Accounting Miscues In 29 Palms Cemetery District Invite DA & GJ Scrutiny

TWENTYNINE PALMS — The San Bernardino County Local Agency Formation Commission’s routine review of operations in the Twentynine Palms Public Cemetery District discovered some accounting irregularities that have now been brought to the attention of the   district attorney’s public integrity unit and the grand jury.
The Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO), which oversees jurisdictional issues throughout the county, conducts community service reviews every five years. On May 7, 2012, LAFCO executive officer Kathleen Rollings-McDonald, assistant executive officer Samuel Martinez and project manager Michael Tuerpe delivered a report relating to the various agencies serving Twentynine Palms and the surrounding area. In carrying out that portion of the review pertaining to the cemetery district, Rollings-McDonald, Martinez and Tuerpe were unable to find any district records updated since the 2008/09 fiscal year. Their report states that the district did not complete audits in a statutory time frame and prepared its budgets without auditing or verifying the numbers utilized.
According to LAFCO, the most recent budget information provided to state and county controllers had not been adopted by the district board at a noticed public hearing. These shortcomings qualify as “a prime indicator of governance challenges,” according to Rollings-McDonald, Martinez and Tuerpe.
While district staff and the board are now racing to redress those shortcomings, LAFCO has referred the matter to the district attorney’s office and the grand jury.
At the district’s regularly scheduled board meeting on May 17, cemetery board secretary Casey Dobler provided board members with an agenda packet containing correspondence from LAFCO dated May 9 belatedly informing the board that the LAFCO board on May 16 was to hold a hearing at which the May 7 report would be reviewed.
The board on May 17 resolved to facilitate the review and audits of the district’s books that would bring it into compliance with standards applicable to governmental special districts by early next month.

County Sets Aside $1.7 Million For Disabled Access At Courthouses

The county board of supervisors this week earmarked $1.7 million to cover the cost of 19 separate improvement projects at 11 of the county’s courthouses which will improve access to those facilities for the handicapped.
The money was set aside as part of county chief executive officer Greg Devereaux’s requests contained in the third quarter budget review presented to the board at its meeting this week. The funding for the projects is to be provided by federal Community Development Block Grants received by the county. The projects are part of a settlement reached by the county in a lawsuit filed by Ruthee Goldkorn, John Lonberg, Kimberly Wilder, Michael Flippin and Alfred Chichester against the county of San Bernardino, San Bernardino Superior Court and Superior Court executive officer Stephen Nash that claimed the county’s courthouses are inaccessible to the disabled.
That suit was being heard in the courtroom of U.S. District Judge Virginia Phillips in Riverside when the case was mediated to a close by U.S. District Court Judge George H. King. That settlement called for the county to pay $80,000 in damages to the plaintiffs in the case or their estates, the payment of another $690,000 in attorneys’ fees and costs, the provision of $61,000 to oversee the efforts to render the courthouses accessible, together with an agreement to make all 13 of the county’s courthouses accessible to the disabled.
Devereaux’s plan calls for a  $93,000 project and another $40,000 project at the Barstow Courthouse to bring it into compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act; a $72,000 project and another $180,000 project at the Big Bear Courthouse to bring it into compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act; a $140,000 project and another $30,000 project at the Central Courthouse in San Bernardino to bring it into compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act; a $95,000 project at the Central Courthouse Annex to bring it into compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act; a $60,000 project at the San Bernardino Civil Courthouse to bring it into compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act; a $35,000 project at the Central Juvenile Dependency Courthouse  to bring it into compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act; a $73,000 project and a $40,000 project at the Chino Courthouse to bring it into compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act; a $35,000 project at the Fontana Courthouse to bring it into compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act;  a $132,000 project and a $50,000 project at the Joshua Tree Courthouse  to bring it into compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act; a $46,000 project and a $40,000 project at the Needles Courthouse to bring it into compliance with the Americans with Disability Act; a $215,000 project at the West Valley Courthouse in Rancho Cucamonga to bring it into compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act; together with a $104,000 contract and a $220,000 contract at the Victorville Courthouse to bring it into compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act.

Chino, Chino Hills Both Looking To Use Reserves To Balance 2012-13 Budgets

It appears that both of the cities in San Bernardino County’s extreme southeast corner will utilize their reserves to balance their 2012-13 budgets.
In Chino, a marginal increase in sales tax and property tax revenues will not be sufficient to ensure that income in the upcoming fiscal year will match expenditures. Accordingly, city officials anticipate utilizing  $2.9 million of $22.8 million in available reserves to balance its 2012-13 budget without curtailing critical services.
In Chino Hills, city manager Mike Fleager will recommend to the city council a more modest $442,000 disbursement from that municipality’s reserves to cover the cost of city operations next year.
As in the case of its neighbor, Chino Hills intends to spend more money next year than it anticipates bringing in to ensure that  the city’s law enforcement, community development and construction regulation, code enforcement, park and recreation functions are adequately funded.  It has roughly $15.5 million in available reserves and will tap into that money to make up the difference.
The governmental fiscal year runs from July 1 to June 30. It is anticipated that both Chino and Chino Hills will finalize their 2012-13 budgets by the middle of next month.

Adelanto School Board Shuts Door On Dickinson’s Charter Start-Up Request

The Adelanto School District Board of Trustees has rejected a proposal  by Michael Dickinson and several of his associates to create a new charter school.
Dickinson, the founder of the San Bernardino Public Safety Academy who was ignominiously terminated as that entity’s president and executive director last year after revelations that he was exploiting the charter school for personal financial gain, applied in April with the Adelanto School District to have the  True North Charter Academy established on a campus in Apple Valley. Dickinson confidently predicted he could have 400 students enrolled at the school, to be devoted to vocational training and college prep, upon opening.  With the district’s blessing, Dickinson intended on applying for $2.35 million in funding from the state for the first year of operation, to commence in late August.
After examining the application and its particulars, however, Adelanto schools superintendent Darrin Brawley recommended against granting True North the charter. At its May 15 meeting, the school board followed suit, voting against chartering the school, which would have functioned out of a campus in Apple Valley with students ranging from kindergarten to 12th grade, offering what Dickinson promised would be flexible hours of instruction coordinated with local businesses for workplace training and Victor Valley Community College for accelerated learning.
Board members were skeptical of the financial figures put forth by the charter school’s applicants.
The San Bernardino Public Safety Academy, which was founded in 1999 by Dickinson as an unaccredited seminar for teenagers pertaining to certain aspects of fire science, was eventually granted charter status by the San Bernardino City Unified School District, specializing in training students for careers in firefighting and law enforcement. It found a niche with interested students and their parents, but from the start Dickinson failed to maintain strict accounting standards for the operation. In 2011, the school fell into controversy and scandal when it was learned that Dickinson was making $121,000 per year as the administrator of a for-profit company the non-profit charter school was contracting with and that Dickinson’s wife, who was serving as an instructor/principal at once of the academy’s schools, had provided some of her students with questions on state standardized tests in advance. When the school’s board moved to fire Dickinson’s wife, Dickinson terminated the board, resulting in a struggle in which Dickinson ultimately was himself terminated as the charter school’s top administrator.

Eaton Hired As Barstow College Academic VP

BARSTOW–Stephen Eaton, formerly the dean of instruction at Bakersfield College, has been brought in to serve as the vice president of academic affairs at Barstow Community College. Eaton replaces Bill Orr, who held the vice president post on an interim basis since November 2010, following the resignation of Antoinette Wheeler.
The reason behind Wheeler’s September 2010 suspension and her subsequent resignation has not been publicly disclosed.
At Bakersfield College Eaton oversaw six academic disciplines and co-chaired the program review committee.

Deal For Colorado River Medical Center Transfer Falls Through

NEEDLES—The arrangement to have Needles Hospital, Inc. purchase and operate the Colorado River Medical Center has fallen through and the city is now seeking to sell the facility to a non-profit division of AM Pharmacy, Inc., a for-profit enterprise.
The non-profit Needles Hospital, Inc. lost its opportunity after it failed to meet an April 26 deadline to prove it had the funding to make the purchase.
The city council in January voted to sell the Colorado River Medical Center and the 5.71 acres it sits upon to Needles Hospital, Inc. for $3,587,002. For that amount, Needles Hospital Inc. was to take possession of most assets and liabilities of the hospital, including accounts receivable, operating inventory in place, outstanding bills and unemployment obligations. Unassumed debts were to  be deducted from the purchase price, but the city was to keep any cash in the hospital’s coffers at the time of sale.
On January 27, the city represented by Mayor Ed Paget, and the board of hospital trustees represented by chairman Jeff Williams, and Needles Hospital, Inc. represented by Rebecca Valentine, signed a purchase agreement, opening escrow. Needles Hospital, Inc. was given until April 26 to show proof of funding for the purchase of the hospital and until May 25 to close escrow.
“The principal of Needles HospitaI, Inc.did not produce proof of financing by the stipulated deadline,” Needles city manager  David Brownlee told the Sentinel.
Needles Hospital, Inc., headed by Valentine, a former Needles councilwoman, has been seeking to arrange an $8.46 million  loan through the U.S. Department of Agriculture that would allow the non-profit to purchase the hospital and make necessary repairs, including reroofing the building, and upgrades, including putting in new boilers and wiring, to keep it operational.
On April 23, Valentine learned that the Department of Agriculture had not finalized approval of the loan and would not be able to provide  documentation of  the financing by the deadline.
Needles Hospital, Inc. sought to have the deadline for proving it had the financing extended until May 25 and the closing of escrow. In a specially-called meeting on April 27, the hospital board refused to grant that extension, effectively ending Needles Hospital, Inc.’s chance of acquiring the institution. Hospital board chairman Jeff Williams, who formerly served as Needles mayor when Valentine was on the city council, was the lone vote in support of granting the extension.
The city immediately moved to find another buyer for the hospital.
“The hospital board will now enter into negotiations with Mr. Bing Lum, principal of AM Pharmacy,” Brownlee said.
Along with other entities, Needles Hospital, Inc. and AM Pharmacy last year submitted competing proposals for the takeover of Colorado River Medical Center. After the other proposals were rejected, the hospital board on January 5 considered both Needles Hospital, Inc.’s and AM Pharmacy’s offers. The board seriously entertained AM’s overture, by which it proposed to buy the hospital and 5.71 acres of surrounding property without the accounts receivable for $3 million, with any debts deducted from the sale price. AM, which is a for-profit entity, had agreed to create a non-profit arm with which to operate Colorado River Medical Center, and have one of its employees, Bing Lum, who was raised in Needles, oversee the hospital operation. The board, however, rejected AM’s offer by a vote of 2-4 before ultimately accepting Needles Hospital, Inc.’s offer on a 3-2 vote. On January 10, the city council followed the hospital board’s recommendation, and voted to approve the sale to Needles Hospital, Inc.
The city took on ownership of the Colorado River Medical Center in April 2008 after Brentwood, Tennessee-based Lifepoint Hospitals, a for-profit corporation, embarked on an effort to move the institution’s equipment and personnel to another hospital it owned in Arizona, roughly 12 miles from Needles.
Because of long-running inadequate billing practices, including failures to invoice Medicare and Medi-Cal as well as insurance companies and patients in a timely fashion, the hospital has lost money, representing a financial liability to the city. The city created the board of trustees to oversee the hospital, and that panel, together with the city council, has come to a consensus that spinning the facility off to an independent operator is the best solution for ensuring that the community has adequate medical care without soaking the taxpayers.
In June 2010, Needles voters passed Measure Q, which called for keeping the hospital open and absolving the city of the financial burden of subsidizing the facility by having a non-profit entity selected to run the hospital.

Jermaine Wright Running Against Old Guard

Jermaine Wright said that as a candidate for First District supervisor, he represents the true antithesis to the entrenched political establishment that has held the county and the High Desert in its grip for too long.
The proof of that, Wright pointed out, is that he is the lone candidate in the field of 8 running for supervisor who tossed his hat in the ring before incumbent supervisor Brad Mitzelfelt withdrew from the race to run for Congress upon Representative Jerry Lewis’ retirement announcement in January.
“We need a change,” Wright said. “I’m tired of the corruption. I’m tired of people not caring about the community and just trying to prop themselves up. Politicians should serve the people. We have not been getting the service we deserve. I am not tied to any of the past problems the county has had. Five of my seven opponents are tied to, worked for, or are friends with or have taken money from the corruption of the past. As supervisors we had Bill Postmus and then Brad. Bob Smith worked for both Bill Postmus and Brad. Michael Orme worked for both. Russ Blewett was Brad’s mentor. He says he worked for Proposition 13 more than 30 years ago but now he doesn’t show up at the Hesperia City Council meetings when he knows they are going to be voting on increasing taxes. Bret Henry is a county employee union president who says he is going to fight to make things better for his one special interest group. Everyone thought I would jump out when they jumped in but I’m still going to fight for what I believe in.”
Wright has been a member of the Adelanto School District Board of Trustees for a little over a year. As such, he is an established politician, but insists he is not an establishment politician. “When I ran I said I will serve as a politician for eight years, two terms, and that’s it, school board or supervisor or whatever. I believe we need term limits because politicians need to be changed like babies’ diapers and for the same reason. I will push for term limits to stop people from turning this into a career and being beholden to one group that is taking care of them.”
And if a ballot measure to reduce county supervisors to part time status succeeds, Wright said, that is fine with him. “Whether the voters say part time, full time, or three-quarter time, I’ll be somebody out there fighting for them as their true voice,” he said.
In sizing up what he considered to be the major issues facing the First District, Wright said “We have so many people unemployed because we are not receiving the services or the infrastructure we were promised. The First District at 15,000 square miles has all this undeveloped land, yet we have the least amount of representation. They gave us another supervisor in the area, with the Third District extended into Barstow, but that is absolutely no help for the people here in the Victor Valley. There is no effort to bring jobs in and move people forward in this area. They say they want to move business in but they forget about businesses that are already here. Nothing is being done for them. We have not backfilled over 200 positions in law enforcement, which makes this area very unsafe.”
Additionally, Wright said, “Hesperia has not gotten the return on property tax revenue it deserves for over twenty years. The entire district has been underserved and underrepresented for years.”
His solution, Wright said, would consist of “First, going in to try to streamline things. A lot of county departments are overstaffed. The money can be pulled out of those departments and put where it needs to be. I would improve things by backfilling departments that need the money instead of overfunding departments that don’t need it.”
The county is on the ropes, Wright said, because “There is no real management skill and no financial plan.”
Looking beyond the narrow needs of the First District to the major problem plaguing the entire county, Wright said, “I think the biggest issue is to end the corruption that has been going on. The board needs to have finance reform as well as setting term limits to make sure this does not become a career for anyone. These elected politicians are going to draw pensions. That is why they are in office, to get money, to make sure the government takes care of them for the rest of their lives. We need to end that.”
Wright said he is best suited of all of the candidates to serve as supervisor because “I’m a small businessman and I will bring the business mentality of how to run a business to the county. I am running this campaign 100 percent on my own money. I will be beholden to the people who vote and not the unions or the self-serving entities trying to take over the board of supervisors. I’m not about getting my name in the papers. I will work by showing up to get a job done for the people of this county. I will not rely on my staff to answer the phone. I will speak to the public I serve. I will never consider myself too busy to answer the phone and get my constituents what they need.”
Wright, 36, was born and raised in Monrovia, graduating from Monrovia High School. He attended Liberty University and Baker College. He owns and operates his own business, a transportation company. He is married with four children.

LAWA Officials Say Ontario’s Pessimism Is Harming Airport

Ontario International Airport is on the brink of failure because it lacks brand identity and because of the downturns in the national, state and local economies, according to an airline industry consultant to the division of the city of Los Angeles which operates its airports.
The city of Los Angeles has had responsibility for running Ontario Airport since 1967 and has owned it since 1985 when Ontario deeded it to the megalopolis for no consideration. Under Los Angeles’s direction, over $550 million in improvements were made to the airport and passenger traffic there increased dramatically from just under 200,000 in 1966 to 7.2 million in 2007. But over the last five years, passengers flying in and out of Ontario have dwindled considerably, with  4.2 million passengers in 2011, and further declines are expected to be registered this year.
Ontario officials blame Los Angeles, and Los Angeles World Airports, the non-profit entity L.A. created to own, maintain, administer and operate its division of airports, which includes Los Angeles International Airport, Van Nuys Airport, Palmdale Airport and Ontario International.
Ontario officials assert Los Angeles World Airports, known by its acronym LAWA, for the last five years has allowed Ontario International Airport to languish, as major improvements have been made to Los Angeles International Airport, where passenger traffic has increased despite the contraction of the airline industry.  Simultaneously, LAWA charges the airlines at Ontario International $14.50 per enplaned passenger, which is substantially more than the $11, $9.93, $5.34, $4.07 and $2.10 charged at Los Angeles International, John Wayne, Long Beach, Palm Springs and Burbank airports, respectively. Indeed, Ontario officials maintain, LAWA is purposefully mismanaging Ontario International as part of an effort to bolster the Los Angeles Economy.
Ontario has embarked on an effort to have Los Angeles relinquish ownership and control of Ontario Airport either back to Ontario or a regional entity. As part of that effort, Ontario has sought, so far unsuccessfully, legislation mandating the airport’s return, and undertaken a public relations campaign, now dubbed “Set ONTario Free,” which castigates Los Angeles and LAWA by celebrating the airport’s alleged mismanagement, emphasizes how the drop in airport use has damaged the local economy and touts local control as a panacea. Ontario has induced more than 70 cities, organizations and elected officials to endorse the concept of Los Angeles returning the airport to Ontario.
LAWA and Los Angeles, which speak from the experience of running the airport, see things differently. They maintain that the drop off in passenger traffic is in some measure a function of the downturn in the economy, local and national, the decline of the airline industry in general, and changes in the way airlines are operating. Additionally, LAWA faults Ontario and its persistent critical and negative comments about the airport and how it is run, as is typified in its public relations campaign, as contributing to the reluctance of passengers to fly out of Ontario.
Edward Shelswell-White, an airline industry expert and consultant to LAWA who was brougt in to look at the reasons Ontario Airport is sputtering and suggest the means by which the beleaguered aerodrome  could be turned around, cited the “negative dialogue” about the airport emanating from Ontario itself as a contributory factor in the perception of Ontario Airport as a destination or place of departure to be avoided. Shelswell-White noted that it is Ontario officials and not Los Angeles ones who are hinting about closing the airport.
Shelswell-White and other Los Angeles World Airport officials such as LAWA Executive Director Gina Marie Lindsey, director of external affairs Celine Cordero and director for air service marketing Mark Thorpe have all indicated that running an entity like Ontario Airport is an extremely complicated matter which Ontario officials ignore in making their highly critical assessments and statements. Lindsey said that merely transferring control of the airport to Ontario will not transform it into a successful and impeccably run aerodrome.
Shelswell-White offered his view that the airport is not capturing the imagination or confidence of its “target customers.” He said Ontario needs to strengthen its “brand identity” and contemplate a “rebranding.” To this end, LAWA offered to let Ontario take on the marketing of Ontario Airport and said it would provide money out of its own budget to help Ontario do that. Ontario officials rejected the offer, maintaining they did not want to market a product, i.e., airline tickets, when they had no control over ticket pricing.
Ontario’s rejection of the offer dismayed LAWA officials, who reference Ontario’s willingness to spend $635,000 in a negative public relations campaign attacking the city of Los Angeles and LAWA with regard to the airport ownership issue but simultaneously evincing unwillingness to run a positive marketing program for the airport. They see Ontario’s inability to take up the marketing campaign as an indication of its larger inability to run an airport.
While LAWA officials believe an improvement in the economy is the only likely cure for the situation dogging Ontario Airport, Ontario officials are hopeful that a currently ongoing study by the Los Angeles City Council subcommittee on trade and the city’s administrative officer, Miguel Santana, looking into Ontario’s proposal to regain control of the airport and a fair market price for Ontario Airport will advance their cause.

Dickinson Proposing New Charter School In Adelanto

Michael Dickinson, whose efforts at bringing the Public Safety Charter Academy into existence was widely lauded until he was ignominiously sacked as chief executive officer of that school last year amid charges he was exploiting it for personal financial profit, is attempting to start another charter school in Apple Valley under the aegis of the Adelanto Elementary School District.
Confidently predicting a start-up enrollment of 400, Dickinson in April submitted to the Adelanto Elementary School District a charter petition for True North Preparatory Academy, seeking $2.6 million from the state to run what  he described as a K-12 vocational training and college preparatory school in the 2012-2013 school year. His application projected steady growth in enrollment calling for the charter’s proposed budget to grow to $3.4 million in the 2013-2014 school year. When queried, his associates posited they would need $4.4 million in the 2014-2015 school year.
Dickinson, a one-time arson investigator, in 1999 initiated what at that time was an unaccredited educational seminar for teenagers pertaining to fire science. The seminars broadened to include law enforcement issues, and with the assistance of others, Dickinson established a campus at the former Norton Air Force Base. In  2005, the school received accreditation and Dickinson made a petition to transform the school into a charter academy under the sponsorship of the San Bernardino City Unified School District, achieving that goal in 2006.  The academy  found a niche among students who aspired to careers in the field of public safety.  Nevertheless, under Dickinson the Public Safety Academy fell short of both educational and accounting goals over the several years of its operation, then plunged into chaos last year. Four years ago a financial review revealed the school had not kept accurate payroll and accounting records and had spent $164,000 that was not budgeted for. There were also questions about $20,000 worth of expenditures for laptops that were either never delivered, misappropriated or stolen.  In January of last year, a report commissioned by the district found the academy’s accounting practices deficient and cataloged arrearages with regard to accounts payable.
Last spring, Michael Dickinson’s wife who served as a principal at one of the school’s campuses, Susan Dickinson, fell under the charter school board’s focus after a report surfaced that she had crossed the line in prepping her students for questions contained in the state’s Standardized Testing and Reporting exam by showing them some of the questions contained in the test. When the charter school’s head principal, Kathy Toy, recommended that the board of trustees terminate Susan Dickinson, Michael Dickinson dismissed the board of trustees before they could do so.
On June 20, 2011 the Public Safety Academy board, led by Peggi Hazlett, filed suit against Public Safety Academy Inc., an adjunct to the academy set up and controlled by Michael Dickinson, who received $121,000 per year in salary for his services. That suit sought to restore the authority of the board that Michael Dickinson had terminated. In July, the court ruled that the board had legal authority to run the charter academy. The board then terminated the contracts of Michael Dickinson, as the chief executive officer, and Dickinson’s hand-picked chief financial officer, Mike Davis, who was paid $120,000 per year.
While the application with the Adelanto Elementary School District is being processed, district officials are skeptical of the application and Dickinson’s true motive on several particulars.
Adelanto school board member Jermaine Wright said it appeared to him that Dickinson was more committed to generating revenue than educating students through the establishment of a new charter academy.
“I believe they are trying to use the Adelanto School District, which is known for being a charter friendly district, to open up another charter to be a money grab. That sort of thing has been going on for a while with charter schools. People who can’t make money anywhere else are opening charter schools and trying to cash in.”
Wright said he found Dickinson’s claim of having an enrollment of 400 suspicious.
“That has to be the second biggest joke on the planet,” Wright said. “It took nearly ten years for him to reach 400 students at the Public Safety Academy. Now he has lost his position there and he is trying to get a charter school here. I don’t know of any charter school that could open the first year with 400 students.”
Moreover, Wright said, the numbers and details in the petition are dubious. “They talk a good game but they have nothing to back up what they are saying. They could not defend their budget. They said it was a K-to-12 school, but everything they had was geared to being a high school. Their budget numbers were incomplete. They are required by the educational code to have a three-year budget but what they had was for two years and their numbers were so far off. The numbers added up to 600 student but they project 400 students. Charter schools always show a low number and pray for a higher number. They did it the other way around.”
Most troubling of all was that Dickinson was a no-show at the May 1 school board meeting at which a public hearing for the True North petition was held, Wright said. Instead, a few of Dickinson’s associates stood in for him.
“He didn’t even take the time to come up and talk to us,” Wright said of Dickinson. Wright said he thought that maybe Dickinson thought he could selectively present his history to the school board, emphasize his success in getting the Public Safety Academy accredited and chartered and keep the derogatory information under wraps.
“He knew that we had closed Sheppard Middle School and he and his people saw we had an empty building, saw a way to get in somewhere and grab money. Those are just my personal thoughts on this. I have concerns they are coming to our district because we are a charter friendly district and they think we are not watching things very closely. Anybody who comes to our district should be subject to a thorough background check,” Wright said.

Legislation Excuses Calico Solar Plan From Tortuous Approval Review

The state Assembly has approved legislation that will allow the Calico Solar plant to proceed toward completion without having to  obtain approval from the county and other local regulatory agencies.
Environmentalists, concerned about the possible impact the proposed 663.5-megawatt plant will have on desert tortoises, golden eagles,  bighorn sheep and other fauna and flora that inhabit the desert valley where the development is to occur, had opposed the project.
The Sierra Club, Defenders of Wildlife and the Natural Resources Defense Council maintain that the project, proposed by K Road Power on 4,604 acres of public land in the Pisgah Valley north of Interstate 40 roughly 37 miles east of Barstow, will prove particularly ecologically damaging. They wanted the project to go through a tortuous environmental and land use review process.  The project was originally intended to utilize a cutting-edge process for converting the heat of the sun to drive a turbine and generate electricity. In that form the project’s then-sponsor, Arizona-based Tessera Solar, in 2010 obtained from U.S. Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar approval for the project and qualified for federal stimulus money to defray a portion of the cost of the project. But last year, Tessera sold the project to New York-based K Road Power. K Road has elected to abandon the original design, which involved parabolic mirrors to catch the sun’s rays and produce heat, and instead substitute photovoltaic cells.
As first proposed, the Calico Solar plant was to employ SunCatcher units, computer controlled parabolic mirrors. The SunCatchers were to track the sun during daylight hours and focus an intense beam of light, i.e. heat, onto a glass tube filled with a synthetic petroleum product known as therminol. Therminol, based on its grade and rating, is capable of absorbing heat up to 1,400 degrees Fahrenheit. The therminol was then to be pumped across the outside of the differing chambers of a Sterling engine to heat gases within those chambers to drive the engine’s pistons. The engine would then turn a turbine to  generate electricity.
Tessera’s design was an improvement upon a similar computer-guided parabolic mirror solar ray-focusing set-up that heated therminol, which was then routed into a heat converter that was brought into contact with water to create steam, which was used to run a turbine. It was believed the use of the Sterling engines would boost the efficiency by as much as 17 percent over the steam driven turbine approach.
In October 2011, K Road abruptly switched to a plan to employ pho-tovoltaic panels on the project.
Part of the rationale for changing the technology stemmed from the September bankruptcy filing of Sterling Energy Systems, which rendered ready availability of the Sterling engines problematic. Another factor was the decrease in the cost of photovoltaic cells over the last three years.
While the photovoltaic cells will not generate as much electricity as the mirror/therminol/Stirling engine configuration, they can be erected and brought on line much more quickly. Originally planned to generate 850 megawatts, the plant has been pared back to 663.5 megawatts. When fully operational, the project will provide electricity sufficient to power about 250,000 homes. Environmentalists maintained the change in the project proposal necessitated an entirely new project application and approval process.
In March, Assemblyman Felipe Fuentes authored emergency legislation, AB 1073, a bill to allow the Calico Solar project to receive state approval to change the technology without having to again go through the project approval and environmental certification process. The bill passed the state Senate 28-2 on March 28. On May 10, it passed 56- to-10 in the Assembly. Upon being signed into law by Governor Jerry Brown, AB 1073 will allow Calico Solar to apply for project approval directly to the California Energy Commission, which is favorably disposed toward renewable energy projects. San Bernardino County and its land use division will have no formal say in the process. Brown lobbied for the bill’s passage.
Opponents sought to have the bill defeated at the Assembly committee level. But Fuentes and Assembly leaders pulled the bill from committee on May 7 and sent it directly to the floor, declaring it “urgent” legislation to ensure that the Energy Commission would hold hearings on the project prior to a June 20 deadline.
While the passage of AB 1073 comes as a decided blow against environmentalist opponents of the project, K-Road yet faces a few hurdles. The company currently has no power purchase agreement with a utility for the project, no established financing and no construction start date. It also must stand down a pending lawsuit by environmentalists. Upon approval of the project by the Energy Commission, K-Road nevertheless will have turned a corner in the battle to move the project forward.