Having made cultural and strategic political inroads few would have predicted, Chino Valley Unified School Board President Sonja Shaw is no longer reaching for the brass ring but the gold one.
Shaw has had a meteoric political rise. In 2022, in her maiden political venture, she was elected to the Chino Valley Unified School District Board of Trustees. Less than four years later, in the June 2026 California Primary, she placed first in the race for State Superintendent of Education.
In the meantime, she has grown into a figure of national renown as the informal spokeswoman for the reform movement seeking a return to the traditional values system that attended the American educational system before the advent of another American cultural/education system reformist, one from the opposite side of the political and cultural spectrum, Madalyn Murray O’Hair.
O’Hair’s lawsuit, Murray v. Curlett lawsuit, challenging the policy of mandatory prayers and Bible reading in Baltimore public schools, in which she named her first son, William J. Murray as the plaintiff, ultimately was heard by the United States Supreme Court, which ruled that officially sanctioned mandatory Bible-reading in American public schools was unconstitutional.
An important element of Shaw’s formula which has paradoxically afforded her uncommon success but is simultaneously limiting the scope of what she might otherwise attain, is its roots in anti-scholasticism, which predictably has put her at odds with the professional educators she aspires to assume authority over.
Shaw lacked a formal higher education beyond high school but had demonstrated a degree of personal dynamism, having obtained a California Real Estate License and owning three other small businesses, a personal fitness and training gym, a women’s health services clinic and a photography studio.
For a time, she had been a stay-at-home mother. Her husband Chis, owned a successful building and construction management business.
Here entry into politics came as a result of her religious affiliation. She is a was a parishioner of the Calvary Chapel Chino Hills Congregation. The pastor at Calvary Chapel Chino Hills is Jack Hibbs, a denominationalist, who holds that Christians have a duty to stand up for their beliefs by either running for election to public office themselves or supporting other Christians who do run, and then, upon taking office, Christianize public policy. With Hibbs encouraging heavy voter turnout of the members of Calvary Chapel and other churches in the 2006 election, a Calvary Chapel member, Sylvia Orozco, was elected to the Chino Valley School Board. In 2008, another Calvary Chapel congregant, James Na, was elected to the school board. In 2012, Andrew Cruz, another member of the Calvary Chapel Chino Hills Congregation, was elected to the school board. With the religious trifecta of Orozco, Na and Cruz in place and in control of the district, there followed increasingly bold efforts to insert conservative Christian activism into the district’s educational curriculum. Milestones in this regard were achieved with making Bible study part of the district curriculum, as well as including benedictions at the beginning of the school board meetings.
This religiosity in a public forum was challenged by 23 parents of some of the district’s students, who in 2014 were represented by the Madison, Wisconsin-based Freedom From Religion Foundation in a suit filed in Federal Court in Riverside against the district. The suit resulted in a U.S. District Court Judge Jesus Bernal in 2016 issuing a ruling, later upheld on appeal, that the district desist in evangelism, extending to so-called Christian witnessing as well as “prayers, Bible readings and proselytizing” in school settings.
In the years since, Orozco left the school board but Shaw and another member of Calvary Chapel, Jon Monroe, were elected to the board in 2022.
With the school board under the tight grip of Na, Cruz, Monroe and Shaw, who was established shortly after her election as the school board president, the district contemplated taking up once more an effort to acculturate public education in Chino Valley in accordance with Christian principles.
With much fanfare, the Shaw-led school board at its July 20, 2023 school board meeting, at which State Superintendent of Schools Tony Thurmond was in attendance to express his opposition, adopted a parental notification policy requiring teachers to inform parents of any student who re-identified his or her gender at school from the gender indicated on his or her birth certificate in a classroom setting. This ran counter to the advisal and recommended policy advocated by the California Department of Education and the state’s prevailing political establishment, which held that minor children in middle school and high school settings be allowed to assume a gender identity of their choosing without any interference.
The California Attorney General’s Officer filed a civil suit in San Bernardino County Superior Court to enjoin the Chino Valley Unified School District from enforcing its parental notification policy, asserting the policy “puts transgender and gender nonconforming students in danger of imminent, irreparable harm from the consequences of forced disclosures” and that as a consequence of the school district action, such students were “under threat’’ and “in fear,” facing “the risk of emotional, physical, and psychological harm from non-affirming or unaccepting parents or guardians.” The challenge of the policy was upheld by San Bernardino County Superior Court Judge Michael Sachs. Judge Sachs ruled that the district policy “singled out” transgender students for disparate treatment and thus ran afoul of California Education Code Sections 200 and 220 and Government Code section 11135 meant to ensure equal rights and opportunities for every student and prohibit discrimination on the basis of gender identity and gender expression.
Judge Sachs’ ruling, however, recognized that parents had a right to be informed of any changes made to the records kept by a school district in reference to their children. The Chino Valley Unified School District Board of Trustees in March 2024 passed a redrafted parental notification requirement that was more general and did not make any specific mention of sexuality or gender, instead requiring that parents be told if the students made any alteration of their school registration records, such as altering their names. This sufficed as a victory for those on the conservative side of the cultural divide, which pushed California’s ruling liberal political establishment, including Governor Gavin Newsom, Thurmond and the California legislature which passed AB 1955, prohibiting schools from making a practice of notifying parents if their children are assuming a gender different from the one assigned them at birth. Immediately after it was signed into law by Governor Newsom on July 15, 2024, the Chino Valley Unified School District and eight parents of district students, represented by attorney Emily Ray of the Austin, Texas-based Liberty Justice Center, sued Newsom, Bonta and Thurmond in an effort to prevent the enforcement of AB 1955.
Even as the Chino Valley Unified School District was assuming a lead role in challenging what the majority of its board members considered to be counterproductive and unjustifiable liberal policies, a parallel lawsuit, Mirabelli vs. Olson,
As this legal back-and-forth was raging in state court, another civil lawsuit, Mirabelli vs. Olson, relating to two teachers in the Escondido School District suing the district in which they worked over that district’s order that they not inform the parents of their students about the names they used in a classroom setting when those names reflected a difference from those students’ biological gender, was wending its way through federal court. Ultimately, in Mirabelli vs. Olson, Judge Roger Benitez ruled that a school district or educators to whom parents have entrusted their children cannot actively deceive those parents.
In March, the U.S. Supreme Court majority ruled that parents who made inquiries with regard to the issue had a right to be told about their children’s sexual orientation presentation at school.
As federal law takes precedence over state law, the Chino Unified School District, which had taken a shellacking in California state court in seeking to propound its conservative vision in the context of classroom education, found itself vindicated in fighting what many considered to be the excessively liberal philosophy of the predominant number of professional educators who had taken over the California public school system.
As the Chino Valley School District’s leader, Shaw found herself lionized as a heroine by many of those in the conservative movement at the national level as controversy over the proliferation of gender altering surgical procedures being performed on underage subjects was raging in the early 2020s.
She parlayed that notoriety into a run for California superintendent of public education.
Contrary to the perspectives of Newsom, Thurmond and the prevailing element of the Democratic Party’s members of the California legislature, a fair number or even majority of the members of their own party were not supportive of permitting adolescents indulging in transsexualism, extending to arranging sex change operations for students/minors without the consent of their parents.
With approximately 26,562 students, Chino Valley Unified is San Bernardino County’s third largest school district and the 33rd largest school district in the state. In reaction to it having carried out what some perceived to be the good fight in being the first district in California to adopt a parental notification policy, several other districts in the state, including the Orange Unified School District, the Murrieta Valley Unified School District, the Temecula Valley Unified School District, the Rocklin Unified School District, the Placentia-Yorba Linda Unified School District and the Cajon Valley Union School District, followed suit.
Her candidacy this spring was boosted by the consideration that in addition to her having unequivocally taken a stand against the liberalisms of the Democratic establishment, the ten-candidate field in June was loaded with five Democrats who proudly proclaimed their affiliation and two who de-emphasized it, while Shaw had the endorsement of the Republican Party. Wen the dust cleared after the June vote, Shaw had 22.7 percent of the vote state wide, while Richard Barrera, a Democrat and the president of the San Diego School Board, had 20.3 percent. In third was another Democrat, Nichelle Henderson, with 9.6 percent, followed by Wendy Castaneda Leal, who was not willing to embrace her Democratic Party affiliation, with 8.8 percent. Democratic Assemblyman Al Muratsuchi captured fifth with 8.4 percent and Anthony Rendon, another Democrat managed to bring in 8.1 percent, followed by Josh Newman, a Democrat 6.8 percent. Frank Lara, a socialist and unionist, garnered 7.5 percent and Ainye Long had 5.5 percent.
Given that 53.2 percent of the vote in June had fallen to clearly identified Democrats and 62 percent was monopolized by Democrats of one sort or another, Shaw had a tough uphill climb in seeking the state’s top educational post.
Still, she and her supporters had hope that the Democrats and Barrera, who had already stumbled over the support of transgenderism, might have but themselves into a downward spiral with regard to trust over the stewardship of California’s educational system from which they might not recover.
Unfortunately for Shaw, she did not garner anywhere near the $35 million to $37 million that it is calculated by political analysts to be the amount of money she needs to win a statewide post while functioning with the liability of being a Republican in a state overwhelmingly populated by Democrats. In California, 10.5 million or 45 percent of the state’s voters are Democrats and 5.7 million or 24.7 percent are Republicans.
Heading toward the November runoff against Barrera, Shaw was the beneficiary of a modicum of relative advantage based upon the overall attitude of Republican, Democrat and independent voters with regard to official educational endorsement of transgenderism, but yet had to overcome the partisan disadvantage that accrued to her based solely upon her Republican affiliation. Moreover, the Chino Valley Unified School District’s official embrasure of other “conservative values” policies entailed her taking positions on issues that, if not in fact problematic, lent themselves to interpretations that created perceptions with a wide spectrum of voters that no politician wants to deal with.
The school board in October 2023 adopted a procedure that allows parents of Chino Valley Unified students to call into question or otherwise challenge the availability of books in district school libraries that are sexually explicit or involve lesbian/gay/bisexual/transsexual themes, potentially leading to them being deemed inappropriate reading material and therefore removed from bookshelves.
There had been some resistance to the consideration of the policy before and at the time of its passage, which included comparisons to the banning of books during the 1930s in Germany under the Nazi regime.
With Shaw running for superintendent of public instruction, Public Counsel, a Los Angeles–based nonprofit law firm, on behalf of local parents Kristi Hirst and Tracie Perez, filed with the California Department of Education, alleged the book banning policy violated the state’s education code. The suit drew attention to criticisms of Shaw, in particular charges that she was close-minded and bigoted.
Shaw said she stood by her commitment to safeguard parents’ rights and that she was not seeking to stifle intellectual curiosity or block students’ access to a wide variety of cross-cultural exposure but wanted to “ensure that sexually explicit material is not placed in the hands of children in our schools.”
Unfortunately for Shaw, while she expressed confidence that “parents overwhelmingly expect us to exercise that control,” in many different forums and contexts her political opponents and Becerra were able to allege that she was an anti-intellectual who was intent on limiting the education of students.
Under the district’s book-challenging policy, calls were made to remove the Bible based on the its sexual content as well as “Juliet Takes a Breath” by Gabby Rivera; “A Court of Mist and Fury” by Sarah J. Maas; “More Happy Than Not” by Adam Silvera; “Looking for Alaska” by John Green; and “Beloved” by Toni Morrison. All but the Bible were removed. This entails gross anti-intellectualism, which is unacceptable in an individual who is to head up the state’s effort to educate its youth, Shaw’s critics say.
Though many parents raising their children want common-sense principles to be applied in the education of their children and are opposed to subjecting their children to ideological indoctrination, the vast majority of those fall somewhere safely within the mainstream, not too far to the left nor to the right. Zealotry either way is nothing they want in the schools entrusted with their children. Though Shaw had established herself as someone resisting the radical progressivism that was present among many involved in the teaching profession, to a good cross section of the public she had swung too far toward rightwing radicalism.
Barrera as much as conceded that a majority of the state’s parents agree with Shaw’s positions regarding transsexualism, but that on other culture war issues she is out of step with the majority of voters.
Barrera said, “Most parents in this state are not in favor of restricting access to books for students,” he said.
Shaw simply does not appreciate the concept of there being a separation between church and state, her critics say. They site the school board she heads having resurrected the move toward permitting school prayer, three years after the U.S. Supreme Court in 2022 made a ruling in the case of Kennedy v. Bremerton School District, which dealt with a football coach’s praying with members of his team on the field in a game setting.The nation’s highest court, in a 6-to-3 ruling said that before prohibiting prayer straight out, a governmental entity should consider “historical practices and understandings” with regard to prayer in the particular community involved.
Na, Cruz, Shaw and Monroe, heartened by the Kennedy v. Bremerton decision, in July 2025, despite the district’s resounding 2016 loss at the trial court level and its loss at the appellate level in 2018, sought to roll the dice in an effort to test the school prayer issue once more. The district retained Advocates for Faith & Freedom, a Murrieta-based nonprofit law firm specializing in issues relating to religious liberty to represent it with regard to what was generically described as “anticipated litigation.” On July 31, 2025 Advocates for Faith & Freedom, on behalf of the district, filed with the Federal District Court in Riverside for relief from Judge Bernal’s 2016 injunction enjoining the board from permitting or endorsing prayers during meetings.
The district’s filing incorporated wording from the Supreme Court’s decision in the Kennedy v. Bremerton case.
In a statement heralding the lawsuit, Shaw insisted that the district had “welcomed voices of all faiths without coercion or preference.” She said that secular “groups driven by political agendas” had straitjacketed the district into having “to abandon a unifying tradition,” namely prayer recitation. “We will not quietly surrender our right to reflect the values of our community and the freedoms our nation was built upon,” Shaw vowed.
Others, however, pointed out that the district had not permitted school board meetings to be kicked off with prayers or homilies or invocations from the standpoint of, for example, Moslems, who might call, devoutly, for the beheading of infidels. For that reason, to prevent the perception of one religion being favored over another, it was the belief of many that all religion – Christianity, Catholicism, Protestantism, Judaism, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Zoroastrianism, Paganism, Universalism – be left out of the schools.
The Freedom From Religion Foundation, which was paid $282,602 by the district to cover its legal expenses in the legal go-round between it and the district in 2014 to 2018, immediately reacted to the filing, and stepped in to oppose the district’s petition.
As a matter of course, the case was routed to Judge Bernal. Based on his familiarity with the subject matter and being up to speed with regard to the case law pertaining to the full range of issues involved.
In the meantime, Shaw, who most likely could have been easily reelected to the school board if she ran again this year, is forgoing keeping that bird in her hand in favor of seeking the bird in the bush of being state superintendent of schools superintendent.
It is of note that in the field of education and education reform, where one ends up often has a lot to do with where that person started.
Comparing and contrasting Shaw to two remarkable education system reformists/standard setters – Madalyn Murray O’Hair and Max Rafferty – it is immediately recognized that o’Hair and Rafferty each enjoyed an advantage that Shaw does not: being steeped deep in the discipline of academia that all three were so intent on influencing.
O’Hair held a bachelor’s degree from Ashland University and had earned a law degree from the South Texas College of Law, though she never passed a bar exam in any of the states in which she resided. Rafferty earned his bachelor of arts and master of arts degrees from the University of California, Los Angeles and went on to get doctorate in eduction from the University of Southern California.
O’Hair and her experience is relevant to Shaw, in that she proved successful in pushing educational policy in the exact opposite direction from that sought by Shaw, doing so in a venue larger than the State of California and in such a way that her reforms have been in place now for three generations. Rafferty was on the same side of the political spectrum as Shaw, and was the successful in being elected to the same office to which Shaw aspires, California superintendent of public instruction, a position he held from 1963 to 1971. He was able to effectuate policy changes and educational approaches throughout the state as California was becoming the largest state in the country. Rafferty began his teaching career in San Bernardino County, first teaching in the Trona Unified School District, then becoming an assistant principal and a prinicpal at Big Bear High School and then a superintendent in the Needles School District.
Though Shaw and her supporters make the case that the immersion of the state’s educators – its teachers, principals, superintendents and the top staff in the California Department of Education in in the liberal atmosphere of academia is in large measure a part of the problem with the educational system in California, that she is unfamiliar with the atmospherics of learn and is not a participant in the classroom culture has left here outsife the culture she needs to be able to move through to effectuate the change she envisions. It has also limited her in the skill set needed to wield the machinery of a large bureaucracy.
Polling shows Shaw running substantially behind Barrera. The latest available poll has him comfortably ahead of her, at 51 percent to 35 percent, with 14 percent undecided.
Running in her place in Board Area 3 is her husband, Chris Shaw. According to polling data, he is running behind his competitor, Frank Gerdine, with 37 percent of those likely to vote backing him and Gerdine favored by 48 percent of voters polled, with 15 percent undecided.
-Mark Gutglueck