building in the 1990s.  When restoration was considered, the only financially feasible alternative seemed to be initial gutting and cleanup.  As of 2002, it has been listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Some restoration and reconstruction of the historic El Garces began in 2007, by the owners of another historic hotel, the La Posada, in Arizona.
Work seems to be intermittent as funding is available, though it is starting to “come around” in appearance with new paint and the prospects look promising for new glass window treatments soon.  An injection of new funds, perhaps a little more help from SANBAG, wouldn’t hurt.

County Wildlife Corner: Coyotes

(October 10) The Coyote (Canis latrans) is found throughout most of California, ranging from the low desert and valley areas to the highest mountain elevations. It proliferates in the foothills of San Bernardino County and often ventures into civilization, usually at night, seeking prey. The most common coyotes in San Bernardino County are  the C. l. clepticus, known as the San Pedro Martir coyote and the C. l. ochropus, known as the  California Valley coyote.
Referred to as the “little wolf,” coyotes resemble a medium sized shepherd type dog in many respects but feature large erect ears, a narrow muzzle and yellow eyes. The tail is round and bushy and is carried straight out below the back. Coyotes typically grow to 30–34 inches in length, not counting a tail of 12–16 inches, stand about 23–26 inches at the shoulder and weigh from 15–46 pounds.
Coyote coloration varies from grayish, tawny brown with a black tip on the tail in the low desert and valley areas to gray with white under parts in the highest elevations. Coyotes are intelligent and facile creatures with exceptional senses of smell, vision and hearing.
Coyotes are active at dusk, night and predawn and have a distinctive vocalization, which consists of various howls, high quivering cries and frenzied high pitched yapping. There are two howling seasons, January/February when breeding season starts and September/October when females are calling to their pups. Pups are ready to hunt on their own in the fall of the year of their birth and will relocate 5 to 10 miles from their parents’ range. The mortality rate for juvenile coyotes is 50% to 70% . Adults typically live 3-5 years. It is estimated 30% to 50% of the adult population dies each year. Coyotes compensate by breeding younger and having larger litters.
A coyote’s range varies  to 30 square miles. They become highly territorial and range far less as the local coyote population increases and there is fierce competition among them for food, water and shelter.
The absence of prey can factor into a smaller litter size. Fewer females will breed when there is a scarcity of food. Coyotes are opportunistic carnivores, feasting on whatever is available, including meat, fish, poultry, rodents, reptiles, insects, vegetables or fruit. They will kill to assuage their appetites but will feed on carrion, or domesticated pets when available. They will dig through trash and gorge on pet food.
A coyote’s sense of smell, vision and hearing allows it to live in rural areas and at the periphery of suburban area without being detected by humans.
Coyote can carry rabies and tularemia, diseases that can be transmitted to man and domestic pets. Specific canine diseases such as distemper and canine hepatitis can travel both ways, putting both coyotes and domestic pets at risk. Parasites that are carried by coyotes include mites, ticks, fleas, worms and flukes. Heartworm is the most important endoparasite in California’s coyote population and can be transmitted to domestic dogs by mosquitoes.
As Coyotes find urban areas a convenient place to find nourishment, they have lost their fear of humans and have become bolder. Efforts to control or exterminate the coyote by predator control agencies have produced an animal that is extremely alert and wary and well able to maintain itself.

An Orange Harvest

(October 10) Orange and October are the perfect combination for the harvest season. The harvest is the prelude to the holiday season. The color orange is making a wave this month and with a punch. I am fascinated by the people wearing bright orange in the middle of fall. It’s a very interesting color that is going to stick around until about the end of the month. Color is a great way to create art, so make sure you take orange to the limits this October. California is very special and different because we really do dress for the weather and we always want things to look different every season. With that said, orange is here and it’s perfect for October. Fashion has reversed gears and the day of realism is here in the most imaginative and colorful way possible. It’s great to dress the body with many interesting things and the beginning of fall is a great time to recreate your style. It’s all about contagious enthusiasms when it comes to dressing in October. Have fun and be creative.

“The tones of gray, pale turquoise, and pink, will prevail.”    -Christian Dior

3 Deaths, $4.25 M Settlement Heighten Concern Over Sheriff’s Deputy

A SB County sheriff’s deputy who in the past two-and-a-half years  has  been involved in the deaths of three suspects finds his action under increasing scrutiny as the family of one of those who died at his hands has received a $4.25 million settlement and the families of the two others are  pressing forward with civil suits against him, the sheriff’s department and the county.
San Bernardino County sheriff’s deputy Ismail Diaz was directly or indirectly involved in the officer-involved deaths of Allen Kephart in May 2011, Kenneth Munoz, Jr. in October 2011 and Merlin Factor in June 2013.
The 350-pound Kephart expired after suffering a heart attack when three officers, including Diaz, administered 16 taser gun jolts to him for his failure to comply with Diaz’s commands following a traffic stop. Diaz administered eight of those electrical shocks.
Munoz was shot twelve times by a sheriff’s sergeant and Diaz after deputies were summoned by Diaz’s father during a dispute over a pickup truck and the younger Munoz grappled with another officer after he was ordered to the ground. Diaz shot Munoz ten times.
Factor, who was allegedly combative and armed, was shot by two sheriff’s deputies after  a call reporting an act of vandalism at a mobile home park led to a confrontation with the deceased. The sheriff’s department has not confirmed that Diaz was one of the deputies involved in the Factor shooting.
The district attorney’s office has completed reviews of the deaths of Kephart and Munoz. A determination with regard to criminal issues in the Factor shooting has yet to be made but it is anticipated it will exonerate the involved deputies.
The district attorney’s office, while acknowledging that the ordeal Kephart was subjected to during the attempt to arrest him resulted in physical stress that was “a significant factor” in his death, concluded “there is insufficient evidence to establish criminal liability on the part of these deputies.”
Diaz maintained that on the afternoon of May 10, 2011, he had attempted pull Kephart over after Kephart failed to make a full stop at an intersection in the San Bernardino Mountains. Kephart, according to Diaz, drove nine-tenths of a mile before pulling over, at which time a confrontation ensued in which Kephart only partially complied with Diaz’s commands that Kephart get down on his knees and then lay prone on the ground. The district attorney’s office said the tactics used by Diaz and two other deputies and a sergeant that arrived on the scene to back up Diaz, “were not unreasonable.”
Kephart’s mother and father, Alfred and Carol Kephart, filed suit, naming the county of San Bernardino, the San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department, and the three sheriff’s officers who used their tasers on Kephart, deputy Diaz, deputy Michael Gardea and sergeant Bryan Lane.
The Kepharts were represented by attorneys Marc Goldstein, Brian Pannish and Thomas Schultz.
The lawsuit offered a different version of events than was put forth by the sheriff’s department and accepted by the district attorney’s office.
An examination of the roadway Diaz and Kephart traveled  while Diaz was using his lights and siren in an effort to pull Kephart over demonstrated there were no safe spots at which to pull over, given the relative narrowness of the highway. Kephart appeared to have stopped at what was the first safe place. Utilizing an audio recording made by Diaz as well as the communications between Diaz and the sheriff’s department’s dispatcher, the legal team countered Diaz’s claim that the encounter ensued after Kephart ran a stop sign. Rather they maintained the encounter began when Kephart honked at Diaz after Diaz pulled in front of Kephart at the intersection. A witness, Magda Haran, testified Kephart had indeed stopped at the stop sign.  The legal team used eyewitness accounts and data retrieved from the Taser devices to show that Kephart was ordered out of his car at gunpoint, shoved face first to the ground and Tasered repeatedly in the upper back, neck and head. In pressing to make the case that Kephart’s civil rights were violated and that he had been subjected to excessive force, the plaintiffs encountered resistance from the county, which deemed  information in  Diaz’s personnel file confidential and at one point obtained a stay of legal proceedings. But after the stay was set aside, Diaz’s videotaped deposition was taken, in which he repeatedly demonstrated an inability to recall specific details relating to the incident as well as other times he had used potentially deadly force in the field, including the shooting of Munoz and at least five other times he had used a Taser.
More than two months ago and less than a month after the Factor shooting, the county on  July 26 quietly moved to close out the litigation, conferring a $4.25 million settlement on Mr. and Mrs. Kephart.
In January 2013, the district attorney’s office entered a determination that Diaz and sergeant Michael O’Brien were legally justified in fatally shooting Kenneth Munoz Jr. on October 26, 2011. Sheriff’s deputies  had been summoned to the 35200 block of Avenue B in Yucaipa by Kenneth Paul Munoz Sr., who reported that his son was refusing to return to him his truck, which they used in common as a work vehicle in their family run business. After deputies arrived and attempted to persuade the younger Munoz to comply with his father’s request, he refused and ran away. The officers gave chase, utilizing a Taser, and a bean-bag shotgun before deputy Joseph Perea commanded him to lie face down on the ground in a neighbor’s yard. After Perea knelt upon Munoz’s back in an effort to handcuff him, Munoz became resistant and combative. In the ensuing struggle between Perea and Munoz, Perea’s gun, a 45-caliber Glock 21 pistol, fell out of its holster. The scuffle between Perea and Munoz continued and when Perea separted from Munoz, O’Brien opened fire, striking Munoz twice. Diaz then shot Munoz ten times as he lay on the ground. Munoz died at the scene.
In ruling the shooting  justified, the district attorney’s office noted that Munoz had numerous intoxicants in his system, including  methamphetamine, opiates and hydrocodone.
Paul Munoz, Jr’s estate, including his father and mother and two of his minor children, have filed a lawsuit against the county, the sheriff’s department, Diaz and O’Brien in U.S. Federal Court. They are represented by attorneys Antonio Rodriguez and Jorge Gonzalez.
In court papers, Rodriguez and Gonzales maintain “the actions of the deputies from start to finish were overly aggressive and drove the situation until lethal force was used. Their actions were independent and reckless uses of force, and have a direct causal relationship to the end result. The officers did not have probable cause to arrest Kenny.”
Rodriguez and Gonzales maintain that Munoz was in the midst of an emotional and psychological breakdown, but did not constitute a physical threat to his father, himself or the responding deputies. “The use of force and attempt to subdue Kenny when he was clearly experiencing a mental breakdown was very provocative, and exactly the opposite of what a well-trained officer would do in such a circumstance,” accoring to Rodriguez and Gonzalez.  They say Diaz arrived at the location at a latter stage of the confrontation with Munoz  and “acted without any knowledge of the prior events, or of Kenny’s mental disturbance… and displayed a severely aggressive attitude to apprehend Kenny regardless of the costs. Further, Diaz was the last of the deputies to fire his handgun, shooting 10 rounds at Kenny, five times that of Sergeant O’Brien.” Diaz, according to Rodriguez and Gonzales, “acted in a panic, and fired an excessive number of rounds for the situation. His conduct in this regard was clearly incompetent.”
Rodriguez and Gonzalez have taken depositions of several of the deputies involved, including Diaz; have made analyses of other materials relating to the case, including the audio recordings from the recorders carried by the officers; and obtained witness statements from civilians who watched the chase and shooting, including Robin Dyrland, in whose yard the shooting occurred.
“The shooting was not in response to an imminent threat of deadly force or great bodily injury, and the deputies later conspired to use this as the justification for the shooting, thus manufacturing the sequence of events,” according to Rodriguez and Gonzalez. “Furthermore the version of the deputies that a wrestling match between Perea and Munoz was underway, described by Perea as a ‘life and death struggle,’ was directly contradicted by Robin Dyrland, who was standing at her back door watching the events unfold, and did not see the deputies wrestling with anyone just before the shooting. She recalls the deputies were all standing erect and stepped back just before they started shooting.  Both the sound recording and the two percipient witness directly contradict the entire version of events as stated by the deputies “
The Munoz case will likely go to trial in 2014.
The case involving the shooting of Merlin Factor is somewhat nebulous, as is Diaz’s role in it.  The district attorney’s office has yet to make a finding with regard to whether the shooting death was a justifiable homicide, although such a finding is anticipated. And while several reliable sources have given indication that Diaz was one of the deputies involved in the shooting, there has been no confirmation of that at an official level.
Los Angeles-based attorney Dale Galipo is representing Factor’s sister, Cassandra Hudson, in a wrongful death complaint against the county, the sheriff’s department and the involved deputies. Galipo told the Sentinel that “We believe Ismail Diaz was one of the two deputies involved in the death of Merlin Factor based upon several statements we have and other information but I do not have confirmation. It has been pretty difficult to get information on this shooting. That may be because of this deputy’s involvement in these other deaths but I cannot say that definitively.”
The initial report of the Saturday, June 29, 2013 shooting, based upon the information provided in a sheriff’s department press release, maintained that deputies opened fire on the 26-year-old Factor after a series of events beginning with a call reporting vandalism to a mobile home in the 12900 block of Second Street in Yucaipa. Factor was identified as having vandalized the mobile home and that he had left the scene with the woman who lived there, possibly against her will. Shortly thereafter, the allegedly abducted woman placed a 911 call and deputies went to the location from which the call had been placed, near Yucaipa Boulevard and Third Street. At that point, deputies were advised  Factor was wanted on a felony warrant.
Deputies located Factor and the woman in a vehicle and pulled him over in the parking lot of the First Baptist church. “Factor got out of the vehicle and began fighting with the deputies,” according to the sheriff’s department statement. “Factor attempted to retrieve a weapon during the struggle, forcing a deputy to shoot him.”
The arrest warrants issued for Factor pertained to his failure to appear in court 23 days earlier on misdemeanor theft and providing a false name to a police officer.
The department seems to have backed off from the assertion that Factor had a gun, but has not clarified its position.
“Our information is that he had no gun when he was shot,” Gallipo told the Sentinel. “We do not know if there was a gun. If there was, where was it? Was it under the seat of the car? He did not have a weapon of any kind when he was shot. We have talked to several witnesses and no one saw a gun or said anything about him having a gun.”
Factor did have a criminal record. He  pleaded guilty to burglary in 2012 and was on probation at the time of his death.
Gallipo said that he and his legal staff have only undertaken a preliminary examination of the circumstances and facts, having been hampered by the sheriff’s department’s reluctance to release information on the shooting. He said it appeared the sheriff’s deputies acted out of anger and annoyance in their fatal confrontation with Factor. “He was known to the sheriff’s department,” Gallipo said. “They had been looking to arrest him on the outstanding warrants before this. They were looking forward to arresting him and he had run away from them before and had gotten away. They were frustrated. They caught him and then just lost it and overreacted.”
Gallipo said he did not expect the district attorney’s office to determine the shooting was an unlawful one. “In almost every case, the district attorney’s office finds officer involved shootings to be within policy and legally justifiable. But when you take these matters to trial and lay out all the facts, juries in many of these cases find the officers’ actions to have been excessive and unreasonable. In officer involved shooting cases, juries tend to disagree with the district attorney.”
While county officials and sheriff’s brass are publicly maintaining a stiff upper lip with regard to Diaz and his continuing tenure with the department, internally there is concern that he may represent a liability to both the department and the county governmental structure. Reportedly, Diaz  is a  foremost concern within the county’s risk management department with respect to current employees. Having been stung for $4.25 million on the Kephart case and with the Munoz and Factor  matters wending their ways through the court system, pressure is mounting to ease Diaz out of the department or transfer him into a role in which he will be unlikely to encounter a use of force situation. When queried about Diaz, county risk management director Hueston Whiteside said, “That is something you should discuss with the sheriff’s department because a reassignment is not something my department is likely to have a hand in.”
The sheriff’s department’s public affairs division, citing the lateness of the Sentinel’s inquiry about Diaz this week, was unable to offer input.
Deputy district attorney William Lee, who reviewed the Kephart matter for his office, maintained that during his encounter with Diaz, “Kephart was defiant and resistant. The force used by the deputies was limited to overcoming that resistance. Diaz is obligated to enforce the laws of the state. It was Kephart’s obligation to submit to legal authority, to follow all reasonable commands and to cease any active resistance. Kephart failed to meet these obligations.”
Chief deputy district attorney Karen Bell, who reviewed the Munoz matter for her office, concluded “The officers had cause to pursue Kenneth Jr. when he failed to cooperate and would not respond to questions.  They had a duty to investigate a possible auto theft but his conduct was out of the ordinary and he might have posed a danger to himelf or others. Despite repeated efforts to convince him to stop running he did not. When Kenneth Jr. finally stopped… the officers approached with great care, based on his earlier conduct to insure (sic) their safety, the public’s and his. Unfortunately, at that moment the circumstances changed radically In such circumstances officers are entitled to use deadly force in protection of themselves or others., Kenneth Jr left them little alternative but to use their last tool – deadly force.”