(March 29) Scot Spencer, the controversial aircraft industry executive who was entrusted with hundreds of millions of dollars by local officials to oversee what has so far proven to be an unsuccessful effort to transform former Norton Air Force Base into an international airport, was arrested earlier this week and charged with engaging in a conspiracy to steal $1.75 million in public funds, a gambit which ultimately netted him $1.03 million, investigators and prosecutors say.
The money prosecutors allege Spencer fraudulently obtained from the San Bernardino International Airport Authority is less than half of one percent of the money a joint powers authority set up to establish and operate the airport expended in the airport development effort. The expenditure of much of that money was done under Spencer’s direction in his capacity as the contract developer of the facility, which officials had hoped would by now attract multiple airlines to become a significant transportation hub.
But Spencer’s own interests at the airport, including several aviation service companies he owns, co-owns, owned or co-owned, in many instances conflicted with the airport authority’s imperative of attracting to the aerodrome aviation related concerns. On more than one occasion Spencer used his status as the airport developer and his access to the authority administration and board to personally profit to the detriment of the airport’s operations and the taxpayers who were underwriting them.
His arrest and the charges filed against him are an outgrowth of a scathing report by the 2010-2011 San Bernardino County Grand Jury and evidence gathered during an FBI raid on the airport, the authority’s headquarters and several offices and hangars where Spencer’s companies were located, along with his Riverside home, on September 21, 2011.
The criminal complaint filed against Spencer by the San Bernardino County District Attorney’s Office alleges Spencer conspired with Felice Luciano to effectuate a fraudulent $1.75 million claim by SBD Aircraft Services, one of Spencer’s companies, against the San Bernardino International Airport Authority in 2008 based on the falsified representation of the cancellation of an aircraft lease by the Democratic National Committee. Prosecutors, based upon an affidavit from the Democratic National Committee’s legal counsel obtained by district attorney’s investigator Schyler Beaty, maintain no such lease ever existed and that Spencer phonied up a fax to the Democratic National Committee to give credence to the claim there was such a lease.
The criminal complaint alleges that on March 26, 2010, Spencer and Luciano met at New York City’s Blue Water Grill, where Luciano allegedly signed an apparently backdated document purporting that SBD Airport Services would lease an aircraft to a company called Unique Aviation Properties, a company co-owned by Luciano, to provide the aircraft to the Democratic National Committee by August 23, 2008. At Spencer’s behest, according to prosecutors, Luciano signed the document on behalf of Unique Aviation and Spencer signed for SBD Aircraft Services. Prosecutors maintain that three days later, on March 29, 2010, Spencer produced a copy of the fraudulent lease agreement in response to a court order.
Spencer is charged with two counts of conspiracy, as is Luciano. Spencer is charged with two counts of perjury and one count of preparing false documentary evidence. Spencer was arrested on March 24 in Boca Raton, Florida. He waived extradition and was brought back to San Bernardino on March 28. There was no record of Luciano, whose domicile is in Tempe, Arizona, being arrested, although there are indications he has been cooperating with the prosecution.
The background behind the alleged fraud would indicate that more than just $1.75 million in public funds were lost as a result of the alleged fraud Spencer perpetrated.
Spencer’s influence over operations at the airport, where several companies he owns were housed, was far reaching. In this way, Spencer’s pursuit of his own agenda conflicted with the corporate aims of other companies functioning at the airport, resulting in those companies departing.
One such company was Aeros Aeronautical Systems Corp., a blimp builder which did work on dirigibles and other lighter-than-air craft in Hangar 695, which it had leased at the airport.
In 2008, business was booming for Aeros, and the company was making its lease payments to the airport authority on time and in full. But that same year, Spencer would claim that two of his companies, SBD Aircraft Services and Norton Aviation Maintenance Services, entered into a subcontract with Luciano’s Unique Aviation, which, it was represented, had orders from the Democratic National Committee for the renovation and refurbishing of a then-35-year-old Boeing 727-227 for use in the Barack Obama presidential campaign. Spencer claimed he needed the hangar space Aeros was using to have SBD and Norton Aviation do the work. Despite the consideration that Aeros was a tenant paying top dollar for the space it was using and that it had secured in June 2008 two successive short term leases with 30-day termination notices to undertake tests on a dirigible, Spencer used his leverage with the airport authority to have the late Timothy Sabo, the legal counsel for the San Bernardino International Airport Authority (SBIAA), author a letter which then-airport authority general manager Don Rogers signed that essentially evicted Aeros.
In July 2008, before Aeros vacated the hangar, Spencer and the airport authority signed a lease for Hangar 695 at a rate less than half of what Aeros was paying for the space and despite the consideration that Aeros had yet to vacate it. When Aeros did not leave quickly enough to satisfy Spencer, who said he was prevented from completing $750,000 worth of repairs on the 727 to be used by the Democrats, he threatened SBIAA with legal action. Before the incident was over, Aeros, which had offered the promise of remaining as a longtime paying tenant, left in a huff, never to return. Spencer lodged a $1.75 million claim against SBIAA, which was eventually settled for $1.03 million, including the forgiving of a $155,000 balance on a previous loan, the extension of another $550,000 loan at 5 percent interest, and an ongoing $315,000 hangar rental subsidy. It is now alleged that the Democratic National Committee had not commissioned the 1973 Boeing 727-227 from Unique Aviation and had no contract with Spencer or any of his companies.
Also in 2008, Spencer forced the exodus of another paying tenant, Virginia-based BaySys West, from San Bernardino International Airport. BaySys West had established an aircraft maintenance operation in San Bernardino employing 300, which Spencer apparently felt was in competition with Norton Aircraft Maintenance Systems, another company he owned. BaySys left in December 2008 under pressure from Spencer.
Spencer, who has long enjoyed extensive contacts throughout the aviation industry and was leasing two hangars at the airport in 2006, was hired by SBIAA in 2007 under a no-bid arrangement and entrusted with converting the former Norton Air Force Base into a true international airport. Yet there had been warning signs about Spencer’s reliability before he was selected to serve as contract developer at the airport.
In 1991, Spencer and financier Jeffrey Chodorow sought to utilize the remaining assets from Braniff International Airways to create Dallas-based Braniff International Airlines, Inc. Braniff Airways, which had been in operation since 1928, had faltered under its corporate successor, Braniff, Inc., which was created after the former company’s 1982 bankruptcy. Spencer’s effort was unsuccessful and Spencer and Chodorow were both convicted of fraud for absconding with $14 million of the company’s funds, which they had partially hidden by making payments from Braniff to a shell company they created. Spencer served a four-year prison term from 1995 until 1999 as a result of that conviction.
After paying his debt to society, Spencer took up where he had left off, becoming involved in the aircraft industry largely on the strength of his contacts with manufacturers, airlines, mechanics and maintenance companies.
In 2003 a charter airline Spencer owned set up shop at the airport and within two years, he was leasing from the San Bernardino International Airport Authority the lion’s share of property at the airport, where several aircraft servicing companies he was an owner or investor in were based. In 2007, without any competitive bidding, Spencer was chosen by the Airport Authority to serve as contract developer of the airport. He was given a contract to oversee what was supposed to be a $38 million renovation of the airport’s passenger terminal and a $7 million development of its concourse. Spencer undertook that assignment amid confident predictions that upon completion of those projects, the airport would attract at least one and perhaps as many as a half dozen commercial passenger carriers. In carrying out that project, Spencer used two corporations he owned, Norton Development Company, LLC and SBD Properties, LLC. The cost of the passenger terminal and the concourse escalated to $142 million and the airport has yet to host any commercial airlines, although corporate jets and other private pilots did land at the Million Air corporate aviation facility, for which Spencer was the franchisee, beginning in 2010.
The cost overruns for the terminal project, the failure of San Bernardino Airport to attract commercial airlines and Spencer’s relationship with former airport authority executive director Don Rogers, as well as T. Milford Harrison, another former airport authority executive director with whom Spencer has jointly formed at least three aviation companies, have raised eyebrows and brought SBIAA under increasingly critical scrutiny.
On June 30, 2011 the San Bernardino County 2010-11 Grand Jury delivered a report that questioned several elements of Spencer’s performance and that of Rogers, calling into question what was characterized as lax oversight of the airport’s operations and favorable treatment accorded Spencer with regard to leasing arrangements. That report referenced the leasing debacle with Aeros and further noted that an inherent conflict of interest pervaded the contractual arrangement Spencer had with the authority in that Spencer’s commission on the project through Norton Development Company and SBD Properties increased as expenditures on the passenger and concourse construction mounted.
Immediately upon the announcement of Spencer’s arrest, speculation about charges against others began. Foremost among those believed to be at risk of being dragged into the criminal case is Harrison, one of Spencer’s closest business associates. Harrison’s business office was subject to the search warrant served by the FBI in September 2011. Rogers, who with the now-deceased Sabo enabled Spencer to evict Aeros on specious legal grounds, has also been mentioned as a possible co-conspirator. The district attorney’s office, however, stopped short of suggesting that further arrests are contemplated, though one investigator said that the prosecution will consider forging a plea arrangement with Spencer in which his cooperation with investigators would be a central element, potentially leading to the doorsteps of other airport officials.
The political fallout from the arrest could be significant. Both San Bernardino Mayor Patrick Morris and Fifth District Supervisor Josie Gonzales were actively involved, as board members of the airport authority, in hiring Spencer as contract developer in 2007. Spencer returned the favor with generous donations to their respective political campaigns and he allowed both to use the opulent and barely used terminal for fundraisers. Both Gonzales and Morris were among the last of the authority’s board members, which include representatives from the cities of Highland, Colton and Loma Linda as well as San Bernardino and the county, to continue to support keeping Spencer in place.
Speaking for both herself and Morris, Gonzales put out a prepared statement that said she now recognized that “the unscrupulous business practices of Scot Spencer have tainted much of the good work done at the airport.” She insisted that “From the moment the commission first learned of the investigation surrounding Mr. Spencer, the airport authority has done everything legally possible to distance itself from Mr. Spencer. We have terminated contracts with Spencer’s companies, hired new administrative leadership, and pursued civil restitution for any outstanding debt owed by Mr. Spencer to the airport. The airport authority has and will continue to cooperate with all law enforcement agencies. I applaud the district attorney’s commitment to seek financial restitution as part of his prosecution. He has my full cooperation and the county will ensure he has the resources needed to see this criminal case to its conclusion.”
Spencer’s presence at San Bernardino International Airport was supposed to have been terminated in October, after Federal Bankruptcy Judge Deborah Saltzman dismissed bankruptcy filings by two of Spencer’s firms through which he was seeking to extend his tenancy there. Nevertheless, he has maintained his de facto presence at the airport by means of a shadow company he created, Pulsar Aviation Services, Inc. While the company is ostensibly operated by David Reed, Ted Reed and Tim Reed, it is actually owned by Spencer and Harrison, and uses the same address, location, tooling and aircraft equipment in its operations that was formerly utilized by SBAM Technics, Norton Aircraft Maintenance Services and Southern California Precision Aircraft, all of which were once or still are owned or co-owned by Spencer.
Judge Reinstates Graham As Hesperia Schools Police Chief
HESPERIA • Michael Graham has been reinstated as the Hesperia School District’s police chief in a ruling by Superior Court Judge John P Vander Feer handed down on March 22.
In February 2012, the Hesperia School Board voted 3-2 to fire Graham after months of protracted battling between Graham, as the chief of police, and then-district superintendent Mark McKinney.
McKinney had previously relieved Graham of his command, but Graham chose to have a public hearing over issues relating to his ouster. In testimony before the board, McKinney maintained Graham had been insubordinate.
Graham insisted that his firing was retaliatory and that he was punished for speaking out against reductions the police department was forced to sustain as well as for his efforts to get to the bottom of an alleged embezzlement of associated student body funds at Sultana High School in late 2009. McKinney said that diminishing revenues required that the district make cuts and the police division was a logical place to make those economies. He said that Graham, who hired on with the district police department in 2001 and was promoted to chief in April 2008, had proven intransigent in carrying out that policy.
Graham, a former San Bernardino County sheriff’s deputy, a one-time deputy marshal with San Bernardino County, and a former security officer with the Air Force, maintained he had attempted to comply with McKinney’s instructions. Graham, however, was undercut by statements he had previously uttered during his oftentimes public feud with McKinney, which on occasion included deprecating remarks about then-school board president Chris Bentley. Bill Holland, one of Grahams’s subordinates in the school district police department who was also a Hesperia city councilman who has since become mayor, sought to ameliorate Graham’s position, telling the board that it was he, rather than Graham, who had ridiculed as “absurd” the directives in one of McKinney’s memos to Graham calling upon him to reduce the activity and authority of the district police department.
Ultimately, a majority of the board did not find credible Graham’s insistence that he had attempted to comply with McKinney’s instructions and had not defied the superintendent. Bentley, joined by board members Eric Swanson and Niccole Childs, upheld McKinney’s firing of Graham. Board members Hardy Black and Anthony Riley voted to sustain Graham’s appeal.
Graham filed a wrongful termination suit against the Hesperia Unified School District in May.
Vander Feer ruled the school board’s accusation of insubordination on Graham’s part was not upheld by a preponderance of the evidence and he ordered Graham be “reinstated with full back pay and benefits.”
The district to which Graham will return has changed in certain respects. Bentley was voted out of office in November. Riley did not seek reelection. Cody Gregg and Ella Rogers have replaced Bentley and Riley. They formed a ruling alliance with Black and fired McKinney as superintendent in December.
Chino Hills Encroachment Lawsuit To Go To Trial With All Causes of Action Intact
(March 29) The encroachment lawsuit filed by a Chino Hills couple against the city will go to trial with all of its causes of action intact, Superior Court Judge Joseph Brisco ruled on March 11.
Michael and Kimberly Denton sued the city in 2011 after the city’s code enforcement division informed them in 2010 that the furthest extension of their backyard was encroaching on city-owned open space and that they had to remove their pool and spa along with landscaping that was already extant when they purchased the home in 1999 from Gloria Vitagliano.
The Dentons, who live on Hunters Gate Circle, offered the city $10,000 for the property, but the city rejected that offer, instead saying it would provide them with a 15-year easement for the continued use of the property. The Dentons then retained the firm of Gresham, Savage, Nolan and Tilden to sue the city.
The Dentons claim the city allowed the Vitagliano/Denton encroachment, which was conspicuous and open, to stand, and did nothing to interfere with Ms. Vitagliano’s or their occupation of the approximately 1,574 square feet of land for more than 15 years. Nor did the city act in a timely manner to prevent them from removing a wrought-iron fence and replacing it with a glass wall and block fence, the Dentons assert.
On March 13, Brisco denied the city’s motion to strike portions of the complaint and he also overruled a demurrer filed by the city.
“Demurrer is overruled as to city of Chino Hills as to all causes of action,” Brisco stated.
A demurrer is a request by a defendant for a determination that the facts alleged are insufficient to establish that the litigation should move forward.
Brisco also ruled that certain exhibits the city wants to enter as evidence would be accepted by the court, while others would not. He also granted the Dentons’ request for the acceptance of certain exhibits.
The Dentons had no knowledge of the encroachment, which the city was obliged to redress in a timely manner, according to the Denton’s lawyer, Theodore Stream.
The city, however, maintains that a document recorded at the time of the sale contains a disclosure statement from Vitagliano to the Dentons stating there is a “possible discrepancy regarding lot size/fence line.” The city maintains that this demonstrates the Dentons were on notice as to the possible encroachment at the time of the sale.
The city had previously sought to have the case dismissed and its lawyer, Elizabeth Calciano, indicated it will again seek to have a new cause of action alleged by the Dentons tossed out. In October, the city requested that Superior Court Judge Ben Kayashima, who was then hearing the case, grant summary judgment. Kayashima rejected that petition, and ordered both parties to be ready for trial, which he set to commence on November 13. There were further delays, and Kayashima, who is a retired judge who was sitting on assignment, had his position as a judge terminated as a result of budget cuts. Brisco called for the case to go to trial beginning on September 30. Calciano said she will bring a motion before Brisco next month to have him throw out a recent amendment to the Dentons’ complaint that cites issues with regard to the covenants, conditions and requirements attending the sale of the property.
The case is of some moment in upscale Chino Hills, since it will conceivably impact other property owners in the city who are alleged to have encroached on open space owned by the city.
City of Needles To Borrow Against CRMC Purchase Escrow Account
(March 29) To meet the immediate operational and payroll deficits at Colorado River Medical Center, the city of Needles will borrow up to $400,000 put into an escrow account by Community Health Care Partners.
The city has entered into a deal to sell the hospital to Community Health Care Partners, Inc., pursuant to arrangements being worked out for the full transfer of all of the property upon which the hospital is located to that buyer. The Bureau of Land Management, which sold the property to the city decades ago so the hospital could be developed, put a revisionary clause into the terms of that original sale so that the property must revert to the Bureau if the land is ever used for a purpose it does not deem beneficial to the public. The Bureau has not yet signed off on that land transfer to Community Health Care Partners, which is owned by Bing Lum.
Community Healthcare Partners has an agreement to purchase the hospital for $2.577 million. As part of a deal accepted by the city council on February 26, a long-term escrow process for the hospital’s purchase, an interim lease, a management agreement and a leaseback agreement was set up whereby Community Healthcare Partners put $2.2 million into an escrow account and effective March 1 Community Healthcare Partners, Inc. became interim manager of Colorado River Medical Center. According to the deal forged between the city and Community Healthcare Partners, once the Bureau of Land Management gives final approval of the transfer, Community Health Care Partners will pay the city another $377,000 to complete the purchase of the hospital and the land it sits upon in full. The second closing deadline has been set for no later than February 22, 2015.
At a special joint meeting with the Needles City Council March 12, the Needles Hospital Board of Trustees approved a revolving loan and security agreement with Community Healthcare Partners. Under that arrangement, the city will be able to tap into as much as $400,000 sitting in the escrow account to pay for current and past due hospital-related operating and payroll bills and has up to 180 days to repay the loan from accounts receivable. The hospital had unpaid bills of $989,554.73 as of early this month. Previously, to ensure that payroll was met on March 9, the city had loaned the hospital $80,000.
Lum said he was amenable to the loan being made as long as it is repaid within the 180-day time frame.
City attorney John Pinkney, who counseled against advancing money out of the escrow account, nevertheless negotiated the terms of the loan and vouched for its legality. There is a security agreement with regard to the loan, extending to the possibility that the hospital purchase is not ultimately consummated whereby the full amount of the money in escrow has to be returned to Community Health Care Partners.
Board member Lana Shaw abstained in the vote to take the loan, which was approved by all other board members. The board also designated having city manager David Brownlee and the city’s in-house accountant, Sylvia Miledi, monitor the hospital’s finances from here on out.
Compton Brought In As Colton Interim Manager
COLTON – Former Omnitrans finance director Stephen P. Compton will fill in as interim city manager in Colton while a replacement for just-departed city manager Rod Foster is carried out.
Foster left Colton on March 14, closing out more than three years as city manager in the 52,154-population Hub City between the San Bernardino County seat of San Bernardino, the Riverside County Seat of Riverside, and Grand Terrace, Loma Linda and Rialto.
Compton, who has 32 years of public administration experience and was once assistant city manager in Ridgecrest, will be provided with a $10,920 per month salary that is augmented with no benefits other than mileage reimbursement for travel outside the city. He is a resident of Redlands.
Veterans Living Memorial At SBSU Dedicated
The groundbreaking for the Veterans Living Memorial Garden at the Veterans Success Center at Cal State San Bernardino was held on March 23.
That ceremony included the planting of 15 olive trees, three each for the five branches of the U.S. military.
“This living memorial of trees will stand as a lasting tribute to the men and women who have served this nation,” said Bill Moseley, director of the county Department of Veterans Affairs.
Sheree Stewart, First Woman Command Echelon Officer In SBSO, Retires
Sheree Stewart, the first woman to rise to the command echelon of the San Bernardino County Sheriff’s Department, is retiring tomorrow, bringing to a close her 31-year law enforcement career.
Stewart holds two firsts with the department, being the first person of her gender to reach the rank of captain and the first to accede to the status of deputy chief.
Known as “Big Mama” by many of the deputies, Stewart cut a sharp swath through the department even relatively early in her career.
A native of Lockport, N.Y., she came to Southern California in 1980 and landed the relatively humble position of a department intern in 1981. She graduated from the department’s academy and then went to work as a patrol deputy. Under former sheriff Floyd Tidwell, she advanced to the rank of sergeant and was given what many considered to be an exile assignment in the department’s internal affairs division, then known as professional standards. In that billet, she promoted to lieutenant and exhibited a flare for in-depth analysis and independence, often sustaining citizen complaints against deputies in an era when such occurrences were rare to non-existent.
Subsequently she was promoted to captain and was given command of the department’s Highland station, where she remained a half dozen years. In 2005, she was promoted to deputy chief.
During her career, women made slow and sometimes uncertain progress but nevertheless steady, and in a few cases such as Steward’s, dramatic strides in San Bernardino County law enforcement as the oftentimes machismo ethos of policing has strained to accommodate distaff officers. In 2007, former Los Angeles police lieutenant Diane Burns became the county’s first police chief when she was hired to head the Barstow Police Department.
Stewart, 54, who is married to a former helicopter pilot with the sheriff’s department, has four sons and a granddaughter.
Court To Keep Barstow Courthouse And Juvenile Courts Open 3 Days Per Week
The Superior Court of San Bernardino County will maintain limited operations in one courtroom in Barstow for three days a week beginning May 6, avoiding the entire closure of the courthouse that was previously slated to begin on that date, according to Stephen Nash, the court’s executive officer.
The remainder of the Barstow Courthouse will close as previously announced, with many of the cases there being transferred to the Victorville and San Bernardino courthouses. Nevertheless, traffic, landlord-tenant, small claims and domestic violence cases will continue to be heard in Barstow. Civil, family law and criminal cases will still be transferred to other locations, Nash said, as was previously announced.
Nash, together with San Bernardino County Presiding Judge Marsha Slough moved to close the Chino Courthouse and transfer cases there to Rancho Cucamonga last year following notification that the state was reducing the county court system’s annual funding from $105,194.436 to $89,732.965, effective July 1 of 2014. Slough and Nash further resolved to reduce the court’s employees from 1,028 to 875.
On December 11, 2012, the court announced a second phase of cost reduction measures, including the closure of the Barstow courthouse by May 6, 2013.
On March 15 of this year, the California Judicial Council distributed unused monies from a two percent statewide reserve to courts throughout the state. Of this amount, San Bernardino Superior Court is scheduled to receive approximately $1.2 million. Slough and Nash apportioned that money to maintain the limited Barstow court operations and to also maintain juvenile delinquency court, including delinquency drug court, three days a week, effective May 6.
Creighton Urges Upland Council To Nix Administrative Citation Ordinance
(March 22) A member of Upland’s city council advisory committee said he will not support the administrative citation ordinance his panel has been tasked with evaluating prior to an upcoming vote.
On March 27, the city council advisory committee, chaired by Tom Mitchell, is scheduled to reconsider a redrafted form of the administrative citation ordinance that was considered by the city council on July 30 and again on August 13 last year, and provide a non-binding recommendation on whether to go forward with the ordinance. That ordinance in its original form was given initial approval but later abandoned when a firestorm of protest manifested at the city council meeting on August 13, when the ordinance was scheduled for a required “second reading,” i.e., final approval.
Prior to, and at, the July 30 meeting when the ordinance was first considered, neither the ordinance itself nor its language were made available to the public. Only after direct appeals by the public and the press did City Hall relent and release the text of the ordinance six days before the council was scheduled to approve it on August 13.
The ordinance as originally drafted substantially intensifies City Hall’s bureaucratic power and increases the amounts of the fines that can be levied. Moreover, the ordinance also sets up a policy similar to that utilized in other municipalities that empowers the city to not only issue citations but adjudicate them and set the penalty, precluding, at least in the first three phases of the administrative process, the individual who is cited from having the matter heard and the fine set by an independent arbiter, such as the municipal or superior court. Only upon being adjudged guilty and assessed with the fine, can a resident or business entity that is cited appeal the matter to an actual court, and then only upon posting the amount of the fine as a bond.
One of the more controversial provisions of the ordinance is its empowerment of the city’s community development director to levy, entirely at his or her own discretion, fines of up to $1,000 per day.
On August 13, the council chambers filled with residents and local business owners who came to weigh in against the ordinance after it was approved by a first 4-0 vote on July 30. Also present were Mayor Ray Musser and city manager Steve Dunn, both of whom were not in attendance at the July 30 meeting. Several residents and business owners questioned Community Development Director Jeff Zwack’s assertion that the ordinance was not intended to generate revenue for the cash-strapped municipality. Zwack and the council also found themselves under attack for withholding the text of the ordinance from the public.
The council at that point tabled the ordinance, and referred the matter back to staff for further evaluation.
In January, at Musser’s urging, the city council advisory committee took up active consideration of the administrative citation ordinance. City staff, particularly Zwack, insist that the city needs administrative citation authority to deal with intractable code enforcement problems. While acknowledging that in the neighborhood of 95 percent of residents and businesses cited under the current code enforcement process readily come into compliance, Zwack maintains that the city needs the administrative citation ordinance as a tool to force the roughly five percent of those who after being cited do not cooperate and comply with the city’s codes and standards and refuse to come to heel.
Ironically, Musser, who did not vote for giving the city’s code enforcement division added power the first time the matter was considered, appears to be the member of the city council most supportive of instituting the administrative citation ordinance now. Musser’s appointment to the city council advisory committee, Mitchell, likewise appeared to be ushering his fellow committee members toward making a recommendation that the city council adopt the ordinance. After examining the ordinance in October, the committee took the matter up again in February, at which time Mitchell said the committee would “hopefully” endorse the ordinance at its meeting next week.
Mark Creighton, the member of the city council advisory commission appointed by councilman Gino Filippi, however, told the Sentinel he is not favorably disposed toward the ordinance and infusing in city officials any more citation and fining authority than they already have. “This is not an ordinance that is going to breed community goodwill,” Creighton said. “I did not see a need for this when they proposed it six or seven months ago and I don’t see anything that has changed so that we need to give our code enforcement crew any more power than it already has. We have the ability to impose fines on people. What this does is give the city more power to hurt people and businesses, to bully them. They may have redrafted the ordinance slightly, but that doesn’t alleviate my fear that this could be or will be abused.“
Creighton said he was not convinced the city had benign intent in drafting the ordinance.
“I sense there is an ulterior motive here,” he said, suggesting that in addition to being a revenue source the ordinance could be selectively applied “the next time somebody wants to drive what they consider to be an undesirable business out of town.”
In several ways, Creighton said, “This is more of a weapon than a remedy.” Moreover, he suggested, it will inadvertently turn the code enforcement division into a cat’s paw that residents can use against neighbors they dislike or business owners can use against competing interests. “Something like this can be very easily abused. It can be used for the exact reasons you don’t want it used for. The little old lady who didn’t mow her grass will get cited. We shouldn’t be citing her. If she is too old to mow her lawn and is living on a fixed income, then we should mow her lawn for her. We’re a community, not an enforcement agency.
“I don’t see this as a way to improve our city,” Creighton continued. “With this we will be dragging Upland into the gutter. What this will do is institute new ways to screw with people. This will give your neighbor the ability to make trouble for you and potentially cost you money. What are we going to do when two neighbors who don’t get along start going back and forth and they bring the city into it? No one has proved to me that we need this ordinance. Yes, we have some problems with properties or businesses that do not meet our code. But we already have ordinances. Mr. Zwack said we need to be doing this because Ontario does it. Is that the justification? Because Ontario does it? Ontario is in far worse repair than Upland is. I don’t see any glaring problems where we need to start fining people a thousand dollars a day.”
Creighton said he did not know whether he would be able to sway the committee from supporting the ordinance and would not venture a prediction about whether the city council would enact it.
“All I can tell you is I am not supporting it,” he said.
Barstow Says Yes, 29 Palms Says No To New Murals
(March 22) Efforts to perk up the aesthetics in two of San Bernardino County’s desert cities had diametric outcomes this month.
In Barstow, artist Kim Capp put the finishing touches on a mural which celebrated Route 66 as the “Main Street of America.”
In Twentynine Palms, the city council rejected a proposal to have artist Art Mortimer complete a mural featuring depictions of Bill Keys’ life.
Both murals, the one completed in Barstow and the one put on hold in Twentynine Palms, were intended as celebrations of local history.
In Barstow, Capp’s artwork was put on a brick wall along the Route 66 Motel and commemorated Barstow as a point along the highway, first established in 1926, linking Chicago and Los Angeles. Capp’s completed mural depicts the eight states – Illinois, Missouri, Kansas, Oklahoma, Texas, New Mexico, Arizona and California – the highway runs through.
In Twentynine Palms, the city’s Action Committee had called upon the city to fund Mortimer’s tribute to Keys, one of the most colorful of local characters. A Nebraska native who worked as a deputy sheriff in Mohave County in Arizona, Keys arrived in the environs of Joshua Tree National Park in 1910, where he made the acquaintance, and eventually acquired the ranch, of notorious cattle rustler Jim McHaney. What became known as the Keys Desert Queen Ranch was a prime example of the innovation and resourcefulness of the region’s early settlers, with an extensive complex of small frame buildings. Keys cannibalized an old gold ore crushing mill that had been located in Pinon Wells and relocated the late-19th Century two-stamp mill machinery to Joshua Tree, dubbing it the Wall Street Mill. He became embroiled in a dispute with Worth Bagley over access to the Wall Street Mill, and in 1943 shot and killed him. Keys was tried for murder and convicted, serving six years in San Quentin Prison. He was paroled in 1950 and was pardoned in 1956 largely as a result of the efforts of Erle Stanley Gardner, author of the Perry Mason novels.
The Twentynine Palms City Council unanimously denied a $10,000 funding request from the Action Council for 29 Palms to pay for Mortimer’s work decorating a wall of the Siam Alterations building on Adobe Road, opposite an existing mural of pioneer constable Jack Cones.
Both Mortimer and his Barstow counterpart, Capp, are accomplished muralists. Mortimer is responsible for the Battle of the Bell mural at Twentynine Palms High School. Capp’s previous work includes murals at the Platas Mexican Restaurant as well as on a hill off Highway 58.
Barstow and Twentynine Palms each have nonprofit groups that support and promote mural painting. In Barstow that group is known as Main Street Murals and it has succeeded in completing an outdoor gallery of murals around the city of 22,639. In 25,048-population Twentynine Palms, the Action Council For Twentynine Palms fills that role, having completed 22 murals around the city utilizing private funds, although in 2012-13, the city’s general capital projects fund has $20,000 earmarked for public art.