Upland Council To Belatedly Consider 2013-14 Budget On August 12

(August 2) UPLAND –Belatedly, the Upland City Council will review and likely pass the city’s 2013-14 fiscal year budget on August 12.
This week the Upland Finance and Economic Development Committee reviewed city manager Stephen Dunn’s proposed spending plan for the ongoing fiscal year running from July 1 to June 30. That panel’s members, councilmen Brendan Brandt and Glenn Bozar, indicated they would recommend Dunn’s proposal to the entire city council.
Anticipating roughly $40 million in income over the entire year, Dunn had pressed the city’s department heads to budget for their divisions in such a way that the city would spend just $38.5 million through its general fund, which covers basic city operations. Dunn’s goal was to be able to salt away $1.5 million into a reserve account by the end of the fiscal year in June 2014.
After several goes at it in May and June, however, that goal was not achieved and Upland did not approve the 2012-14 budget prior to July 1, as is traditionally done. Twenty-two of San Bernardino County’s 24 cities had approved spending plans for the current fiscal year by or before June 30.
Ultimately, Dunn’s goal of preserving $1.5 million was not met. Instead, the city predicts it will take $39.37 million into the general fund while spending $38.6 million on basic operations, netting a reserve of $770,000.
Dunn acknowledged that a carryover miscalculation from last year hampered the city in meeting the $1.5 million reserve goal. He said that last year $980,000 in funding for the police department had been inadvertently withdrawn from the 2012-13 budget. That amount was restored to the baseline figures the police department had to work within in establishing its 2013-14 budget. Dunn said police chief Jeff Mendenhall succeeded in paring $300,000 of the $980,000 that had been returned to the police department budget.
Total operating funds for the city, including the general fund and spending outside the general fund such as Upland’s various enterprise and special funds, will total $106.23 million in expenditures.
The city will spend $8,759,670 on capital improvement projects.
The city will shell out $108,000 in merit increases, will increase its overtime budget by $130,490, increase fringe benefit payouts by $41,190, increase its contribution to the state employees retirement fund by $165,840, set another $164,780 aside for increases in retiree benefits, increase its outlay for fleet maintenance by $191,030, and up its contribution into its self-funded liability account by $300,000. The city will see its legal fees decrease by $1.5 million due to the settlement of litigation it had with the county over flood control issues at the Colonies Project,. The city also obtained, Dunn said, $1,047,950 in savings as a result of labor concessions.
While the city’s animal services division will generate $415,750 in income, its operating expenses will run to $895,540.
On the revenue side, while the city anticipates a $351,800 increase in property tax proceeds and a $569,850 increase in sales taxes due primarily to new retail outlets at the Colonies Crossroads Center, Dunn said the city will see a $69,890 decrease in fees due to the anticipated drop in fee-generating services provided by the police department and a $20,000 decrease in revenue from development services map and plan check activity.

Fontana Extends Hunt’s Contract Five Years

(August 2) FONTANA – The city of Fontana has extended its contract with city manager Ken Hunt for another five years.
Hunt, the successor to a string of notable city managers in Fontana, including Jack Ratelle, John O’Sullivan, and Greg Devereaux, has been with the city in the capacity of top administrator since 1999. Prior to that, he was with the city for nine years, serving in the capacities of city auditor, budget officer, purchasing manager, finance director and human resources director.
In extending Hunt’s contract, his annual salary was upped from to $264,600 to $277,000.

SB County Will Host World’s Largest Solar Plant By December

(August 2) IVANPAH—What will be the largest solar plant in the world when it becomes operational in December is nearing completion at the northeast corner of San Bernardino County.
The $2.2 billion Ivanpah Solar Electric Generating System is a joint venture by BrightSource Energy, Google and NRG Energy, located 110 miles east of Barstow, five miles west of the California-Nevada border. According to the California Energy Commission, which licensed the Ivanpah project in 2010 in keeping with the state’s goal of promoting clean renewable energy and having 33 percent of the state’s energy produced from such sources by 2020, construction is 95 percent complete. The 377-megawatt plant, consisting of three 459-foot tall towers and 170,000 heliostats, i.e., mirrors reflecting solar energy to the towers, on 5.3 square miles of federal land, will provide sufficient energy for 140,000 households and will connect to both Pacific Gas and Electric and Southern California Edison’s systems.
A significant portion of the funding for the project consists of a $1.6 billion loan guarantee by the U.S. Department of Energy.

Hesperia Code Enforcement Policy Levies Hefty Fines On Animal Rescuers

(July 26) With the dog days of summer upon us, the number of dying stray animals is on the rise, due in part to the region’s seasonal unforgiving sultriness.
In Hesperia, one of San Bernardino County’s hottest cities, the already-elevated incidence of neglected animals expiring due to exposure to the elements is exacerbated by the municipal code and city policy.
The city of Hesperia runs the Hesperia Animal Shelter, which despite admirable intentions, is inadequate to the task of humanely dealing with the demands of a 73-square mile city and the widespread desire that the facility be maintained as a no-kill asylum for lost pets, strays or unwanted animals.
Simultaneously, despite the consideration that Hesperia features as much or more property zoned for “residential agricultural” use as nearly any other city or town in the county, the city nonetheless enforces a strict limit on how many pets a homeowner may have according to lot size. Under the threat of draconian code enforcement action and heavy fines, homeowners have in many case chosen to abandon animals that have come under their care or ownership.
One case in point – that of the city’s code enforcement effort against Esther and Janet Duran –  illustrates how the city’s policies and overzealousness in the enforcement of its codes lacks sensitivity to not only humane considerations with regard to citizens efforts to protect animals but the ill-advised and ultimately costly lengths city officials have gone to in enforcing those coldhearted  rules.
In January 2010, the Hesperia code enforcement division took up a case that to all appearances was indistinguishable from the thousands of others in which the municipality used its authority, bankroll and control of the code enforcement process to overwhelm its citizens and obtain an inevitable adjudication in the city’s favor.
The division’s focus in this case was a property on Redwood Avenue owned by Esther Duran. which her daughter, Janet, was using as a temporary rescue shelter for horses that would otherwise have been sent to slaughterhouses for euthanization or processing for the dog food or glue manufacturing industries.
Janet Duran, an ambulance driver, in 2004 took up the cause of doomed horses, including wild mustangs run to ground by cowboys in Nevada and Arizona and ones being sold by their owners at auction, ostensibly to buyers interested in using them for horsemeat for as little as $5, $10, or $15 a head.
The Redwood property prior to city incorporation was zoned for agricultural use. The post-incorporation zoning was agricultural residential and the Durans were permitted under the city’s code to have up to six horses on the property per its acreage.
On January 13, 2010, a team of city employees that included two code enforcement officers, four armed sheriff’s department deputies in flak jackets and two animal control officers descended on the Durans’ property. One of the code enforcement officers served Esther Duran with papers and the team then seized three horses and five dogs, one of which was a stray whose owner the Durans were seeking to locate. Both Esther and Janet were cited and slapped with a total of $129,000 in fees, which upon the city’s processing protocol were ratcheted up into liens against the property. Those liens resulted in Esther Duran’s mortgage increasing from $1,400 to $4,700 per month.
Unwilling to take the city’s action lying down, the Durans hired Upland-based attorney Louis G. Fazzi. Fazzi brought several principles to bear which the city had in the past routinely overlooked in its enforcement efforts, including compliance with the city’s own codes, which actually allowed for the presence of up to three more horses than the Durans had on the property on January 13, 2010 and up to five dogs, as well as the right to due process. The city’s response was to seek a series of delays, which had the effect of increasing the Durans’ legal costs while the underlying issue – the return of their animals – remained unresolved.
Despite the cost, the Durans did not simply duck out of the fight. Fazzi persisted on their behalf, successfully removing the matter to federal court. Still, the city told the court the Durans were maintaining a substandard property and that the animals for that reason should not be returned to them. Fazzi maintained that the property was up to code and in compliance in all regards. In March 2012, a court-appointed independent inspector went over the Redwood property with a fine-tooth comb, concluding the property was indeed up to code.
In April 2012, U.S. District Court Judge John E. McDermott ruled that the city’s action against the Durans was improper and that their animals would have to be returned to them. Fazzi immediately brought a motion to have McDermott consider whether the entire process the Durans had been subjected to was unconstitutional.
While McDermott’s ruling was pending, the city offered the Durans a $200,000 settlement. The tendering of that offer, and the Durans’ acceptance of it, put the matter to rest, preventing a potentially precedent-setting ruling that would prohibit the city from continuing to employ the same tactics against other city residents.
There is no shortage of half-acre, one-acre, two-acre and even five acre and ten acre residential agricultural properties in Hesperia. Those lot sizes have not prevented the large scale demise of abandoned animals to the brutal elements in Hesperia or them being put to sleep by animal shelter workers.
Meanwhile, agricultural residential property owners and advocates of a more humane approach toward animal control are campaigning to have Hesperia change its animal control regulations and code enforcement tactics. Specifically, those advocates want reform that would  relax the city’s regulations regarding the number of animals per acre, so that animal rescuers would be free to take in, care for, feed and potentially adopt more animals, including ones incarcerated at the city’s shelter facing inevitable slaughter.

Over 400 Cal Water Agencies Call Fish Protection Unreasonable

(July 26) Nine San Bernardino County water agencies have obtained the backing of more than 400 of their counterparts from around the state in propounding an argument that the federal government’s expansion of the designated critical habitat of the Santa Ana Sucker Fish is unreasonable.
The Bear Valley Mutual Water Co. in Redlands; Big Bear Municipal Water District; the city of Redlands; the city of San Bernardino Municipal Water Department; the East Valley Water District in Highland; the San Bernardino Valley Municipal Water District; the San Bernardino Valley Water Conservation District; the West Valley Water District in Rialto and the Yucaipa Valley Water District last year joined with three of their equivalents in Riverside County,  the city of Riverside; the Riverside County Flood Control and Water Conservation District; and the Western Municipal Water District in Riverside; in making a case with the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals to reverse U.S. District Court Judge James V. Selna’s approval of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service’s plan for protective measures for the Santa Ana Sucker,  a fish that dwells in the Santa Ana River and which federal  biologists say is threatened with possible extinction. The Santa Ana River, which has its headwaters at the base of the San Bernardino Mountains and then winds 96 miles through San Bernardino County into Riverside County and through Orange County to the Pacific Ocean, is the highest quality habitat available to the Santa Ana sucker.
In October 2012, Selna upheld Fish & Wildlife’s December 2010 plan to double to more than  9,000 acres the land along the Santa Ana River in San Bernardino and Riverside counties that was designated as critical Sucker habitat. The agencies sued the service in 2011 over the approval of that plan, which calls for a limit on the amount of water that water districts can draw from the river, a limitation intended to protect the typically six-inch long fish inhabiting the river.
The nine San Bernardino County agencies and three Riverside County agencies are  represented by attorney Greg Wilkinson, who maintains that the Fish & Wildlife strategy of doubling what is deemed critical habitat for the fish will significantly complicate the water agencies’ functions of drawing water for domestic consumption and agriculture, groundwater recharge and flood control measures along the river. The limitations are most acute, according to Wilkinson, at the Seven Oaks Dam, some four miles northeast of Redlands and east of Highland.
The Fish & Wildlife agency insists sufficient water must be released from Seven Oaks Dam and remain in the river to maintain a flow to stir up the riverbed and allow the fish to reproduce and sustain itself.
But purveyors of water in both counties maintain they have already made herculean efforts to safeguard the fish and that the sucker’s numbers are not threatened at present. They contend they are keeping faith with a conservation plan previously certified by Fish & Wildlife as sufficient, which reserved 400,000 acres for sucker habitat and protects 145 other species. Wilkinson said that Fish & Wildlife officials impermissibly reneged on the acceptance of that approach and the agencies are being squeezed, on one hand, by federal officials, and on the other by the California Fish and Game Commission, which has listed the Delta smelt as endangered, leading to limitations on the importation of water from the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta in Northern California.
Wilkinson drummed up the support of 440 water agencies in the state, banned together under the aegis of the Association of California Water Agencies, which filed a brief with the U.S. Court of Appeals on June 3, highlighting the water agencies’ collective misgivings with regard to the doubling of the critical habitat area for the Santa Ana Sucker, which dines in large measure on algae. Expansion of the habitat violates provisions within the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 [NEPA], the water agencies contend, in that the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service plan relating to the Sucker approved by Judge Selna dispensed with the cooperation of the various agencies involved. NEPA requires that federal, state and local agencies cooperate on environmental plans.
Wilkinson charged the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service with having purposefully avoided consultations with the agencies impacted by the plan while the plan was being drafted.
Wilkinson wants the matter heard by the entire Ninth Circuit Court Bench rather than just a three member panel thereof, as is normally the case. He intends to argue that the steps already taken to protect the Santa Ana Sucker have been extraordinary and that the additional measures the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is insisting upon  will have other equally, or even more, onerous consequences to the environment by depriving outlying areas of the watershed of water and/or entailing an expensive and potentially wasteful and damaging effort to import water from elsewhere, involving threats to endangered species at other locations  and “the entirety of the human environment, not just the protection of listed species.”
According to Wilkinson, the protective measures the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service is calling for would in time result in the water agencies sustaining more than $4 billion in additional costs due to the individual and collective needs to make other arrangements to serve their customers, including but not limited to sinking wells and obtaining water elsewhere, such as from Northern California and the Colorado River.
While the Santa Ana River is the prime habitat and breeding grounds for the Sucker,  a genetically identical example of the fish is present in the Angeles National Forest’s San Gabriel River, in portions of its west, north and east forks, all of which are located in Los Angeles County.
Conservationists and environmentalists  believe the Fish & Wildlife Service’s designation is critical to the sucker fish’s prospects for long term survival in that the fish needs gravel-size rocks upon which to lay its eggs and the protection measures in the plan include areas that meet that criteria in both the perennial part of the Santa Ana River and the Santa Ana River Wash.

Leon Gets Most Votes In Assembly Race But Fails To Shut Out Rodriguez

(July 26) Ontario Mayor Paul Leon on Tuesday outpolled all eight of his rivals in the race to succeed Norma Torres in representing Pomona, Chino, Montclair, Ontario and a portion of Fontana in the California Assembly, bringing in 25.1 percent of all of the votes cast across the district, which straddles portions of Los Angeles and San Bernardino Counties.
Despite his showing, Leon cannot lay claim to a spot in the state legislature yet.  Because none of the nine running in Tuesday’s race captured a majority of the vote, a run-off between Leon and second place finisher Freddie Rodriguez will now follow.
Leon, formerly a Republican but more recently registered as an independent, bested  Rodriguez, a Pomona city councilman who is also a Democrat. In his strong showing, Rodriguez racked up 21.6 percent of the vote in both counties.
The special election was held on Tuesday, July 23 to replace Torres as assemblywoman after she was elected 32nd District State Senator in May. The May special election came about because Gloria Negrete-McLeod had to leave the State Senate when she was elected to Congress in November.
Though Leon prevailed this week, his work in beating Rodriguez in the run-off is cut out for him. Despite his being newly registered as an independent, Leon has long been identified as a Republican and in fact ran as a Republican in March and May against Torres in the race to succeed Negrete-McLeod. In that Senate race as in the-yet-to-be decided assembly race, Republicans are at a disadvantage because of the overwhelming registration lead Democrats have in both the 32nd State Senate and 52nd Assembly districts. In the 32nd, 48 percent of those registered to vote are Democrats and 28 percent are Republicans. In the 52nd, 46 percent are registered as Democrats and 29 percent are registered as Republicans.
On Tuesday, seven of the nine candidates were Democrats – Rodriguez, Jason Rothman, Danielle Soto, Doris Wallace, Manuel Saucedo, Tom Haughey, and Paul Avila. One, Dorothy Peneda, was a Republican.
For Leon to prevail in the September rematch against Rodriguez, he will need to make a convincing appeal to independent-minded Democrats, while maintaining his residual appeal as a former Republican to convert to his cause the voters Pineda picked up. Pineda placed third in the polling, capturing 2,211 votes in both counties, or nearly 14.5 percent.
The assumption of many political observers and strategists is that nearly all of the votes that this week went to Democrats Rothman, Soto, Wallace, Saucedo, Haughey and Avila – totaling 38.8 percent of the ballots cast – will fall to Rodriguez in the run-off. Prior to Tuesday, the Democratic Party heavily invested in Rodriguez, providing him with over $60,000 in direct contributions and facilitating independent expenditures that bankrolled mailers attacking Leon as a Republican wolf in an independent sheep’s clothing.
Leon did particularly well on Tuesday in San Bernardino County, capturing 3,041 votes, or 28.66 percent there. In Los Angeles County, he tied for second with Rothman, the son of Pomona’s mayor. Both pulled 787 votes or 18.99 percent. Rodriguez won in his native county, taking in 1,470 votes for an impressive 31.73 percent. In San Bernardino County, Rodriguez polled 1,822 votes, or 17.17 percent.

Needles Offers City Manager In Desert Hot Springs Top Job

(July 26) The Needles City Council this week offered controversial Desert Hot Springs City Manager Rick Daniels a contract as its new city manager, though Daniels’ acceptance of that offer had not been made by press time.
Daniels, if he is hired, will replace David Brownlee, whose contract is not set to expire until next May.
Daniels will not be able to take on the helm in Needles, San Bernardino County’s smallest city population-wise at 4,844, until he resolves loose ends in Desert Hot Springs, a municipality of 25,938 in adjoining Riverside County.
Daniels’ pending departure from Desert Hot Springs comes in the midst of an increasingly rocky tenure there. While he appeared to maintain the support of three-fifths of the city council in the Riverside County City, two of that panel’s members have grown increasingly hostile toward him in recent months.
Daniels gravitated into the municipal management field in a somewhat unorthodox fashion after having been an executive with Waste Management, Inc. He came to Desert Hot Springs officials’ attention after he founded a company in the late 1990s, Mine Reclamation Corporation, with which he proposed to operate a landfill within the abandoned Eagle Mountain Mine next to Joshua Tree National Park, into which he proposed depositing millions of tons of trash from Los Angeles transported to the site by train. The venture was dropped when the Supreme Court ruled against the environmental certification for the plan. Along the way Daniels had assumed the position of president and CEO of the Coachella Valley Economic Partnership, a consortium of business owners, financiers and developers. From that position he obtained the post of top administrator with the Salton Sea Authority. It was his experience in this public sector position that he used to leverage obtaining the Desert Hot Springs city manager position.
While with Desert Hot Springs, one of the poorest cities in the state, Daniels pulled a seeming rabbit out of his hat, undertaking infrastructure improvements that previously seemed beyond the city’s means, including paving 34 miles of city streets. He then undertook to build a municipal Health and Wellness and Aquatic Center. The cost of that project ran to $20 million, however. Daniels’ spending spree has ultimately left Desert Hot Springs with an intractable debt in the form of more than $30 million in delinquent bonds  and an ongoing yearly operation cost at the health center of more than $1 million.
In 2010, Daniels ventured $250,000 in taxpayer funds to lay the ground for and promote a music festival that never came off. Though he initially said the city would recover the money from the concert series’ promoter, the city never did so.
Also in 2010, Daniels narrowly averted being consumed by a scandal after he had a falling out with Linda Green, a woman he had brought to work in Desert Hot Springs first as a media liaison and later as community services director. At a conference in San Diego, an inebriated Daniels groped the married Green, resulting in a claim against the city which was ultimately resolved with Green departing from the city with $99,328.16 in severance pay and Daniels completing a two month stint in an alcohol rebab clinic while assistant city manager Jason Simpson filled in for him.
After  councilman Karl Baker was replaced by Adam Sanchez, Daniels’ support on the council began to erode. More aggressive questioning of Daniels’ policies took place, prompting Daniels to file a claim against Sanchez and councilman Russell Betts in which he claimed they were harassing him with emails and phone calls after official city business hours. The city’s insurance company formally rejected Daniels’ claim.
In June, city finance director Terrence Beaman resigned after a lengthy dispute with Daniels with regard to Daniels’ proposal to utilize $4 million in city reserves to cover a $4 million deficit. After the municipal and financial management consulting firm Urban Futures assessed Desert Hot Springs’ economic condition, it concluded the city was in a deteriorating financial state that would lead to insolvency within 12 to 24 months.
In April, Daniels, one of the highest-paid city managers in California with a total annual compensation package exceeding $300,000, sought to leave Desert Hot Springs, applying for the position of county administrator position in Clackamas County in Oregon. He was selected as one of three finalists in the competition for that position and as the interview process advanced, Daniels maintained a cover story to the effect that he was merely vacationing in Oregon, where he was raised and attended college. At the final stages of the Clackamas County selection process at the end of June, it appeared that Daniels had the job and it then became publicly known that he was gearing up to leave Desert Hot Springs. Daniels’ move to Oregon fell through, however, when Donald Krupp, one of the other two finalists, was given the county administrator’s post last week.
According to Needles City Clerk Dale Jones, Daniels was offered the position of Needles city manager but the terms of the hiring were not fully specified. Jones said negotiations between the Needles  city manager search committee, consisting of council members Linda Kidd, Jim Lopez and Tom Darcy were yet ongoing and that she anticipated a contract would be ready for the full council to vote on at its August 13 meeting.
It would appear that Daniels will be taking a substantial pay cut if he comes to Needles. The budgeted range for the city manager in Needles is $129,000 to $132,000 per year. Brownlee, who was elevated into a caretaker city manager post in 2010 when previous city manager Bill Way’s contract was not extended, is not paid according to that schedule, however, and receives $50.47 per hour based on furlough-truncated annual hours of 1,976. All employees in Needles are required to take furloughs. Brownlee’s annual salary is therefore $99,728.72. If the furloughs were to be discontinued and he were to work a full 2080-hour work year, he would be earning $104,977.60 per annum.
Brownlee was the city’s assistant city manager and utilities service manager at the time he was upgraded to acting city manager.
Brownlee’s current contract runs from June 1 of this year through May 31, 2014. The terms of that contract give him retreat rights to return to being a city employee with the title of assistant city manager/utilities general manager.
Multiple attempts to reach Daniels at his Desert Hot Springs office were unsuccessful.

Some See Saving Of Recreation & Cultural Programs As Effect Of Yucca Valley Recall

(July 26) YUCCA VALLEY — While advocates of the recall of two Yucca Valley town council members have yet to achieve their stated goal of having councilmen Robert Lombardo and George Huntington removed from office, their petition gathering effort to qualify a vote on the Lombardo and Huntington recall is progressing, with nearly a third of the 2,356 signatures needed to endorse the petitions having been collected.
Moreover, the effort has been accompanied by some town policy changes which supporters of the recall say are a direct result of their undertaking.
Among the issues fueling the recall attempt was the town council’s vote in February to extend town manager Mark Nuami’s employment contract another three years and up his total compensation package to over $300,000 annually. Nuaimi’s contract and salary enhancements were accompanied by the announcements that the town would do away with or severely curtail four popular municipal programs – the operation of the town’s pool during summer months, the Fourth of July Fireworks Spectacular, the town museum and Yucca Valley’s Concerts in the Park.
Lombardo and Huntington, along with their colleagues Dawn Rowe and Mayor Merle Abel, found themselves at the center of a firestorm following those votes. Bob Leone, elected to the council in March during a special election to replace Isaac Hagerman, who departed last year, was not subjected to the enmity nor obloquy reserved for the rest of the  Yucca Valley town  council. Leone, in fact, had been critical of the raise provided to Nuaimi and advocated against the closure of the pool and museum and the discontinuation of the firework and concert events.
Lombardo and Huntington’s supporters, as well as those of Rowe and Abel, have denounced the recall attempt as misguided, saying Lombardo and Huntington have done nothing meriting the attempt to remove them and had merely taken prudent steps to ensure the town’s solvency.  Nevertheless, the cancelation of town recreation and cultural programs while the council was rerouting money that would have paid for their maintenance into the town manager’s pocket was resonating around the community, making the task of signature gathering for the petitions much more easy.  Significantly, the pool has not been closed, at least entirely. It remains open in the morning, when swim lessons are offered and lap swimming and exercising activity is allowed. At 11:30 a.m. it is open for general public use and remains open until 1:30 p.m.
Likewise, the threatened cancellation of the fireworks show did not materialize. That display was again put on after sundown on Independence Day. The museum remains open three days a week. Concerts in the park are being put on through August.
While Lombardo and Huntington supporters deny the continuation of the programs were in no way an outgrowth of the recall campaign, certain elements of the community have a different perception.

PG&E Hit With Class Action Lawsuit Over Lingering Hinkley Contamination

(July 26) HINKLEY—Scores of Hinkley residents have signed onto a class action lawsuit representing them against Pacific Gas and Electric, one that seeks compensation for their losses as a consequence of hexavalent chromium contamination that blights the San Bernardino County Mojave Desert community northwest of Barstow.The Hinkley hexavalent chromium contamination came about as a consequence of Pacific Gas and Electric’s operation of a compressor station there beginning in 1952. The compressor station was a facility located on a pipeline that ran between Texas and Canada and delivered in excess of three billion cubic feet of natural gas per day. The compressor station in Hinkley was one of eight such stations along the line in California. Natural gas available in the line was used to fuel compressors which repressurized the gas to push it through the pipeline. At Hinkley, the compressed gas was cooled with water circulating through two cooling towers. From 1952 until 1966, hexavalent chromium, also known as chromium 6, was added to the cooling water to prevent corrosion to the cooling towers and the water circulation system. Wastewater from the cooling system was disposed of in unlined ponds at the Hinkley site. Beginning in 1964, after the danger of chromium 6 was recognized, the cooling water was treated to remove the chromium before it was disposed in the pools and a non-chromium-based additive was substituted into the cooling system in 1966. As of 1972 the cooling water was pumped into lined evaporation ponds.
These improvements to the system, however, did not undo the ecological havoc that had occurred up until 1972.
In 1988, the Lahontan Regional Water Quality Control Board, which oversees water quality issues in that portion of the desert, issued a cleanup and abatement order to PG&E to investigate a plume of chromium 6 in the water table. In 1991, the water board issued permits to treat the contaminated groundwater using land treatment units.
In 1993, attorney Ed Masry, with whom Erin Brockovich, a Hinkley resident, was working, filed a multi-plaintiff direct action suit against PG&E, alleging contamination of the town’s drinking water and untoward consequences of that pollution. In 1996, the case was settled for $333 million, the largest settlement ever paid in a direct-action lawsuit until that time. In 2000, the matter became an international cause célèbre, with the release of the blockbuster movie Erin Brockovich, which related a substantially accurate version of events in Hinkley. Contrary to widespread public assumptions, Pacific Gas & Electric’s payment of the $333 million did not redress the underlying problem. Masry and his law firm netted over $100 million in legal fees. Only a few of the plaintiffs received more than $100,000. No physical solution to the contamination problem was effectuated.
In 1997 and 2004, the water board reissued follow-up permits to PG&E for the use of land treatment units in the treatment of the contaminated groundwater around Hinkley. In 2006, with the Hinkley groundwater contamination issue fading from public consciousness, the water board gave permits for two subterranean remediation systems to clean up the source and central areas of the plume. In 2008, however, the issue was resurrected as one of regional and local concern when, amidst the water board’s provision of a permit for Pacific Gas & Electric to apply additional cleanup measures, it issued redrafted cleanup and abatement orders. Steadily over the last five years, the condition of the lingering contamination in Hinkley has grown into a larger and larger public issue as evidence of how the underground plume of chromium 6 continues to migrate through the water table into the area from which local wells draw water used for household purposes has emerged.
The best hydrological data now available indicates the plume is more than six miles long and two miles wide and gradually expanding.
Chromium is the 21st most abundant element in the earth’s crust and as such naturally occurs in rocks, soil, ground water and plants.
Under current guidelines, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency specifies 100 micrograms per liter as the maximum acceptable total chromium contaminant level acceptable in water to be consumed by humans. The California state standard is half that at 50 micrograms per liter. But that standard applies to the most benign form of chromium, and not hexavalent chromium or chromium 6.
Trivalent chromium – chromium 3 – is the dominant form of chromium in nature, and is virtually insoluble in water and stable and immobile in soil. Hexavalent chromium – chromium six – is not abundant in nature, is soluble in water and is a potential carcinogen if inhaled.
Pacific Gas and Electric has been wrestling with the contamination issue and has applied a number of experimental cures to the problem which have proven inadequate, including pumping groundwater through a subsurface drip irrigation system and organic matter in the soil around plant root zones to create conditions, which Pacific Gas & Electric hoped  would “chemically reduce the level of chromium 6 in the water [reducing] the hexavalent chromium  to insoluble trivalent chromium.” Pacific Gas & Electric sought ways of keeping the contaminated water from migrating to other areas of the aquifer and tainting the water there. One effort Pacific Gas & Electric made to prevent the spreading of the plume entailed drawing up to 80 gallons of water per minute from supply wells south of the compression station, pumping it north through new underground pipes and injecting the water outside the northwestern plume boundary. This strategy, Pacific Gas and Electric claimed, was intended to “create a hydraulic barrier designed to prevent spreading of the plume.” While partially effective, that measure did not achieve the goal of reducing the chromium 6 in the water supply to an acceptable level.
As a practical means of ensuring that the tainted water does not end up in the drinking glasses, cooking utensils, showers, baths, toilets and garden hoses of Hinkley residents, PG&E offered to provide every household and business in Hinkley with either a filtration/treatment system to capture the chromium before it would be dispensed at the tap or in the alternative, commercial bottled drinking water.
But with no certain, final and comprehensive cure of the problem in sight, Pacific Gas & Electric in April 2012 began surveying homeowners with regard to their willingness to sell their property and move elsewhere. When roughly two-thirds of those surveyed indicated their readiness to depart the community, PG&E began making offers to individual property owners and undertook appraisals of their properties.  As soon as mutually acceptable terms between PG&E and the individual homeowners were arrived at, purchases were made. Since February, houses in Hinkley are being sold to PG&E at a rate of two to four per week.  Once the houses are empty, Pacific Gas & Electric has not spared time in having those homes razed, foreclosing any possibility that squatters or anyone else will be tempted to take up residence therein ever again.
Last week, the Santa Ana-based law firm Callahan & Blaine filed suit against PG&E in San Bernardino County Superior Court on behalf of a substantial number of Hinkley residents who were not a part of the litigation brought by Masry. Callahan & Blaine are seeking that the plaintiffs be recompensed for the damages they have sustained as a consequence of the continuing contamination and the ongoing expansion of the toxic plume and its threat to the area’s groundwater.
Of issue is that PG&E, in offering “fair market value” for the properties, is benefiting by its deliberate efforts to convert Hinkley to a ghost town. Under various theories, PG&E should be required to pay more for the homes than they are currently offering, since the company is responsible for the depression in Hinkley’s land values. In early 2012,  Hinkley’s population stood at 1,900. Today it has dwindled to an estimated 1,300, as residents continue their exodus. Earlier this year, the Barstow Unified School District moved to shutter Hinkley School at the end of the 2012-13 school year last month. The town is down to one market, a post office and a tavern.

County Absorbs Crest Forest Fire District

(July 26) The county fire department on Saturday took over operation of the Crest Forest Fire Protection District.
In a relatively seamless transition, the firefighters who had previously been employed by the Crest Forest Fire Protection District were laid off and immediately rehired by the San Bernardino County Fire Department. The district, which has been in existence since 1929, remains as a corporate entity contracting with the county, though it is likely that in a relatively short period of time it will be subsumed by the county. The district’s board remains in place.
While county officials assert that there will be no diminution in fire protection or service levels, the county will keep just two-thirds of the firemen it absorbed on July 20 at the two stations within the boundaries of the Crest Forest Fire Protection District, Station 25 in Crestline and Station 26 in Twin Peaks.
According to battalion chief John McLinn, the county fire division will now station an ambulance and its two-person crew at Station 26. That ambulance was previously staged out of Station 94 in Lake Arrowhead.
“By moving that ambulance to Station 26, it will be placed in a more centrally located position and will provide improved response time to its area of operations,” McLinn said.
Previously, the Crest Forest Fire District had two firefighter paramedics on a paramedic engine functioning out of Station 26 in Twin Peaks.  In addition to the ambulance at Station 26, County Fire will stage a three-person paramedic engine out of that site.
Previously, at Station 25 in Crestline, the Crest Forest Fire District had a medical fire engine with two men manning it. Under the new County Fire arrangement, according to McLinn, there will be a two-person crew manning the medical engine and a paramedic ambulance, also manned by two paramedic firefighters at Station 25.
The total staff for the department will consist of six captains, six engineers, six firefighter-paramedics and six  ambulance operators-medics.