Touting GOP Ties, Leon Aims To Break Democratic Gridlock In State Senate Race

(April 19) Having outdistanced four other candidates vying to succeed  Gloria Negrete-McLeod as State Senator in the 32nd District, Ontario Mayor Paul Leon is now looking to best former Pomona mayor and current assemblywoman Norma Torres in a run-off election May 14 to move into the California Legislature’s upper house.
A Republican, Leon is seeking to propound the conservative fiscal principles of his party in a campaign against Torres, a Democrat whose party enjoys a 48 to 28 percent registration advantage over Republicans in the 32nd District.
On March 12, Torres and Leon fought to the top of the heap of six candidates in the special election that was held because Negrete-McLeod, who was reelected to a four-year term in the state Senate in 2010, resigned that post to depart to Washington D.C. after she was elected to Congress in November.
Torres proved the top vote-getter with 13,295 votes or 43.6 percent throughout the district, which spreads into both Los Angeles and San Bernardino counties. Leon polled 8,064 votes or 26.4 percent in both counties. Since no candidate captured a majority of the vote, the run-off will be held on May 14.
Torres and Leon bested Democrat Larry Walker, with 13.9 percent; Joanne Gilbert, also a Democrat, who received seven percent; Ken Coble, a Republican, who polled 6.5 percent; and Paul Vincent Avila, a Democrat by registration who was disowned by his own party after he engaged in the highly unorthodox move of endorsing Leon, who garnered 2.6 percent.
Despite the voter registration numbers in the 32nd District favoring Democrats, Leon believes he can make a successful electoral appeal based upon what he insists is the Republicans’ more level-headed approach to governance and his demonstrated success in applying those Republican principals to Ontario, which is the most successful city in San Bernardino County in terms of economic performance and revenue generation based upon sales tax inflow.
“The way this state has of creating overregulation kills jobs,” Leon said, noting that what he called the tax and spend philosophy of the Democrats, who now have a supermajority in both the state Senate and Assembly, is to blame for the overregulation.  The tide is turning against the Democrats, Leon said, despite the political upper hand they now hold. “People have this idea there will be this groundswell and  all of the things the Democrats are pushing will end in one swoop,” he said. “That isn’t true. We [the Republicans] need to take each seat we can back to change the face of politics in the state to California.”
Leon cited the experience Ontario had in fighting off challenges to a WalMart superstore that is supposed to be built at Fifth and Mountain in Ontario at the site of the old White Front Department Store. He said the delay in that project is directly attributable to the overregulation mentality typical of Democrats and the legislation they have put in place allowing for the proliferation of lawsuits against development of commercial uses on environmental grounds.
“In Ontario we fought for nine years to allow a WalMart to come in,” Leon said. “That WalMart represented more jobs and an increase in local business and tax revenues but it was challenged for years by a California Environmental Quality Act lawsuit. Becaue of the holdup, the city of Ontario lost into our general fund over $8 million and that does not include the increase in business that would  have taken place around that center. That is just one example of what is going on in the state of California. Businesses are leaving the state or never opening up in the first place because they don’t want to pay what the state of California imposes on them in terms of taxes and regulations.”
Leon said he represents a superior choice to Torres because of both his party affiliation and basic political orientation.
“The Democratic Party, in my mind, has not remembered what it takes to run local municipalities,  and having one more Democratic senator will exacerbate the problem,” Leon said. “My intention is to balance the scales in Sacramento and help undo the mismanagement and bring fiscal responsibility. My main objective is to put California back to work so our citizens have the money to pay for goods and services, so we can rejuvenate the economy.”

Vandalism Spree Prompts Partial Closure Of Joshua Tree National Park

(April 19) JOSHUA TREE— The marring of boulders, rock outcroppings and other features within Joshua Tree National Park with graffiti has become so pervasive that earlier this week federal park officials closed several of the most popular hiking trails in the area to the public. More than 300 acres of the park deemed most vulnerable to vandalism have been declared off limits.
Rangers have found no fewer than 19 effaced areas within Rattlesnake Canyon alone, including world-renowned rock formations and historic Native American grounds. At Barker Dam, a century-old landmark, vandals used knives, chisels or other implements to scrape or carve words into the concrete.
Graffiti has long been a reality at the park, but was relatively limited as visitors to the remote desert area seemed for the most part to have a reverence for the wonders of the natural landscape there. But vandalism at Joshua Tree National Park has increased markedly in the last six to eight months, brought on, it seems by the new phenomenon of taggers posting photos of their handiwork on the internet, prompting others to join with them in a competition to scar the terrain. An effort is now underway to determine if those responsible can be identified. In some instances, the graffiti appears to be the names of the perpetrators. Some of the photos have been posted on social network sites such as Facebook.
Vandalism in a National Park is punishable by a fine of up to $5,000 or six months in jail. Defacing a historic Native American is a felony, with fines of up to $25,000 and prison terms of more than one year.

Twentynine Palms Tribe Has Initiated Work On Tortoise Rock Casino

(April 19) TWENTYNINE PALMS — The Twentynine Palms Band of Mission Indians is moving ahead with what has been dubbed the Tortoise Rock casino project on tribal land in Twentynine Palms, and is seeking to have the gaming facility open by late this year.
The casino will become the third gambling house in San Bernardino County and the second one owned by the Twentynine Palms Band, which since 1995 has operated the Spotlight 29 Casino in Coachella in Riverside County.
In 2007, the tribe submitted an application for a 60,000-square-foot casino with 350 slot machines along with table games, a bingo hall, two restaurants, a sports bar, an RV park that would accommodate up to 100 RVs and also provide tent camping and rustic cabins, campfire rings and barbecue facilities, as well as hookups for  electricity, water, cable TV, and wastewater treatment. The project also called for wireless Internet access, swimming pools, showers, locker rooms, and a laundry facility.
The tribe temporarily abandoned the plan for the facility to be located on a site south of Baseline Road and west of Adobe Road, after both the Department of Defense and the National Park Service stated their opposition to what the tribe then called the Nüwü Casino. The Marine Corps was less than enthused at the prospect of having the temptation of a gaming enterprise at such easy disposal to its troops. The project site is located within the city of Twentynine Palms’ National Park Buffer Overlay, which is intended to deter development that will interfere with the natural panorama.
Two-and-a-half  years ago, the tribe sought to relocate the proposed Nüwü Casino some 23 miles away, in Joshua  Tree, on a 130-acre parcel on the north side of Twentynine Palms Highway west of White Feather Road east of downtown Joshua Tree and just east of Desert View Homes’ metal dinosaurs. That site was well outside the tribe’s reservation and what is recognized as the tribe’s ancestral land, so the tribe was required to file an application with the Bureau of Indian Affairs to place the land in a public trust and transfer the tribe’s right from its tribal property to the Joshua Tree site. That would have involved making a case that the tribe had ancestral roots in the Joshua Tree area, where it had an historical relationship to the property in question by virtue of aboriginal activity, including hunting, foraging and trading in particular.  That application would have entailed an anthropological study to demonstrate the tribe’s ancestors ranged into Joshua Tree.
Tribal Chief Darrel Mike and his advisors, including the band’s chief financial officer, Steve Gralla, reassessed the likelihood of prevailing in a bruising battle with those opposed to locating the casino in Joshua Tree.
The local land use authority vested in the city of Twentynine Palms is not applicable to tribal land, since Indian Tribes are held to be sovereign nations.
Twentynine Palms interim city manager Homer Croy this week told the Sentinel, “That is Indian tribal land and it falls under a different jurisdiction. It is my understanding that some of our [city] council members attend the tribal council meetings, where those [land use] issues are discussed. The authority is the tribe’s. They can work with us as far as mitigating those issues but we have to wait to find out what their decisions are. They are the final authority and the city has no control.”
By early this year, the tribe abandoned entirely its plan for the Joshua Tree casino and instead submitted a draft environmental impact report for the project within 29 Palms to the state. That draft has been finalized and accepted. This week, Croy told the Sentinel, “I was out at the site and they have the property fenced off and are saturating the ground for pre-grading.”
The environmental report for the project, prepared by Sacramento-based Environmental Science Associates, says the 30,000 square-foot casino will sit on a site extending to cover a footprint of roughly 32 of the 160 acres at that location owned by the tribe and will include a parking lot with 450 parking spaces.  The casino will be 35 feet high and offer its customers 500 slot machines, six card or roulette tables, a delicatessen, restaurant, bar, administrative offices and ancillary structures. The casino will employ approximately 100 full- and part-time workers. A tortoise-exclusion barrier will be erected to protect that species from danger that might befall it on the to-be-developed property.
In keeping with its presence within the National Park Buffer Overlay, the casino’s design is to incorporate natural colors in its building materials and paint schemes that complement the existing landscape as well as to shield its external lighting to keep light from being projected upward or onto adjacent property, in keeping with Twentynine Palms’ Night Sky Ordinance, according to the draft environmental statement for the project.
The casino will be visible from Palm Vista Elementary School on Baseline Road, located 3,375 feet northeast of the project, as well as the  Oasis of Mara, which is a half mile northeast of the site. According to Environmental Science Associates, the one-story structure will obstruct to some degree the scenic views from residences to the north and east, Palm Vista Elementary to the northeast, the Oasis of Mara and those of motorists transiting Baseline Road, Adobe Road and Utah Trail. That obstruction will not be total, according to the draft report. “[T]he tops of mountainous areas to the south and west would still be visible behind the proposed development,” according to the draft statement.
Some negative impact on air quality in the nearby area will result from construction activity, according to the environmental impact report.
Water to the project will be provided by the Twentynine Palms Water District, which will extend services to the site by means of an 8-inch water line on Baseline Road.

Olsen-Binks Leaving FUSD To Take Position With Yucaipa-Calimesa

Fontana Unified School District Superintendent Cali Olsen-Binks, who rose through the ranks at the district to become top administrator five years ago, will leaving her position at the end of the current school year to become superintendent with the Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified School District.
The announcement of Olsen-Binks departure comes just five months after her mother-in-law, Kathy Binks departed after 24 years on the Fontana School Board.
Olsen-Binks was originally an elementary school teacher within the district, which boasts 40,000 students. She began her teaching career in 1990.
Olsen-Binks encountered rough sledding over the last four years as the state has steadily reduced education funding. Factionalism on the school board made for strained relations with some of those she had to answer to. On four occasions within the last 13 months, the board held closed door sessions in which her possible firing was discussed, though the board did not pull the trigger on her. The two members of the school board who had asked for Olsen-Binks’ performance reviews, Leticia Garcia and Sophia Green, are now the target of a recall effort.
She said her departure from Fontana is a bittersweet one that will be best for her family. The Yucaipa-Calimesa district has about one fourth the number of students as Fontana Unified.

Ontario Escalates Hostilities In Clash With LA Over Airport Ownership

(April 12) ONTARIO–The jousting between Los Angeles World Airports, the entity that manages and operates Ontario International Airport, and Ontario municipal officials and their allies continues over the terms by which the ownership of the airport should be returned to Ontario.
This week,  Ontario rejected Los Angeles’s offer to sell the airport back to Ontario for $474 million and then followed up with a threat of legal action against Los Angeles.
Ontario, which deeded the airport to the city of Los Angeles in 1985, has come to rue that move.
While Ontario Airport prospered and grew under the management of the Los Angeles Department of Airports for four decades, since 2008 passenger traffic into and out of Ontario  has steadily declined. Ontario officials blame Los Angeles and its successor to its Department of Airports, Los Angeles World Airports, for the decreases. They maintain that Los Angeles World Airports (LAWA) has purposefully operated and promoted the airport inefficiently as part of its design to promote ridership at Los Angeles International Airport.
In response to an ever more vituperative campaign by Ontario officials, LAWA officials, on behalf of Los Angeles, have been negotiating transfer of control of the airport, or outright ownership, with Ontario officials.
Since the forging of an agreement between Los Angeles and Ontario in 1967, Los Angeles, first under its Department of Airports and then under the aegis of LAWA, has managed the airport’s operations.
Using its leverage over  airlines based upon its ability to dole out or withhold favorable gate positions at Los Angeles International Airport, the Los Angeles Department of Airports induced more and more airlines to fly into and out of Ontario. By 1969, flights out of Ontario dramatically increased. In short order, Continental Airlines, PSA, Western, United, American Airlines, Hughes Air West, and Delta established routes from Ontario. In the early 1970s, Ontario was in competition with John Wayne Airport in Orange County, which at that time was expanding dramatically. Though a benchmark of 10 million passengers at the airport by 1975 was not achieved, the Los Angeles Department of Airports still assiduously promoted Ontario International.  In 1981, a modern, second east-to-west runway was built, necessitating the removal of the old northeast-to-southwest runway. Los Angeles officials stepped up pressure on Ontario officials to have them cede ownership of the airport in total to Los Angeles, but Ontario’s then mayor,  Robert  Ellingwood, resisted, maintaining that all of the criteria specified in the transfer portion of the 1967 agreement had yet to be met. As tensions mounted between the cities and Ontario began levying a parking tax at the airport, which L.A. objected to as unwarranted and illegal in a lawsuit, Ellingwood pressed for the recission of the joint powers agreement and for Ontario to take full control of the airport. Los Angeles, which  had control over the revenue being generated at the airport and was bankrolling the cost of operations there, threatened to stand down from the joint powers agreement, leaving Ontario in the position of paying all operational costs.  Ellingwood’s four council colleagues, believing Ontario did not have the financial means to operate the airport on its own, broke with him and during Ellingwod’s absence from the February 19, 1985 council meeting, voted 4-0 to transfer title to the airport to the city of Los Angeles.
In 1987, the departure runway was extended to the east.  In 1997 and 1998, Los Angeles built two modern 530,000-square foot terminals at the airport at a cost of $270 million. In 2005-2006, the airport’s departure runway was repaved, received storm drains, and runway lighting was improved. The airport’s taxiways were widened. The same year Aeroméxico started seasonal flights to Guadalajara and Mexico City, making Ontario a true international airport.  The airport was also renamed Ontario/LA International Airport, ostensibly to avoid confusion with an airport in Canada.
In 2007, use of the airport peaked, with 7.2 million passengers enplaning there and using its terminals. In recent years, Ontario Airport has seen its use decline. In 2008, 6.2 million passengers took flights from the airport, a drop of 13.5 percent compared to 2007. In 2009, the airport had 4.95 million passengers pass through it. That trend continued in 2010, with 4.8 million travelers flying from Ontario International. Simultaneously Los Angeles World Airports was undertaking a flurry of improvements at Los Angeles International Airport intended to make traveling in or out there more convenient to its passengers.
Just under 4.6 million passengers took flights out of Ontario International in 2011. That figure dropped to 4.5 million in 2012.
In 2009, Ontario officials, believing that Los Angeles airport officials were intent on driving up passenger traffic in Los Angeles, potentially to the detriment of Ontario, began a dialogue with Los Angeles World Airports about combating the downward trend in passenger traffic at Ontario. But Los Angeles airport officials were not keen on surrendering any share of the market Los Angeles International had captured in the aftermath of the extensive improvements made there. They countered with offers to improve the marketing of Ontario Airport, at one point offering to bankroll such a marketing campaign to be run by Ontario officials. Ontario declined that offer.
Ontario officials gravitated toward the conclusion that reacquiring the airport was paramount and that not leaving its destiny in the care of Los Angeles officials, whose first loyalty consisted in keeping Los Angeles International Airport thriving, was the only realistic approach to the problem.
They began pushing Los Angeles to allow a public agency-to-public agency transfer of the airport at no consideration, reversing the 1985 action.
Los Angeles officials balked at that.
Quietly, so as to not publicly contradict its official position that the airport grounds are a public benefit property and thus of no sales value, the city of Ontario privately tendered a $250 million offer to Los Angeles World Airports for transfer of the airport’s title and operational control. That offer included the city assuming $75 million of the outstanding bond debt obligations for past improvements to the airport, $125 million in future passenger facility charges to be realized at the airport and $50 million cash.
Los Angeles World Airport officials scoffed at the $250 million figure, pointing to the $560 million in improvements made to the airport since 1967 utilizing revenues generated at both Ontario and Los Angeles International Airports, Federal Aviation Administration grants, and proceeds from bonds issued by the city of Los Angeles at Los Angeles World Airports’ direction.
Last year, Los Angeles World Airports commissioned an appraisal of Ontario Airport by the consulting firm of Leigh Fisher, which pegged the airport as being worth at least $243 million and as much as $605 million, depending on cash flow expectations over the next half century.
Los Angeles World Airport officials indicated that bargaining toward an eventual sale would start at the high end of the estimate, i.e., $605 million. At one point, Gina Marie Lindsey, the executive director of Los Angeles World Airports, indicated  that a buyer, public or private, would need to put up $560 million, an amount equal to the investment in improvements made at the airport over the last 45 years while Los Angeles has had operational control there. Privately, Los Angeles World Airports officials have suggested Los Angeles would be amenable to selling the airport to Ontario for $450 million.
Ontario officials, who created with the county of San Bernardino the Ontario International Airport Authority last year as an entity intended to eventually wrest ownership of the airport from Los Angeles and subsequently manage its operations, maintain Los Angeles World Airports has greatly inflated the airport’s value.
The Ontario International Airport Authority recently commissioned Oliver Wyman, a New York-based consulting firm, to review and refute Leigh Fisher’s estimation of the airport’s fair market value. Oliver Wyman delivered a document that met Ontario’s specifications, one that said the property was not worth the  $243 million to $605 million Leigh Fisher derived but rather had a breathtaking value below zero – i.e., from negative-$78 million to negative-$104 million.
“The low valuation for ONT (the Federal Aviation Administration acronym for Ontario International), even under a privatization valuation approach, should come as no surprise to anyone who has analyzed ONT’s finances, high airport charges, competitive position and passenger traffic trends,” according to Oliver Wyman.
Oliver Wyman paints a picture of such dire prospects at Ontario Airport that it leaves the reader of  the report questioning why any entity would be interested in acquiring it.
No investor using sound investment guidance criteria would consider purchasing the airport, Oliver Wyman maintains. The average rate of return for the S&P 500 since the Great Depression has stood at 7.1 percent annually. Even if the airport were to be valued at the minimum $243 million Leigh Fisher envisioned for it, it would still need to garner $17.25 million in profit per year to meet the S&P average, which Oliver Wyman asserts, “is inconceivable… based on ONT’s revenue and operating profile.”
In fact, the airport is incapable of generating any profit whatsoever, Oliver Wyman maintained, in that expenses will outrun revenues.
Oliver Wyman said Leigh Fisher’s notion that a private operator can take over Ontario Airport and drive down its per enplaned-passenger charge – which at $12.68  is one of the highest in the nation  –  and then operate successfully charging $10 per passenger was highly questionable.
Oliver Wyman pitched the concept of making a public agency-to-public agency transfer of the airport for no consideration. That option was more viable, Oliver Wyman wrote, than selling the airport to a private operator, which the firm said, would not be able to run the facility at a profit.
In delivering the report, Oliver Wyman acknowledged it was hampered by not having available, and not being able to rely upon, financial documents relating to Ontario Airport’s operations that are in the exclusive possession of Los Angeles World Airports.
This week, in a letter to Lindsey dated April 10 and stamped “privileged and confidential” but which was immediately leaked to the press, Ontario City Manager Chris Hughes referenced Lindsey’s heretofore undisclosed $474.5 million counteroffer to sell the airport made in response to Ontario’s $250 million purchase proposal. Hughes rejected that counteroffer and threatened legal action, stating, “LAWA’s approach in this matter…leaves Ontario with no meaningful option other than to pursue its legal remedies arising from LAWA’s conduct in connection with the airport.” On Thursday April 11, the Washington, D.C.-based law firm of  Sheppard Mullin Richter & Hampton  filed a 67-page administrative claim against the city of Los Angeles and Los Angeles World Airports charging them with chronic mismanagement of the airport. The claim seeks to abrogate the 1967 joint powers agreement between the two cities.

Musser Outfoxes Filippi

(April 12) Upland Councilman Gino Filippi this week was on the cusp, or so it appeared, of achieving a significant breakthrough in preparing for his future political efforts.
Previously, the city had adopted campaign contribution limits that restricted elected officeholders from receiving more than $2,000 from any single donor per four-year election cycle.
In Upland, all elected officials – the mayor, city council members and treasurer – are elected to four-year terms.
Before the campaign contribution ordinance was passed in 2011, Filippi garnered election to the city council in 2010. In 2012, with two years yet remaining in his term as councilman, Filippi ran for mayor against incumbent Ray Musser. Also in the race was Musser and Filippi’s council colleague, Debbie Stone.
Filippi proved to be by far the most prolific fundraiser, taking in $91,722.47 to fuel his mayoral campaign. Musser brought in a total of $27,625.56. Stone ran her campaign on $4,748 in donations. A number of Filippi’s donors provided him with money that neared or equaled the $2,000 per entity donation limit. Despite his fundraising prowess, Filippi lost to Musser.
In 2014, Filippi has intentions of running for reelection to the council again, perhaps positioning himself for another mayoral run in 2016.
In recent months, Filippi has posited an argument that the spirit of campaign contribution reform involved the intent of curtailing the influence of donors per election rather than per four-year term. In this way, Filippi asserted, those seeking or holding council office who are also vying for mayor two years after a council run, should be eligible to receive $2,000 per donor for each election, for the council and for mayor.
Musser did not see it that way, arguing that the $2,000 contribution limit from any particular donor was intended to limit the donor’s influence over the politician, or politicians, in question. For that reason the $2,000 restriction should stay in place, Musser asserted, regardless of whether the politician runs just once every four years or twice every four years.
In March, the city council took up the issue but failed to come to a clear consensus, and tabled the matter to give the city attorney and the council advisory committee an opportunity to review the regulations to determine what the advisory committee, which had recommended the limitations to the council in 2011, had intended.
This week the city council was provided with the input of the advisory committee and the city attorney which basically called for Upland’s campaign contribution ordinance to impose the limit per election.
A divided council, with Glen Bozar and Brendan Brandt joining with Filippi, voted to direct the city attorney to redraft the ordinance, changing the limitation to each election a candidate is involved in, so that the proposed changed ordinance can be brought back for a vote at a later meeting.
At that point, it appeared that Filippi had obtained an outcome that was in keeping with him being able to exploit his fundraising talent  in future elections.  But sly Mayor Musser, who has been a member of the city council since 1998, utilized his control of the gavel and mastery of parliamentary procedure to outfox Filippi.
Before moving on to the next order of business, Musser inquired of the city attorney whether he could make a motion at that point to reduce the contribution limit to go into the newly drafted ordinance. He was told that he could indeed do so. Thereupon, Musser made a motion to reduce the contribution limit from $2,000 to $1,000. That vote passed by a 3-2 margin, with Musser, Stone and Bozar supporting it.
In this way, the redrafted campaign limitation ordinance to be considered by the council will have the effect of attenuating one of Filippi’s major political assets, that is, his ability to draw substantial money to his electioneering efforts.
Musser, who of late has been belittled and lampooned by his critics and political foes as a doddering yokel who is  unable to keep up with the pace of events or his younger council colleagues, showed with his adroit maneuver that he remains a political force to be reckoned with and even faster  on his parliamentary feet than those decades his junior.
Asked what he thought of being outmaneuvered by Musser with his add-on ploy, Filippi noted that the actual redrafted ordinance has yet to come before the council and he hinted that there will still be an opportunity to liberalize the campaign contribution law.
“This isn’t over yet,” Filippi said.

GT Mayor: Past Neglect Of Economic Development Necessitates City Tax

(April 12) Grand Terrace Mayor Walt Stanckiewitz recently defended his administration’s handling of the challenges facing the city, asserting that under his watch the city has defied doomsayers that predicted the town’s demise because of a perpetually weak revenue base that has been worsened in recent years by the economic downturn.
Stanckiewitz, who zoomed into the mayoralty in some measure on the strength of his criticism of the city’s historical reliance on diverting money from its redevelopment agency to shore up its general fund, was nevertheless critical of the state’s wholesale dissolution of municipal redevelopment agencies in 2011, which he said puts Grand Terrace at a disadvantage.
Moreover, the mayor said he was determined to go hat in hand to the city’s residents later this year to request that they approve some form of tax to provide the city with more substantial operating revenue.
Though the county Local Agency Formation Commission did not oppose Grand Terrace’s incorporation in 1978, the commission’s staff was skeptical of the city’s ability to generate sufficient tax revenue to sustain itself as a municipality. From the outset, the city’s limited population and its geographic isolation  which discourages outsiders from traveling through it translated into a severely limited number of shoppers frequenting Grand Terrace’s modest commercial district.
Today, among San Bernardino County’s 24 incorporated cities, Grand Terrace is the third smallest population-wise, with 12,040 residents. It ranks 24th as a producer of tax revenue of all sorts, such that it has the most meager of the county’s 24 municipal budgets. The city’s financial status as a municipality being outhustled by practically every other incorporated city in Southern California for tax revenue clashes with the image the city has enjoyed otherwise. In 2007, Money magazine ranked Grand Terrace as one of the United States’ “Top 100 Cities to Live In.”
For years, under the stewardship of former city manager Tom Schwab, the city made a practice of diverting a sizeable amount of the Grand Terrace Redevelopment Agency’s available funding into the city’s general fund, using that money to defray a portion of municipal operations.
Schwab, who began with the city in 1984 as a finance department employee and became city manager in 1989, left as city manager in 2008, which corresponded with Stanckiewitz’s election to the city council. Stanckiewitz was outspokenly critical of Schwab’s use of redevelopment money to fund city operations and in 2010, successfully ran for mayor as a municipal and financial reform candidate in a campaign which made frequent reference to Schwab’s diversion of redevelopment money.
Upon becoming mayor, however, Stanckiewitz was given a very dire assessment of the city’s financial standing and in his first state of the city speech just a few months after becoming mayor he raised the specter of disincorporating the city and returning the 3.502 square miles within its city limits to the county for administration. Simultaneously, the city was hit with the state’s dissolution of redevelopment agencies as well as being informed by the county auditor-controller that in 2008-09 and 2009-10, the auditor-controller’s office, which handled the apportioning of state redevelopment pass-through funding, had mistakenly credited Grand Terrace with $2.294 million that should have gone to the redevelopment agency for the San Bernardino Valley Municipal Water District. That overpayment was later recalculated to actually have been $2,052,000. Grand Terrace has since entered into an agreement to repay that money over ten years, tantamount to  a $205,200 shrinking of the city’s yearly budget for the next decade.
Stanckiewitz stridently assailed the state for the destruction of  redevelopment as a tool available to his city.  That raised questions about Stanciewitz’s earlier attacks on Schwab for his creative use of redevelopment funding. Stanckiewitz’s growing chorus of critics noted that as mayor he was put in the position of having to deal with the city’s intrinsic financial shortcomings and was fairing no better than had Schwab, who for 19 years had sustained the city. In the light of harsh financial reality, it was said, Stanckiewitz’s criticism’s of Schwab’s approach were not only politically motivated, but self-delusional and mean-spirited, as well.
Stanckiewitz rejects those portrayals, maintaining that Schwab’s formula was one of using the redevelopment agency as a crutch, such that the city never adjusted to walking on its own.
“The truth is we never did develop an adequate tax base and relied heavily, too heavily, on our redevelopment agency to cover general fund expenditures,” Stanckiewitz said. “Mr Schwab’s strategy was to substitute available redevelopment funding for economic development. We are weaning ourselves from [our financial dependency on] the redevelopment agency. When you are as dependent on your redevelopment agency to shore up your general fund as Grand Terrace was, that is not something you can do overnight.  This is something the state is forcing us to do, but we have been cutting and cutting for years, so we are not in a position where this shocked us. We are not, for example, as hard hit as the city of San Bernardino. It is basically a structural deficit. We have got to address those problems that were identified by LAFCO [the county’s local agency formation commission] when we formed as a city 35 years ago. We were told by LAFCO that we don’t have the tax base we need to hold together as a city. Now we are faced with the cold hard facts. What we will now need to do is go out with a tax measure.”
Stanckiewitz said he believes a vote can be scheduled for later this year to get the tax in place, if the voters approve it, by January 1.
“We could have that on the ballot in November if we hit all the time lines right,” he said.
He said he had no fear of asking the people he represents to tax themselves for the city’s sake.
“I think if we lay it out right and explain it  to people and involve citizens in the city so they know the whole process and give them the choice and say, ‘This is what it will cost to keep the services you are accustomed to. If you don’t approve it, we will be providing you less service,’” Stanckiewitz said.
In fact, Stanckiewitz said, the reductions that will be necessitated if no tax is imposed will result in Grand Terrace residents “receiving less service than if we were part of the county. We need to lay it out and show people we are not asking for pie in the sky to start grandiose programs but just want to maintain our little city to the level of service we are accustomed to having.”
While he is now the mayor and the chickens are coming home to roost, Stanckiewitz said, he is not the one to blame for the city’s long slide into the fiscal morass. He insisted Schwab was the culprit.
‘Thirty years passed and nobody did anything,” he said.
As the guy in office now, Stanckiewitz said, he is looking for long term solutions. The foremost prospect he sees is expanding the city’s commercial base and generating more sales tax.
“The city needs to put a welcome mat out,” he said. “I’m not sure the city was real open to a lot of commercial development. Once they found out how they could use the redevelopment agency to divert money into the general fund, doing commercial development became secondary. We had some attempts ten or twelve years ago with the Outdoor Adventure Center, with lakes and businesses around it. I’m not sure anyone was dedicated to that. At other times, city officials were talking about Lowes [i.e., a hardware store]. What it came down to is if you don’t have the traffic counts you can’t get businesses to look at you seriously. If you don’t have commercial development, you don’t get traffic counts. Stater Bros. took it upon themselves to put in a new store and a new center that held out the promise of bringing in even more. The world went sour and they are having a tough time attracting business to come in there. In the old Stater Bros. center, we have had some companies look at the space there, but it all comes back to the traffic counts aren’t there. There is not an overnight fix. They had thirty years to do it and it wasn’t done.”
The city is still afloat, but struggling to dogpaddle and keep its head above water, the mayor said.
“We will end the current fiscal year with a balanced budget and some reserves, how much we are not sure,” he said. “Next year could be the challenge. Given the redevelopment agency takeaways by the California Department of Finance, we will be short in the general fund. Our reserves cannot fill the hole. We’ve got a budget workshop coming up on April 23, which should give us a clearer picture relative to what the state is doing with the redevelopment agency takeaways.”

Chino Airport Contamination Monitoring Tab Mounting

(April 12) The cost of monitoring the spread of contamination from Chino Airport has escalated.
This week, the county board of supervisors upped its contract with an environmental services company from $964,100 to $1,695,880 for work relating to an assessment of the extent of the underground pollution at and around the airfield.
San Bernardino-based Tetra Tech, Inc. was given a previous contract for that work, necessitated by known contamination of the water table around the airport, including a perchloroethylene and trichloroethene (PCE/TCE) plume. Subsequently, it was discovered that fifty-one drums of what is believed to have been napalm were buried at Chino Airport decades ago and remained there until they were discovered in 2010, according to documents in the possession of the Sentinel.
Leakage from those drums partially accounts for the pollution of the area’s aquifer, technicians say.
On the afternoon of July 22, 2010, three buried drums were discovered at the airport during trenching for installation of a storm drain pipeline for a new Southern California Edison facility. The county of San Bernardino Department of Airports was notified and it contacted the county fire department’s hazardous materials division and Tetra Tech, with which the county has an ongoing contract for environmental assessment.  Tetra Tech retained Double Barrel, a commercial hazardous materials emergency responder, to assess the situation.
Additional drums were discovered that day and by sunset on July 22, 2010, eight buried drums had been removed from the excavation. The drums did not have lids and contained soil on top of a tan resinous material. The contents of the drums were field tested using a chemical identification kit and determined to be a non-explosive, flammable, non-corrosive, organic resin-type material.
Soil samples were delivered to Microbac Laboratory in Riverside for analysis. Results of those tests indicated that high concentrations of benzene were present in all of the samples. Benzene concentrations ranging from 1,600 milligrams/kilogram (mg/kg) to 6,800 mg/kg were detected in the resinous material in the drums. The benzene concentration in the soil sample was 170 mg/kg. Also detected were toluene, ethylbenzene, xylene, styrene, 1,2,4-trimethylbenzene, and naphthalene. The tan resinous material appeared to be a jellied fuel mixture.
On July 28, 2010, a geophysical survey was conducted in an effort to locate any additional buried drums. During the survey, anomalies were found in several areas to the east and west of the original excavation, and were marked as possible targets for further investigation. Tetra Tech formulated a removal strategy and submitted it to the California Regional Water Quality Control Board office in Riverside on August 9, 2010 and the staff for the board provided same-day verbal approval of that plan.  Excavation and removal of the remaining drums was conducted between August 16 and August 25, 2010. A total of 51 drums, several aluminum canisters and pieces of wood were removed from the excavation and placed into six vapor tight closed top roll-off bins. Excavated soil without obvious contamination was stockpiled and additional soil was excavated from beneath the drums, placed in stockpiles and covered. The resulting excavation measured approximately 100 feet from east to west and 20 feet from north to south. The bottom of the excavation varied from 10 to 15 feet below ground surface.
Well prior to these events, on October 17, 2006, the San Bernardino County Board of Supervisors approved a $200,000 contract with Tetra Tech to conduct a ground water assessment of the water table at the Chino Airport and investigate possible sources of contamination from the airport property. On September 11, 2007, the board approved a $200,000 amendment to extend the assessment services, including investigation, characterization, testing and quarterly report preparation required to identify and mitigate soil and water contamination together with preparing bid documents for an additional 24 months. On September 22, 2009, the board approved a $185,000 amendment to extend the assessment services an additional 12 months to continue the same efforts. A third amendment in the amount of $148,000 was approved by the board on February 15, 2011 to continue investigation, characterization, testing report preparation through February 2012 and perform historical research. On December 13, 2011, the board approved a $231,100 amendment to provide continued inspection and testing services and quarterly sampling/reports.
As a result of Tetra Tech’s work to this point, the county has now completed its required work to characterize the extent of the offsite plume and has filed a timely report with the California Regional Water Quality Control Board. The cleanup and abatement order now requires the county to do more work to investigate sources of contamination on the airport property that are contaminating the groundwater.
This week, the board voted to make a fifth amendment to the contract with Tetra Tech, Inc., increasing the total contract amount by  $731,780 from $964,100 to $1,695,880 and extending the contract through April 30, 2015 for professional services related to required compliance with the cleanup and abatement order, including historical site assessment, Phase ll environmental site assessments, environmental compliance audits and the ongoing annual monitoring program.
According to James E. Jenkins, the director of the San Bernardino County Department of Airports,  “At times, the California Regional Water Quality Control Board staff have expressed some frustration with the time being taken by the county to come into compliance with the orders. Unfortunately, this resulted in the issuance of a notice of violation on March 28, 2012. The informed and competent representation by Tetra Tech was essential to the county being released by the water board in February 2013 from the obligation to submit monthly status reports on the county’s compliance with its clean-up and abatement orders. These efforts resulted in the water board rescinding the notice of violation. Tetra Tech has proven to be a successful advocate and credible representative of the county to the California Regional Water Quality Control Board and this continued representation will be of great value to the county as it works to complete the investigation at the airport property.”
Jenkins said the contamination survey and cleanup effort at Chino Airport has been complicated by the emergence of information, such as that represented by the discovery of the drums of napalm. “At that time, neither the actual extent nor the chemical make-up of the plume was known, and little was known about contamination on the airport property,” Jenkins said. “The work started by Tetra Tech over the last 6 1/2 years has identified the extent of the plume and its chemical make-up and has identified suspected source areas of contamination. The time needed to complete this part of the work was sometimes delayed by off-site access and permitting problems, but also it appears now that the original time estimation was simply too short to complete the work required by the California Water Quality Control Board. In order to maintain compliance with the water board orders, it is now necessary to extend the contract with Tetra Tech to continue the investigation work on the airport property to locate and identify the sources of the contaminants in the plume.”
Tetra Tech will collect water samples from each of the 33 previously installed monitoring wells at and around the airport, test the samples collected; compile and evaluate the data obtained on a quarterly basis; and prepare reports as mandated by the water board.

Yucca Valley Council Refuses To Endorse Leone’s Town Commission Nominations

Robert Leone, who returned to the town council last month after a four-and-a-half year hiatus following a special election to choose resigned councilman Isaac Hagerman’s replacement, was unable to get either of his commission choices approved by his colleagues.
After outdistancing Michael Hildebrand and Jennifer Collins in the March 5 election, Leone was due to make his appointment to the park, recreation and cultural commission and planning commission. Those appointees will serve terms concurrent with Hagerman’s underlying term which Leone will now fill. That term will end in December 2014, with an election due in November 2014. Approval of a council member’s commission appointments has traditionally been a formality in Yucca Valley, where council members normally ratify one another’s appointments with little question or fanfare.
Right off, however, Leone ran into opposition when he nominated Curt Duffy to replace Hildebrand as a member of the planning commission. Not one member of the council seconded Leone’s motion to elevate Duffy. With that issue temporarily unresolved, Leone went on nominate former councilwoman Lori Herbel to the park, recreation and cultural commission. Councilman George Huntington seconded Leone’s motion, but no vote on her appointment was taken. Leone wanted Herbel to replace Collins.
When it became clear that the council would not accept Duffy, Leone relented and nominated Hildebrand to remain on the commission for the next 19 months. That motion passed unanimously.
Councilwoman Dawn Rowe said that Leone had not given adequate consideration to the several qualified applicants for the positions and that she wanted to resist a nomination process that was pre-determined and not transparent.
Mayor Merl Abel said he wanted to avoid the specter of a backroom deal that would hang over the council if it had gone along with Leone’s nominations. Huntington suggested that Duffy had not been a resident of Yucca Valley long enough to merit appointment to the planning commission.
Whereas Rowe and Abel’s statements hinted that the balance of the council’s support of Leone’s nominations would have been improper, Leone was of the opinion that his fellow council members’ stony silence in the face of his nomination of Duffy and their collective unwillingness to support either of his preferred appointments indicated connivance on their part.
“I find it very strange that all of them were on the same page and I could not even get a second to my motion so we could at least discuss Curt Duffy’s merits,” Leone said. “I think he is a very capable and intelligent person who will make decisions on a fiscal level as well as with regard to good land use. He availed himself to the town and we did not even hold a serious discussion about his qualifications. I think George Huntington said he doesn’t live here or hasn’t lived here that long. Well, he does live here and he owns a home here. I have been on the council before and I never encountered that before. It makes you wonder if a Brown Act violation took place. I don’t know that I can go that far, to say there was some behind-the-scenes collusion that took place. I don’t want to say that and I am not saying that. I am going to have to work with the rest of the council for the next 20 months and I don’t want to accuse them. It just makes you wonder why they were suddenly very silent when I made my nomination.”
The Brown Act is California’s open meeting law which prohibits a quorum of elected officials from discussing public business or arriving at a decision outside the forum of an official public hearing.
Leone said he moved to keep Hildebrand on the planning commission when it became obvious he would not be able to get Duffy approved. He said he could live with Hildebrand remaining in place.  “He’s a nice young man,” Leone said of Hildebrand. “Why not retain him? He has grown into the position. Charles McHenry was another possible choice, but he would have been a new person on the commission and would have had to backfill a lot of information.”
In an unexpected development, Hildebrand on April 8 tendered  his resignation from the planning commission, citing his increased work schedule.
So, while Leone said he would have been comfortable with Hildebrand remaining as planning commissioner, he was not prepared to keep Collins as his appointment to the parks, recreation and cultural commission.
“A lot of negative things against me came out of her mouth during the election campaign,” Leone said. “She directly accused me of things that I know were not true. She seems to be against what I stand for. That is why I wanted Lori Herbel.”
Leone said the difficulty he is having getting his commission appointments approved is probably attributable to his problematic relationship with the town manager, Mark Nuami.
He said he believes the town council has fallen too heavily Nuami’s sway and are allowing him to set the agenda for the town rather than adhering to their elected duty of developing a vision for the community and setting policy for local governance and having the city manager execute on that vision and policy.
“I just got elected to fill out the rest of Isaac Hagerman’s term for the next 19 months,” Leone said. “I think the people want a change from what we have. Mark Nuami is a bright young man and he has a lot of pull with the council. Unfortunately, a lot of his moves are duplicating the same baggage as he had in Fontana, where he was mayor. He wants to select people for the two commissions using the power of his office. I think he is running the town into the ground. He is pulling the town in a direction people don’t want to go. The town council is going along with him. They have given him a raise to almost $300,000. That has upset a lot of people in a town where the median income is somewhere between $35,000 to $42,000. At the same time the town is cutting programs. I think people believe we are spending our money on a lot of the wrong things.”
Leone said he will work to fill the two vacant commission spots as soon as possible.
“I am accepting applications for the planning commission and the parks, recreation and cultural commission, pending printed notification in the newspaper,” Leone said.

Cable Tells Upland Inflexibility On Stale Liens Will End In Lawsuit

(April 12) Bob Cable, the owner of Cable Airport in Upland, on April 8 sternly warned the Upland City Council that he is on a collision course with the city over city staff’s unwillingness to remove a long dormant lien against his property.
“We are possibly going to litigation on that,” Cable said. “I bet you don’t know. I’m here to tell you now. Upland touts itself as a business friendly city. I do not see it from where I sit. I have been working for six months to get two liens that are more than 35 years old removed. Hopefully you will end this foolishness before it costs the city a lot of money.”
Cable later explained to the Sentinel, “We are refinancing some construction loans on hangers. Wells Fargo was doing some in-depth title research and came across two liens and an operating agreement, all three of which are over 35 years old. The operating agreement gave the city the right to run the airport if we ever failed to do so. We have consistently kept the airport operating and that agreement has been removed. One of the liens was for streetlights, sidewalks and trees along Benson Avenue near the entrance to the airport. The streetlights and sidewalks were put in long ago and the trees cannot be placed there because of how close it is to being beneath the flight path and the city has given us word that it will release that lien. The other lien applies to where decades ago we built a row of hangars within six feet of the property line and the lien called for the construction of an 800 foot-long block wall there as a separation. The lien called for it to be reviewed every five years. The block wall was never constructed and the city never said anything until we brought it up. Now the city wants us to indemnify them forever. My position is that I didn’t keep up with the terms and the city did not keep up with the terms, so neither of us should be responsible and the lien itself should be null and void. Those liens are so old they should be thrown out. Nobody kept them up for 35 years, so why is it a big deal now? I want this to go away and I made every effort to inform the city of the situation and come to a reasonable resolution. The first two issues are taken care of but when we came to the second lien, the city attorney’s attitude is ‘We’ll see you in court.”
Part of the problem, Cable said, is that the city’s paramount decision making body, the city council, “doesn’t know what is going on.”
Cable continued, “Typically city staff are the only ones who know what the situation is until the day of the council meeting or just a few days before, when the council gets the staff report. And the council almost always goes with the recommendation in the staff report. Then, if that decision is to become litigious, it becomes a closed session item from there on and they remain isolated from the information they need to make an informed decision. I went there on Monday because I was pretty sure that the council at that point had no clue as to what is going on and it looks that once again they are going to end up in a situation they do not need to be in where they spend tens of thousands of dollars or hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal fees.”
The problem is exacerbated, Cable said, by the city having a new city attorney who is not fully acclimated to the city, does not have a full grasp of the situation or the city’s history and is seeking to establish her place in the municipal pecking order while simultaneously generating billable hours for her law firm.
“I don’t want to get into a lawsuit,” Cable said. “I don’t think the city wants to get into a lawsuit. Those liens are so old and neglected, I think the court will just throw them out. I’m not going to back down. I went directly before the city council because they are the ones that make the ultimate decision. We’ll see in two weeks if they make the right decision and keep the city out of a lawsuit.”
Attempts to reach Upland City Manager Stephen Dunn for  comment were unsuccessful.